Case file · Social enterprise

Patchwork Digital

A Glasgow social enterprise that refurbishes laptops for pupils and trains people leaving prison is offered a contract its trainees could not work on.

Source: Simulated data Fictional organization Advanced Updated 3 November 2026

The decision

How should Patchwork meet more of the need for laptops without losing the second half of its mission?

Patchwork Digital refurbishes donated laptops, sells them to schools at a fraction of their value for pupils who have none at home, and does the work with trainees who have criminal convictions. It is running a small deficit, its grant is tapering, and schools have a waiting list of 3,600 pupils. A bank has offered a three-year contract that would clear the waiting list and earn a large surplus, but everyone who handles the bank's laptops must pass a background check that most trainees would fail. The directors must recommend a plan of action.

Organization
Patchwork Digital CIC
Sector
Social enterprise (laptop refurbishment and training)
Location
Glasgow, United Kingdom
Size
One workshop; six permanent staff and eight trainees
Legal form
Community interest company (a for-profit social enterprise)
Figures in
GBP (£), thousands of pounds sterling (£000), and pounds for prices
Functions
Strategy and management, Finance and accounts, Operations management
For
IB DP SL, IB DP HL, Undergraduate, MBA
Key concepts
Ethics, Sustainability
Status
Fictional case. An invented organization. Every figure is simulated for teaching and checked for consistency.

Section 01: The story so far

Morag Kerr taught in a prison for eleven years. Daniel Okoye spent the same years wiping and scrapping companies' old computers. When they met in 2019 they saw two problems with one answer. Pupils in Glasgow's poorest neighbourhoods were falling behind because they had no laptop at home, while companies were paying to destroy machines that still worked. And people leaving prison could rarely get a first job, however much they wanted one.

Patchwork Digital, the community interest company they founded, collects laptops that companies, councils and universities no longer need, wipes their data to a certified standard, and refurbishes the ones that can be saved. Schools buy them for £60 each for pupils without a laptop at home; some are sold online at £180 to pay for the rest; the machines that cannot be saved are stripped for parts. The work is done by six permanent staff and eight trainees a year, people with convictions on twelve-month paid traineeships (Exhibits 1 and 2).

It works. Patchwork supplied 2,400 laptops to schools in 2025, and five of the seven trainees who finished in 2024 were in work six months later (Exhibit 3). But it does not quite pay. Patchwork ran a deficit of £12k in 2025, its reserves are about a month's costs, and the foundation whose grants have kept it going has said its support was always meant to taper (Exhibit 8). Meanwhile 41 schools have nominated 3,600 pupils who are still waiting for a laptop.

In September, Clydeport Bank offered Patchwork a three-year contract to destroy the data on the 9,000 laptops it retires each year, and to keep the machines (Exhibit 5). It would clear the waiting list and earn a large surplus. But everyone who handles the bank's devices must pass the bank's enhanced background check, which most trainees would fail. The contract would have to be done by new staff, in a secure room the trainees could not enter.

Morag and Daniel have costed four plans (Exhibit 4). Morag fears that the contract would turn Patchwork into an ordinary IT disposal firm with a charity's name; Daniel fears that without it Patchwork will not survive long enough to help anyone. The board, which includes a head teacher and a former trainee, meets in November.

Section 02: The industry

How the industry works and what is changing in it, in general terms. The figures in this case are the business's own, and simulated.

Social enterprises trade like businesses but exist for a social or environmental purpose, and reinvest most of what they earn in that purpose. In the United Kingdom many take the form of a community interest company, a limited company whose profits and assets must be used for the community purpose it states.

Organizations replace their laptops every few years, often long before the machines stop working. Refurbishing them extends their life, which is one of the ideas behind circular business models, but it depends on secure data destruction, because donors' devices hold confidential data. Certified wiping is a service that organizations pay for, which gives refurbishers a source of income as well as a source of machines.

Pupils without a suitable device at home find it harder to do schoolwork as more of it moves online. Social enterprises that also employ people facing barriers to work, such as people with convictions, serve two purposes at once, and must balance both against earning enough to survive.

Section 03: The key challenge

Patchwork exists to meet two needs: laptops for pupils who have none, and work for people leaving prison. It can meet more of the first only by growing, and it must grow without a reliable grant and with almost no reserves. The plan that grows it fastest would be done by people without convictions, and the plan that grows the traineeships would lose money. The directors must find a plan of action that meets more of the need while keeping the enterprise both solvent and true to its purpose.

Section 04: Financial information

Patchwork's income was £525k in 2025, of which grants were £120k, or 22.9%; its costs were £537k, leaving a deficit of £12k, 2.3% of income. Grants have fallen each year since 2023 (Exhibit 3). Each refurbished laptop costs about £30 in parts and licences; the larger costs are people, and the trainees' wages of £160k are the price of the second half of the mission. Exhibit 4 sets out what each plan would add each year.

Exhibit 1

Income and costs, 2025 (£000)

Source: Simulated data
Item £000
Laptops sold to schools144
Laptops sold online162
Data-wiping fees72
Parts and recycling27
Grants120
Total income525
Permanent staff186
Trainees' wages160
Parts and software licences99
Premises48
Transport and collection30
Other costs14
Total costs537
Surplus or deficit for the year−12

Eight trainees are paid £20k each for a year. Reserves at the end of 2025 were £45k.

Source Simulated teaching data, from Patchwork's accounts.
Exhibit 2

Devices in 2025, and the price or fee for each

Source: Simulated data
Devices Number Price or fee for each (£)
Collected from donors6,00012
Refurbished and sold to schools2,40060
Refurbished and sold online900180
Stripped for parts and recycled2,70010

Donors pay £12 for each device to have its data destroyed to a certified standard. Each refurbished laptop needs about £30 of parts and software licences.

Source Simulated teaching data, from the workshop's records.
Exhibit 4

Four plans, a year from 2026

Source: Simulated data
Plan Extra income (£000) Extra costs (£000) Change in yearly surplus (£000) One-off cost (£000) Extra pupils with a laptop each year Extra traineeships each year
A. The bank contract473283190403,6000
B. A second workshop239285−46601,2008
C. Sell more online720720−6000
D. License the model241014000

The directors' estimates.

  • A. The bank's 9,000 laptops a year at £15 each for data destruction (£135k); 4,000 can be refurbished, 3,600 for schools at £60 and 400 online at £180; 5,000 recycled at £10. Costs: four technicians who pass the bank's check at £32k each, £30 of parts for each refurbished laptop, £20k of transport and £15k to run a secure room, which costs £40k to build.
  • B. A second workshop in another part of the city, with eight more traineeships at £20k each, a supervisor at £32k and premises at £36k a year. 2,500 more devices from councils: 1,200 laptops for schools, 200 sold online, 1,100 recycled, £12 data-wiping fees on all 2,500 and £30 of parts for each refurbished laptop, with £15k of transport. Income includes a new grant of £90k a year, which the foundation has not yet agreed. The £60k fit-out would be crowdfunded.
  • C. Sell 600 of the laptops that now go to schools online instead, at £180 rather than £60.
  • D. License Patchwork's methods, name and training to social enterprises in two other Scottish cities for £12k a year each, with £10k a year of support. Each plans 1,500 laptops for its own schools and six trainees a year.
Source Simulated teaching data, prepared by the directors.

Section 05: The rest of the evidence

5 exhibits. Each is labelled with what kind of evidence it is.

Exhibit 3

Three years of Patchwork

Source: Simulated data
Year Devices collected Laptops to schools Trainees completing In work six months later Grants (£000) Surplus or deficit (£000)
20234,2001,600541506
20245,1002,00064140−4
20256,0002,40075120−12

Eight traineeships start each year. In work six months later counts trainees from that year who were in a job six months after finishing.

Source Simulated teaching data, from Patchwork's impact reports.
Exhibit 5

Email from Clydeport Bank

Source: Simulated data

We retire around nine thousand laptops a year, and every one must have its data destroyed to a certified standard. We would like Patchwork to do this for three years from January, and you may keep the machines. Every person who handles our devices must pass our enhanced background check. We understand what that means for your trainees, and we cannot make an exception.

Alasdair Ross, head of technology operations, Clydeport Bank
Source Fictional email, written for this case.
Exhibit 6

A head teacher's post on social media

Source: Simulated data

Our pupils without a laptop at home used to fall behind every time homework went online. This term Patchwork's laptops went to the families at the top of our list, and the difference in the classroom is real. We still have more names on the list than laptops. Thank you, Patchwork.

Fiona MacLeod, head teacher of a primary school in Glasgow's East End
Source Fictional post, written for this case.
Exhibit 7

A trainee's view

Source: Simulated data

When I came out, every application asked about convictions, and that was the end of it. Here they asked what I could learn. Six months on, I'm the one showing the new trainees how to replace a screen.

Jamie Boyle, trainee technician, Patchwork Digital
Source Fictional interview, written for this case.
Exhibit 8

The foundation's position

Source: Simulated data

Our support was always meant to taper. We will consider one final three-year grant for growth, but we want to see Patchwork earning more of its own income, and we will decide in the spring.

Ruth Okafor, director of grants, the Clydeside Foundation
Source Fictional letter, written for this case.

Section 06: Constraints

  • Reserves are £45k, about one month of costs.
  • The bank requires an enhanced background check for anyone who handles its devices, and will not make an exception; most trainees could not pass it.
  • The foundation will decide on any new grant in the spring, six months away.
  • As a community interest company, Patchwork must use its surplus and its assets for its community purpose.
  • The current workshop has room for a secure area or for more trainees, but not both.

Section 07: The people with a stake

Stakeholder Interest Influence Stake Concern
Morag Kerr and Daniel Okoye, founders and directors An enterprise that meets both needs and survives. High High Morag fears mission drift; Daniel fears closure.
Trainees Paid work, skills and a route into a job. Low High Growth that happens without them.
Pupils and their families A laptop at home for schoolwork. Low High Waiting another year.
Schools Affordable laptops for the pupils who need them. Medium High Higher prices, or fewer laptops.
Clydeport Bank Secure, certified data destruction, and a story of social value. High Low Any risk to its customers' data.
The Clydeside Foundation Lasting social impact for its grants. High Medium An enterprise that depends on it for ever.
Permanent staff Secure jobs in work they believe in. Medium High Supervising more people with no more resources.
Donor organizations Safe disposal of their old devices, and doing some good. Medium Low Data security.

Section 08: Strategic alternatives

A. Take the bank contract

Destroy the data on Clydeport Bank's laptops for three years, refurbish the machines, and clear the schools' waiting list.

Requires
Four new technicians who pass the bank's check, and a secure room costing £40k.
Upside
Clears the waiting list of 3,600 pupils and adds £190k a year to the surplus, enough to fund more traineeships elsewhere.
Risks
The growth is done by people without convictions, so the traineeships do not grow unless the surplus is committed to them; one large customer for three years; mission drift.

Evidence: Exhibit 4, Exhibit 5

B. Open a second workshop

Open a second workshop with eight more traineeships, funded by crowdfunding and a new grant.

Requires
£60k from crowdfunding, a new three-year grant of £90k a year, and 2,500 more donated devices.
Upside
Doubles the traineeships, the heart of the mission, and supplies 1,200 more laptops a year.
Risks
Loses £46k a year even with the grant, and more without it; the grant will not be decided for six months.

Evidence: Exhibit 4, Exhibit 8

C. Sell more laptops online

Sell 600 of the laptops that now go to schools online, at £180 rather than £60.

Requires
Nothing new.
Upside
Adds £72k a year at once, and turns the deficit into a surplus.
Risks
600 fewer pupils get a laptop; the mission pays for the enterprise rather than the other way round.

Evidence: Exhibit 2, Exhibit 4, Exhibit 6

D. License the model to other cities

License Patchwork's methods, name and training to social enterprises in two other Scottish cities.

Requires
Partners who meet Patchwork's standards, and staff time to support them.
Upside
Spreads the model to other cities at little cost or risk, adding £14k a year.
Risks
Does nothing for Glasgow's waiting list; Patchwork's reputation rests on partners it does not control.

Evidence: Exhibit 4

Section 09: Questions for analysis

Original practice questions written for this case, not IB examination questions. The marks are each question's own allocation, set to the size of the task. Answer first, then open the guidance.

Source: Original practice question
Show content for

Showing everything. HL-only material is marked HL.

  1. Describe the human need that Patchwork Digital addresses.

    Describe AO1 Paper 3 style 1.2 Types of business entities HL

    Guidance for a strong answer
    Source: Assessment explanation The platform's guidance, not an official markscheme.

    One mark for identifying a need, and one for describing it with the case. Either need earns the marks: pupils without a laptop at home, who fall behind as schoolwork moves online (3,600 are on the waiting list); or people with convictions who cannot get a first job after prison.

    [2 marks]

  2. Explain the key challenges Patchwork Digital faces in meeting this need.

    Explain AO2 Paper 3 style 1.2 Types of business entities; 3.2 Sources of finance Exhibit 1, Exhibit 3, Exhibit 5, Exhibit 8 HL

    Guidance for a strong answer
    Source: Assessment explanation The platform's guidance, not an official markscheme.

    Up to three marks for each of two challenges, explained with the resource material. Strong challenges: financial sustainability, with a deficit of £12k, reserves of £45k and grants falling to 22.9% of income; growth that cannot include the trainees, because the bank's checks exclude them; and dependence on donated devices and on one foundation. An answer that lists challenges without explaining them, or without the case, stays at the bottom of the range.

    [6 marks]

  3. Using all the resource material, recommend a plan of action for Patchwork Digital to meet more of the need.

    Recommend AO3 Paper 3 style 1.2 Types of business entities; 1.3 Business objectives; 1.4 Stakeholders; 3.2 Sources of finance Exhibit 1, Exhibit 3, Exhibit 4, Exhibit 5, Exhibit 6, Exhibit 7, Exhibit 8 HL

    Guidance for a strong answer
    Source: Assessment explanation The platform's guidance, not an official markscheme.

    In the style of the paper, a plan like this is judged on four things: how well it uses the resource material, how well it uses business management tools and theories, how well it evaluates, and how clearly its ideas and actions are sequenced. A strong answer:

    • uses every exhibit, including the figures in Exhibit 4 and the voices in Exhibits 5 to 8;
    • applies tools that fit, such as a stakeholder map, sources of finance, or a SWOT analysis of the enterprise;
    • weighs each plan against both needs and against the enterprise's survival, not against money alone;
    • sets out a plan in order, with who does what and when, and how Patchwork will know whether it is working.

    The marks are the question's own allocation in the style of the paper; this guidance is the platform's, not the IB's criteria or markbands.

    [17 marks]

  4. Distinguish between a for-profit social enterprise, such as Patchwork, and a non-governmental organization (NGO).

    Distinguish AO2 1.2 Types of business entities

    Guidance for a strong answer
    Source: Assessment explanation The platform's guidance, not an official markscheme.

    Two marks for each side of the distinction, with the case. A for-profit social enterprise such as Patchwork trades, earning most of its income from selling goods and services, and uses its surplus for its social purpose; as a community interest company, its profits and assets are tied to that purpose. A non-profit NGO usually relies more on donations and grants, and is not run to make a surplus. The best answers note that Patchwork's falling grants push it towards trading.

    [4 marks]

  5. Using Exhibit 1, calculate (i) Patchwork's deficit as a percentage of its income and (ii) the percentage of its income that came from grants in 2025.

    Calculate AO4 3.3 Costs and revenues Exhibit 1

    Guidance for a strong answer
    Source: Assessment explanation The platform's guidance, not an official markscheme.

    (i) Deficit = 537 − 525 = £12k; 12 ÷ 525 × 100 = 2.3%. (ii) Grants = 120 ÷ 525 × 100 = 22.9%.

    Two marks for each, one for the method and one for the answer.

    [4 marks]

  6. Explain two sources of finance Patchwork could use for the one-off costs of its plans.

    Explain AO2 3.2 Sources of finance Exhibit 4, Exhibit 8

    Guidance for a strong answer
    Source: Assessment explanation The platform's guidance, not an official markscheme.

    Two sources, each explained with its fit to Patchwork, for two marks each. Strong choices: crowdfunding, which suits a cause people care about and is planned for the second workshop's fit-out; loan capital, which the bank contract's surplus could repay; or retained surplus from the contract itself. Business angels and share capital need care: a community interest company's profits and assets are tied to its purpose, which limits what an investor can be offered.

    [4 marks]

HL-only questions are hidden in the SL view. Choose HL above to see them.

Section 10: The decision exercise

Decide before you read the debrief. The exercise is the platform's own; it is not an IB task.

Your role

You are Morag Kerr, co-founder and director of Patchwork Digital.

The board meets in November: Daniel, a head teacher, a former trainee and you. The bank wants an answer by December, the foundation will decide on any grant in the spring, and 3,600 pupils are waiting. You have said many times that Patchwork exists for two reasons.

The task
Recommend a plan of action that meets more of the need and keeps Patchwork solvent and true to its purpose.
What to produce
A plan of action of about 300 words, setting out the steps in order, who they depend on, their cost and effect, and how the board will know whether they work.
Time
45 minutes

Choose one of the strategic alternatives and write down your reasons before you open the debrief below. With JavaScript on, this page keeps your decision on this device and shows how the evidence judges the alternative you chose.

Make your decision

Which alternative do you choose?
The alternative you choose, the evidence for it, its main risk, and what would change your mind, at the length the task asks for. 0 words

Section 11: The debrief

The worked analysis, then every alternative judged against the evidence. One defensible reading, not the only one: try your own first.

Read the debrief
Source: Arjun Agrawal framework

Patchwork's two purposes grow in different ways: laptops for pupils with any capable workforce, traineeships only with supervision, space and subsidy. The strongest plans use the part of the business that can grow profitably to pay for the part that cannot, and make the link binding, so that growth serves the mission rather than replacing it.

The worked analysis

DataWhat the exhibits say

  • Income was £525k in 2025 and costs £537k, a deficit of £12k; grants were 22.9% of income and have fallen from £150k to £120k since 2023 (Exhibits 1 and 3).
  • Reserves are £45k, and 3,600 nominated pupils are waiting for a laptop.
  • The bank contract would add £190k a year to the surplus and 3,600 laptops for schools, but no traineeships; the second workshop would add eight traineeships and lose £46k a year even with a grant (Exhibit 4).
  • Selling 600 more laptops online would add £72k a year and serve 600 fewer pupils (Exhibit 4).

InsightWhat it means

  • Patchwork's two purposes pull apart at scale. Laptops for pupils can grow with any workforce; traineeships grow only with more supervision, space and subsidy.
  • The bank contract is not mission drift in itself. It becomes mission drift only if its surplus does not flow back to the purposes; committed to traineeships, it could fund six more a year.
  • The second workshop has the right purpose and the wrong economics. It depends on a grant that is uncertain and still loses money with it.

OptionsWhat each choice does

  • The bank contract meets the first need in full and can pay for the second, if the board commits its surplus.
  • The second workshop grows the second need and endangers the enterprise.
  • Selling more online trades pupils for money.
  • Licensing spreads the model but does not help Glasgow now.

RecommendationOne defensible answer

One defensible plan: accept the bank contract for three years, and commit £120k a year of its surplus to six more traineeships doing the school and recycling work, which the bank's checks do not cover. Build the secure room in the current workshop, and keep the trainees' space elsewhere. Rebuild reserves with the rest of the surplus. Tell the foundation and the schools exactly how the contract's money is used, and report both the laptops and the traineeships each year. License the model to other cities once the contract is running.

CaveatWhen it would change

This depends on there being enough school and recycling work for fourteen trainees, and on the board holding to the commitment when the surplus could be used for other things. If the bank's contract ended after three years with no replacement, Patchwork would have expanded its costs on a single customer's income, so the plan must also look for other paying donors of devices.

Every alternative, judged

  1. A. Take the bank contract

    Defensible if its conditions hold

    The only plan that clears the waiting list, with 3,600 laptops a year, and adds a large surplus, £190k a year. But it grows Patchwork through people without convictions, because the bank's checks exclude the trainees, so the second half of the mission stands still unless the surplus is committed to traineeships. Strong with that commitment; mission drift without it.

  2. B. Open a second workshop

    Defensible if its conditions hold

    It doubles the traineeships, the heart of the mission, and supplies 1,200 more laptops a year. But it loses £46k a year even with a grant that has not been agreed, and £136k without it, with reserves of £45k. The right purpose on the wrong economics; worth doing later, funded by something that pays.

  3. C. Sell more laptops online

    Weakly supported by the evidence

    A quick £72k a year that turns the deficit into a surplus, paid for by 600 pupils who would not get a laptop. It uses the mission to fund the enterprise rather than the enterprise to fund the mission.

  4. D. License the model to other cities

    Defensible if its conditions hold

    A low-cost way to spread the model, adding £14k a year and helping pupils and trainees in other cities. But it does nothing for Glasgow's waiting list, and Patchwork's reputation would rest on partners it does not control. A good second step, not a first.

The trade-offs

  • Scale against purpose. The plan that helps most pupils does not employ more trainees.
  • Earned income against grants. The foundation wants Patchwork to earn more; the most mission-focused plan needs a grant.
  • One large customer against many small ones. The bank contract brings money and dependence together.
  • Pupils against money. Selling more online improves the accounts by serving fewer pupils.

The evidence that matters most

  • The deficit, the falling grants and the reserves of a month (Exhibits 1 and 3).
  • The plans' effects on the surplus, on pupils and on traineeships, side by side (Exhibit 4).
  • The bank's refusal to make an exception (Exhibit 5).
  • The voices of the head teacher and the trainee, which show what each need means (Exhibits 6 and 7).

What would change the recommendation

  • The foundation agrees a three-year grant early. The second workshop becomes affordable alongside, or instead of, the contract.
  • There is not enough school and recycling work for more trainees. The contract's surplus cannot buy traineeships, and the contract becomes harder to justify.
  • Another large donor offers devices without the background check. That would grow both purposes at once.

Common errors

  • Judging the plans on the surplus alone, as if Patchwork were an ordinary company.
  • Rejecting the bank contract as mission drift without asking what its surplus could pay for.
  • Recommending the second workshop without noticing that it loses money even with the grant.
  • Describing a plan without an order of steps, owners and measures.

Section 12: Theories and frameworks

The theories and tools this case calls for, each with how it applies here and where the platform teaches it.

Section 13: For seminar discussion

Prompts for undergraduate and MBA seminars. They go beyond the IB course and are labelled as enrichment.

Source: Enrichment
  1. When does growth funded by a commercial contract become mission drift? Propose a rule a board could adopt in advance to decide.
  2. Patchwork's two purposes have different economics. Should a social enterprise with two purposes ever split them into two organizations?
  3. The bank gains a story of social value from the contract. How should Patchwork price that, and should it?