FictionalScenario growth-route-1SL and HL
Pellworth Cycles: which way to grow?
Unit 1, Introduction to business management: 1.5 Growth and evolution, 4.2 Marketing planning
You advise the owners of Pellworth Cycles.
Pellworth Cycles is a medium-sized business in Manchester, the United Kingdom, with 138 staff. It makes city bicycles of its own design and sells them to commuters in its home city. Sales have grown slowly for three years, and the owners want them a fifth higher within three years.
Four ideas are on the table: run a trade-in offer for commuters who already ride its bikes; launch electric cargo bikes for the same commuters; open a showroom selling its existing bikes in a second city; or start a bicycle courier service. The business can fund one of them.
The decision Which route to growth should Pellworth Cycles take?
The evidence pack Simulated data
Exhibit 1 What each idea would take
| Idea | Set-up cost | Time to first sales |
|---|---|---|
| The trade-in offer | £30,000 | 1 month |
| The cargo bikes | £200,000 | 9 months |
| Existing range, the second city | £120,000 | 4 months |
| A courier service | £550,000 | 12 months |
Simulated data: the operations manager’s estimates.
Exhibit 2 Email from the office manager
The delivery vans are due for new livery this year. The designers have sent three options; I think the green one suits the brand best.
Exhibit 3 The home market
| Year | Market sales | Its sales | Its share |
|---|---|---|---|
| Year 1 | £17,000,000 | £1,700,000 | 10% |
| Year 2 | £18,020,000 | £1,800,000 | 10% |
| Year 3 | £19,100,000 | £1,910,000 | 10% |
Simulated data. Year 3 is the latest.
Exhibit 4 From the founder’s speech at the trade dinner
“We are ready to take on anyone, anywhere. Our product is the best in the country, and the next three years will prove it.”
Exhibit 5 Survey of current customers
Asked about the cargo bikes, 20% of the business’s current buyers said they would probably order it; the rest said they would wait to see how it sold elsewhere. (Simulated survey of 40 buyers.)
Step 1: Identify the problem
Check step 0 to open this step.
Why each answer fits or not
- Partly fits Sales at home are growing too slowlyTrue, and it is why the owners want to act, but it is the symptom. The problem to solve is which route to take, and slow sales alone do not say which.
- Does not fit Deciding whether to grow by a merger or an acquisitionThat is a question about the method of growth. None of the four ideas is a merger or an acquisition: the choice here is the direction, which products for which markets.
- Does not fit Updating the livery on the delivery vansThe livery is a distractor in the evidence pack. It costs little and says nothing about where growth should come from.
- Best fit Choosing the direction of growth that meets the owners’ target at a risk the business can carryThis is the decision in front of the owners: four routes are open, they differ in risk and cost, and the evidence on the home market can settle which fits.
Step 2: Select the evidence
Check step 1 to open this step.
Which exhibits matter, and why
- Relevant Exhibit 1: What each idea would takeIt gives the cost and the wait for each route, which a business of this size must weigh against the risk.
- Distractor Exhibit 2: Email from the office managerNew livery for the vans is a small, separate decision; it is no evidence about which direction of growth fits.
- Relevant Exhibit 3: The home marketIt shows how fast the home market is growing and how much of it Pellworth Cycles already holds, which decides whether there is room to grow at home.
- Distractor Exhibit 4: From the founder’s speech at the trade dinnerAmbition is not evidence: the speech says what the founder hopes for, not what the market or the costs show.
- Relevant Exhibit 5: Survey of current customersIt shows how much interest there is in the cargo bikes, the evidence on the risk of product development.
Step 3: Choose a tool
Check step 2 to open this step.
Why each tool fits or not
- Does not fit Decision treesA decision tree compares options with uncertain outcomes by weighting each outcome’s payoff by its probability. There are no probabilities or payoffs for the routes yet, so a tree would produce figures with no basis.
- Does not fit BCG matrixThe BCG matrix places products by market growth and relative market share, to decide which deserve cash. The business has one main product line, and the question is where to grow, not which existing products deserve cash.
- Best fit Ansoff matrixThe four ideas differ in whether the product is existing or new and whether the market is existing or new, which is exactly how the Ansoff matrix sorts them, from the lowest usual risk to the highest.
- Partly fits SWOT analysisSWOT analysis sorts what is strong and weak inside the business from the opportunities and threats outside it. It would give useful background on the business’s position, but it does not set the four routes against one another by product, market and risk.
Step 4: Analyse
Check step 3 to open this step.
Work through it in this order:
- For each idea, say whether the product is existing or new, and whether the market is existing or new.
- Place each idea in its quadrant of the matrix.
- Rank the ideas by their usual risk, then adjust the ranking for the evidence: the home market’s growth, the business’s share of it and the cost of each route.
Optional. Kept on this device with your answers.The model analysis
- Market penetration Run a trade-in offer for commuters who already ride its bikesThe existing product, sold more to existing customers: market penetration.
- Product development Launch electric cargo bikes for the same commutersA new product for customers the business already serves: product development.
- Market development Open a showroom selling its existing bikes in a second cityThe existing product in a market the business does not yet serve: market development.
- Diversification Start a bicycle courier serviceA new product in a new market, where both are unfamiliar: diversification.
- Market penetration keeps the product and the customers the business knows, so its usual risk is the lowest; but here the home market is growing by 6% a year and Pellworth Cycles holds only 10% of it, so there is room to win customers without a price war.
- Market development takes a proven product to the second city: the customers, rivals and distributors are new, so the risk is moderate, for £120,000 and four months.
- Product development keeps the customers but needs the cargo bikes: only 20% of buyers said they would probably order it, and it takes nine months.
- Diversification is new on both counts and costs the most, £550,000: the riskiest route for a medium-sized business.
Step 5: Recommend
Check step 4 to open this step.
At least eight words. Kept on this device.Why each recommendation fits or not
- Partly fits Market development: open a showroom selling its existing bikes in a second cityReasonable later, but it means new buyers, rivals and distribution while there is still room to grow at home at lower cost and risk.
- Best fit Market penetration: run a trade-in offer for commuters who already ride its bikesThe home market is growing by 6% a year and Pellworth Cycles holds only 10% of it: there is room to win customers the business already knows how to serve, at the lowest cost (£30,000) and the lowest usual risk.
- Does not fit Diversification: start a bicycle courier serviceNew products in a new market, at the highest cost (£550,000) and the longest wait. With no experience of that business, it is the riskiest route for a medium-sized business.
- Partly fits Product development: launch electric cargo bikes for the same commutersDefensible, because the customers are known, but only 20% of buyers said they would probably order the cargo bikes, and development takes nine months. It is a step further from what the business knows.
A strong justification:
- Names the evidence: how fast the home market is growing and the share the business already holds
- Compares the risk of the chosen route with at least one other route
- Says what the business should check before committing, such as a small trial
Step 6: Evaluate the consequences
Check step 5 to open this step.
Why each judgement fits or not
Which stakeholder carries the most risk if the chosen route disappoints?
- Best fit The owners, who pay the set-up cost and wait for the returnThey fund the route and their return depends on it: if it disappoints, the cost falls on them first.
- Partly fits The employees, whose jobs depend on the business growingTheir security matters, and some would gain new work, but they do not fund the route; the owners carry the financial risk first.
- Does not fit Commuters, who would have more choiceCustomers can switch to another brand at little cost, so they carry almost no risk from this decision.
What is the main risk of the route you would recommend?
- Partly fits Customers buy more only while the offer lastsA common pattern with promotions, which is why the offer should be judged on repeat orders, not the first month.
- Best fit Rivals answer the offers with their own, and the extra sales come at a lower marginPenetration wins customers partly from rivals, who can respond; the gain can shrink into a price war.
- Does not fit The business has never made the product beforePenetration uses the existing product: there is nothing new to make.
Which finding would most change the recommendation?
- Does not fit A rise in the cost of ingredients and materialsIt squeezes every route’s margin alike, so it does not change which route fits best.
- Partly fits Interest in the cargo bikes rising to well over half of buyersIt would make product development a closer rival, though at higher cost and a longer wait.
- Best fit New figures showing the home market’s growth falling to almost nothingPenetration needs room to grow at home. Without it, extra sales must come from rivals, and a new market becomes the better route.
The model answer, in outline
The model answer opens when you have checked all six steps.
- Identify the problem
- Pellworth Cycles must choose a direction of growth that meets the owners’ target at a risk a medium-sized business can carry. Slow sales are the symptom, not the problem.
- Select the evidence
- Exhibits 1, 3 and 5 (what each idea would take, the home market and survey of current customers) are the evidence. They show how fast the home market is growing and how much of it Pellworth Cycles holds, what each route costs and how much interest the cargo bikes attracts. The livery and the speech are distractors.
- Choose a tool
- The Ansoff matrix, because the ideas differ in whether the product and the market are new, and the matrix ranks them by usual risk.
- Analyse
- Penetration carries the lowest usual risk and diversification the highest. The decisive evidence is that the home market is growing by 6% a year and Pellworth Cycles holds only 10% of it.
- Recommend
- Market penetration: there is room to grow at home, at the lowest cost and risk.
- Evaluate the consequences
- The owners carry the risk; rivals may answer with offers of their own, and a home market that stops growing would change the recommendation.