Boardroom · Executive simulation
Take charge of a business in decline
Corvell Furniture has slipped from a profit margin of 10.1% to 1.0% in three years. Join its executive team in one of seven roles, find out why, choose a strategy, spend a budget, and live with three years of consequences.
- Company
- Corvell Furniture
- Industry
- Solid-wood furniture for the home
- Location
- Wexley Bridge, a fictional mill town in the Pennines, England
- Founded
- 1972
- Size
- 160 makers in the workshop, and about 45 more in design, sales, two showrooms and the office
- Ownership
- The Corvell family holds 70% of the shares; an investment fund bought the other 30% in 2019.
The question for the executive team How should Corvell restore its profitability by 2029 without exhausting the bank's patience, the workforce's goodwill or the brand it has built?
- 7 roles, each with its own briefing and goals
- 9 stages, from the accounts to the evaluation
- 3 years of decisions, each run by the engine
- 6 levers, four of them sharing one budget
- 4 strategies, every one played out for comparison
Section 01: The company and its decline
Four years of Corvell Furniture's figures, worked by the simulation's engine from the company's opening position and its decisions.
Corvell Furniture makes dining tables, chairs, sideboards and beds in oak and walnut in a converted mill at Wexley Bridge. Every piece is made to order by 160 makers, finishers and fitters, and sold through two showrooms, the company's website and about forty independent furniture shops. Ruth Corvell's grandfather founded the business in 1972. It has never moved and has never made a loss, though 2026 came close.
Until recently it was comfortably profitable. In 2023 Corvell delivered 23,682 pieces and earned £19.81m, a profit margin of 10.1% and a return on capital employed of 23.2%. In 2026 it delivered 20,780 pieces for £18.26m; the profit margin was 1.0% and the return on capital employed 2.1%.
Nothing dramatic happened. Timber, finishes and fittings cost more every year, and the price list rose more slowly. Importers of cheaper solid-wood furniture held or trimmed their prices. To protect profit the marketing budget was cut every year, from £760k in 2023 to £420k in 2026, and pay was frozen in 2025 and 2026. A second showroom opened in 2025 on a ten-year lease. Experienced makers began to leave: 25 left in 2026, against 10 in 2023.
In November 2026 the board asked its executive team for a three-year plan. You join that team in one of seven roles. The decisions are the team's; your role decides what you watch most closely and what you will answer for.
Corvell Furniture at the end of 2026
Source: Simulated data-
Revenue
£18.26m
Change from 2025: −£371k Down, worse
-
Operating profit
£186k
Change from 2025: −£495k Down, worse
-
Profit margin
1.0%
Change from 2025: −2.6 pts Down, worse
-
ROCE
2.1%
Change from 2025: −5.6 pts Down, worse
-
Net cash
£1.54m
Change from 2025: +£57k Up, better
-
Market share
1.9%
Change from 2025: −0.1 pts Down, worse
-
Brand
62out of 100
Change from 2025: −2 Down, worse
-
Service quality
71out of 100
Change from 2025: −5 Down, worse
-
Utilization
79.5%
Change from 2025: +1.8 pts Up
-
Morale
50out of 100
Change from 2025: −3 Down, worse
Section 02: The board's mandate
Three years, a budget, two targets and six levers.
The board has given the executive team three years, 2027 to 2029, and up to £2.50m a year to spend on marketing, new machinery, a people programme and international expansion. Prices and overheads are the team's to set. The board's targets are a profit margin of at least 5% in 2029, and no year ending with the overdraft above the bank's limit of £2.50m. Whatever is not spent stays in the bank. The family will take no dividend until the margin recovers.
The board planned on these forecasts: the home market growing by about 3% to 4% a year as house moves recover; competitors raising their prices by 1% to 2% a year; timber, finishes and fittings rising by about 2% a year; the agreed pay award of 2.5% a year; and the euro staying near €1.15 to the pound. They are forecasts. What happens each year is reported when the year is over, and it will not all match.
| Lever | Range | What it does |
|---|---|---|
| Price change | −10% to +10% | Per cent on last year’s prices, from −10 to +10. Demand responds through the price elasticity of demand. |
| Efficiency programme | None to 15% of overheads | Per cent of overheads cut this year, from 0 to 15. The saving lasts; so does the strain on quality and morale. |
| Marketing | None to £2m | This year’s whole marketing spend. Half of its effect on the brand arrives this year and half next year. |
| Capacity investment | None to £2.50m | Machinery that adds plant capacity and cuts the hours each piece needs. Paid now; in use next year. |
| People programme | None to £1m | Training, development and retention pay. Morale responds this year; productivity next year. |
| International expansion | None to £1.50m | Entering the export market: set-up first, then building sales. Exports start the year after set-up. |
Section 03: Seven roles, one company
The same company seen from seven chairs. Your role sets what you watch, what each stage asks you to look for first, and what you are judged on.
-
Chief executive (CEO)
You answer to the board for all of it. In 2023 Corvell earned a profit margin of 10.1%; in 2026 it earned 1.0%, and the return on the capital the owners have tied up in it fell from 23.2% to 2.1%. The family wants the business kept whole and in Wexley Bridge; the fund wants the margin back quickly; the bank wants a plan that does not live on its overdraft.
Your job is the balance. Every executive will argue for their own function; you are the one who has to say what comes first, what can wait, and what the plan will cost the people who carry it out.
Play as the chief executiveAnswers for
- The profit margin back to the board's target of 5% by 2029.
- Every year inside the bank's overdraft limit.
- A business left stronger than you found it, in its brand, its workforce and its capacity.
- The family and the fund behind one plan.
Watches, in 2026
- Profit margin
- 1.0%
- Net cash
- £1.54m
- Brand
- 62
- Morale
- 50
Judged on
- A profit margin of at least 5% in 2029
- No year ending over the overdraft limit
- Brand strength of at least 60 in 2029
- Morale of at least 55 in 2029
-
Chief financial officer (CFO)
You look first at what the numbers say and when the cash moves. Operating profit fell from £2m in 2023 to £186k in 2026, the gross profit margin from 58.1% to 53.6%, and return on capital employed from 23.2% to 2.1%. Liquidity is not yet the problem: net cash was £1.54m at the end of 2026, the current ratio 3.77, and the overdraft unused.
That comfort will not last if the plan spends the whole budget and the returns come late. Each year's spending is paid for now; most of it earns next year or after. Your task is to make sure the plan is affordable on the way, not only at the end.
Play as the chief financial officerAnswers for
- Return on capital employed back to at least 12% by 2029.
- Net cash never below zero at a year end.
- Every pound of the budget justified by what it returns.
- Profit over the three years at least covering the losses on the way.
Watches, in 2026
- ROCE
- 2.1%
- Net cash
- £1.54m
- Gross margin
- 53.6%
- Headroom
- £2.50m
Judged on
- Return on capital employed of at least 12% in 2029
- Net cash never below zero at a year end
- Profit for the year, added over the three years, of at least zero
-
Chief marketing officer (CMO)
You see the customers Corvell has lost. Market share fell from 2.3% to 1.9% while the market grew, because Corvell's prices rose against rivals that held or trimmed theirs: on an index of its price against competitors' (competitors = 100), Corvell went from 110 to 118. Marketing was cut from £760k to £420k, and the brand, at 62, has only begun to show it.
You also know what the finance team can forget: a brand fades when it is not maintained, and marketing takes a year to show its full effect.
Play as the chief marketing officerAnswers for
- Win back share of a growing market.
- Rebuild the brand before it fades further.
- Price for value, neither the cheapest nor out of reach.
- Grow revenue by 2029.
Watches, in 2026
- Market share
- 1.9%
- Brand
- 62
- Revenue
- £18.26m
- Price
- £879
Judged on
- Market share of at least 2% in 2029
- Brand strength of at least 65 in 2029
- Revenue up by at least £2m on 2026
-
Chief operating officer (COO)
You run the workshop. It can make about 22,735 pieces a year in normal hours and 26,145 with overtime; it delivered 20,780 in 2026. That looks like room to grow, but there is less of it than there was: in 2023, normal hours could make 26,171. Experienced makers have left (25 in 2026), new starters are slower, and the share of pieces returned or remade rose from 2.6% to 3.9%.
Whoever wins the argument upstairs, you will have to make the plan. If marketing works, can you make the pieces? If the efficiency programme bites, who will check the finish?
Play as the chief operating officerAnswers for
- Service quality of at least 75 by 2029.
- No year relying on heavy overtime.
- Returns below 3% of deliveries.
- Capacity ready before the demand arrives.
Watches, in 2026
- Utilization
- 79.5%
- Service quality
- 71
- Returns
- 3.9%
- Overtime
- 0
Judged on
- Service quality of at least 75 in 2029
- No more than 5,000 hours of overtime in any year
- No more than 3% of pieces returned or remade in 2029
-
Chief human resources officer (CHRO)
You see what the last three years did to the people who make the product. Pay was frozen in 2025 and 2026. Morale in the staff survey fell from 64 to 50, and labour turnover rose from 6.3% to 15.6%: 25 people left in 2026, many of them experienced makers who went to better-paid work down the valley.
The union wants a pay rise; the fund wants costs cut; the makers who stayed want to know whether the company has a future. A plan that ignores them will be carried out by people who no longer believe in it.
Play as the chief human resources officerAnswers for
- Morale back to at least 60 by 2029.
- Labour turnover below 10%.
- No year in which morale falls below 50.
- Change handled with the workforce, not done to it.
Watches, in 2026
- Morale
- 50
- Labour turnover
- 15.6%
- Skill
- 0.99
- Overtime share
- 0.0%
Judged on
- Morale of at least 60 in 2029
- Labour turnover of no more than 10% in 2029
- Morale never below 50 at a year end
-
Strategy director
You look beyond the next year. Corvell has been losing share at home for three years while the market grew by 5.6%, and its return on capital employed has fallen from 23.2% to 2.1%. A distributor has offered to sell the range in the Netherlands, Belgium and Germany, and rivals compete on price at home.
Your question is where Corvell will earn its return in 2030 and after: in the same market, defended better, or in new ones? A plan that only repairs the past may leave the company with nowhere to grow.
Play as the strategy directorAnswers for
- Revenue growth by 2029 that the business can sustain.
- Return on capital employed back above 10%.
- A position that does not depend on one market.
- Options for the years after the plan.
Watches, in 2026
- Revenue
- £18.26m
- ROCE
- 2.1%
- Export share
- 0.0%
- Market share
- 1.9%
Judged on
- Revenue up by at least £3m on 2026
- Return on capital employed of at least 10% in 2029
- At least 10% of revenue earned abroad in 2029
-
Management consultant
The board has hired you for an independent view. You have no function to defend, and you will be judged on whether the plan works for the whole business: the margin, the workshop, the people and the bank.
Your first reading of the figures: revenue fell by 7.8% between 2023 and 2026, but operating profit fell from £2m to £186k. The company has cash (£1.54m) and time, but not unlimited amounts of either, and each executive sees a different part of the problem. Your value is in seeing how the parts connect.
Play as the management consultantAnswers for
- A profit margin of at least 4% by 2029.
- Service quality and morale restored, not traded away.
- No breach of the bank's limit.
- Recommendations each executive can act on.
Watches, in 2026
- Profit margin
- 1.0%
- Service quality
- 71
- Morale
- 50
- Net cash
- £1.54m
Judged on
- A profit margin of at least 4% in 2029
- Service quality of at least 72 in 2029
- Morale of at least 58 in 2029
- No year ending over the overdraft limit
Section 04: How the simulation works
Nine stages and a debrief. The first six are analysis; the last three are your plan and its consequences.
- 1 Examine the financial information. Read four years of statements and ratios, and calculate where the margin went.
- 2 Identify the causes of the decline. Choose them from eleven pieces of evidence, and see what each choice tells you.
- 3 Analyse the market. The home market, the competitors, a price test and an offer to sell abroad.
- 4 Review operational capacity. What the workshop can make, what limits it, and what happens when it is pushed.
- 5 Consider employees and other stakeholders. The workforce after two years of frozen pay, and the stakeholders who can make or break a plan.
- 6 Select a strategic alternative. Four ways forward, each fitting some of the evidence. Choose the one you will lead with.
- 7 Allocate resources. Set a price, any efficiency programme, and a budget across marketing, machinery, people and expansion.
- 8 Implement, year by year. Commit each year, see what happened and why, and adjust the plan for the next.
- 9 Evaluate the consequences. Your role’s goals, the figures before and after, and the questions to ask of your own plan.
- 10The debrief. The trade-offs explained, your plan lever by lever, and every strategy played out by the same engine beside yours.
Your work stays on this device, under the name bb:executive, and you can leave and come back. Without JavaScript, the simulation page is a casebook: the evidence, every question with its answer,
and a worked example played through three years with its debrief.
Section 05: The model behind the figures
One engine works every year of every plan. It is deterministic: the same plan always gives the same figures, so a plan can be replayed, compared and tested.
Each year the engine works through the business in a fixed order: the world moves (the market, competitors' prices, timber, pay and the exchange rate); last year's decisions arrive; this year's levers apply; morale, turnover and productivity are set; the brand and demand follow; capacity, output and quality are worked out; then costs, profit, working capital and cash. The table lists every link from one part of the business to another, and when it takes effect.
| What changes | What it moves | When | How |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price | Orders at home and abroad | Now | Through the price elasticity of demand: about 2.0 at home, measured against competitors’ prices. |
| Marketing | Brand strength | Half now, half next year | Diminishing returns: the first pounds do most. Without marketing the brand loses 15% of its strength a year. |
| Brand strength | Orders at home | Now | A stronger brand raises demand at any price. |
| Service quality | Brand strength | Next year | Reviews and recommendations: this year’s finish and delivery dates are next year’s reputation. |
| Orders against capacity | Output, overtime and lost orders | Now | Normal hours first, then overtime of up to 15% more hours at a premium of 50%; orders beyond that are lost. |
| Load on the workshop | Service quality | Now | Above 88% of normal-hours capacity, faults and late deliveries rise. |
| Efficiency programme | Overheads, morale and quality | Now, and it lasts | The saving is immediate, with a one-off cost of 15% of it. The first 5% of cuts remove slack; beyond that, quality suffers for as long as the cuts last. |
| People programme | Morale, then skill | Morale now, skill next year | Training, development and retention pay, with diminishing returns. |
| Morale | Turnover, productivity and quality | Now; quality next year | Low morale means more leavers and slower work, and shows in the finish a year later. |
| Labour turnover | Capacity, skill and cost | Now and next year | Each leaver is replaced at a cost; a new starter makes about 50% as much in the first year, and skill drains away. |
| Machinery | Plant capacity and hours per piece | Next year | Paid for now, in use a year later, depreciated over its life from then. |
| International expansion | Export orders | The year after set-up | Set-up first; then each year’s spending builds the market, with diminishing returns, and fades without more. |
| The exchange rate | Export revenue | Now | The distributor pays in euros at a price set at the planning rate: a stronger pound means fewer pounds for every piece. |
| Sales, stock and purchases | Debtors, stock and creditors | Now | Working capital follows its days, so profit and cash part company; customers abroad pay more slowly. |
| The overdraft | Interest | Next year | Interest is charged on the balance at the start of each year; above the limit, a penalty rate is added. |
What the tests check
- The engine against a small business worked by hand: demand, capacity, overtime, the statements, working capital and cash.
- In every year of every plan they run: profit before interest and tax equals gross profit less expenses; closing cash equals opening cash plus the operating, investing and financing flows; net assets equal equity.
- That the model behaves as it says: more marketing never lowers orders; a cut raises the first year's margin and lowers morale, and beyond the slack, quality; machinery adds nothing until the year after; a stronger pound lowers export revenue.
- Every claim the debrief makes about the four strategies, against the engine's own figures.
What the model leaves out
- Chance: a plan always gives the same result. Real decisions are taken under uncertainty that one run cannot show, which is why the debrief shifts the exchange rate to show a plan's exposure.
- Detail: one average price, one product, one workforce that keeps its size, no new borrowing. Tax is a flat simulated rate.
- Judgement: the coefficients (how strongly price moves orders, how fast the brand fades) are teaching assumptions, stated in the simulation's file, not estimates for any real business.
Section 06: Who it is for
IB Business Management students
The stages exercise these parts of the course. HL-only ideas are marked and kept to notes, so that every question can be answered at SL.
- 1.3 Business objectives
- 1.4 Stakeholders
- 1.5 Growth and evolution
- 1.6 Multinational companies (MNCs)
- 2.1 Introduction to human resource management
- 2.4 Motivation and demotivation
- 2.7 Industrial/employee relations HL
- 3.2 Sources of finance
- 3.3 Costs and revenues
- 3.4 Final accounts
- 3.5 Profitability and liquidity ratio analysis
- 3.6 Efficiency ratio analysis HL
- 3.7 Cash flow
- 3.8 Investment appraisal
- 3.9 Budgets HL
- 4.1 Introduction to marketing
- 4.5 The seven Ps of the marketing mix
- 4.6 International marketing HL
- 5.1 Introduction to operations management
- 5.3 Lean production and quality management HL
- 5.5 Break-even analysis
- 5.6 Production planning HL
Undergraduates, MBA students and professionals
Beyond the course, the debrief draws on research on decisions whose results arrive late, on anchoring and escalating commitment, and on balanced sets of measures, each labelled as enrichment and cited. Play the same company from two roles and compare what each would have you protect.
Teachers
Assign roles across a class and ask each group to defend its plan to the others; the debrief's comparison of strategies gives the discussion its figures. The casebook works without JavaScript and prints.
Arjun Agrawal | The Business Brief, https://the-business-brief-dun.vercel.app/boardroom/executive/. Original teaching material, not an IB publication. The organizations in the teaching cases are fictional unless a case says otherwise.