Business Brief 3.3 · Finance and accounts

Costs and revenues

What a business's costs are, how they behave as output changes, where its revenue comes from, and how contribution connects them to break-even, profit and the orders worth accepting.

SL and HL Verification: Verified Updated 20 November 2026
Show content for

Showing everything. HL-only material is marked HL.

The decision

What does each unit really cost, and what does that mean for the price and for the orders a business should accept?

Atelier Barro, a ceramics studio in Porto, sells about 640 hand-made mugs a month at €22. In the same week its electricity costs rose and a hotel group offered to buy 300 mugs at €11, half the shop price. The owner's instinct is to raise prices and refuse the order. To know whether her instinct is right, she needs to know which of her costs change with output, which do not, and what each mug contributes.

Study mode

Text size

Why it matters

Almost every business decision changes costs or revenues: a price, an order, a new product, a cut. Classifying costs correctly is what makes those decisions calculable. Getting it wrong, by treating a fixed cost as variable or by forgetting a cost that rises with the price, gives a confident answer to the wrong question.

By the end you can

  • Classify costs as fixed, variable or semi-variable, and as direct or indirect for a stated cost object.
  • Calculate total cost, total revenue and profit, with working and units.
  • Identify a business's revenue streams and explain how each behaves.
  • Calculate contribution per unit and use it to find the break-even quantity, the margin of safety and the target profit output (5.5).
  • Evaluate a pricing decision using contribution, and state the limits of the model.
  • Use contribution to decide whether to accept a special order. HL only
  • Explain how cost structures and revenue streams differ between industries, and why the difference matters for profit.
  • Analyse how a decision about costs or prices moves money between stakeholders.
In the IB course: subtopic 3.3 Verification: Verified

Checked against the Business management guide. Subtopic 3.3 (pp. 28 to 29) covers types of cost (fixed, variable, direct and indirect or overhead) and total revenue and revenue streams, at AO2. This brief also teaches break-even analysis, subtopic 5.5 (p. 34), and, for HL, contribution costing from the toolkit (p. 14). Semi-variable costs are not in the guide's list; they are included because real cost ledgers contain them, and in an answer they should be split into their fixed and variable parts.

  • Types of cost: fixed, variable, direct and indirect (overhead), with examples Verification: Verified
  • Total revenue and revenue streams, with examples Verification: Verified
  • Break-even analysis (5.5): contribution per unit and total contribution, the break-even chart, margin of safety, target profit output, target profit and target price, the effects of changes in price or cost, and the limitations of break-even Verification: Verified
  • Toolkit, contribution (HL): contribution costing, including special orders HL only Verification: Verified

See the whole syllabus map · What the platform covers

Section 01: The situation

One studio, two letters, and an instinct to check.

Source: Simulated data

Inês Carvalho's studio makes about €1,600 a month from its mugs, after every cost including her own salary. From November the kiln will cost more to run. In the same week a hotel group asked for 300 mugs at €11 each. She is inclined to raise her prices and to say no to the hotel, because €11 looks like less than a mug costs.

Both instincts depend on what a mug costs, and that turns out to be two different questions. What does one more mug add to the studio's costs? And what does a mug cost on average, once every bill is shared out? The first answer is about €7. The second is about €20. Which one matters depends on the decision.

Section 02: Types of costs

Two separate questions about every cost. How does it behave, and can it be traced?

Source: Subject knowledge
Fixed costs

Costs that do not change with the level of output, within a range of output and over a given period. Rent and salaries are the usual examples.

Source: Subject knowledge
Variable costs

Costs that change in direct proportion to output. Raw materials and packaging are the usual examples.

Source: Subject knowledge
Semi-variable costs

Costs with a fixed part and a variable part, such as an electricity bill with a standing charge and a charge for each unit used.

The guide's list of cost types (3.3) does not include semi-variable costs. In an examination answer, split one into its fixed part and its variable part.

Source: Subject knowledge
Direct and indirect costs

A direct cost can be traced to a particular cost object, such as a product. An indirect cost, or overhead, cannot, because it is shared across the business.

Cost behaviour at Atelier Barro

Source: Simulated data
Aspect How it behaves as output risesExample at Atelier Barro
Fixed Stays the same in total, so it falls per unit.Studio rent of €1,900 a month, whether the studio makes 200 mugs or 1,200.
Variable Rises in proportion to output, so it is the same per unit.Clay and glaze at €2.30 for every mug.
Semi-variable Has a fixed part and a part that rises with output.Electricity, at €340 a month plus about €0.75 for each mug fired.

Interaction

Classify Atelier Barro's costs

Source: Subject knowledge

Classify each cost twice. The cost object is one mug.

For each cost, decide how it behaves as output changes, and whether it can be traced to one mug.

  1. Clay and glaze

    €2.30 for each mug

    How it behaves
    Traced to one mug?
  2. Thrower's piece rate

    €2.40 for each mug that passes inspection

    How it behaves
    Traced to one mug?
  3. Packaging

    €0.85 for each mug sent out

    How it behaves
    Traced to one mug?
  4. Card and platform fees

    4% of the price of each mug sold

    How it behaves
    Traced to one mug?
  5. Electricity

    A standing charge of €340 a month, plus about €0.75 for each mug fired

    How it behaves
    Traced to one mug?
  6. Studio rent

    €1,900 a month

    How it behaves
    Traced to one mug?
  7. Kiln lease

    €450 a month

    How it behaves
    Traced to one mug?
  8. Studio manager's salary

    €2,300 a month

    How it behaves
    Traced to one mug?
  9. Owner's salary

    €2,400 a month

    How it behaves
    Traced to one mug?
  10. Social media advertising

    €480 a month, set by the owner

    How it behaves
    Traced to one mug?
Every cost, sorted

Fixed costs

  • Studio rent (indirect)
  • Kiln lease (indirect)
  • Studio manager's salary (indirect)
  • Owner's salary (indirect)
  • Social media advertising (indirect)

Variable costs

  • Clay and glaze (direct)
  • Thrower's piece rate (direct)
  • Packaging (direct)
  • Card and platform fees (direct)

Semi-variable costs

  • Electricity (indirect)

Choose an answer for each item, then open its answer to compare. 10 to do. Choose your answers, then check each one or check them all.

Source: Subject knowledge
Misconception

Labour is always a fixed cost.

Better reasoning

It depends on how people are paid. Atelier Barro's throwers are paid €2.40 for each mug, so their pay is a variable, direct cost. A salaried studio manager is a fixed, indirect cost. The same work can be either.

Source: Subject knowledge
Misconception

A cost the owner can cut, such as marketing, must be a variable cost.

Better reasoning

Whether a cost is fixed or variable depends on whether it changes with output, not on whether it can be changed by a decision. Marketing of €480 a month is fixed: it is the same whether the studio makes 500 mugs or 700.

Fixed, within a range

Source: Subject knowledge

Fixed costs are fixed only within a range of output and over a period. The kiln can fire 1,200 mugs a month. To make more, Atelier Barro would need a second kiln, and its fixed costs would step up. Over a long enough period every cost can change, which is why break-even analysis is a short-run tool.

Section 03: Revenue and revenue streams

Where the money comes from, before any cost is paid.

Source: Subject knowledge
Total revenue

The value of a business's sales in a period, found by multiplying the price of each product by the quantity sold and adding up.

Source: Subject knowledge
Revenue stream

A distinct source of revenue, such as sales of a product, fees for a service, subscriptions, commissions or licences.

Exhibit 2

Revenue streams, last twelve months

Source: Simulated data From the case file: Atelier Barro
Stream Basis Revenue, €
Mug sales, online shop5,376 mugs at €22118,272
Mug sales, studio shop2,304 mugs at €2250,688
Weekend workshops24 sessions, 8 people, €55 each10,560
Kiln firing for other pottersCharged per firing3,600
Total183,120

Mug sales were 92% of revenue. The workshops and firing service have costs of their own, which are not in Exhibit 1.

Source Simulated teaching data.
Reading the exhibit

Atelier Barro has four revenue streams, but mugs bring in 92% of the money. The workshops and the firing service use the studio's spare capacity. Notice that each stream has its own costs: revenue alone does not say which stream is worth growing.

Common revenue streams

Source: Subject knowledge
Sales of goods
The price of each item sold, as with Atelier Barro's mugs.
Fees for services
Payment for work done, as with the studio's workshops and firing service.
Subscriptions
Regular payments for continuing access, as with a streaming service.
Commission
A share of the value of sales made on behalf of others, as with an estate agent.
Licensing and royalties
Payment for the right to use a brand, design or idea, as with franchise royalties.
Advertising
Payment for access to an audience, as with a free app or website.
Rental
Payment for the use of an asset, as with renting out kiln time or equipment.
Source: Simulated data

Total revenue from mugs in an average month

Given
  • Selling price per mug: €22.00
  • Sales per month: 640 mugs
Formula
Total revenue = selling price per unit × quantity sold
Substitution
= €22.00 × 640
Working
22.00 × 640 = 14,080.00
Answer
€14,080
Unit
€ per month
Interpretation

The mugs bring in €14,080 in an average month, before any cost is paid.

Business implication

Revenue says nothing about profit on its own. The studio's costs that month are almost as large.

Source: Subject knowledge
Misconception

Rising revenue means the business is doing better.

Better reasoning

Revenue is not profit. Suppose Atelier Barro cut its price to €20 and sales rose to 720 mugs a month. Revenue would rise from €14,080 to €14,400. But each mug would contribute only €12.90 instead of €14.82, so total contribution, and with it profit, would fall: from €9,484.80 to €9,288. The studio would work harder for less.

Section 04: Total cost, total revenue and profit

Three calculations, each set out the same way.

Source: Subject knowledge

Total cost

TC = TFC + (AVC × Q)

TC
Total cost
TFC
Total fixed costs
AVC
Variable cost per unit
Q
Output
Source: Simulated data

Atelier Barro's total cost in an average month, from November

Given
  • Fixed costs per month: €8,140
  • Variable cost per mug: €7.18
  • Output per month: 640 mugs
Formula
Total cost = total fixed costs + (variable cost per unit × output)
Substitution
= €8,140 + (€7.18 × 640)
Working
Total variable cost = 7.18 × 640 = 4,595.20
8,140.00 + 4,595.20 = 12,735.20
Answer
€12,735.20
Unit
€ per month
Interpretation

Making and selling 640 mugs costs €12,735.20 a month in total.

Business implication

Of that, €8,140 is paid whatever happens. Only €4,595.20 depends on how many mugs are made.

Source: Simulated data

Atelier Barro's profit in an average month, from November, at €22

Given
  • Selling price per mug: €22.00
  • Variable cost per mug: €7.18
  • Fixed costs per month: €8,140
  • Sales per month: 640 mugs
Formula
Profit = total revenue − total cost
Substitution
= (€22.00 × 640) − (€8,140 + €7.18 × 640)
Working
Total revenue = 22.00 × 640 = 14,080.00
Total cost = 8,140.00 + 4,595.20 = 12,735.20
14,080.00 − 12,735.20 = 1,344.80
Answer
€1,344.80
Unit
€ per month
Interpretation

The studio makes €1,344.80 a month, down from €1,616.80 before the new electricity tariff.

Business implication

The cost rise takes about a sixth of the studio's profit if nothing else changes. That is the problem the owner has to solve.

Section 05: From costs to break-even

Contribution connects costs and revenue. Break-even analysis is subtopic 5.5; its inputs are the costs of 3.3.

Source: Subject knowledge
Contribution

The amount each unit sold adds towards paying the fixed costs and, once they are covered, towards profit. Contribution per unit is the selling price minus the variable cost per unit.

Source: Simulated data

Contribution per mug at €22, from November

Given
  • Selling price per mug: €22.00
  • Variable cost per mug: €7.18
Formula
Contribution per unit = selling price per unit − variable cost per unit
Substitution
= €22.00 − €7.18
Working
22.00 − 7.18 = 14.82
Answer
€14.82
Unit
€ per mug
Interpretation

Each mug sold adds €14.82 towards the studio's €8,140 of monthly costs.

Business implication

This is the figure that answers "what does one more mug do for the business?"

Source: Simulated data

Break-even quantity at €22, from November

Given
  • Fixed costs per month: €8,140
  • Selling price per mug: €22.00
  • Variable cost per mug: €7.18
Formula
Break-even quantity = fixed costs ÷ contribution per unit
Substitution
= €8,140 ÷ (€22.00 − €7.18)
Working
Contribution per unit = 22.00 − 7.18 = 14.82
8,140.00 ÷ 14.82 = 549.26
Answer
550 mugs

Rounded up, not to the nearest whole number: at 549 mugs the result would be a loss of €3.82.

Unit
mugs per month
Interpretation

The studio must sell 550 mugs a month to cover all its costs.

Business implication

In an average month it sells 640, so it is above break-even, but only just.

Source: Simulated data

Margin of safety at 640 mugs, from November

Given
  • Forecast sales per month: 640 mugs
  • Fixed costs per month: €8,140
  • Selling price per mug: €22.00
  • Variable cost per mug: €7.18
Formula
Margin of safety = forecast (or actual) output − break-even output
Substitution
= 640 − (€8,140 ÷ (€22.00 − €7.18))
Working
Break-even output = 8,140.00 ÷ 14.82 = 549.26, rounded up to 550
640 − 550 = 90
As a share of forecast sales: 90 ÷ 640 × 100 = 14.1%
Answer
90 mugs

Sales could fall by 90 mugs (14.1%) before the business makes a loss.

Unit
mugs per month
Interpretation

Sales could fall by 90 mugs a month, about 14%, before the studio makes a loss.

Business implication

A slow month, or a lost wholesale customer, could wipe out the profit. That is why the owner is worried.

Interaction

Work the numbers yourself

Source: Simulated data

Change the price, the costs or the forecast and watch every figure, the chart and the working update. Try each scenario, then predict before you click the next.

Inputs
Excluding costs that are a share of the price.
Card fees, commissions, royalties.
Try a scenario

Each scenario changes only the inputs it names, starting from the case's figures.

Results

Variable cost per mug
€7.18includes 4% of the price
Contribution per mug
€14.82
Break-even quantity
550 mugsexactly 549.26, rounded up
Break-even revenue
€12,083.67
Margin of safety
90 mugs14.1% of forecast sales
Profit at forecast sales
€1,344.80
Output for the target profit
685 mugswithin capacity

Reading. The business must sell 550 mugs a month to cover its costs. At forecast sales of 640 it makes a profit of €1,344.80, and sales could fall by 90 mugs (14.1%) before it makes a loss.

Implication. The business could absorb a moderate fall in sales, but each mug lost costs €14.82 of profit.

Break-even chartTotal revenue and total cost meet at 550 mugs a month (the break-even point, rounded up). Forecast sales of 640 give a margin of safety of 90 and a profit of €1,344.80. Capacity is 1,200.010,00020,00030,00040,00005001,0001,500mugs a month€ a monthLossProfitTotal revenueTotal costFixed costsCapacity 1,200Forecast 640Margin of safety 90Break-even 550
Chart Total revenue (blue), total cost (black) and fixed costs (dashed). Simulated teaching data from the case file; the chart is redrawn from the inputs above.
The chart's figures as a table
PointOutputTotal revenueTotal costProfit or loss
Zero output0 mugs€0.00€8,140.00−€8,140.00
Break-even550 mugs€12,100.00€12,089.00€11.00
Forecast640 mugs€14,080.00€12,735.20€1,344.80
Capacity1,200 mugs€26,400.00€16,756.00€9,644.00

The working: break-even quantity

Given
  • Fixed costs per month: €8,140
  • Selling price per mug: €22.00
  • Variable cost per mug: €7.18
Formula
Break-even quantity = fixed costs ÷ contribution per unit
Substitution
= €8,140 ÷ (€22.00 − €7.18)
Working
Contribution per unit = 22.00 − 7.18 = 14.82
8,140.00 ÷ 14.82 = 549.26
Answer
550 mugs

Rounded up, not to the nearest whole number: at 549 mugs the result would be a loss of €3.82.

Unit
mugs per month
Interpretation
The business must sell 550 mugs a month to cover its costs. At forecast sales of 640 it makes a profit of €1,344.80, and sales could fall by 90 mugs (14.1%) before it makes a loss.
Business implication
The business could absorb a moderate fall in sales, but each mug lost costs €14.82 of profit.

Interaction

Find the error

Source: Subject knowledge

Each worked solution below contains one wrong line. Find it before you look at the explanation.

Each solution has exactly one wrong line. Choose it, then check.

  1. Solution 1 of 5

    Calculate Atelier Barro's break-even quantity from November, at a price of €22.

    Which line contains the error?
  2. Solution 2 of 5

    Calculate the break-even quantity before November, at a price of €22.

    Which line contains the error?
  3. Solution 3 of 5

    Calculate contribution per mug at a price of €24, from November.

    Which line contains the error?
  4. Solution 4 of 5

    Calculate the margin of safety at 640 mugs a month and a price of €22, from November.

    Which line contains the error?
  5. Solution 5 of 5

    How many mugs must the studio sell at €22 to make a profit of €2,000 a month, from November?

    Which line contains the error?

Choose an answer for each item, then open its answer to compare. 5 to do. Choose your answers, then check each one or check them all.

Section 06: Costs and revenue streams across industries

Every business has fixed and variable costs and at least one revenue stream; the balance decides how its profit behaves.

Source: Subject knowledge

The same two questions about costs, how they behave and whether they can be traced, apply in every industry, but the answers differ. In some businesses most costs are fixed: an airline pays for its aircraft and crews whether a flight is full or half empty, and a software company pays its developers whatever it sells. In others most costs are variable: a supermarket's largest cost is the goods it sells, and a builder buys the materials for each job. Revenue streams differ as much, from a single product to tickets, subscriptions, advertising and licences.

The balance matters because it decides how profit responds when sales change. Where fixed costs are high, each extra sale adds a large contribution, so profit rises fast when sales grow and falls fast when they shrink. Where variable costs are high, profit moves more gently in both directions. At HL, subtopic 5.6 calls this operating leverage.

Cost structures and revenue streams in six industries

Source: Subject knowledge

Typical patterns, which vary from one business to another within each industry.

Aspect Typical fixed costsTypical variable costsMain revenue streams
Airline Aircraft leases, salaried crews, maintenance programmes and the head office.Fuel and airport charges for each flight, and catering for each passenger.Tickets, baggage and seat fees, cargo, and fees from partners in loyalty schemes.
Software sold by subscription Developers' salaries, offices and most server capacity.Payment fees and some hosting for each extra user.Monthly or annual subscriptions, premium tiers, and fees for setting up and supporting large customers.
Hotel The building or its lease, salaried staff and insurance.Cleaning, laundry and energy for each occupied room, and commission to booking websites.Room nights, food and drink, events and meeting rooms, and parking.
Supermarket Store rents, salaried managers, systems and distribution centres.The goods it sells, by far the largest cost, plus packaging and card fees.Sales of products, delivery charges, and payments from suppliers for promotions.
Professional football club Players' and staff wages under contract, and the stadium.Stewarding and catering for each match.Match tickets, broadcasting rights, sponsorship, merchandise and fees for players transferred to other clubs.
Social enterprise café Rent, and the salaries of the trainers who teach young people to cook.Ingredients and packaging.Food and drink sales, catering contracts, and grants for the training it provides.

Two gyms, two cost structures (fictional)

Source: Simulated data

Two fictional gyms each have 1,000 members paying $45 a month, so each takes $45,000 a month and makes a profit of $5,000.

  • Ironside Gym employs salaried staff and owns its equipment: fixed costs of $38,000 a month and a variable cost of $2 a member, for towels and card fees. Each member contributes $43.
  • Flowline Studios pays its instructors for each class they teach, so its costs follow attendance: fixed costs of $15,000 a month and a variable cost of $25 a member. Each member contributes $20.

If membership rises by 20% to 1,200, Ironside's profit rises to $13,600 and Flowline's to $9,000. If it falls by 20% to 800, Ironside makes a loss of $3,600 while Flowline still makes $1,000. Ironside breaks even at 884 members ($38,000 ÷ $43 = 883.7, rounded up) and Flowline at 750 ($15,000 ÷ $20). Same profit today, very different risk: the gym with high fixed costs gains more in a good year and loses more in a bad one.

An aquarium's revenue streams (fictional)

Source: Simulated data

Tidewater Aquarium, a fictional charity, took $2,000,000 last year from five streams: tickets $1,040,000 (52%), memberships $360,000 (18%), the café and shop $280,000 (14%), grants and donations $200,000 (10%) and school visits $120,000 (6%).

Five streams look like a spread of risk, but tickets, the café and shop, and school visits all depend on people coming through the door: together $1,440,000, or 72% of revenue. A wet summer or a closure for repairs would hit all three at once. Memberships are paid in advance and grants are agreed for a year, so they are steadier, which is why the aquarium is trying to grow its membership.

Source: Subject knowledge
Misconception

More revenue streams always make a business safer.

Better reasoning

Only if the streams do not depend on the same customers or events. Tidewater's tickets, café and school visits are three streams with one weakness, the number of visitors, so a bad season hits them together.

Section 07: The evidence

The ledger is the only source of costs. The survey is the only source of demand.

Exhibit 1

Cost ledger, before and from 1 November

Source: Simulated data From the case file: Atelier Barro
Cost How it is incurred Before, € From November, €
Studio rentEach month1,9001,900
Kiln leaseEach month450450
Studio manager's salaryEach month2,3002,300
Owner's salaryEach month2,4002,400
InsuranceEach month150150
Website and softwareEach month120120
Marketing (social media advertising)Each month480480
Electricity standing chargeEach month260340
Electricity for firingPer mug0.450.75
Clay and glazePer mug2.302.30
Thrower's piece ratePer mug2.402.40
PackagingPer mug0.850.85
Card and platform feesPer mug, 4% of the price0.880.88

Costs incurred each month total €8,060 before November and €8,140 from November. Costs per mug total €6.88 and €7.18 at a price of €22. The card and platform fee is 4% of the price, so it changes if the price changes. All the studio's monthly costs are counted against the mugs; workshops and firing services are left out.

Source Simulated teaching data, from the studio's accounts and the supplier's letter.
Reading the exhibit

Read down the second column: most of the studio's costs are incurred each month, whatever is made. The fee of 4% of the price is the cost most often forgotten when the price changes.

Exhibit 3

Customer survey and price test, estimated mugs sold a month at each price

Source: Simulated data From the case file: Atelier Barro
Price, € Estimated mugs a month Basis of the estimate
20700Survey
22640Actual average over the last twelve months
24590Survey and a two-week price test on the website
25560Survey
27480Survey

Survey of 410 customers in September; price test at €24 for two weeks in October. The estimates assume the mugs and the packaging do not change. Inês believes premium packaging could hold sales nearer 580 at €25, but that has not been tested.

Source Simulated teaching data. Survey estimates are judgements about behaviour, not records of it.
Reading the exhibit

Every pricing decision rests on this table, and every figure in it except the current one is an estimate. Ask how much a decision would change if the estimate were wrong.

Section 08: Make the decisions

Price first, then the hotel's order.

Section 09: The arithmetic and the judgement

A calculation answers a narrower question than the decision.

What the calculation tells you, and what you still have to judge

Source: Arjun Agrawal framework
Aspect What the calculation tells youWhat you still have to judge
Raising the price to €24 Contribution per mug rises to €16.74 and the break-even quantity falls to 487.Whether sales really fall only to 590, and how regular customers feel about it.
Cutting marketing Fixed costs fall by €280 and the break-even quantity falls to 531.How far sales depend on the advertising being cut.
The hotel's order The order adds €1,395 to November's profit.Whether half-price mugs in hotel rooms change what shop customers will pay.

The limits of break-even analysis

Source: Subject knowledge
  • It assumes the price and the variable cost per unit stay the same at every level of output. In practice bulk discounts and price cuts change both.
  • It assumes every unit produced is sold, with no stock left over.
  • It assumes fixed costs are fixed. Above the kiln's capacity they would step up.
  • It is simplest for one product. With several products, the answer depends on the mix sold.
  • It is only as good as the estimates it uses, and the sales estimate is often the weakest.

Sources Business management guide, first assessment 2024 (published February 2022, updated May 2022)

Source: Simulated data HL only

The hotel's order at €11

Given
  • Price offered per mug: €11.00
  • Variable cost per mug: €5.85
  • Order size: 300 mugs
  • Extra costs caused only by the order: €150
Formula
Change in profit = (order price − variable cost per unit) × order size − extra fixed costs
Substitution
= (€11.00 − €5.85) × 300 − €150
Working
Contribution per unit on the order = 11.00 − 5.85 = 5.15
5.15 × 300 = 1,545.00
1,545.00 − 150.00 = 1,395.00
Answer
€1,395

Valid only if there is spare capacity and the lower price does not change what regular customers pay or buy.

Unit
€, change in profit for the month
Interpretation

The order adds €1,395 to November's profit.

Business implication

On the numbers, accept. The judgement is whether the order harms the price position, and whether the kiln can take it in November.

Interaction

Test the order on contribution

Source: Simulated data HL only
The order
Clay, the thrower's piece rate, firing and bulk packaging. No card fee on an invoiced order.
€14.82, the contribution of a shop mug at €22 from November (Exhibit 1).
Total cost divided by mugs sold, at 640 mugs a month. It includes fixed costs.
Try a scenario

Each scenario changes only what it names, starting from the offer.

Results

Contribution per mug on the order
€5.15
Contribution from the order
€1,545.00
Spare capacity before the order
370 mugs
Regular sales displaced
0 mugsnone
Change in profit
+€1,395.00
Lowest price that does not reduce profit
€6.35average cost is €19.90

Reading. The price is €8.90 below the average cost of a mug, yet the order adds €1,395.00. Regular sales already cover the fixed costs, so each mug on the order only has to cover its own variable cost of €5.85.

Implication. On these figures the lowest price that does not reduce profit is €6.35 a mug. Before accepting, weigh what the figures leave out: whether regular customers would expect the same price, and what the order does to the brand.

The working: change in profit

Given
  • Price offered per mug: €11.00
  • Variable cost per mug: €5.85
  • Order size: 300 mugs
  • Extra costs caused only by the order: €150
Formula
Change in profit = (order price − variable cost per unit) × order size − extra fixed costs
Substitution
= (€11.00 − €5.85) × 300 − €150
Working
Contribution per unit on the order = 11.00 − 5.85 = 5.15
5.15 × 300 = 1,545.00
1,545.00 − 150.00 = 1,395.00
Answer
€1,395

Valid only if there is spare capacity and the lower price does not change what regular customers pay or buy.

Unit
€, change in profit for the month
Interpretation
The price is €8.90 below the average cost of a mug, yet the order adds €1,395.00. Regular sales already cover the fixed costs, so each mug on the order only has to cover its own variable cost of €5.85.
Business implication
On these figures the lowest price that does not reduce profit is €6.35 a mug. Before accepting, weigh what the figures leave out: whether regular customers would expect the same price, and what the order does to the brand.

Think it through

  1. Why does the order add profit when its price is below the average cost of a mug?
  2. What would accepting the order cost if it were for December, when regular sales are about 1,020 mugs?
  3. What could the order cost the studio that this calculation does not show?

Source: Subject knowledge HL only
Misconception

An order priced below the average cost of a unit must lose money.

Better reasoning

Average cost includes fixed costs that are already covered by regular sales. If they are, the order only has to cover its own variable costs to add profit. The belief is right only when the order displaces sales at the full price or needs extra fixed costs.

HL This section has HL-only material, hidden while you are viewing SL content. Switch to HL at the top of the page to see it.

Section 10: Who pays, who gains

Every decision about costs or prices moves money between groups. The arithmetic shows how much; the stakeholders decide whether it works.

Source: Subject knowledge

A business can respond to a rise in costs by raising its price, cutting other costs, changing what it sells or accepting lower profit, and each response moves the burden onto a different group. A price rise falls on customers; cheaper materials may fall on quality and so, in time, on customers again; a cut in pay or hours falls on employees; slower payment falls on suppliers. Contribution and break-even show how large each effect is, which is what makes a stakeholder analysis (1.4) of a cost decision precise rather than general.

Atelier Barro's options and its stakeholders, in a month from November

Source: Simulated data

From the cost ledger, the price test and the hotel's request. The price rise assumes that sales fall to 590 mugs a month, as the survey and the price test suggest.

Aspect Raise the price to €24Cut marketing by €280Accept the hotel's order
Inês, the owner Profit rises from €1,344.80 to €1,736.60 a month, if sales fall only to 590 mugs.Profit rises by €280 a month if sales hold, but each lost mug costs €14.82, so 19 fewer mugs would wipe out the saving.€1,395 more profit in November, and a possible repeat order next year.
The two throwers 50 fewer mugs a month, so €120 less pay between them at €2.40 a mug.No change, unless fewer advertisements mean fewer sales.300 more mugs, so €720 more pay between them in November.
Rui, the studio manager Fewer orders to pack, and questions from regular customers about the price.Less advertising to run, and more pressure on the website to sell without it.A busier November, with 300 hotel mugs on top of the season's 830.
Online and studio customers Pay €2 more, about 9%; about 50 a month stop buying, by the survey estimate.See fewer advertisements, so fewer new customers find the studio.May find the same mugs in hotel rooms at half the price, which could change what they think a mug is worth.
Casa Alfama Hotels No effect.No effect.300 distinctive local mugs at €11 each, delivered for its guests' winter season.

Beyond the studio: who carries a change in costs

Source: Subject knowledge
Customers
Pay for cost rises through prices, or through quality when cheaper materials replace better ones.
Employees
Paid by the piece, they share the risk of falling sales, because their pay is a variable cost. On salaries they are protected week to week, but a business with high fixed costs may cut jobs when sales fall.
Suppliers
Feel cost-cutting as pressure on their prices or as slower payment.
Owners
Take what is left. A business with high fixed costs gives them large profits in good years and losses in bad ones.
Government
Collects taxes on profit and on sales, so it shares in the result, and sets rules, such as a minimum wage or taxes on energy, that change costs for many businesses at once.
The environment
Using less energy lowers a variable cost and emissions at the same time, which is why rising energy prices can push businesses towards more sustainable processes.
Source: Subject knowledge
Misconception

Cutting costs is always good for a business.

Better reasoning

It depends on which costs, and on who bears the cut. Cutting marketing lowers fixed costs, but if Atelier Barro's sales then fall by 19 mugs a month or more, its profit falls. Cutting the piece rate would raise contribution, but could cost the studio its throwers, and with them its product.

Section 11: Exam-style practice

Original questions in the style of the papers, each followed by what a strong response does. They are not IB questions, and the guidance is not an official markscheme. Answer before you read it.

Question 1 · Suggest · 4 marks

Source: Original practice question

Suggest two ways Atelier Barro could reduce the effect of the electricity price rise on its costs, other than by raising its price.

Question 2 · Demonstrate · 4 marks

Source: Original practice question

Ironside Gym and Flowline Studios, two fictional gyms, each have 1,000 members paying $45 a month. Ironside has fixed costs of $38,000 a month and a variable cost of $2 a member; Flowline has fixed costs of $15,000 a month and a variable cost of $25 a member.

Demonstrate why the gym with the higher fixed costs gains more when membership rises by 20%, and loses more when it falls by 20%.

Question 3 · Comment · 4 marks

Source: Original practice question

Tidewater Aquarium, a fictional charity, took $2,000,000 last year: tickets $1,040,000, memberships $360,000, the café and shop $280,000, grants and donations $200,000, and school visits $120,000.

Comment on the spread of the aquarium's revenue streams.

Question 4 · Analyse · 6 marks

Source: Original practice question

Analyse the effect of raising the price of a mug from €22 to €24 on two of Atelier Barro's stakeholders.

Section 12: Diagrams

Original diagrams from the platform's library for this subtopic, each with a text description.

Costs and revenue as output changesFour small charts against output, using fictional figures. Fixed costs, such as rent and salaries, stay at $20,000 whatever the output in the short run. Variable costs, such as materials and packaging, rise by $15 with each unit. Total costs are fixed plus variable costs, so they start at $20,000 and rise by $15 a unit. Total revenue is price times quantity sold, rising by $25 a unit from zero. Costs can also be direct, traced to one product, or indirect overheads shared across products.Fixed costsOutputDo not change with outputin the short run: rent,salaries. Here $20,000.Variable costsOutputRise with each unit made:materials, packaging. Here$15 a unit.Total costsOutputFixed plus variable costs.They start at the fixedcosts.Total revenueOutputPrice × quantity sold.Here $25 a unit.

Costs and revenue as output changes Fixed, variable and total costs, and total revenue.
Text description

Four small charts against output, using fictional figures. Fixed costs, such as rent and salaries, stay at $20,000 whatever the output in the short run. Variable costs, such as materials and packaging, rise by $15 with each unit. Total costs are fixed plus variable costs, so they start at $20,000 and rise by $15 a unit. Total revenue is price times quantity sold, rising by $25 a unit from zero. Costs can also be direct, traced to one product, or indirect overheads shared across products.

The break-even chartBreak-even chart for a fictional product selling at $25 with a variable cost of $15 a unit and fixed costs of $20,000. Fixed costs are a horizontal line at $20,000. Total costs start at $20,000 and rise by $15 a unit. Total revenue starts at zero and rises by $25 a unit. The lines cross at the break-even point, 2,000 units and $50,000 of revenue. Below that output the gap between the lines is a loss; above it, a profit. At current sales of 3,000 units the margin of safety is 1,000 units and the profit is $10,000.0$20k$40k$60k$80k$100k01,0002,0003,0004,000Output and sales (units)Costs and revenue ($)LossProfitFixed costsTotal costsTotal revenueBreak-even point2,000 units, $50,000Current sales 3,000 unitsMargin of safety 1,000 unitsProfit at current sales $10,000Fictional: price $25, variable cost $15 a unit, fixed costs $20,000.
The break-even chartBreak-even chart for a fictional product selling at $25 with a variable cost of $15 a unit and fixed costs of $20,000. Fixed costs are a horizontal line at $20,000. Total costs start at $20,000 and rise by $15 a unit. Total revenue starts at zero and rises by $25 a unit. The lines cross at the break-even point, 2,000 units and $50,000 of revenue. Below that output the gap between the lines is a loss; above it, a profit. At current sales of 3,000 units the margin of safety is 1,000 units and the profit is $10,000.0$50k$100k02,0004,000Costs and revenueOutput (units)FCTCTRBreak-even: 2,000 units, $50,000 ofrevenue, where total revenue (TR)meets total costs (TC).At current sales of 3,000 units(dotted line): margin of safety 1,000units, profit $10,000.Shaded: loss below break-even, profitabove it. FC: fixed costs.Fictional: price $25, variable cost$15 a unit, fixed costs $20,000.

The break-even chart Where total revenue meets total costs; profit, loss and the margin of safety on either side.
Text description

Break-even chart for a fictional product selling at $25 with a variable cost of $15 a unit and fixed costs of $20,000. Fixed costs are a horizontal line at $20,000. Total costs start at $20,000 and rise by $15 a unit. Total revenue starts at zero and rises by $25 a unit. The lines cross at the break-even point, 2,000 units and $50,000 of revenue. Below that output the gap between the lines is a loss; above it, a profit. At current sales of 3,000 units the margin of safety is 1,000 units and the profit is $10,000.

Every diagram in the library

Section 13: Practice questions

Original practice questions in the style of each paper. They are not IB questions, and their marks and level descriptors are the platform's.

Paper 2 style [2 marks]

Why electricity is semi-variable

Source: Original practice question Command term: Explain AO2

Based on the case Atelier Barro (fictional, simulated data).

Exhibit 1

Cost ledger, before and from 1 November

Source: Simulated data From the case file: Atelier Barro
Cost How it is incurred Before, € From November, €
Studio rentEach month1,9001,900
Kiln leaseEach month450450
Studio manager's salaryEach month2,3002,300
Owner's salaryEach month2,4002,400
InsuranceEach month150150
Website and softwareEach month120120
Marketing (social media advertising)Each month480480
Electricity standing chargeEach month260340
Electricity for firingPer mug0.450.75
Clay and glazePer mug2.302.30
Thrower's piece ratePer mug2.402.40
PackagingPer mug0.850.85
Card and platform feesPer mug, 4% of the price0.880.88

Costs incurred each month total €8,060 before November and €8,140 from November. Costs per mug total €6.88 and €7.18 at a price of €22. The card and platform fee is 4% of the price, so it changes if the price changes. All the studio's monthly costs are counted against the mugs; workshops and firing services are left out.

Source Simulated teaching data, from the studio's accounts and the supplier's letter.

Explain why electricity is a semi-variable cost for Atelier Barro.

Write your answer before you open the mark scheme. It is saved on this device only.
Mark scheme and guidance
Source: Assessment explanation
Award marks for

Tick each point your answer makes to check it against the mark scheme.

Errors that cost marks
  • Calling electricity variable because the bill goes up in busy months.
  • Describing semi-variable costs in general without the studio's two parts.
Paper 2 style [4 marks]

Direct and indirect costs

Source: Original practice question Command term: Distinguish AO2

Based on the case Atelier Barro (fictional, simulated data).

Exhibit 1

Cost ledger, before and from 1 November

Source: Simulated data From the case file: Atelier Barro
Cost How it is incurred Before, € From November, €
Studio rentEach month1,9001,900
Kiln leaseEach month450450
Studio manager's salaryEach month2,3002,300
Owner's salaryEach month2,4002,400
InsuranceEach month150150
Website and softwareEach month120120
Marketing (social media advertising)Each month480480
Electricity standing chargeEach month260340
Electricity for firingPer mug0.450.75
Clay and glazePer mug2.302.30
Thrower's piece ratePer mug2.402.40
PackagingPer mug0.850.85
Card and platform feesPer mug, 4% of the price0.880.88

Costs incurred each month total €8,060 before November and €8,140 from November. Costs per mug total €6.88 and €7.18 at a price of €22. The card and platform fee is 4% of the price, so it changes if the price changes. All the studio's monthly costs are counted against the mugs; workshops and firing services are left out.

Source Simulated teaching data, from the studio's accounts and the supplier's letter.

Distinguish between a direct cost and an indirect cost, using two costs from Exhibit 1.

Write your answer before you open the mark scheme. It is saved on this device only.
Mark scheme and guidance
Source: Assessment explanation
Award marks for

Tick each point your answer makes to check it against the mark scheme.

Errors that cost marks
  • Confusing direct with variable, and indirect with fixed. The two classifications answer different questions.
Paper 1 style [4 marks]

Revenue streams beyond the mugs

Source: Original practice question Command term: Outline AO1

Based on the case Atelier Barro (fictional, simulated data).

Exhibit 2

Revenue streams, last twelve months

Source: Simulated data From the case file: Atelier Barro
Stream Basis Revenue, €
Mug sales, online shop5,376 mugs at €22118,272
Mug sales, studio shop2,304 mugs at €2250,688
Weekend workshops24 sessions, 8 people, €55 each10,560
Kiln firing for other pottersCharged per firing3,600
Total183,120

Mug sales were 92% of revenue. The workshops and firing service have costs of their own, which are not in Exhibit 1.

Source Simulated teaching data.

Outline two revenue streams of Atelier Barro other than mug sales.

Write your answer before you open the mark scheme. It is saved on this device only.
Mark scheme and guidance
Source: Assessment explanation

For each stream, award [1] for identifying it and [1] for a brief account of how it earns revenue.

Award marks for

Tick each point your answer makes to check it against the mark scheme.

Errors that cost marks
  • Listing the two shops (online and studio) as separate streams. They are channels for the same stream, mug sales.
Paper 2 style [3 marks]

Break-even quantity from November

Source: Original practice question Command term: Calculate AO4

Based on the case Atelier Barro (fictional, simulated data).

Exhibit 1

Cost ledger, before and from 1 November

Source: Simulated data From the case file: Atelier Barro
Cost How it is incurred Before, € From November, €
Studio rentEach month1,9001,900
Kiln leaseEach month450450
Studio manager's salaryEach month2,3002,300
Owner's salaryEach month2,4002,400
InsuranceEach month150150
Website and softwareEach month120120
Marketing (social media advertising)Each month480480
Electricity standing chargeEach month260340
Electricity for firingPer mug0.450.75
Clay and glazePer mug2.302.30
Thrower's piece ratePer mug2.402.40
PackagingPer mug0.850.85
Card and platform feesPer mug, 4% of the price0.880.88

Costs incurred each month total €8,060 before November and €8,140 from November. Costs per mug total €6.88 and €7.18 at a price of €22. The card and platform fee is 4% of the price, so it changes if the price changes. All the studio's monthly costs are counted against the mugs; workshops and firing services are left out.

Source Simulated teaching data, from the studio's accounts and the supplier's letter.

Calculate Atelier Barro's break-even quantity per month from November, at a price of €22. Show your working.

Write your answer before you open the mark scheme. It is saved on this device only.
Mark scheme and guidance
Source: Assessment explanation
Answer

550 mugs a month.

Award marks for

Tick each point your answer makes to check it against the mark scheme.

Errors that cost marks
  • Rounding down to 549, which leaves a loss of €3.82.
  • Dividing the fixed costs by the price instead of by contribution per mug.
Paper 2 style [3 marks]

Margin of safety from November

Source: Original practice question Command term: Calculate AO4

Based on the case Atelier Barro (fictional, simulated data).

Exhibit 1

Cost ledger, before and from 1 November

Source: Simulated data From the case file: Atelier Barro
Cost How it is incurred Before, € From November, €
Studio rentEach month1,9001,900
Kiln leaseEach month450450
Studio manager's salaryEach month2,3002,300
Owner's salaryEach month2,4002,400
InsuranceEach month150150
Website and softwareEach month120120
Marketing (social media advertising)Each month480480
Electricity standing chargeEach month260340
Electricity for firingPer mug0.450.75
Clay and glazePer mug2.302.30
Thrower's piece ratePer mug2.402.40
PackagingPer mug0.850.85
Card and platform feesPer mug, 4% of the price0.880.88

Costs incurred each month total €8,060 before November and €8,140 from November. Costs per mug total €6.88 and €7.18 at a price of €22. The card and platform fee is 4% of the price, so it changes if the price changes. All the studio's monthly costs are counted against the mugs; workshops and firing services are left out.

Source Simulated teaching data, from the studio's accounts and the supplier's letter.

Calculate the margin of safety, in mugs and as a percentage of sales, at 640 mugs a month from November and a price of €22.

Write your answer before you open the mark scheme. It is saved on this device only.
Mark scheme and guidance
Source: Assessment explanation
Answer

90 mugs a month, or 14.1% of sales.

Award marks for

Tick each point your answer makes to check it against the mark scheme.

Errors that cost marks
  • Giving the margin of safety in euros.
  • Confusing it with profit.
Paper 2 style [3 marks]

Profit at €24

Source: Original practice question Command term: Calculate AO4

Based on the case Atelier Barro (fictional, simulated data).

Exhibit 1

Cost ledger, before and from 1 November

Source: Simulated data From the case file: Atelier Barro
Cost How it is incurred Before, € From November, €
Studio rentEach month1,9001,900
Kiln leaseEach month450450
Studio manager's salaryEach month2,3002,300
Owner's salaryEach month2,4002,400
InsuranceEach month150150
Website and softwareEach month120120
Marketing (social media advertising)Each month480480
Electricity standing chargeEach month260340
Electricity for firingPer mug0.450.75
Clay and glazePer mug2.302.30
Thrower's piece ratePer mug2.402.40
PackagingPer mug0.850.85
Card and platform feesPer mug, 4% of the price0.880.88

Costs incurred each month total €8,060 before November and €8,140 from November. Costs per mug total €6.88 and €7.18 at a price of €22. The card and platform fee is 4% of the price, so it changes if the price changes. All the studio's monthly costs are counted against the mugs; workshops and firing services are left out.

Source Simulated teaching data, from the studio's accounts and the supplier's letter.
Exhibit 3

Customer survey and price test, estimated mugs sold a month at each price

Source: Simulated data From the case file: Atelier Barro
Price, € Estimated mugs a month Basis of the estimate
20700Survey
22640Actual average over the last twelve months
24590Survey and a two-week price test on the website
25560Survey
27480Survey

Survey of 410 customers in September; price test at €24 for two weeks in October. The estimates assume the mugs and the packaging do not change. Inês believes premium packaging could hold sales nearer 580 at €25, but that has not been tested.

Source Simulated teaching data. Survey estimates are judgements about behaviour, not records of it.

Using Exhibits 1 and 3, calculate Atelier Barro's monthly profit from November if it raises its price to €24.

Write your answer before you open the mark scheme. It is saved on this device only.
Mark scheme and guidance
Source: Assessment explanation
Answer

€1,736.60 a month.

Award marks for

Tick each point your answer makes to check it against the mark scheme.

Errors that cost marks
  • Keeping the card fee at €0.88, the fee at the old price, which gives €1,783.80.
  • Using 640 mugs instead of the 590 expected at €24.
Paper 2 style [10 marks]

How useful is break-even analysis here?

Source: Original practice question Command term: Evaluate AO3

Based on the case Atelier Barro (fictional, simulated data).

Exhibit 1

Cost ledger, before and from 1 November

Source: Simulated data From the case file: Atelier Barro
Cost How it is incurred Before, € From November, €
Studio rentEach month1,9001,900
Kiln leaseEach month450450
Studio manager's salaryEach month2,3002,300
Owner's salaryEach month2,4002,400
InsuranceEach month150150
Website and softwareEach month120120
Marketing (social media advertising)Each month480480
Electricity standing chargeEach month260340
Electricity for firingPer mug0.450.75
Clay and glazePer mug2.302.30
Thrower's piece ratePer mug2.402.40
PackagingPer mug0.850.85
Card and platform feesPer mug, 4% of the price0.880.88

Costs incurred each month total €8,060 before November and €8,140 from November. Costs per mug total €6.88 and €7.18 at a price of €22. The card and platform fee is 4% of the price, so it changes if the price changes. All the studio's monthly costs are counted against the mugs; workshops and firing services are left out.

Source Simulated teaching data, from the studio's accounts and the supplier's letter.
Exhibit 3

Customer survey and price test, estimated mugs sold a month at each price

Source: Simulated data From the case file: Atelier Barro
Price, € Estimated mugs a month Basis of the estimate
20700Survey
22640Actual average over the last twelve months
24590Survey and a two-week price test on the website
25560Survey
27480Survey

Survey of 410 customers in September; price test at €24 for two weeks in October. The estimates assume the mugs and the packaging do not change. Inês believes premium packaging could hold sales nearer 580 at €25, but that has not been tested.

Source Simulated teaching data. Survey estimates are judgements about behaviour, not records of it.
Exhibit 5

Capacity, the season and the order

Source: Simulated data From the case file: Atelier Barro
Kiln capacity
1,200 mugs a month
Average monthly sales
640 mugs
November sales
About 830 mugs Usually 30% above average
December sales
About 1,020 mugs Usually 60% above average
Custom stamp for the hotel
€150 Once
Packaging for an invoiced bulk order
€0.40 a mug Instead of €0.85
Card and platform fee on an invoiced order
€0
Source Simulated teaching data.

Evaluate the usefulness of break-even analysis to Inês Carvalho in deciding the price of Atelier Barro's mugs.

Write your answer before you open the mark scheme. It is saved on this device only.
Mark scheme and guidance
Source: Assessment explanation

Practice level descriptors written for this question, not the IB's markbands.

These levels were written by the platform for this practice question. They are not the IB's markbands, which are in the Business management guide (pp. 44 to 45 at SL, 47 to 48 at HL) and are not reproduced here.

Which level best fits your answer?
Choose Marks Descriptor
0 Nothing that addresses the question.
1 to 2 Some knowledge of break-even analysis, not applied to Atelier Barro.
3 to 4 Strengths or limitations of break-even analysis, applied to the studio in places, with little weighing.
5 to 6 Strengths and limitations applied to the pricing decision, using the studio's figures, with some weighing.
7 to 8 A balanced evaluation in context. For example, it shows the effect of each price on break-even and the margin of safety, but its result depends on the sales estimates in Exhibit 3. A supported judgement.
9 to 10 As for 7 to 8, with a judgement that says how the analysis should be used (for example, as a test of each price against the uncertain demand estimates) and what else Inês needs to decide.

A strong answer might read

Useful: it shows quickly that at €24 the break-even quantity falls from 550 to 487 mugs and the margin of safety rises, so the studio is safer if the survey is right. Limited: it assumes every mug made is sold, and the sales at each price are estimates, so the answer is only as good as Exhibit 3. It says nothing about the brand or regular customers' reactions. Judgement: useful for comparing prices on the same assumptions, but the decision depends more on the reliability of the demand estimates than on the arithmetic.

Errors that cost marks
  • Listing generic limitations, such as "it assumes a straight line", without saying why they matter for this decision.
  • Forgetting that the 4% fee changes with the price.
Paper 2 style [10 marks]

The hotel's order (HL)

Source: Original practice question HL only Command term: Recommend AO3

Based on the case Atelier Barro (fictional, simulated data).

Exhibit 4

The hotel's request

Source: Simulated data From the case file: Atelier Barro

We would like 300 mugs in your Douro glaze, stamped with our name, delivered to Lisbon by 20 November. We can pay €11 a mug, invoiced. We may want more next year.

Marta Sousa, purchasing manager, Casa Alfama Hotels
Source Fictional email, written for this case.
Exhibit 5

Capacity, the season and the order

Source: Simulated data From the case file: Atelier Barro
Kiln capacity
1,200 mugs a month
Average monthly sales
640 mugs
November sales
About 830 mugs Usually 30% above average
December sales
About 1,020 mugs Usually 60% above average
Custom stamp for the hotel
€150 Once
Packaging for an invoiced bulk order
€0.40 a mug Instead of €0.85
Card and platform fee on an invoiced order
€0
Source Simulated teaching data.

Using contribution, recommend whether Atelier Barro should accept Casa Alfama Hotels' order.

Write your answer before you open the mark scheme. It is saved on this device only.
Mark scheme and guidance
Source: Assessment explanation

In the style of the 10-mark extended response in section B of HL paper 2, which assesses AO3. Practice level descriptors written for this question; the IB's markbands are in the guide and are not reproduced here. The calculation is (€11.00 − €5.85) × 300 − €150 = €1,395.

Answer

The order adds €1,395 to November's profit.

These levels were written by the platform for this practice question. They are not the IB's markbands, which are in the Business management guide (pp. 44 to 45 at SL, 47 to 48 at HL) and are not reproduced here.

Which level best fits your answer?
Choose Marks Descriptor
0 Nothing that addresses the question.
1 to 2 A recommendation with little use of contribution, or a calculation with no recommendation.
3 to 4 A contribution calculation, perhaps with errors, and a recommendation that refers to it, with little use of the case.
5 to 6 A correct calculation and a recommendation that uses it, with some reference to the case beyond the figures, but one-sided.
7 to 8 A correct calculation weighed against at least one non-financial factor from the case, such as the brand or capacity, with a supported recommendation.
9 to 10 As for 7 to 8, balanced, with a recommendation that states its conditions (for example that the order must not fall in December, when it would displace shop sales) and the limits of the data.

Errors that cost marks
  • Comparing the €11 price with the average cost of a mug (about €20) and rejecting the order.
  • Forgetting the €150 stamp.
  • Recommending on the calculation alone, when the question asks for a judgement that weighs the brand and the timing.

HL HL-only questions are hidden while you are viewing SL content.

Section 14: The concept lens

The four IB concepts, applied to this topic's case.

Change

What changes when a cost changes?

An energy price rise changes contribution, the break-even quantity and the margin of safety at once. The concept asks how the business adapts: through its price, through its costs, or through what it makes.

Creativity

Can the business change its cost structure rather than its price?

Atelier Barro could fire fuller kilns, schedule firings at cheaper times, or sell spare kiln time to other potters. Creative answers change the numbers the calculation starts from.

Ethics

Who pays for the cost rise?

Customers through the price, the throwers through fewer mugs at a piece rate, or the owner through lower profit. Passing a cost to the people with the least power to object is a choice, and an ethical one.

Sustainability

Can this cost structure be kept up?

A margin of safety of 90 mugs leaves the studio one bad month from a loss. An energy-intensive process also raises the question of how to use less energy, not just how to pay for it.

Beyond the course

For Entrepreneurs and professionals

Know your three numbers

Source: Arjun Agrawal framework

Contribution per unit, the break-even quantity and the margin of safety. Without them you cannot tell whether a discount, a hire or an order makes you richer or poorer. Include the costs that are a share of the price, such as card fees, marketplace commissions and royalties: they are the ones most often forgotten.

For Undergraduate business and management

From cost behaviour to relevant costing

Source: Enrichment

University management accounting extends this topic into cost-volume-profit analysis, activity-based costing and relevant costing. The hotel's order is an example of relevant costing: only the costs and revenues that change because of the decision count.

For MBA and advanced management

Operating leverage

Source: Enrichment

A business with high fixed costs and a high contribution per unit, like Atelier Barro, has high operating leverage, a measure HL students meet in subtopic 5.6: its profit rises fast when sales rise and falls fast when they fall. MBA finance courses combine it with financial leverage, the extra risk that borrowing adds, to judge how risky a business's profits are. That is why the margin of safety matters more than the profit in a good month.

For Secondary business foundations

For IGCSE and other courses

Source: Arjun Agrawal framework

Most secondary courses teach fixed and variable costs and break-even, often by reading break-even from a chart. Check whether your course uses the word overheads for indirect costs, and whether it expects the contribution method of calculating break-even.

Section 15: Revision

Open the one-page revision brief, ready to print.

Key points

  • Fixed costs do not change with output within a range. Variable costs change in proportion to output. Semi-variable costs have both parts.
  • Direct costs can be traced to a cost object such as a product. Indirect costs, or overheads, cannot.
  • Total cost = fixed costs + (variable cost per unit × output). Total revenue = price × quantity. Profit = total revenue − total cost.
  • Contribution per unit = price − variable cost per unit. Break-even quantity = fixed costs ÷ contribution per unit, rounded up.
  • Margin of safety = actual or forecast output − break-even output, measured in units.
  • Break-even analysis assumes a constant price and unit cost, and that everything produced is sold.
  • Cost structures differ by industry. Where fixed costs are high, profit rises fast when sales grow and falls fast when they shrink; where variable costs are high, profit moves more gently. At HL this is operating leverage (5.6).
  • Every cost or price decision moves money between stakeholders: a price rise falls on customers, a piece rate passes falling sales on to workers, and the owner takes what is left.

Traps

  • Dividing fixed costs by the price instead of by contribution per unit.
  • Rounding the break-even quantity down.
  • Forgetting that a cost which is a share of the price changes when the price changes.
  • Confusing the margin of safety with profit.
  • Counting revenue streams without asking whether they depend on the same customers or events.

Retrieval practice

Answer each question from memory, out loud or on paper, before you reveal the answer. Your ratings also schedule these questions in your flashcards.

  1. What is a semi-variable cost?

    A cost with a fixed part and a part that varies with output, such as electricity with a standing charge and a charge for each unit used.

    How well did you recall it?
  2. Is a piece rate a fixed or a variable cost?

    Variable, because it is paid for each unit produced.

    How well did you recall it?
  3. What is a revenue stream?

    A distinct source of revenue, such as product sales, service fees, subscriptions or commission.

    How well did you recall it?
  4. How do you calculate contribution per unit?

    Selling price per unit minus variable cost per unit.

    How well did you recall it?
  5. Why is the break-even quantity rounded up?

    Because one unit fewer than the exact figure leaves a loss.

    How well did you recall it?
  6. In what is the margin of safety measured?

    In units of output, or as a share of sales. Not in money.

    How well did you recall it?
  7. Two businesses make the same profit. One has high fixed costs and a large contribution per unit; the other has low fixed costs and a small contribution per unit. Whose profit changes more when sales change?

    The one with high fixed costs, because each unit gained or lost changes its profit by its larger contribution.

    How well did you recall it?
  8. Why are several revenue streams not always safer than one?

    If the streams depend on the same customers or events, such as the number of visitors, one bad season hits them all at once.

    How well did you recall it?

Reveal and rate each card.

Section 16: How it connects

Where 3.3 meets the rest of the course: worked connections with an exam-style question on each, then the further links the notes name.

  1. With 2.4 Motivation and demotivation

    Rewards are costs

    Every financial reward in 2.4 is also a cost in 3.3. A salary is a fixed cost, paid whatever the level of output; wages paid by piece rate and sales commission are variable costs, because they rise and fall with output or sales. The choice of reward therefore changes the cost structure: moving sales staff from salary to commission lowers fixed costs but raises the variable cost of every sale, which moves the break-even point and shares the risk of a poor month between the business and its staff, though it may also encourage pushy selling. Fringe payments and profit-related pay add costs that the business hopes better motivation will repay.

    Exam-style question Source: Original practice question Command term: Explain (AO2)

    Explain why sales commission is a variable cost while a salary is a fixed cost. [4 marks]

  2. With 5.5 Break-even analysis

    Costs and revenue are break-even's raw material

    Break-even analysis rests on the classification of costs in 3.3. Fixed costs must be paid whatever the output; variable costs rise with each unit made; and the difference between the price and the variable cost per unit is the contribution each sale makes, first towards fixed costs and then towards profit. The break-even quantity is fixed costs divided by contribution per unit. A cost classified wrongly, such as one that is partly fixed and partly variable treated as wholly fixed, gives a wrong break-even point, and every decision based on it inherits the error.

    Exam-style question Source: Original practice question Command term: Calculate (AO4)

    A café has fixed costs of $6,000 a month. It sells coffee at $4.00 a cup, and the variable cost of each cup is $1.50. Calculate the café's break-even quantity per month. [2 marks]

    The worked answer

    Contribution per unit = $4.00 − $1.50 = $2.50. Break-even quantity = $6,000 ÷ $2.50 = 2,400 cups a month.

Also linked in the notes

See 3.3 on the course connections map, with every link drawn across the five units.

Section 17: Connected learning

Everything else on the platform that teaches, applies or tests 3.3, each labelled by its standing.

Revise
Practise
Cases
Decisions and simulations
Frameworks
Tools
Business Intelligence
Advanced Management
Course connections

Section 18: Connections and sources

For teachers: a lesson sequence and discussion prompts
Source: Arjun Agrawal framework
Minutes Activity
5 Hook. Ask: should Atelier Barro sell a mug for €11 when it charges €22? Take a vote and keep the result.
15 Pairs use the cost classifier, then the class discusses the three costs most pairs disagreed on.
15 Work contribution, the break-even quantity and the margin of safety on the board in the eight-part form, stopping at the rounding.
15 In the break-even workspace, each pair tests one scenario and reports what changed and why.
10 Return to the hook with the special order panel (HL) or the profit comparison (SL), then vote again.
5 Exit ticket. Explain, in one sentence, why the break-even quantity is rounded up.

Discussion prompts

  • Is the owner's salary a cost of the business?
  • When is it right to sell below average cost?
  • Who should bear an energy price rise?
  • What does break-even analysis assume that is not true at Atelier Barro?
  • Who should carry the risk when sales fall, the owner, the workers or the customers?

Watch for students who divide fixed costs by the price, who round the break-even quantity down, and who leave out the 4% fee when the price changes. The error diagnosis activity targets all three.