No. 03 The Boardroom Briefings Profit recovery
How should a company respond to declining profitability?
Kittiwake Air's margins fall for a third year
A regional airline in Atlantic Canada is carrying more passengers than ever and making almost no money. Its board has four ways to restore its profits, and each would hurt someone.
- Company
- Kittiwake Air, Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada
- Industry
- Aviation
- Decision
- Profit recovery
- Functions
- Finance and accounts, Operations management, Marketing, Human resource management
- Key concepts
- Change, Ethics
- Editions
- Student, then Analysis
You are reading the Student edition. The recommendation is withheld.
This briefing has two editions. The Student edition comes first: the case and the questions. The Analysis edition follows it, closed, so that you can decide before you read the recommendation.
The edition switch could not start. Both editions are on the page: the Analysis edition follows the Student edition.
The Student edition
Section 01: Executive summary
The decision in brief. In this edition the summary stops short of a recommendation.
The situation
Kittiwake Air flies from Halifax to cities and smaller communities across Atlantic Canada and to Toronto and Montréal. It carried 1,090,000 passengers in 2025, more than ever, but its operating profit fell from C$13.8m in 2023 to C$1.9m, and the finance team forecasts a loss in 2027 if nothing changes.
The decision
How to restore the airline's profitability: by cutting its two loss-making routes, raising fares where it has no competitor, cutting its costs with its workforce and suppliers, or giving up its Toronto route to a low-cost rival.
What is at stake
The airline's profit margin has fallen from 8.0% to 1.0% in two years. Each response affects someone the airline depends on: its staff and their unions, passengers in remote communities with no other airline, or the routes that feed its network.
Section 02: Business background
Kittiwake Air was founded in 1998 by a group of pilots who saw that the smaller cities of Atlantic Canada were poorly served. It now flies 14 turboprop aircraft from its base in Halifax, to Toronto, Montréal, St. John's, Charlottetown and Sydney, and along the Labrador coast under a contract with the provincial government. It employs 1,150 people, most of them members of a pilots' union or a cabin crew union.
For most of its history the airline made steady profits. Then its costs rose faster than its fares: between 2023 and 2025 its operating costs grew by 16.4% while its revenue grew by 8.1%, and its profit margin fell from 8.0% to 1.0% (Exhibits 2 and 3). In 2024 a low-cost airline began flying between Halifax and Toronto, Kittiwake's busiest route, and Kittiwake cut its fares there to keep its passengers.
The airline is owned 60% by a regional pension fund and 40% by the founders' families. Both want it back in good health. The chief executive, Marie Thibodeau, has asked her team to cost four responses (Exhibit 5), and will put one of them to the board next month.
- Company
- Kittiwake Air
- Business
- Regional airline
- Based in
- Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada
- Size
- 14 turboprop aircraft, 1,150 employees and revenue of C$186.0m in 2025
- Ownership
- Privately held company, 60% owned by a regional pension fund and 40% by the founders' families
- Figures in
- CAD, in millions (C$m)
- Status
- A fictional company. Every figure is simulated for teaching and checked for consistency.
Section 03: Strategic context
The industry and the forces on the decision, in general terms. The only figures in this briefing are the company's own.
An airline's costs are mostly fixed in the short run. The aircraft, the leases, the crews and the maintenance teams have to be paid for whether a flight leaves full or half empty, so the share of seats filled, the load factor, decides whether a route makes money. A small fall in passengers or fares can wipe out a thin profit, and a small rise can restore it.
Regional airlines sit between two kinds of competitor. National airlines connect the regions to the rest of the world and can offer frequent flyers more; low-cost airlines take the busiest routes with fewer frills and lower fares. A regional airline that tries to match both can end up with the costs of one and the fares of the other.
Some regional routes are essential services. Remote communities may have no road or no reliable one, and depend on the airline for travel, health care and supplies. Governments often pay airlines to keep such routes running, and expect a say in their fares and schedules.
Section 04: Relevant evidence
The company's own evidence (simulated), established research (cited, and stated only as its central idea) and how the market works.
-
The company’s own evidence Source: Simulated data
More passengers, thinner margins
Revenue rose from C$172.0m to C$186.0m between 2023 and 2025, but operating profit fell from C$13.8m to C$1.9m, and the return on capital employed from 23.0% to 3.0% (Exhibit 2). Revenue per passenger rose only slowly, from C$165.38 to C$170.64, while the load factor slipped from 68.4% to 66.5% (Exhibit 1).
-
The company’s own evidence Source: Simulated data
Where the costs rose
Maintenance costs rose by 34.3% and staff costs by 20.2% between 2023 and 2025, both faster than revenue (Exhibit 3). The three oldest aircraft, all over 25 years old, account for much of the maintenance bill.
See Exhibit 3
-
The company’s own evidence Source: Simulated data
Which routes pay
In 2025 the routes earned a total contribution of C$12.4m towards the C$10.5m of costs no single route can be charged with (Exhibit 4). St. John's earned the most, C$5.9m. Two routes lost money: Sydney, at −C$1.4m, and the Labrador coast, at −C$2.6m. Toronto, the busiest route, earned C$2.6m, at an average of C$200.00 a passenger against C$214 before the low-cost airline arrived.
See Exhibit 4
-
Established research Cited research
The danger of being stuck in the middle
Porter argued that a firm earns above-average returns by competing either on cost or on difference, across a whole market or in a focused part of it, and that a firm which tries to do both without achieving either risks being stuck in the middle, with neither the lowest costs nor a premium.
Source: Michael E. Porter (1980), Competitive Strategy: Techniques for Analyzing Industries and Competitors
-
How the market works General context
Why airline profits swing
Because most of an airline's costs are fixed in the short run, its profit changes much more than its revenue when passenger numbers or fares change. The same leverage that turns a small fall in revenue into a large fall in profit works in the other direction once costs are brought back under control.
The exhibits
Passengers, seats and fares, 2023 to 2025
Source: Simulated data| Year | Passengers (000) | Seats flown (000) | Load factor (%) | Revenue per passenger (C$) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 | 1,040 | 1,520 | 68.4 | 165.38 |
| 2024 | 1,075 | 1,590 | 67.6 | 168.84 |
| 2025 | 1,090 | 1,640 | 66.5 | 170.64 |
The load factor is the share of the seats flown that carried a passenger, the airline's capacity utilization rate.
Section 05: Financial information
Exhibit 2 gives the airline's results and returns for three years, and Exhibit 3 its operating costs by type. Exhibit 4 shows the contribution each route made in 2025, before the costs that cannot be charged to a route. Exhibit 5 gives the finance team's estimates of what each response would add to operating profit each year from 2027, and what it would cost once in 2026. If nothing changes, the team forecasts an operating loss of C$4.2m in 2027.
Kittiwake Air's results, 2023 to 2025 (C$m)
Source: Simulated data| Year | Revenue | Operating costs | Operating profit | Profit margin (%) | Capital employed | ROCE (%) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 | 172.0 | 158.2 | 13.8 | 8.0 | 60.0 | 23.0 |
| 2024 | 181.5 | 174.2 | 7.3 | 4.0 | 62.0 | 11.8 |
| 2025 | 186.0 | 184.1 | 1.9 | 1.0 | 64.0 | 3.0 |
Operating profit is profit before interest and tax. The profit margin and ROCE are worked as on the guide's formula sheet.
Operating costs by type, 2023 and 2025 (C$m)
Source: Simulated data| Cost | 2023 | 2025 | Change (%) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fuel | 36.2 | 41.0 | 13.3 |
| Staff | 52.0 | 62.5 | 20.2 |
| Maintenance | 18.1 | 24.3 | 34.3 |
| Airport and navigation charges | 25.6 | 27.9 | 9.0 |
| Aircraft leases | 17.8 | 18.6 | 4.5 |
| Sales and other costs | 8.5 | 9.8 | 15.3 |
| All operating costs | 158.2 | 184.1 | 16.4 |
What each route contributed in 2025
Source: Simulated data| Route | Passengers (000) | Revenue (C$m) | Direct costs (C$m) | Contribution (C$m) | Load factor (%) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Halifax to Toronto | 260 | 52.0 | 49.4 | 2.6 | 71 |
| Halifax to Montréal | 150 | 27.8 | 25.1 | 2.7 | 69 |
| Halifax to St. John's | 190 | 36.1 | 30.2 | 5.9 | 74 |
| Halifax to Charlottetown | 140 | 19.6 | 17.0 | 2.6 | 66 |
| Halifax to Sydney | 120 | 17.5 | 18.9 | −1.4 | 58 |
| Labrador coast service | 90 | 21.0 | 23.6 | −2.6 | 55 |
| Charters and cargo | 140 | 12.0 | 9.4 | 2.6 | Not measured |
| All routes | 1,090 | 186.0 | 173.6 | 12.4 | 66.5 |
Direct costs are the costs a route causes, such as fuel, crews on the route, landing fees and maintenance by flying hour. Costs that cannot be charged to a route, such as head office and standby aircraft, came to C$10.5m. The Labrador coast service is flown under a contract with the provincial government that runs to 2028.
The finance team's estimates for each response (C$m)
Source: Simulated data| Response | Added to operating profit each year from 2027 | One-off cost in 2026 |
|---|---|---|
| A. Cut the Sydney and Labrador routes | 2.9 | 1.5 |
| B. Raise fares by 8% on the four routes with no competitor | 3.2 | 0.0 |
| C. Cut costs with the workforce, suppliers and a newer fleet | 9.0 | 3.5 |
| D. Leave the Toronto route to the low-cost airline | 0.8 | 0.6 |
A loses the C$1.1m contribution that Sydney and Labrador passengers make on their connecting flights, and pays C$1.5m to leave the Labrador contract early. B assumes a price elasticity of demand of −0.6 on those routes. C saves C$2.4m on a new maintenance contract, C$2.7m net by replacing the three oldest aircraft with two newer ones, and C$3.9m from new crew rosters, which the unions must agree. D moves three aircraft to two new regional routes expected to contribute C$3.4m.
Section 06: Stakeholder implications
Who has a stake in the decision, how much they care and how much they can affect it, what they want, and what the decision would mean for them.
-
The pension fund and the founders' families
- What they want
- An airline that earns a fair return again and keeps its reputation in the region.
- What the decision means for them
- Every option needs their approval. Option C costs C$3.5m before it saves anything, which the owners must be willing to wait for.
-
Pilots and cabin crew, and their unions
- What they want
- Secure jobs, fair pay and rosters they can live with.
- What the decision means for them
- Option C saves C$3.9m only if the unions agree new rosters, so it gives them great influence over the result. Options A and D could cut flying, and with it jobs.
-
Communities along the Labrador coast
- What they want
- A reliable service at fares they can pay; for some, the airline is the only way in or out.
- What the decision means for them
- Option A would end their service unless another airline takes it on; option B would make it dearer. They have little power on their own, but they are heard through the provincial government.
-
The provincial government
- What they want
- The Labrador service kept running under the contract, at a fair cost to taxpayers.
- What the decision means for them
- Leaving the contract early costs C$1.5m and goodwill. The government might pay more to keep the route, which would change the case for option A.
-
Passengers on the busiest routes
- What they want
- Low fares and convenient times; on Toronto they now have a cheaper choice.
- What the decision means for them
- Option D would leave Toronto passengers to the low-cost airline and the national carrier. Raising fares on the routes with no competitor (option B) does not touch them.
-
Aircraft lessors and the maintenance contractor
- What they want
- Long contracts and payment on time.
- What the decision means for them
- Option C asks the maintenance contractor for a cheaper contract and the lessors to swap three old aircraft for two newer ones. Both will want something in return, such as longer terms.
Section 07: The strategic options
The courses of action open to the board. Each is set out on its own terms; the Analysis edition judges them.
Section 08: Evaluation criteria
How the board has said it will judge the options, and how much each criterion counts. The weights add up to 100.
| Criterion | How it is judged | Weight |
|---|---|---|
| Profit recovery | How much the response adds to operating profit, and how soon. | 30% |
| Risk of delivery | How likely the estimate is to be achieved, and what happens if it is not. | 20% |
| Employees and their unions | The effect on jobs, pay and the airline's relations with its workforce. | 20% |
| Communities and passengers | Whether the communities and passengers who depend on the airline are treated fairly. | 15% |
| Strategic position | Whether the airline ends up with a clearer and stronger position against its competitors. | 15% |
Section 09: Discussion questions
Answer them before you open the Analysis edition, which has notes on each.
In the style of the IB course
The platform's own questions, written for this briefing; they are not IB examination questions. The marks are each question's own allocation.
-
Using Exhibit 2, calculate Kittiwake Air's profit margin and its return on capital employed (ROCE) for 2025.
[4 marks]
-
Using Exhibit 1, calculate the airline's capacity utilization rate (its load factor) in 2023 and in 2025.
[4 marks]
-
Explain why a fall in passenger numbers has a larger effect on Kittiwake Air's profit than on its revenue.
[4 marks]
-
Discuss the proposal to raise fares by 8% on the four routes where Kittiwake Air has no competitor.
[10 marks]
-
Evaluate the cost programme (option C) as a strategy to improve Kittiwake Air's profitability ratios.
[10 marks]
HL-only questions are hidden in the SL view. Choose HL above to see them.
For seminars, beyond the course
For undergraduate, MBA and professional readers. These questions go beyond the IB course and are labelled as enrichment.
- Is a regional airline that competes with both a low-cost airline and a national carrier stuck in the middle? If so, what is its way out?
- Should a business keep a loss-making service that a remote community depends on? Who should pay for it?
- Most of an airline's costs are fixed in the short run. What does that imply for the order in which Kittiwake should try the four responses?
The Analysis edition The worked discussion: the evidence, the assumptions, every option judged and the recommendation. Open it when you have decided. About 7 minutes to read.
The Analysis edition
From here, the page gives the platform's reading of the case: its interpretation of the evidence, its judgement and its recommendation. It adds no new facts, and the same evidence can support other conclusions if they are argued well.
Section A1: Executive summary
Recommended Option C: Cut costs with the workforce, suppliers and a newer fleet
Restore profitability through costs, not through routes or captive passengers (option C). The airline's problem is that its costs rose by 16.4% in two years while its revenue rose by 8.1%; the cost programme answers that directly, and is worth an estimated C$9.0m a year, enough to turn a forecast loss of C$4.2m in 2027 into a profit of C$4.8m. It depends on an agreement with the unions, so the board should negotiate it openly, share the gains, and set a date by which, without agreement, it will reconsider the routes.
Section A2: What the evidence shows
The exhibits worked through. Every figure here is recomputed from the exhibits on every build.
- The fall in profit is a cost problem more than a revenue problem. Revenue grew by 8.1% between 2023 and 2025, but maintenance rose by 34.3% and staff costs by 20.2% (Exhibit 3), and the load factor fell from 68.4% to 66.5% (Exhibit 1), so each passenger carried more cost.
- The losing routes are a small part of the problem. Sydney and Labrador lost C$4.0m between them, but cutting them saves only C$2.9m once lost connections are counted, and costs C$1.5m to leave the Labrador contract (Exhibit 5).
- Only option C closes the gap. Against a forecast loss of C$4.2m in 2027, the options would leave operating profit at −C$1.3m (A), −C$1.0m (B), C$4.8m (C) and −C$3.4m (D) (Exhibit A1).
- The fare rise works on paper because demand on those routes is estimated to be inelastic: at −0.6, an 8% rise loses 4.8% of passengers but raises revenue by 2.816%. That estimate is the weakest number in the paper, and the routes are the ones whose passengers have nowhere else to go.
Operating profit in 2027 under each response (C$m)
Source: Simulated data| Response | Added each year | Operating profit in 2027 |
|---|---|---|
| No change | 0.0 | −4.2 |
| A. Cut the Sydney and Labrador routes | 2.9 | −1.3 |
| B. Raise fares by 8% on the four routes with no competitor | 3.2 | −1.0 |
| C. Cut costs with the workforce, suppliers and a newer fleet | 9.0 | 4.8 |
| D. Leave the Toronto route to the low-cost airline | 0.8 | −3.4 |
Without a roster agreement, option C would add C$5.1m, leaving a profit of C$0.9m in 2027.
Section A3: The assumptions
What the analysis takes as given, and how a manager would test it before relying on it.
-
The unions will agree new rosters that save C$3.9m a year.
How to test it Open talks before the board commits, and share the numbers. If a deal includes a pay rise, rework the saving net of it.
-
The newer aircraft will save C$2.7m a year net of their higher lease cost.
How to test it Ask the lessors for firm terms and check the fuel and maintenance savings against other airlines flying the same type.
-
Demand on the routes with no competitor has a price elasticity of −0.6.
How to test it It is an estimate. Test a smaller rise on one route first and measure what happens to bookings.
-
Without action, the airline would lose C$4.2m in 2027.
How to test it The forecast assumes costs keep rising at recent rates. Check it against the fuel price and the pay settlements already agreed.
Section A4: The trade-offs
What the board gives up to get what it wants. No option avoids all of them.
Speed, or depth
A fare rise adds money at once; the cost programme takes two years and costs C$3.5m first. The faster fix leaves the cause, rising costs, untouched.
Profit, or the region's trust
Cutting the Labrador service or charging its passengers more improves the accounts by exploiting the weakest stakeholders. An airline whose brand is the region may lose more in goodwill than it gains.
Savings, or relations with the workforce
The largest saving needs the unions' agreement. Imposing new rosters could save money on paper and cost it in disputes and departures; negotiating them shares some of the gain with the crews.
Section A5: The alternatives, judged
Every option judged against the evidence, then scored against the board's criteria.
The options scored against the board's criteria
Each option is scored from 1 (poor) to 5 (strong) on each criterion. The weighted score is the sum of each weight times its score, divided by 100. The scores are the analysis's judgement; a scoring matrix organizes judgement, it does not replace it.
| Criterion | Weight | Option A | Option B | Option C | Option D |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Profit recovery | 30% | 3 | 3 | 5 | 1 |
| Risk of delivery | 20% | 3 | 4 | 3 | 2 |
| Employees and their unions | 20% | 3 | 4 | 2 | 3 |
| Communities and passengers | 15% | 1 | 2 | 4 | 4 |
| Strategic position | 15% | 2 | 2 | 4 | 3 |
| Weighted score | 100% | 2.55 | 3.10 | 3.70 (the highest) | 2.35 |
Section A6: The recommended course of action
Option C: Cut costs with the workforce, suppliers and a newer fleet
Adopt the cost programme: a new maintenance contract, three of the oldest aircraft replaced by two newer ones, and new crew rosters negotiated with the unions, with part of the saving shared with the crews through a profit-related bonus. Keep every route, hold fares, and ask the government to review the Labrador contract on the evidence of its cost.
Why
- It acts on the cause of the decline, costs rising twice as fast as revenue.
- It is the only response that returns the airline to profit in 2027.
- It keeps the routes and fares that the airline's reputation in the region rests on.
- Sharing the gain gives the unions a reason to agree, which is the plan's main risk.
On these conditions
If no roster agreement is reached by the end of 2026, the saving falls to C$5.1m a year, which still returns the airline to a small profit of C$0.9m in 2027; the board should then reconsider the Sydney route, not the Labrador service.
Section A7: Implementation
What happens, in what order, and who answers for it.
- Months 1 to 2 Share the route and cost figures with the unions and open talks on rosters, with a profit-related bonus on the table. Chief executive and the head of people
- Months 1 to 4 Tender the maintenance contract and agree terms with the lessors for two newer aircraft. Finance director and head of engineering
- Months 4 to 12 Retire the three oldest aircraft as the newer ones arrive, and train crews on the new type. Head of operations
- Month 6 Present the Labrador route's costs to the provincial government and agree how the contract will be reviewed. Chief executive
- Month 12 Review progress against the measures below; if rosters are not agreed, reopen the case for the Sydney route. The board
Section A8: Evaluation: how to tell if it is working
The evaluation criteria, applied after the decision: what to measure, what counts as working, and when to look.
| Measure | Target | Reviewed |
|---|---|---|
| Operating profit | A return to profit in 2027, C$4.8m on the finance team's estimates, against a loss of C$4.2m with no action. | Every quarter |
| Costs by type | Maintenance and staff costs growing no faster than revenue from 2027. | Every quarter |
| Load factor | Back above the 68.4% of 2023 as the smaller, newer fleet flies fuller aircraft. | Every month |
| Relations with the workforce | A roster agreement signed by both unions, with no industrial action. | Every month during talks |
Section A9: Limitations
What the analysis cannot see, and what would change its recommendation.
The limits of the analysis
- Every saving is an estimate by the finance team, and the largest depends on negotiations whose outcome nobody can know.
- The route contributions depend on how shared costs are divided between routes; a different method would move the numbers.
- The forecast loss for 2027 assumes that recent cost increases continue; a fall in the fuel price would ease the pressure on every option.
What would change the recommendation
- If the unions refuse new rosters outright, the case for cutting the Sydney route grows.
- If the government offered to pay the full cost of the Labrador service, option A would no longer need to touch it, and the comparison would change.
- If the low-cost airline left the Toronto route, fares there would recover and the urgency of every option would fall.
Section A10: Notes on the discussion questions
What a strong answer to each discussion question does. Guidance, not a markscheme.
-
Question 1 [4 marks]
Profit margin = profit before interest and tax ÷ revenue × 100 = 1.9 ÷ 186.0 × 100 = 1.0%. ROCE = profit before interest and tax ÷ capital employed × 100 = 1.9 ÷ 64.0 × 100 = 3.0%. Two marks for each, with the working.
-
Question 2 [4 marks]HL
Capacity utilization rate = actual output ÷ productive capacity × 100, here passengers ÷ seats flown. 2023: 1,040 ÷ 1,520 × 100 = 68.4%. 2025: 1,090 ÷ 1,640 × 100 = 66.5%. The airline flew more seats but filled a smaller share of them, so its unit costs rose.
-
Question 3 [4 marks]
Most costs (aircraft leases, crews, maintenance, head office) are fixed in the short run and do not fall with passengers, so lost revenue comes almost straight off profit. Applied to the case: an operating profit of C$1.9m on revenue of C$186.0m leaves very little room.
-
Question 4 [10 marks]HL
Strong answers use the price elasticity of demand: at −0.6, passengers fall by 4.8% and revenue on those routes rises by 2.816%, about C$2.65m, plus C$0.57m of costs saved. They then weigh the estimate's reliability, the ethics of raising prices on a captive market, the government's view of the Labrador service and the risk of attracting a competitor, and reach a judgement.
-
Question 5 [10 marks]
Good answers note that C adds the most to profit, C$9.0m a year, turning the forecast loss of C$4.2m into a profit of C$4.8m and a profit margin of about 2.5%, still well below 2023's 8.0%. They weigh the union agreement it depends on, the C$3.5m of one-off costs and the two-year delay, and compare it with cheaper but more damaging options.
-
Seminar question 1 Enrichment
Arguments for: it has neither the lowest costs nor the network of the national carrier. Against: it may have a focus strategy, serving the region's smaller cities better than either. Good answers use the route contributions to say where its advantage lies, which is not on Toronto.
-
Seminar question 2 Enrichment
This turns on the business's objectives, its obligations under the contract, and whether the community's need is better met by a subsidy than by a cross-subsidy from other passengers. Good answers distinguish what the airline owes from what the government should buy.
-
Seminar question 3 Enrichment
Fixed costs make volume precious: cutting routes or giving one up shrinks the base that carries them, while cost and price changes act on the same base. Many answers will argue for costs first, prices second and routes last.
Notes on HL-only questions are hidden in the SL view.
The course and beyond
Where this briefing meets the IB course, and, kept apart and labelled, the ideas it draws on from beyond it.
Subtopics
- 3.5 Profitability and liquidity ratio analysis The profit margin and ROCE, and strategies to improve the profitability ratios.
- 3.3 Costs and revenues Fixed and variable costs, and why fixed costs make profit swing more than revenue.
- 4.5 The seven Ps of the marketing mix Pricing on routes with and without competition; at HL, price elasticity of demand.
- 5.6 Production planning HL The capacity utilization rate, which an airline calls its load factor.
- 2.7 Industrial/employee relations HL Collective bargaining with the pilots' and cabin crew unions over rosters.
- 1.4 Stakeholders Conflict between owners, employees, communities and the government over the response.
Frameworks in the course
- Porter's generic strategies IB toolkit HL Ask whether Kittiwake is a cost leader, a differentiator or focused on its region, and which response fits the answer.
- Contribution IB toolkit HL Judge each route by the contribution it makes towards the costs no single route causes.
- Force field analysis IB toolkit HL Weigh the forces for and against the cost programme, the unions' agreement above all.
Course terms
Ideas beyond the course
- Stuck in the middle Porter's argument that a firm must choose between lower cost and a valued difference, or risk earning less than rivals that choose, gives the board a test for each response: does it make Kittiwake cheaper than its rivals, or more valued by its passengers? The cost programme does the first; the region's routes may do the second. Source: Michael E. Porter (1980), Competitive Strategy: Techniques for Analyzing Industries and Competitors
Frameworks beyond the course
- The balanced scorecard Enrichment Track the recovery on more than profit, including the load factor, relations with the workforce and the communities served.
Go further: Advanced Management
- Competitive advantage and industry analysis Beyond the IB course Advanced strategy: the module behind this decision, with real organizations, models and a decision exercise.
- Strategy execution, change and crisis Beyond the IB course Advanced strategy: the module behind this decision, with real organizations, models and a decision exercise.
- Financial statement analysis Beyond the IB course Advanced financial management: the module behind this decision, with real organizations, models and a decision exercise.
Work it through
The platform's tools that apply the briefing's ideas to its figures, or to your own.
- Financial Laboratory Profit margin Rework the profit margin for each year in Exhibit 2.
- Financial Laboratory Return on capital employed (ROCE) Rework the return on capital employed.
- Financial Laboratory Contribution per unit and total contribution Work a route's contribution from its revenue and direct costs (HL).
- Strategy Studio Porter's generic strategies Place Kittiwake against the low-cost airline and the national carrier.
- IB toolkit guide Porter's generic strategies The toolkit guide to the generic strategies (HL).
Sources and method
- Method How the Boardroom Briefings and their figures were made, Arjun Agrawal | The Business Brief (2026). The platform’s own method.
- Research Competitive Strategy: Techniques for Analyzing Industries and Competitors, Michael E. Porter, Free Press (1980). Cited as a reference; not opened for this release.
Arjun Agrawal | The Business Brief, https://the-business-brief-dun.vercel.app/boardroom-briefings/declining-profitability/. Original teaching material, not an IB publication. The organizations in the teaching cases are fictional unless a case says otherwise.