Decision Room

Stakeholder impact simulator

Choose a decision and how it is carried out. See who gains, who loses, when and why.

Fictional businesses Simulated model How the model works

The decision

Scripts are off, so this is the worked example: Corvane Cartons with the settings below. Turn scripts on to choose another decision or change the settings.

Corvane Cartons, Monterrey, Mexico Fictional

Corvane Cartons, a family-owned maker of food cartons with 180 staff, plans to replace hand-fed folding and gluing machines with an automated line. The line now employs about forty people.

Draws on 1.4 Stakeholders, 2.1 Introduction to human resource management, 5.1 Introduction to operations management

How it is carried out

Scale: Moderate; Speed: Standard; Compensation and mitigation: None; Communication: Timely.

Scale How big a change?
Speed How quickly is it carried out?
Compensation and mitigation How much is done for those who lose?
Communication When and how openly is it explained?

At this scale: Two of the three folding lines are automated.

The impact on each group

Automate a production line at Corvane Cartons: the owners gain most; employees lose most.

Scores are the model's, on a scale of about −5 to +5: a teaching model, not a measurement.

  1. Employees Internal

    LosesLargeMainly in the first year

    Jobs on the folding lines go, and the staff who stay must learn to run and maintain the new machines. Nothing is offered to soften the loss, though redundancy pay, retraining for maintenance roles and help to find work could.

    First year−2.3After−1.0

  2. Customers External

    Loses first, gains laterModerateBoth: one way in the first year, the other after

    Installation can delay orders for a few weeks; after that the line runs faster with fewer faulty cartons.

    First year−0.5After+1.2

  3. Owners and shareholders Internal

    Loses first, gains laterLargeBoth: one way in the first year, the other after

    The machines cost a large sum up front and pay back through a lower labour cost per carton and more output. Announcing early lets some skilled staff leave before the machines are ready, which can leave gaps on the old lines.

    First year−1.1After+2.5

  4. Suppliers External

    GainsSmallIn the first year and after

    The machine maker wins a contract, and more output means more board and glue bought.

    First year+0.5After+0.5

  5. Government External

    Loses first, gains laterSmallBoth: one way in the first year, the other after

    Job losses cost the state income tax and support payments at first; a more productive firm pays more tax on its profit later.

    First year−0.5After+0.5

  6. Local communities External

    LosesModerateMainly in the first year

    Households lose a wage, and local shops lose some of their spending. Nothing is offered to soften the loss, though a training fund run with the local college and priority hiring for local people could.

    First year−1.4After−0.5

  7. Wider society External

    GainsSmallMainly after the first year

    Higher productivity and less waste help the wider economy, though routine jobs give way to fewer, more skilled ones.

    First year0.0After+0.5

Trade-offs

Who gains

  1. Owners and shareholders loses first, gains later, large
  2. Suppliers gains, small
  3. Customers loses first, gains later, moderate
  4. Wider society gains, small

Who loses

  1. Employees loses, large
  2. Local communities loses, moderate

Conflicting interests

  • Owners and shareholders against employees The owners’ lower labour cost is the employees’ lost wages: profit against job security, the classic conflict in 1.4.
  • Customers against local communities Customers get faster, more reliable deliveries, while the town loses jobs and spending.

What your settings trade off

  • No mitigation keeps the owners' costs down, but leaves employees and the local community to carry the full loss.
  • The owners pay in the first year for a gain later: a judgement about the long term, not a certainty.

Power and interest

Each group placed by its power over the business and its interest in this decision. Squares are internal stakeholders, circles external; the sign shows whether the group gains (+), loses (−), both (±) or neither (0). Stakeholder mapping is enrichment: the guide does not name it, but it supports 1.4.

Stakeholders by power and interestPower-interest grid for automate a production line at Corvane Cartons: Employees, power 5, interest 10, loses: keep informed; Customers, power 6, interest 4, loses first, gains later: keep satisfied; Owners and shareholders, power 9, interest 10, loses first, gains later: manage closely; Suppliers, power 3, interest 5, gains: monitor; Government, power 6, interest 3, loses first, gains later: keep satisfied; Local communities, power 3, interest 7, loses: keep informed; Wider society, power 2, interest 2, gains: monitor.KEEP SATISFIEDMANAGE CLOSELYMONITORKEEP INFORMED11551010Interest in the decisionPower over the business−±±+±−+EmployeesCustomersOwnersSuppliersGovernmentLocal communitiesWider society
Manage closely high power, high interest
Owners and shareholdersInvolve them early and consult them often; agree how their concerns will be met before the decision is final.
Keep satisfied high power, low interest
Customers, GovernmentMeet their needs and avoid surprising them; brief them on anything that touches their interests, because their interest can rise quickly.
Keep informed low power, high interest
Employees, Local communitiesExplain the decision and listen to them; they can add useful ideas, and together or through the media they can gain power.
Monitor low power, low interest
Suppliers, Wider societyLittle effort is needed now; watch for changes in their power or interest.

Evaluate

Answer one of these in a paragraph, as you would in an exam: a judgement, the evidence for it and the condition that would change it.

  1. Is automation a decision about efficiency only, or also about the kind of employer Corvane wants to be?
  2. Which group has the power to slow the change down, and what would win its support?
  3. What evidence would you want before deciding how many lines to automate?
  4. With no mitigation, employees lose most. What is the least the business could offer them that the owners would still accept?
  5. Which of your four settings would you change first, and which stakeholder would notice the change most?

Kept on this device for this decision, and nowhere else.

Section 01: How the model works

The same rules apply to every decision, so a change in a setting always moves the results the same way.

  1. Each decision sets the starting effects

    For every group, the decision gives an effect in the first year and an effect after it, from −3 (serious harm) to +3 (a large gain), with the reason. These are the model’s judgements about a fictional business, not measurements.

  2. Scale multiplies everything

    A small change halves every effect and a large one multiplies it by one and a half, including what the owners pay for mitigation. A bigger change never shrinks an effect or turns a loss into a gain.

  3. Speed concentrates or spreads the first-year harm

    Done fast, first-year harm to every group except the owners is 40% greater; phased, it is 40% smaller. The owners’ first-year gains move the other way: a quarter larger when fast, 40% smaller when phased. Effects after the first year do not depend on speed.

  4. Mitigation softens the loss and costs the owners

    For the groups a decision can help (with redundancy pay, retraining, notice or support), standard mitigation cuts their first-year harm by 30% and their later harm by 20%; generous mitigation doubles both cuts. Gains are never changed. The owners pay for it in the first year.

  5. Communication helps those who must plan

    Timely communication cuts the first-year harm to employees, customers, suppliers and the local community by 10%, and early, open communication by 20%. For some decisions early notice has a cost to the owners, such as staff leaving before the change; the page says when.

  6. Reading the result

    A group gains or loses only when an effect reaches a quarter of a point. Size is small below 1, moderate below 2 and large above. Interest rises with the size of the effect; power is set by the decision. A group with power of 6 or more is high power, and the same for interest, as in the Strategy Studio’s stakeholder map.

Section 02: What it cannot tell you

  • The scores are judgements built into the model, chosen to show how stakeholder effects usually run. A real decision needs evidence: costs, surveys, the views of the people affected.
  • Each group is treated as one. In practice a group splits: the staff who keep their jobs and those who lose them, the suppliers who win the new contract and those who lose the old one.
  • Power and interest change as a decision unfolds. A group with little power can gain it through the media, a union or a regulator.
  • The model shows who gains and who loses. Whether the decision is right is still your judgement, and so is how much weight each group's claim deserves: a question of ethics, not arithmetic.

Section 03: The 8 decisions

Every business is fictional; the decisions are the kind the course asks about.

  1. Automate a production line

    Corvane Cartons, Monterrey, Mexico

    Corvane Cartons, a family-owned maker of food cartons with 180 staff, plans to replace hand-fed folding and gluing machines with an automated line. The line now employs about forty people.

  2. Relocate production abroad

    Ferraby Knitwear, Leicester, England

    Ferraby Knitwear, a maker of jumpers and cardigans with 220 staff, plans to move its knitting and finishing to a new plant in a country where wages are much lower. Design and sales would stay at home.

  3. Raise prices

    Fennick Fitness, Johannesburg, South Africa

    Fennick Fitness, a chain of nine gyms, plans to raise its monthly membership fee to cover higher energy and equipment costs.

  4. Expand into a new country

    Teraka Sauces, Penang, Malaysia

    Teraka Sauces, a maker of cooking sauces with 90 staff, plans to open a sales office and warehouse in Australia, its first market outside Malaysia.

  5. Switch to certified sustainable suppliers

    Kettlewood Coffee, Toronto, Canada

    Kettlewood Coffee, a chain of fourteen cafés, plans to buy only coffee and dairy certified to an independent sustainability standard, which costs more than its current supplies.

  6. Close a branch

    Penhallow Hardware, Canterbury, New Zealand

    Penhallow Hardware, a chain of twelve hardware stores, plans to close its branch in a small rural town, where sales have fallen for three years and the branch now makes a loss.

  7. Accept a takeover offer

    Corrib Lens Works, Galway, Ireland

    Corrib Lens Works, a family-owned maker of precision lenses with 150 staff, has an offer for the whole company from a larger rival based in another European country.

  8. Cut the marketing budget

    Rivette Toys, Lyon, France

    Rivette Toys, a maker of wooden toys with 60 staff, plans to cut its marketing budget to protect this year’s profit after a fall in sales.

Section 04: Read with

The seven groups are employees, customers, owners and shareholders, suppliers, government, local communities, wider society.