Room 08 of 15 Partly built
Operations Floor
Operations turn inputs into outputs. The room is laid out as a production system: design the process, run it and keep it supplied, with a working tool for each question and one fictional business, Wrenhurst Cycles, running through most of them. The room's first interactions, on Atelier Barro's studio and Marigold Kitchens' restaurants, are here too. Break-even (5.5) is worked on the Finance Desk.
Section 01: The production system, stage by stage
Design the process, run it, and keep it supplied. Each question has a working tool with your own figures, a fictional worked example and its syllabus status.
Stage 1
Design the process
How and where to produce, before anything is made.
How should we produce it?
Where should we produce?
Stage 2
Run the process
Using the capacity well, and getting the output right first time.
How hard is the capacity working, and how much does each input produce?
Stage 3
Feed the process
Keeping materials arriving: when to reorder, how much, and where supply can fail.
When should we reorder, and what happens when demand or a delivery does not go to plan?
How much should we order at a time?
Section 02: One business through the floor
Wrenhurst Cycles, the fictional bicycle maker of the notes on production planning, runs through most of the tools, so their figures connect.
- 250 bikes a week: the capacity of the assembly line, which builds about 200
- 200 gear sets used a week, reordered 800 at a time when stock falls to 600
- 8 weeks by sea for every frame, from a single partner factory overseas
Wrenhurst in the tools
- Weighted location assessment
- Capacity utilization and productivity calculator
- Stock control simulator
- Economic order quantity calculator (enrichment)
From the notes on production planning (5.6). The business is fictional and every figure simulated.
Section 03: Case work
The room's first three interactions, each built on a fictional case: a location in Mumbai for Marigold Kitchens, and the kiln and the clay at Atelier Barro.
Section 04: Choosing a location
Subtopic 5.4, AO2. Weigh the factors yourself, and see how much the answer depends on the weights.
Interaction
Where should the first Mumbai restaurant go?
Weighted scoring turns a location decision into numbers you can argue about. The scores are given; the weights are yours.
The tool could not start. The ranking below uses the suggested weights.
If Meera chooses organic growth, the first of the four Mumbai restaurants needs a site. Farah Sheikh, the finance manager, has visited three and scored each factor from 1 (poor) to 10 (excellent).
- Site A A ground-floor unit on a busy street in an office district. Rent ₹6.6m a year. Full at weekday lunchtimes, with many restaurants nearby.
- Site B A narrow unit beside a suburban railway station, with a small kitchen. Rent ₹5.4m a year. Heavy footfall at commuting hours.
- Site C A residential neighbourhood beside a produce market. Rent ₹4.2m a year. Families nearby in the evening, but few offices, so lunchtimes would be thin.
| Factor | Weight | Site A | Site B | Site C |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rent and running costs | 4 | 3 (low) | 6 | 8 |
| Customers nearby at lunch and dinner | 5 | 9 | 7 | 3 (low) |
| Access to fresh produce and suppliers | 3 | 5 | 5 | 7 |
| Cooks available to recruit | 2 | 6 | 5 | 7 |
| Little direct competition nearby | 2 | 3 (low) | 6 | 7 |
| Fit with a home-style brand | 3 | 7 | 3 (low) | 7 |
Weighted ranking
| Site | Rank | Total | % of maximum | Bar |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Site C | 1 | 117 | 61.6% | |
| Site A | 2 | 111 | 58.4% | |
| Site B | 3 | 105 | 55.3% |
Reading. Site C ranks first with 117 points, 6 ahead of Site A. The ranking is sensitive to the weights: at a weight of 2 on rent and running costs (now 4), Site A ranks first; at a weight of 0 on access to fresh produce and suppliers (now 3), Site A and Site C tie; at a weight of 0 on little direct competition nearby (now 2), Site A ranks first; at a weight of 0 on fit with a home-style brand (now 3), Site B and Site C tie.
Implication. A close ranking means the decision rests on the weights, which are judgements about priorities. Agree the weights before seeing the totals, and check the qualitative factors the scores leave out.
Scores of 3 or below: check whether any rules a site out
- Site A: rent and running costs, 3 out of 10
- Site A: little direct competition nearby, 3 out of 10
- Site B: fit with a home-style brand, 3 out of 10
- Site C: customers nearby at lunch and dinner, 3 out of 10
How the totals are worked out
Each site's total is the sum, over the factors, of the factor's weight times the site's score. With the suggested weights, Site C scores 4 × 8 + 5 × 3 + 3 × 7 + 2 × 7 + 2 × 7 + 3 × 7 = 117. The most a site could score is the sum of the weights times 10, which is 190. Weighted scoring is a decision-making method, not one of the guide's toolkit tools or formulas.
Showing everything. HL-only material is marked HL.
Section 05: Capacity utilization and productivity
Subtopic 5.6, HL only, AO2 and AO4.
Interaction
How hard is the kiln working?
Atelier Barro's kiln can fire 1,200 mugs a month. Compare a quiet October with a November that includes the hotel's order, and see what happens to each measure.
The workspace could not start. The figures below are for October, actual.
Showing October, actual. With JavaScript on, you can change month and edit the figures.
Results
- Capacity utilization
- 53.3%640 of 1,200 mugs
- Defect rate
- 5.88%40 of 680 mugs failed inspection
- Labour productivity
- 2.00good mugs a labour hour
- Productivity rate
- 113.0%output value ÷ input cost × 100
- Fixed cost carried by each mug
- €12.59€8,060 ÷ 640 mugs
Reading. The studio is using 53.3% of its capacity, with 560 mugs of spare capacity. Each mug carries €12.59 of fixed costs.
Implication. Much of the capacity stands idle, so fixed costs are spread over few units. More sales, or selling the spare capacity, would lower the cost of each unit; cutting capacity would save cost but limit growth.
The bands used in the reading (below 60%, 60 to 85%, 85 to 97%, 97% and above) are the platform's rule of thumb, not an IB rule.
The working: capacity utilization rate
- Given
- Actual output this month: 640 mugs
- Productive capacity: 1,200 mugs
- Formula
- Capacity utilization rate = actual output ÷ productive capacity × 100
- Substitution
- = 640 ÷ 1,200 × 100
- Working
- 640 ÷ 1,200 = 0.53330.5333 × 100 = 53.33%
- Answer
- 53.3%
The guide gives this formula (p. 65).
- Unit
- per cent of capacity
- Interpretation
- The studio is using 53.3% of its capacity, with 560 mugs of spare capacity. Each mug carries €12.59 of fixed costs.
- Business implication
- Much of the capacity stands idle, so fixed costs are spread over few units. More sales, or selling the spare capacity, would lower the cost of each unit; cutting capacity would save cost but limit growth.
The working: productivity rate
- Given
- Total output, valued at its selling price: €14,080
- Total input, valued at its cost: €12,463.20
- Formula
- Productivity rate = total output ÷ total input × 100
- Substitution
- = €14,080 ÷ €12,463.20 × 100
- Working
- 14,080 ÷ 12,463.20 = 1.12971.1297 × 100 = 112.97%
- Answer
- 113.0%
The guide gives this formula (p. 65) without units. Output and input are valued in the same currency here so that the result is a percentage.
- Unit
- per cent: output value for each 100 of input value
- Interpretation
- Every €100 of inputs produced €112.97 of output, valued at selling prices.
- Business implication
- Compare periods, not single figures: the rate rises when fixed inputs, such as the studio and the kiln, are spread over more output.
The working: defect rate
- Given
- Mugs that failed inspection: 40
- Mugs made: 680
- Formula
- Defect rate = units that fail to meet the quality standard ÷ units made × 100
- Substitution
- = 40 ÷ 680 × 100
- Working
- 40 ÷ 680 = 0.05880.0588 × 100 = 5.88%
- Answer
- 5.88%
A standard definition. The guide's formula list does not include it; the teacher support material's glossary describes the defect rate as a percentage (TSM, p. 83).
- Unit
- per cent of mugs made
- Interpretation
- 5.9% of the mugs made never reach a customer.
- Business implication
- A lower defect rate raises good output without more hours or more material, and it is usually cheaper to prevent a defect than to find it.
The working: labour productivity
- Given
- Good mugs produced: 640
- Labour hours worked: 320
- Formula
- Labour productivity = output ÷ labour input
- Substitution
- = 640 ÷ 320
- Working
- 640 ÷ 320 = 2.000
- Answer
- 2.00 mugs an hour
A standard definition. The guide's formula list does not include it. Labour input can also be measured in workers rather than hours.
- Unit
- good mugs a labour hour
- Interpretation
- Each labour hour produced 2.00 good mugs.
- Business implication
- Long hours in a busy month can hold output up even if each hour produces less; compare this figure across months before drawing a conclusion.
Section 06: Stock control
Subtopic 5.6, HL only, AO2 and AO4.
Interaction
When should the studio order more clay?
A stock control chart shows when to reorder, how much to keep in reserve and what happens when usage or a delivery does not go to plan.
The chart could not start. It is shown below for the planned figures.
In stock stoneware clay, in 25 kg bags.
Results
- Reorder level
- 10 bags4 + 3 × 2
- Maximum stock
- 16 bags4 + 12
- Weeks an order lasts
- 4reorder quantity ÷ usage a week
- Lowest stock
- 4 bagsnever below the buffer
Reading. At 3 bags a week, the studio reorders when stock falls to 10 bags (buffer 4 bags plus 6 bags used during the 2-week lead time). Stock peaks at 16 bags and each order lasts about 4 weeks.
Implication. When usage and lead time are as planned, each delivery arrives just as stock reaches the buffer, so the buffer is never touched.
The chart's figures as a table
| Week | Stock at the start | Used | Delivered | Stock at the end | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 16 | 3 | 13 | ||
| 2 | 13 | 3 | 10 | Order placed | |
| 3 | 10 | 3 | 7 | ||
| 4 | 7 | 3 | 12 | 16 | |
| 5 | 16 | 3 | 13 | ||
| 6 | 13 | 3 | 10 | Order placed | |
| 7 | 10 | 3 | 7 | ||
| 8 | 7 | 3 | 12 | 16 | |
| 9 | 16 | 3 | 13 | ||
| 10 | 13 | 3 | 10 | Order placed | |
| 11 | 10 | 3 | 7 | ||
| 12 | 7 | 3 | 12 | 16 | |
| 13 | 16 | 3 | 13 | ||
| 14 | 13 | 3 | 10 | Order placed | |
| 15 | 10 | 3 | 7 | ||
| 16 | 7 | 3 | 12 | 16 |
Check your understanding
-
Answer
10 bags: buffer 4 + 3 a week × 2 weeks.
-
Answer
16 bags: buffer 4 + reorder quantity 12.
-
Answer
Some of it, but not all. The lowest point is 2 bags.
HL Capacity utilization, productivity and stock control are HL-only material, hidden while you are viewing SL content. Switch to HL above to see them.
Section 07: Unit 5, subtopic by subtopic
Operations management in the guide's order: what the platform has for each subtopic, and the tools that serve it.
- 5.1
Introduction to operations management
Full notes, mindmap, terms and diagrams
No tool yet: start with the subtopic page.
- 5.2
Full notes, mindmap, terms and diagrams
Tools here Production methods exercise
- 5.3
Lean production and quality management HL only
Full notes, mindmap, terms and diagrams
No tool yet: start with the subtopic page.
- 5.4
Full notes, mindmap, terms and diagrams
Tools here Weighted location assessment
Interactions Where should the first Mumbai restaurant go?
- 5.5
Full notes, mindmap, terms and diagrams
- 5.6
Production planning HL only
Full notes, mindmap, terms and diagrams
- 5.7
Crisis management and contingency planning HL only
Full notes, mindmap, terms and diagrams
No tool yet: start with the subtopic page.
- 5.8
Research and development HL only
Full notes, mindmap, terms and diagrams
No tool yet: start with the subtopic page.
- 5.9
Management information systems HL only
Full notes, mindmap, terms and diagrams
No tool yet: start with the subtopic page.
Section 08: Decide on a case
Decision Rooms where operations choices meet costs, prices and growth.
Section 09: Planned for this room
Not built yet, so not linked.
- A supply chain mapper, with stages, lead times, risks and the critical weaknesses highlighted
- A quality management simulation comparing quality control with quality assurance
- Tools for crisis management and contingency planning (5.7, HL), research and development (5.8, HL) and management information systems (5.9, HL)
Arjun Agrawal | The Business Brief, https://the-business-brief-dun.vercel.app/operations-floor/. Original teaching material, not an IB publication. The organizations in the teaching cases are fictional unless a case says otherwise.