Change
In the guide
Moving from one form or state to another: causes, processes, consequences.
The lens asks
What does growing from one shop to two change, and is it worth it?
A question
Should Crumb & Co. open a second shop in Eastgate?
Internal assessment · SL and HL
A real issue facing one organization, analysed through one key concept. The same task at SL and HL, for students assessed from May 2024 onwards.
Requirements were checked against the IB guide itself. Examiner emphasis is given as the creator's assessment guides state it, with the guide named beside it; the subject reports they cite were not supplied to this platform. More on the sources
What you produce, and where the 25 marks are earned.
IB requirement
Verification: Verified Sources: Business management guide, first assessment 2024 (published February 2022, updated May 2022); Diploma Programme and Career-related Programme Assessment procedures 2027, as recorded in the creator's assessment procedures platform. The page follows each statement.
IB requirement Recommended strategy Guide, pp. 51 to 58; the order of work is the platform's suggestion
Your teacher
approves the question before work starts
Your teacher
comments on your work plans and on one draft
Your teacher
marks it, and the IB moderates
Stages and the teacher's role come from the guide; the order of work is the platform's suggestion. Criteria are marked best fit, in whole marks (guide, p. 52).
25 marks across 7 criteria: their names, maxima and a brief paraphrase of each top level. The level descriptors themselves are in the guide; read them with your teacher.
IB requirement Guide, pp. 56 to 58, paraphrased
| Criterion | Marks | The top level, in brief |
|---|---|---|
| A Integration of a key concept | 5 | Its link to the organization, analysed and integrated throughout |
| B Supporting documents | 4 | Three to five, relevant and in depth, with a range of ideas and views |
| C Selection and application of tools and theories | 4 | Selected and applied effectively, clearly relevant to the question |
| D Analysis and evaluation | 5 | Document data used effectively: thorough analysis and evaluation, ideas integrated, assumptions and implications weighed |
| E Conclusions | 3 | Consistent with the evidence, and an explicit answer to the question |
| F Structure | 2 | An appropriate structure |
| G Presentation | 2 | Title page, accurate contents, headings and sub-headings, numbered pages |
Frame a question your documents can answer, through one lens.
Recommended strategy Illustrative example
IB requirement Recommended strategy Examiner emphasis Guide, p. 53; IA research guide, p. 2
The guide allows a research question that looks forward or backward, and does not define the two. Reading them as a decision still to be made and a decision already taken is the IA research guide's suggestion.
IB requirement Illustrative example "In the guide": pp. 12 to 13, paraphrased
In the guide
Moving from one form or state to another: causes, processes, consequences.
The lens asks
What does growing from one shop to two change, and is it worth it?
A question
Should Crumb & Co. open a second shop in Eastgate?
In the guide
New ideas, or existing ideas from new perspectives, and their value.
The lens asks
Has a new idea created value for the business?
A question
How effectively has Crumb's seasonal range attracted new customers?
In the guide
Moral principles that govern behaviour, and their consequences for stakeholders.
The lens asks
Is the decision right, and who bears its cost?
A question
Should Crumb & Co. switch to fair-trade cocoa despite the higher cost?
In the guide
Meeting present needs without compromising future generations: people, planet, profit.
The lens asks
Does it serve people, planet and profit together?
A question
Should Crumb & Co. sell unsold bread through a food-waste app?
In the course, all four concepts underpin every unit. In your project, you choose one and use it explicitly as a lens, from question to conclusion; any other idea, such as globalization, scores 0 for criterion A (guide, pp. 53 and 56).
Build yours. The research question builder drafts a question from your organization, issue, decision and lens, and checks its form against the guide as you type. The key concept guide shows which lens your issue points to.
Where most of your information must come from. Choose them in three passes.
Gate 1
IB requirement Guide, pp. 54 to 55
Gate 2
Recommended strategy
Gate 3
IB requirement Guide, pp. 54 and 57
Recommended strategy
IB requirement Guide, p. 55
Illustrative example
| Document | Voice | What it adds | |
|---|---|---|---|
| SD1 | Crumb & Co. accounts, 2025 | The business | Average sale, ingredient costs, wages and overheads |
| SD2 | Council footfall survey of Eastgate, 2025 | Independent | About 9,000 shoppers a day |
| SD3 | Estate agent's listing for the site, 2026 | Commercial | Rent of $36,000 a year |
| SD4 | Own survey of 80 Eastgate shoppers: blank questionnaire and tally | Primary | 24 of 80 (30%) would visit weekly |
| SD5 | Local newspaper report on two café closures, 2026 | Sceptical | Evidence that demand may not last |
Five documents from Crumb's own website would lack balance, as would five surveys of similar people: the guide gives both as examples (p. 54).
Examiner emphasis IA research guide, p. 3
The checker needs JavaScript. The three gates above work as a paper checklist.
Your set against the guide
Dates are checked to the month, by the same rule as the supporting documents tool and the planner. A checker can count, date and compare. It cannot tell whether a document is relevant to your question, deep enough, or credible: you and your teacher judge that. Your list stays on this device.
How the same documents earn three different sets of marks.
IB requirement Illustrative example Guide, pp. 57 to 58, paraphrased
B · Supporting documents 4
Are the three to five documents relevant, in depth, and varied in their views?
At Crumb: accounts, council footfall data, a rent listing, a shopper survey, a report on two closures.
Not credited here: how well you use them; that is D.
C · Tools and theories 4
Are the tools right for this question, and applied to its figures?
At Crumb: break-even analysis for the new shop; a force field analysis of the change (HL).
Not credited here: a SWOT that does not help answer the question.
D · Analysis and evaluation 5
Is document data selected and used to analyse, weigh and question the evidence?
At Crumb: break-even needs under 1% of passers-by, but the survey was run only on Saturdays.
Not credited here: statistics quoted without being used.
Recommended strategy Illustrative example
$8 a sale, $3 ingredients, $64,000 wages and overheads (SD1); $36,000 rent (SD3); 9,000 shoppers a day (SD2).
($64,000 + $36,000) ÷ $5 = 20,000 sales a year: about 67 a day over 300 trading days, under 1% of passers-by.
SD1 costs are the current shop's; the survey ran on two Saturdays (SD4); two cafés closed (SD5).
Open, but only after a weekday trial confirms the demand that the costs require.
The change lens runs through every step: what the move from one shop to two changes in costs, staffing and risk, and whether that change is worth making now.
Examiner emphasis Illustrative example IA research guide, p. 4
The top level of D asks for a thorough analysis and evaluation, with a sustained integration of ideas and the assumptions underpinning the arguments and their implications considered (guide, p. 58). Always show where a figure comes from (SD1, SD2). The evidence analysis tool checks each piece of your evidence in this way.
Recommended strategy Illustrative example
A new illustrative case: Harbour Cycles, a fictional repair shop deciding whether to open a second workshop.
This exercise could not start. Each item's answer is in the "Answer and explanation" section below it.
Decide what each sentence does with the evidence, then check it.
SD3 shows that 42% of surveyed cyclists repair their own bikes.
Answer: Quoting.
A figure is reported, but nothing is done with it: no tool, no comparison, no consequence.
Fixed costs of $48,000 a year divided by a $40 contribution per repair give a break-even of 1,200 repairs a year, about 23 a week.
Answer: Using.
A tool (break-even) is applied to document data to produce a new figure: $48,000 ÷ $40 = 1,200, and 1,200 ÷ 52 is about 23.
Break-even needs about 23 repairs a week, but the footfall count (SD2) was taken in summer and SD4 says winter trade halves, so the second workshop is safe only if winter demand reaches 23 repairs.
Answer: Integrating.
The result is tested against an assumption the documents expose (seasonal demand), and the implication for the decision is stated.
According to SD1, the shop's revenue was $310,000 last year.
Answer: Quoting.
Accurate, but only restated from the document.
Revenue grew from $280,000 to $310,000 (SD1), a rise of 10.7%, faster than the 4% market growth reported in SD2.
Answer: Using.
The data is processed (a growth rate: 30,000 ÷ 280,000 × 100 = 10.7%) and compared with a second document.
The 10.7% growth looks strong, yet SD5 reports a rival opening nearby next spring; if it takes even a tenth of local repairs, the growth that justifies a second workshop may not continue.
Answer: Integrating.
Two documents are weighed against each other, the assumption behind the growth is questioned, and the consequence for the decision follows.
IB requirement Examiner emphasis Illustrative example Guide, pp. 55 and 58; IA research guide, p. 4
The stronger version answers the question as asked and adds no new facts. If the question names two things, answer both.
This exercise could not start. Each item's answer is in the "Answer and explanation" section below it.
Harbour Cycles again: which conclusions answer the question explicitly?
In conclusion, there are many advantages and disadvantages of opening a second workshop.
Answer: Not yet explicit.
It summarizes without answering: should the shop open it or not?
Harbour Cycles should open the second workshop only if a winter trial shows at least 23 repairs a week, because break-even depends on winter demand the documents do not yet show.
Answer: Explicit answer.
A decision, its condition and the reason, all from evidence already in the project.
To some extent the second workshop could be a good idea for Harbour Cycles.
Answer: Not yet explicit.
A vague "to some extent" is the form that, as the IA research guide reports, subject reports warn cannot reach the top of criterion E.
Harbour Cycles should not open the second workshop this year: the rival's opening (SD5) puts the 10.7% growth at risk, and break-even needs every summer customer to stay through winter.
Answer: Explicit answer.
A clear answer, consistent with the evidence, with no new facts introduced.
It is difficult to decide without more information about the market.
Answer: Not yet explicit.
Naming a limitation is useful, but on its own it is not an answer to the question.
How to organize, count and present a project that meets every rule.
IB requirement Examiner emphasis Guide, p. 55; IA research guide, p. 5
The guide's elements, not compulsory headings. The IA research guide reports that subject reports advise against a long research proposal or methodology section.
IB requirement Examiner emphasis Guide, pp. 55 and 58; IA research guide, p. 5
Criterion G looks only at these elements; the IA research guide points out that fonts and layout preferences are not among them.
IB requirement Guide, p. 56
The word count goes on the cover page. Over the limit, your teacher marks only the first 1,800 words, and moderators do not read beyond them. Not counted: acknowledgments, the contents page, tables of statistical data, diagrams or figures, equations, formulae and calculations, the supporting documents, citations (which go in the body), references (which go in footnotes or endnotes) and the bibliography. Definitions of business terms and quotations go in the body, and count; footnotes and endnotes may hold references only.
Recommended strategy The guide does not exclude headings, so the platform's reading is that they count. The word count planner shares the 1,800 words between your sections.
This exercise could not start. Each item's answer is in the "Answer and explanation" section below it.
Which of these count towards the 1,800 words?
Headings and subheadings
Answer: Counted.
They are part of the text, and the guide does not exclude them: the platform’s reading is that they count.
A table of statistical data
Answer: Not counted.
Tables of statistical data are excluded (guide, p. 56).
A definition of a business management term in your text
Answer: Counted.
Definitions must be in the body of the work, and they count.
Your break-even calculation
Answer: Not counted.
Equations, formulae and calculations are excluded.
A quotation from a supporting document
Answer: Counted.
Quotations must be in the body, and they count.
The bibliography
Answer: Not counted.
Excluded, like the contents page and the acknowledgments.
A diagram of your force field analysis
Answer: Not counted.
Diagrams and figures are excluded.
Citations in the body of the project
Answer: Not counted.
Citations are excluded, and if used they must be in the body; full references go in footnotes or endnotes.
IB requirement Examiner emphasis First two columns: guide, pp. 53 to 58; the third: IA research guide, p. 5
Must
The guide requires it, though not all of it is marked
Should, or recommended
The guide advises it
Not required
As the IA research guide reports from subject reports: not penalized if absent
Read your draft once for each criterion. Each list starts from what the criterion asks, paraphrased, with its maximum; the prompts help you look. They do not predict a mark, which only your teacher's marking and the IB's moderation decide.
IB requirement Recommended strategy What each criterion asks and its maximum: guide, pp. 56 to 58, paraphrased; the prompts are the platform's
To give yourself a best-fit mark for each criterion and note what one more mark would need, use step 9 of the ten-step planner, as the teacher support material suggests for your penultimate draft (TSM, p. 72).
Start from the decision your question asks about, then pick the tools that inform it. Criterion C rewards tools that are relevant and applied, not many tools.
Recommended strategy
| Your question asks | Tools that can answer it | What they decide |
|---|---|---|
| Should the organization invest, expand or launch? | Break-even analysis, investment appraisal, decision trees | Whether the numbers support the move, and how much risk it carries |
| How healthy is its finance, and why? | Ratio analysis, cash flow forecast | Where the strain is, and what would ease it |
| Which direction should it grow in? | Ansoff matrix, BCG matrix, STEEPLE | The options, their risk, and the environment they face |
| Will a change succeed with its people? | Force field analysis (HL), motivation theory, leadership styles | The forces for and against, and how to shift them |
| How should it compete? | Porter's generic strategies (HL), position maps, the marketing mix | The basis of its advantage, and whether its mix supports it |
Force field analysis and Porter's generic strategies are HL tools in the guide's toolkit (p. 14); any relevant tool may be used in the project. The toolkit explains each one.
9 tools, in the order a project uses them. Each checks your own plans against the guide and the IA research guide, labels every check by its standing, and gives feedback. None writes any part of your project, awards a mark or approves a question: your teacher does that.
Recommended strategy
A question built from your organization, issue, decision and lens, and checked against the guide
Which of the four concepts fits your issue as a lens, and checks of your question’s form
Primary and secondary research planned against the guide: what to attach, and what to say in your introduction
The guide’s rules for the set, and each document’s origin, purpose, date, reliability and relevance
The toolkit and syllabus tools that fit your question and the data in your documents
Each piece of evidence from your documents: quoted, used with a tool, or integrated into the argument
Your 1,800 words shared between the sections, against the guide’s limit and its list of what does not count
Milestones counted back from your deadline, to print or add to your calendar
Each stage, the words that count and the checks before you submit
What the IB requires of authentic work, and how the platform recommends using any outside help, including AI.
IB requirement Business management guide; the page follows each point
Recommended strategy
Arjun Agrawal | The Business Brief, https://the-business-brief-dun.vercel.app/assessment/internal-assessment/. Original teaching material, not an IB publication. The organizations in the teaching cases are fictional unless a case says otherwise.