Unit 1: Introduction to business management

1.6 Multinational companies (MNCs)

SL and HL Full notes Mindmap 8 key terms
Show content for

Showing everything. HL-only material is marked HL.

Study mode

Text size

Section 01: What the IB course asks

The content statements for 1.6, in the platform's words, with the depth of teaching the guide sets (guide, from p. 24).

  • The impact of MNCs on host countries AO3

AO1 knowledge and understanding · AO2 application and analysis · AO3 synthesis and evaluation · AO4 a range of skills. A question can use a command term at its statement's level or below. The whole course.

Section 02: Why it matters

Some of the largest organizations in the world operate in dozens of countries at once. When one of them builds a factory, opens a chain of stores or buys a local firm, the effects reach far beyond its own accounts: jobs, wages, taxes, local businesses, the environment and even the culture of the host country can change.

The guide asks one thing of this subtopic, at its most demanding level: to evaluate the impact of multinational companies (MNCs) on the countries that host them (AO3). That means weighing benefits against costs for a particular company in a particular country, and saying what the balance depends on, rather than reciting a list of advantages and disadvantages.

By the end you can

  1. Describe what makes a company multinational, and the difference between its home country and its host countries.
  2. Explain why companies invest abroad, and why their motive shapes their impact.
  3. Analyse the benefits an MNC can bring to a host country, and the costs and risks it can impose.
  4. Examine how far the impact depends on the type of investment, the industry, the terms agreed and the strength of the host's institutions.
  5. Evaluate the impact of a particular MNC on its host country, using STEEPLE and the interests of different stakeholders.

Section 03: What makes a company multinational

A multinational company (MNC) is a business that owns or controls operations, such as factories, offices, mines, stores or service centres, in more than one country. It is directed from a head office in its home country, where it is legally based and where its main decisions are taken. Every other country in which it operates is a host country, and the guide's question is about those countries: what does the MNC's presence do to them?

The key word is operations. A business that only exports, selling abroad what it makes at home, trades internationally but is not multinational, because it has nothing in the countries it sells to. An MNC invests in its host countries through foreign direct investment (FDI): it builds a new site from scratch (a greenfield investment), buys or merges with a business that already operates there, or forms a joint venture with a local partner. These are the external growth methods of 1.5, used across a border. Franchising sits on the boundary: a franchisor may have outlets in fifty countries, but local franchisees invest in and own them, so its own presence in each host is small.

MNCs range from global giants to medium-sized firms with a single plant abroad, and they work in every sector: mining and farming, manufacturing, retailing, banking, technology and services. The largest employ hundreds of thousands of people and can choose between many possible host countries. That choice is the source of their bargaining power over governments that compete for their investment, and it runs through every judgement about their impact.

Multinational company (MNC)

A business with operations in at least two countries, directed from a head office in its home country. Also called a multinational corporation or multinational enterprise.

Home country

The country where the MNC has its head office and legal base. Its main shareholders and senior managers are usually there, and profits earned abroad are often sent back to it.

Host country

Any country in which the MNC operates outside its home country. One MNC can have many host countries, and its impact can differ in each.

Foreign direct investment (FDI)

Investment in operations that the investor will own or control in another country, by building, buying or partnering. Buying a few shares in a foreign company purely for income is not FDI, because it brings no say in how the business is run.

International trade is not enough

Exporting, or licensing a brand or patent to a foreign firm, involves no operations abroad, so on its own it does not make a business multinational.

Section 04: Why companies invest abroad, and why the motive matters

Operating abroad is costly and risky. A company must learn new laws, languages and customs, manage people at a distance and accept exposure to changes in exchange rates and politics. It takes on these costs because it expects higher returns than it could earn by staying at home or simply exporting, and its reasons usually fall into a few groups. Most investments combine more than one.

The motive matters here because it predicts much of the impact. A company that comes for the host's customers builds stores, offices or a local factory and competes with local firms. One that comes for low wages employs many people, but may leave when wages rise. One that comes for minerals or oil brings enormous capital and pays large royalties, but employs relatively few people and leaves a physical mark on the land. Before judging an MNC's impact, ask why it came, and what it is likely to do next.

New markets

Selling to customers in the host country and its region, especially when the home market is mature. Being close to customers also makes it easier to adapt products to local tastes and to deliver quickly.

Lower costs

Cheaper labour, land, energy or materials lower the cost of each unit. Weaker regulation can lower costs too, which is where the ethical questions begin.

Access to resources

Minerals, energy, farmland, water or specialist skills that exist only in particular places. A mining company has to go where the ore is.

Getting round trade barriers

Producing inside a country, or inside a group of countries that trade freely with each other, avoids tariffs and quotas on imports and can earn goodwill from the government.

Economies of scale and spreading risk

Selling in many markets spreads fixed costs, such as research and brand building, over more units, and a slump in one country can be offset by growth in another.

Incentives from host governments

Tax holidays, grants, cheap land or places in special economic zones offered to attract investment. They change the balance of costs, sometimes decisively.

Section 05: Benefits for the host country

An MNC can bring a host country things it would struggle to provide for itself: capital, technology, management skills and access to markets around the world. Governments compete to attract foreign investment for exactly these reasons. Each benefit is real, but each is possible rather than guaranteed, and each depends on what the company does and on the terms it has agreed.

The benefits also reach beyond the MNC's own gates. A factory buys components, food, transport and cleaning from local businesses, and its employees spend their wages in local shops, so each direct job can support others in the wider economy. Economists call this a multiplier effect. It works only to the extent that the money is spent locally: the benefits shrink when an MNC imports most of what it uses and sends most of its profit home. That is why the share of an MNC's revenue that stays in the host country is a useful test of how much it contributes, as the example shows.

Jobs and incomes

Direct jobs at the MNC, and indirect jobs at its suppliers and in the businesses where its employees spend their wages. MNCs often pay more than local employers, especially for skilled work, and may offer better training and conditions.

Investment and capital

FDI brings money for factories, equipment and infrastructure that the host could not raise at home, without the government having to borrow it.

Technology transfer and skills

New technology, production methods and management practices arrive with the MNC. They spread when local staff are trained and later move to local firms, and when suppliers must raise their standards to win the MNC's orders.

Tax revenue

Taxes on the company's profits, its employees' incomes and its sales help to pay for schools, hospitals and roads, unless incentives reduce them or the company avoids them.

Exports and foreign currency

An MNC that sells abroad from the host earns foreign currency for the country and can open export markets for local suppliers.

Local suppliers and linkages

Contracts to supply parts, food, services and transport give local firms a larger market, and meeting the MNC's quality standards can make them competitive elsewhere.

Infrastructure

Roads, ports, power lines and telecommunications built for or by the MNC can serve the whole area once they exist.

Choice and competition

Consumers gain new products, often at lower prices or higher quality, and local firms are pushed to improve.

The impact of a multinational company on a host countryTwo columns. Possible benefits for the host country: jobs and training for local workers; investment, new technology and know-how; more choice and competition for consumers; tax revenue and export earnings; business for local suppliers; and better infrastructure. Possible costs: local firms forced out by competition; profits sent back to the home country; low-wage or insecure jobs in some cases; pressure on the environment and resources; influence over governments and policy; and tax avoidance through transfer pricing. The balance depends on the company, the country and the terms agreed.Possible benefits for the host countryJobs and training for local workersInvestment, new technology and know-howMore choice and competition for consumersTax revenue and export earningsBusiness for local suppliersBetter infrastructurePossible costs for the host countryLocal firms forced out by competitionProfits sent back to the home countryLow-wage or insecure jobs in some casesPressure on the environment and resourcesInfluence over governments and policyTax avoidance through transfer pricing

MNCs and their host countries The possible benefits and costs to weigh.
Text description

Two columns. Possible benefits for the host country: jobs and training for local workers; investment, new technology and know-how; more choice and competition for consumers; tax revenue and export earnings; business for local suppliers; and better infrastructure. Possible costs: local firms forced out by competition; profits sent back to the home country; low-wage or insecure jobs in some cases; pressure on the environment and resources; influence over governments and policy; and tax avoidance through transfer pricing. The balance depends on the company, the country and the terms agreed.

Section 06: Costs and risks for the host country

The same investment that brings jobs and capital can also impose costs, and they often fall on different people from those who gain. Critics argue that governments eager for good news overstate the benefits, and that the costs arrive later, once the incentives have been paid and the company has the stronger hand.

Many of the costs come from an imbalance of power. A large MNC can usually place its next investment elsewhere, while the host's workers, suppliers and communities cannot move. That gives the company leverage over wages, taxes and regulation, and it means the host can lose heavily if the company leaves. None of the costs below is inevitable, but each is a reason to look closely at the evidence before accepting a government's or a company's claims.

Local firms forced out

Domestic businesses may not be able to match the MNC's prices, brands or technology. If local competitors close, the market comes to depend on foreign owners, and the jobs lost offset some of those created.

Profits sent home

Repatriated profits leave the host's economy. Over the life of an investment, the outflow of profit can exceed the capital that came in.

Tax avoidance through transfer pricing

Subsidiaries of the same MNC trade with one another, and the prices they set can make profit appear in countries with low taxes. The host where the work is done may then collect little tax.

The cost of incentives

Tax holidays and grants mean taxpayers pay for jobs that might have come anyway, and hosts competing for the same investment can bid each other's terms down.

Low pay and poor conditions, in some cases

Where labour laws are weak or poorly enforced, some MNCs and their suppliers pay very low wages, demand long hours or run unsafe workplaces.

Environmental damage

Pollution, waste, heavy water use and the depletion of natural resources, most serious in mining, energy, chemicals and farming, and where regulation is lax.

Footloose investment

An MNC drawn by low costs or incentives may leave when they end, closing plants and leaving unemployment behind. Such investment is called footloose.

Skills drawn away

The MNC's higher pay can draw the best engineers, managers and graduates away from local firms and public services.

Political and cultural influence

A large MNC can lobby for laws that suit it, and global brands can crowd out local products, customs and languages.

Section 07: Weighing the impact with STEEPLE

Because an MNC's impact touches almost every part of a host country, a framework helps to make sure an answer covers the effects that matter and then weighs them. The guide suggests STEEPLE analysis as a toolkit tool for this unit. It is usually used to scan the external environment of a business. Here it is turned around, to scan the effects of a business on its environment.

Work through the seven headings for the particular MNC and host country in the case. Under each, note the likely benefits and costs, the evidence for them, and who feels them. Then judge which effects matter most. The headings will not carry equal weight: for a software company the technological and legal effects may dominate, for a mine the environmental and economic ones. A STEEPLE list is the start of an evaluation, not the evaluation itself.

Social

Jobs, skills, working conditions, people moving to the area for work, and the effects on local communities, health and culture.

Technological

New production methods, management practices and digital systems, and whether local people learn to adapt and improve them or only to operate them.

Economic

Investment, output and incomes, tax revenue, exports and imports, profits sent home, and the effect on local suppliers and competitors.

Environmental

Pollution, waste, water and energy use, land use and the depletion of resources, set against any cleaner technology the MNC introduces.

Political

The government's bargaining power and the incentives it offers, the influence the MNC may gain over policy, and the risk that it leaves.

Legal

Whether the host's laws on employment, health and safety, competition, tax and the environment are strong and enforced, and whether the MNC keeps to them.

Ethical

How the MNC behaves where the law is weak or silent, on pay, conditions, tax, bribery and honesty with communities. This is where its corporate social responsibility (1.3) is tested.

Hofstede's cultural dimensions (toolkit) HL

An HL toolkit tool for comparing national cultures. Large differences between the home and host country, for example in attitudes to hierarchy or to uncertainty, help to explain why an MNC's ways of managing may clash with local expectations, which affects both its success and the experience of its local employees.

HL This section has HL-only points, hidden while you are viewing SL content.

STEEPLE analysisSeven external factors around a business and its decision. Social: demographics, lifestyles and attitudes. Technological: new products, processes and digital change. Economic: growth, inflation, interest and exchange rates. Environmental: climate, resources, pollution and waste. Political: government policy, stability and trade. Legal: employment, consumer and competition law. Ethical: what is right, such as fair pay and honest marketing.The businessand its decisionSSocialDemographics,lifestyles, attitudesTTechnologicalNew products, processes,digital changeEEconomicGrowth, inflation,interest and exchangeratesEEnvironmentalClimate, resources,pollution, wastePPoliticalGovernment policy,stability, tradeLLegalEmployment, consumer andcompetition lawEEthicalWhat is right: fair pay,honest marketing
STEEPLE analysisSeven external factors around a business and its decision. Social: demographics, lifestyles and attitudes. Technological: new products, processes and digital change. Economic: growth, inflation, interest and exchange rates. Environmental: climate, resources, pollution and waste. Political: government policy, stability and trade. Legal: employment, consumer and competition law. Ethical: what is right, such as fair pay and honest marketing.The business and its decisionSSocialDemographics, lifestyles,attitudesTTechnologicalNew products, processes,digital changeEEconomicGrowth, inflation, interestand exchange ratesEEnvironmentalClimate, resources, pollution,wastePPoliticalGovernment policy, stability,tradeLLegalEmployment, consumer andcompetition lawEEthicalWhat is right: fair pay,honest marketing

STEEPLE analysis Seven kinds of external factor that bear on a decision.
Text description

Seven external factors around a business and its decision. Social: demographics, lifestyles and attitudes. Technological: new products, processes and digital change. Economic: growth, inflation, interest and exchange rates. Environmental: climate, resources, pollution and waste. Political: government policy, stability and trade. Legal: employment, consumer and competition law. Ethical: what is right, such as fair pay and honest marketing.

Advantages

  • Makes sure the analysis covers social, environmental, legal and ethical effects, not only jobs and money.
  • Gives a clear structure for a long answer, with each heading a possible paragraph.
  • Separates effects that are often confused, such as a law's existence and its enforcement.

Limitations

  • It lists effects but does not weigh them; the judgement still has to be made.
  • The headings overlap. Weak labour laws are a legal, social and ethical issue at once.
  • It is only as good as the evidence, much of which comes from parties with an interest in the result.

Section 08: What the balance depends on

Whether an MNC is good or bad for a host country cannot be settled in general. The same company can be a valuable partner in one country and a burden in another, and the same investment can look different after ten years than after one. A strong evaluation names the factors that decide the balance in the case, says which way each points, and reaches a judgement that states its conditions.

Two habits help. First, compare with the alternative: what would have happened without the MNC? Jobs at a new supermarket chain are not all new jobs if local shops close, and a tax holiday is a waste of public money if the company would have come anyway. Second, ask for whom. An investment can benefit a country on average while particular groups lose, and deciding whose interests come first is an ethical judgement, not only an economic one.

The type of investment

A greenfield plant adds new capacity and jobs. An acquisition changes the owner of capacity that already exists and may bring job cuts as the business is reorganized, though it can also rescue a struggling local firm.

The industry and the motive

Mining is capital-intensive, with few jobs but large royalties and environmental risks. Assembly is labour-intensive but footloose. Retailing competes directly with local businesses.

Links with the local economy

The more an MNC buys from local suppliers and trains and promotes local managers, the more of its spending and know-how stays in the host. A plant that imports everything and fills its senior posts from abroad adds little beyond its wages.

The terms agreed

Local content requirements, training commitments, environmental standards and the length of any tax holiday shape what the host receives.

The strength of the host's institutions

Laws are only as good as their enforcement. Corruption, slow courts and under-resourced regulators let damaging practices go unchecked.

The MNC's own conduct

Two companies in the same industry can behave very differently. Ethical objectives and CSR matter most where the law is weak.

The time horizon

Construction jobs and tax receipts come quickly; technology transfer and supplier development take years; so can the costs of pollution or of a closure.

Who gains and who loses

An overall gain can hide losers, such as the owners of local firms that close or communities moved off their land. A judgement should say whose interests it puts first.

Section 09: How host governments shape the impact

Host governments are not passive. They decide whether to let an MNC in, on what terms and under what rules, and those decisions shape much of the impact. They face a trade-off. Generous incentives and light rules attract investment but leave the host with a smaller share of its value; tough conditions capture more of the value but may send the company to a rival host.

Their bargaining power varies. A country with a large and growing market, scarce resources or a skilled workforce can set conditions, because the MNC needs what only it can offer. A small country competing with many others for the same factory has far less room, and may find itself bidding against its neighbours with ever larger incentives. The terms are also not fixed for ever: once a plant is built, the company cannot easily move it, and some governments use that moment to raise taxes or tighten rules, which is one reason MNCs value political stability so highly.

Incentives

Tax holidays, grants, subsidized land or energy, and special economic zones with lighter rules. They attract investment but cost public money, and they can draw companies that leave once the incentives end.

Local content requirements

Rules that a share of components or services must be bought from local suppliers. They build links with the local economy but can raise the MNC's costs and lower its quality at first.

Local partners or ownership

Requiring a joint venture with a local firm, which shares profits and know-how but can deter investors that want full control of their technology.

Training and employment commitments

Targets for hiring and training local people, including for senior roles, so that skills stay when the MNC's managers move on.

Regulation and enforcement

Employment, environmental, competition and tax law, including rules on transfer pricing, with regulators who have the resources to enforce them.

Screening

Reviewing proposed investments in sensitive sectors, such as energy, defence or data, and approving them only with conditions, or not at all.

Section 10: In practice: industries and stakeholders

The same ideas look different from one industry to the next, and land differently on each group with a stake in the business.

Across industries

Mining and energy

Projects are capital-intensive, so a huge investment creates relatively few jobs, but royalties and taxes can fund a large share of public spending. The environmental and community risks are the highest of any sector. A host has most bargaining power when prices for its resource are high, and countries that come to rely on one resource export can find their other industries weakening.

Manufacturing and assembly

Plants employ many people and can build strong local supplier networks, through which technology spreads. Low-wage assembly is often footloose, so a host's aim is to move its workforce and suppliers up to more skilled work before rising wages push the MNC elsewhere.

Hotels and tourism

International hotel chains bring visitors, foreign currency and jobs. Much of the spending can leak abroad through imported food and drink, foreign managers and profits sent home, especially in all-inclusive resorts, and many of the jobs are seasonal. Pressure on water, coastlines and local culture can be heavy.

Retail and fast food

Chains bring choice, lower prices and modern supply chains, and some buy much of their food locally. Independent shops and markets may close. When a chain grows by franchising, local owners keep more of the profit, but the brand, the rules and the fees still come from abroad.

Technology platforms

Online platforms can serve a country with few local staff, so they create few direct jobs, and their profits are hard to tax where their users are. Local businesses may gain access to customers, advertising and payment systems, while regulators worry about data, competition and the platform's power over local firms.

Pharmaceuticals and healthcare

MNCs can bring new medicines, clinical expertise and research jobs. Their impact is debated over the prices of patented medicines in poorer host countries and over the ethics of running clinical trials where patients have few other options.

For each stakeholder

Host government

Gains tax revenue, jobs, growth and a reputation for attracting investors, but pays for incentives, loses some freedom over policy and carries the risk of a closure. It is in conflict with the MNC over tax and regulation, and with local firms that resent favours for a foreign competitor.

Local employees

Gain jobs, training and often higher pay than local employers offer. But a single large employer can hold down wages in a small town, conditions vary between companies, and the jobs depend on decisions taken abroad. Their interest in pay conflicts with shareholders' interest in low costs.

Local businesses

Suppliers gain orders and learn to meet higher standards; competitors face a powerful rival; and all may lose skilled staff to the MNC's higher pay. Local business owners are rarely of one mind about an MNC's arrival.

Local community and environmental groups

Gain new roads, services and spending, but may bear the pollution, congestion, water use and loss of land. They often oppose the terms a government offers, which can delay or block a project.

Consumers in the host country

Gain choice, lower prices and often better quality and safety standards, but may lose familiar local brands and see profits leave the country.

The MNC's shareholders and managers

Seek returns from lower costs and new markets, which pushes them towards generous incentives and low taxes. Damage to the host can come back as protests, boycotts and stricter rules, so a company that plans to stay has a reason to care about its impact. Workers in the home country may also lose jobs when production moves abroad.

Section 11: Evaluation and limits

What to weigh before reaching a judgement.

  • There is no general verdict. The impact depends on why the MNC came, the type of investment, the industry, its links with local suppliers, the terms agreed and the host's institutions, so a strong answer names these for the case and says which way they point.
  • Gross gains are not net gains. Jobs at the MNC may replace jobs lost at local competitors, and a factory may have come without the incentives offered for it. Asking what would have happened without the MNC is the most powerful question in this subtopic.
  • Time changes the balance. Construction jobs and tax revenue arrive quickly, technology transfer and supplier development take years, and so can pollution and the risk of a closure. A judgement should say over what period it holds.
  • Averages hide who wins and who loses. A host can gain overall while local firms, displaced communities or a town that depends on one employer lose. Whose interests come first is an ethical judgement, and ethics and sustainability are two of the course's four key concepts.
  • Bargaining power decides how the gains are shared. Hosts with large markets, scarce resources or skilled workers can set conditions; small hosts competing for the same investment often cannot. The same MNC may therefore behave differently in different countries.
  • The evidence is contested. Figures from the company, the government and pressure groups each serve a purpose, so say where the case's evidence is incomplete. The teacher support material notes that even a strong answer to a 10-mark question tends to score 4 marks or fewer if it stays theoretical and never applies its points to the case (p. 57).

Section 12: Make the decision

Use the ideas on a business choice: weigh the options, decide, and say what would change your mind.

Decision brief · a fictional business

How should Halvard enter the province?

Halvard's board must decide how to start production in the coastal province from the situation above. It wants batteries coming off the line within three years, and expects the plant to make a profit of about $75 million a year once running. The provincial government will offer a tax holiday, but the opposition party and the environmental group are campaigning against what they call a giveaway to a foreign company, and an election is due in two years. The board has three proposals.

  1. A wholly owned plant with the full tax holiday

    Halvard builds, owns and runs the plant, imports most components from its home suppliers and takes the ten-year tax holiday. It is the fastest route and gives full control of the technology. About a third of sales would stay in the province.

  2. A joint venture with local conditions

    Halvard owns 60% of the plant and a local engineering group 40%. It commits to buying 30% of parts, materials and services locally by year five and to a training academy costing $4 million a year, and accepts a five-year tax holiday. Slower, with shared profit and control.

  3. Buy and expand a local battery maker

    Halvard buys Pellam Power, a struggling local firm with 600 staff and an old factory, and expands it. Approvals are quicker and no farmland is needed, but the factory must be modernized and some of the 600 jobs may go.

How to weigh the options

Start with what each option does for the host, because Halvard's own risk depends on it. Option A keeps about a third of sales in the province and gives up corporate tax for ten years, roughly $75,000 per direct job. It is the most profitable on paper, but it is the option the opposition can most easily attack as a giveaway, and a deal that a new government reopens, or that a community delays in the courts, is worth less than its forecast suggests.

Option B gives up part of the profit and control: the partner takes 40% of the profit, the academy costs $4 million a year and tax starts after five years. In return, more of each sale stays in the province, through local suppliers and the partner's share of the profit; the partner knows the regulators and the supply base; and the academy answers the engineering firms' complaint that Halvard will simply take their staff. The risks are slower decisions, disputes with the partner and local parts that may not meet Halvard's standards at first.

Option C is quick to approve and spares the farmland, but it buys old capacity rather than adding new, so the province gains little at first, and job cuts at Pellam would turn the welcome sour.

A strong judgement weighs these against Halvard's objectives and time horizon. If the board wants the quickest return and believes the political deal will last, A is defensible. If it means to stay for decades, B buys support and resilience at a cost it can estimate. Say what would change your mind: evidence that local suppliers can meet the quality standard, the opposition's chances at the election, or a rival province offering similar terms.

Section 13: Exam-style practice

Original questions written by the platform in the style of the papers, with what a strong response does. They are not IB questions and the guidance is not an official markscheme.

  1. Question 1 Define 2 marks Paper 1 style Original practice

    Define the term host country.

    What a strong response does

    A strong response gives a precise definition in one or two sentences: a country in which a multinational company operates, other than its home country, where it has its head office.

    • A full definition makes the contrast with the home country clear.
    • "The country an MNC invests in" is only partly right, because it does not say that the host is outside the MNC's home country.
    • No example is needed, and an example cannot replace the definition.
  2. Question 2 Explain 4 marks Paper 1 style Original practice

    Halvard Batteries, a fictional battery maker, plans a $900 million plant employing 2,000 people in a coastal province with high youth unemployment (see the situation above). Explain two benefits the plant could bring to the host country.

    What a strong response does

    A strong response identifies two distinct benefits and explains each with a reason, applied to Halvard and the province. For example:

    • Jobs and incomes: 2,000 direct jobs in a province with high youth unemployment, plus indirect jobs at local suppliers and in the shops where employees spend their wages.
    • Technology transfer and skills: workers new to factory work are trained in battery production and automated assembly, skills that can later spread to local firms.
    • Other valid choices include investment the province could not raise itself, orders for local parts makers, infrastructure, and exports earning foreign currency.

    Tax revenue is a weak choice for this case, because the plant pays no corporate tax for ten years; a response that spots this shows good use of the stimulus. The teacher support material notes that answers to AO2 questions without application to the case are typically limited to half the marks (p. 56).

  3. Question 3 Distinguish 4 marks Paper 1 style Original practice

    Distinguish between a greenfield investment and the acquisition of a local firm as ways for an MNC to enter a host country, in terms of their impact on the host.

    What a strong response does

    A strong response makes the difference clear on both sides, rather than describing each separately.

    • Greenfield: the MNC builds new facilities, so it adds new capacity, construction work and new jobs to the host economy, but it may use new land and compete with existing firms.
    • Acquisition: the MNC buys a business that already operates in the host, so at first the capacity and jobs already exist; the host gains a new owner, possibly new investment and know-how, but the business may be reorganized with job cuts, and decisions move abroad.
    • The key distinction: a greenfield investment adds to what the host has, while an acquisition changes who owns it. An acquisition can still benefit the host, for example by rescuing a struggling firm.
  4. Question 4 Comment 4 marks Paper 1 style Original practice

    Halvard forecasts these figures for the plant's first full year (all $ million): sales 500; components and materials imported from its home country 275; purchases from local suppliers 75; wages for 2,000 local employees 50; energy, water, transport and premises from local providers 25; profit 75, of which 60 will be sent to the home country and 15 reinvested in the plant. No corporate tax is due during the tax holiday.

    Using these figures, comment on how much of the plant's sales revenue would stay in the host country.

    What a strong response does

    A strong response works out the figure, then makes a judgement about it.

    • Revenue that stays in the host: 75 + 50 + 25 + 15 = $165 million, which is 165 ÷ 500 × 100 = 33% of sales.
    • Revenue that leaves: imports of $275 million (55%) and repatriated profit of $60 million (12%), 67% in all.
    • Judgement: $165 million a year is a large injection for one province, but two-thirds of the revenue leaves, mainly because most components are imported, and during the tax holiday the government receives no corporate tax.
    • A top response adds what would raise the share, such as buying more parts locally, reinvesting more profit or taxing profit after the holiday, and notes that these are the company's own forecasts.
  5. Question 5 Analyse 6 marks Paper 1 style Original practice

    Analyse how a ten-year tax holiday affects the balance of benefits and costs of Halvard's plant for the host country.

    What a strong response does

    A strong response breaks the question into its parts and links each to the case.

    • The benefit it may secure: the holiday may be what persuades Halvard to choose this province over rivals, bringing 2,000 jobs, $75 million a year of local purchases and $50 million of wages.
    • The cost: at a 20% tax rate on a $75 million profit, the province gives up about $15 million a year, $150 million over ten years, or $7,500 per job each year.
    • The counterfactual: if Halvard would have come anyway for the port and the workforce, the holiday is a transfer from taxpayers to the company with no gain.
    • The risk: investment attracted mainly by incentives can be footloose, leaving when the holiday ends, as low-cost plants sometimes do.
    • A strong analysis ends by identifying what the balance depends on, such as whether a shorter holiday tied to local purchasing or training targets could secure similar benefits at lower cost.
  6. Question 6 Evaluate 10 marks Paper 1 style Original practice

    Evaluate the likely impact of Halvard Batteries' plant on its host country.

    What a strong response does

    A strong response weighs strengths and limitations, uses the case throughout and reaches a supported judgement. One way to organize it:

    • Define and frame: an MNC operating in a host country; the question is whether the benefits to the province outweigh the costs, and for whom.
    • Benefits, applied: 2,000 jobs where youth unemployment is high; training and technology; local orders for parts makers; $165 million a year staying in the province, about a third of sales.
    • Costs, applied: no corporate tax for ten years; water use in a farming area and hazardous waste; engineering firms losing staff; profit sent home; the risk of a footloose exit when the holiday ends.
    • What the balance depends on: whether Halvard buys more locally over time, whether the regulator can enforce environmental rules, and whether the plant would have come without the incentive. A STEEPLE scan helps to show that the environmental and political factors could reverse the economic gains.
    • Judgement: for example, that the plant is likely to benefit the province overall, because the jobs and local spending are large and immediate, provided conditions on water, waste and local purchasing are agreed and enforced; without them, the costs could fall heavily on farmers and the town.
    • Limits of the evidence: the figures are the company's forecasts, and nothing is known about Halvard's conduct elsewhere.

    The teacher support material advises at least two arguments for and two against when evaluating one option, each applied to the case, and a conclusion that goes beyond repeating them (p. 56). A list of general advantages and disadvantages of MNCs, not applied to Halvard, scores low.

Section 14: Revision summary

The subtopic on one page: what to remember.

  • An MNC owns or controls operations in more than one country, directed from its home country; every other country it operates in is a host country.
  • MNCs enter through foreign direct investment: greenfield sites, acquisitions or joint ventures. Exporting alone does not make a business multinational.
  • Companies invest abroad for new markets, lower costs, resources, to get round trade barriers, for scale and for incentives. The motive predicts much of the impact.
  • Possible benefits for the host are jobs and incomes, capital, technology transfer and skills, tax, exports, orders for local suppliers, infrastructure, and choice for consumers.
  • Possible costs are local firms forced out, profits sent home, tax avoidance through transfer pricing, the cost of incentives, poor conditions in some cases, environmental damage, footloose plants, skills drawn away, and political and cultural influence.
  • The share of revenue that stays in the host, through local purchases, wages, taxes and reinvested profit, is a practical test of the benefit.
  • The balance depends on the type of investment, the industry, local links, the terms agreed, the host's institutions, the MNC's conduct and the time horizon.
  • Host governments shape the impact through incentives, conditions and enforcement, limited by their bargaining power.
  • STEEPLE structures the evaluation; the judgement must say who gains, who loses, over what period, and compared with what alternative.

Section 15: The mindmap

What makes a business multinational, why businesses expand abroad, and how to weigh the benefits and costs of MNCs for the host countries they operate in.

Mindmap: Multinational companies (MNCs)What makes a business multinational, why businesses expand abroad, and how to weigh the benefits and costs of MNCs for the host countries they operate in. The same content follows as an outline.1.6Multinationalcompanies (MNCs)What an MNC is=Operates in more than onecountryDirected from a head officein its home country=Host country: where itoperates abroadExpands through foreigndirect investmentWhy businesses gomultinationalNew markets and customersLower costs of labour,materials or taxProducing inside tradebarriersGlobalization makes iteasierBenefits for hostcountries+Jobs and higher incomes+Technology transfer and newskills+Tax revenue for thegovernment+Orders for local suppliers+Investment in infrastructure+More choice and competitionfor consumersCosts for hostcountries−Local firms forced out bycompetition−Profits sent back to thehome country−Less tax paid throughtransfer pricing−Low pay or poor conditionsin some cases−Pollution and the using upof resources−May leave when incentives orcosts change−Pressure on local cultureand traditionsJudging the impactDepends on the type ofinvestmentDepends on the host's lawsand bargaining powerShort-term gains versuslong-term dependenceDoes the MNC actresponsibly??Who gains and who loses inthe host country?ConnectionsGrowth by FDI, jointventures, alliances: 1.5Stakeholders in the hostcountry: 1.4Entering markets abroad: 4.6HLCultural differences:Hofstede's dimensionsHL

Drag to move the map, or use the arrow keys. Click a branch to fold it away. Whole map shows all of it; zoom with the buttons, or with Ctrl and the scroll wheel.

  • Core ideas
  • Evaluation
  • Applications
  • Connections
  • Advantage
  • Limitation
  • HL HL only
The map as an outline

What an MNC is

Core ideas

Why businesses go multinational

Core ideas
  • New markets and customers
  • Lower costs of labour, materials or tax
  • Producing inside trade barriers A local factory avoids tariffs and quotas on imports.
  • Globalization makes it easier Cheaper transport and communication, and fewer trade barriers.

Benefits for host countries

Evaluation
  • Advantage Jobs and higher incomes
  • Advantage Technology transfer and new skills
  • Advantage Tax revenue for the government
  • Advantage Orders for local suppliers
  • Advantage Investment in infrastructure
  • Advantage More choice and competition for consumers

Costs for host countries

Evaluation

Judging the impact

Applications
  • Depends on the type of investment A factory buying from local suppliers differs from a sales office.
  • Depends on the host's laws and bargaining power
  • Short-term gains versus long-term dependence
  • Does the MNC act responsibly?
  • Question Who gains and who loses in the host country?

Connections

Connections

Open the mindmap on its own page, with its terms and connections.

Section 16: Key terms

Defined in the platform's own words. Each opens its full entry.

Foreign direct investment (FDI)
Investment by a business from one country in productive assets in another country, such as building a factory or buying a large stake in a foreign company, giving it a lasting interest and a say in how those assets are run.
Globalization
The growing integration of economies around the world through increased trade, investment, movement of people, technology and ideas.
Home country
The country where a multinational company has its head office and legal base, from which its operations in other countries are directed.
Host country
A country in which a multinational company operates, other than the home country where it has its head office.
Multinational company (MNC)
A business that owns and controls operations, such as factories, offices or stores, in more than one country, while being directed from a head office in its home country.
Repatriation of profits
The transfer of profits earned by an MNC's operations in a host country back to its head office or shareholders in its home country.
Technology transfer
The spread of technology, skills and know-how from one organization or country to another, for example when an MNC brings new production methods to a host country and trains local workers.
Transfer pricing
The prices that one part of an MNC charges another part, in a different country, for goods, services or the use of brands and patents.

Section 17: Tools and practice

3 tools on the platform for 1.6, by room, with exercises, worked calculations and practice questions.

Strategy Studio

  • Stakeholder map Enrichment Map the host country's stakeholders, from workers and suppliers to local competitors and the government, by their power and interest in a multinational's arrival.
  • STEEPLE builder IB toolkit Scan a host country's environment from the multinational's side, to see the opportunities and threats behind a decision to invest there.

Practice questions with mark schemes

Section 18: Check your recall

Answer from memory, then reveal and rate yourself. Your ratings stay on this device.

Answer each question from memory, out loud or on paper, before you reveal the answer. Your ratings also schedule these questions in your flashcards.

  1. What is the difference between an MNC and a business that exports?

    An MNC owns or controls operations, such as factories, offices or stores, in more than one country. An exporter sells abroad goods it makes at home and has no operations in the countries it sells to.

    How well did you recall it?
  2. Distinguish between a home country and a host country.

    The home country is where the MNC has its head office and legal base. A host country is any other country in which it operates.

    How well did you recall it?
  3. What is foreign direct investment, and what are its three main forms?

    Investment in operations the investor will own or control in another country. It can build a new site (greenfield), buy or merge with an existing business, or form a joint venture with a local partner.

    How well did you recall it?
  4. Give four reasons why a company might invest abroad.

    For example, new markets, lower costs, access to resources, getting round trade barriers, economies of scale and spreading risk, and incentives offered by host governments.

    How well did you recall it?
  5. What is technology transfer, and how does it reach local firms?

    The spread of technology, skills and know-how from the MNC to the host. It reaches local firms when trained staff move to them and when suppliers raise their standards to meet the MNC's requirements.

    How well did you recall it?
  6. Why does the repatriation of profits matter to a host country?

    Profits sent home leave the host's economy instead of being reinvested there, so less of the value the MNC creates stays in the country.

    How well did you recall it?
  7. How can transfer pricing reduce the tax an MNC pays in a host country?

    Its subsidiaries can set the prices at which they trade with each other so that costs appear in the high-tax host and profits in a low-tax country.

    How well did you recall it?
  8. What is meant by footloose investment?

    Investment by an MNC that is easily moved, for example a plant attracted by low wages or incentives, which may close and leave when those advantages end.

    How well did you recall it?
  9. Why might a greenfield investment benefit a host more than an acquisition?

    A greenfield investment adds new capacity and jobs; an acquisition changes the owner of existing capacity and may lead to job cuts as the business is reorganized.

    How well did you recall it?
  10. Name three conditions a host government could attach to an MNC's investment.

    For example, local content requirements, a local partner or joint venture, targets for training and employing local people, environmental standards, and a limited tax holiday.

    How well did you recall it?
  11. A plant has sales of $200 million. It buys $60 million from local suppliers, pays local wages of $30 million and local taxes of $10 million, and reinvests $5 million of profit locally. What share of its sales stays in the host country?

    (60 + 30 + 10 + 5) ÷ 200 × 100 = 105 ÷ 200 × 100 = 52.5%.

    How well did you recall it?
  12. Why is it important to ask what would have happened without the MNC?

    Because gross effects overstate the gain. Jobs at the MNC may replace jobs lost at local competitors, and an incentive is wasted if the company would have come anyway.

    How well did you recall it?

Reveal and rate each card.

Section 19: How it connects

Where 1.6 meets the rest of the course: worked connections with an exam-style question on each, then the further links the notes name.

  1. With 1.4 Stakeholders

    Who gains when a multinational arrives

    The impact of a multinational company on a host country is not one effect but several, and each stakeholder group feels a different one. Workers may gain jobs and training; local suppliers may win contracts or lose out to the company's own supply chain; local competitors may struggle against its economies of scale; the government gains tax revenue and investment but may have offered incentives to attract it; and nearby communities may bear environmental costs. Because the gains and losses fall on different groups, judging an MNC's impact means saying whose interests are being weighed, and over what period.

    Exam-style question Source: Original practice question Command term: Discuss (AO3)

    Discuss the impact on two stakeholder groups in a host country of a multinational company's decision to open a factory there. [10 marks]

  2. With 5.4 Location

    Why multinationals arrive, and why they leave

    A multinational company's location decisions explain much of its impact on a host country. It may offshore production to reach lower labour costs, raw materials or customers, or to produce inside a trade barrier, and its arrival brings jobs and investment. The same reasoning can reverse: if wages rise, transport costs grow or the supply chain proves fragile, it may reshore production to its home country, and the host loses what it gained. A host country's benefit from an MNC therefore depends on how long the reasons for locating there last.

    Exam-style question Source: Original practice question Command term: Explain (AO2)

    Explain two reasons why a multinational company might offshore its production to another country. [4 marks]

Also linked in the notes

  • 1.3 Business objectives Ethical objectives and corporate social responsibility decide how an MNC behaves where a host's laws are weak or poorly enforced.
  • 1.5 Growth and evolution Acquisitions, joint ventures, strategic alliances and franchising are how many MNCs enter host countries, and economies of scale are one of their motives.
  • 2.6 Communication Multinational companies communicate across languages, cultures and time zones, where barriers multiply.
  • 4.6 International marketing At HL, the opportunities and threats of operating in international markets are the other side of the same investment, seen from the company's point of view.

See 1.6 on the course connections map, with every link drawn across the five units.

Section 20: Connected learning

Everything else on the platform that teaches, applies or tests 1.6, each labelled by its standing.

Revise
Practise
Tools
  • 3 tools for 1.6 In Tools and practice on this page: Strategy Studio, Operations Floor
Boardroom Briefings
Business Intelligence
Advanced Management
Course connections

Notes checked against: Business management guide, first assessment 2024 (published February 2022, updated May 2022), pp. 23 to 24 (The content statement and its assessment objective (p. 24); the unit's conceptual understandings and suggested tools (p. 23)); Business management teacher support material, pp. 6, 56 to 57 (The debatable inquiry question on multinationals and host countries (p. 6) and the advice on applying answers and on theoretical 10-mark answers (pp. 56 to 57), read; nothing reproduced). Updated 2026-11-03. The IB guide is the authority on the course.