Keep the price at €22
Absorb the higher electricity costs.
- Requires
- Nothing new.
- Upside
- Customers see no change and sales should hold at about 640 mugs.
- Risks
- Contribution per mug falls and the margin of safety narrows.
Evidence: Exhibit 1
Case file · Manufacturing and craft
A ceramics studio in Porto faces an energy price rise and an order at half its usual price, in the same week.
The decision
How should Atelier Barro respond to higher energy costs, and should it accept the hotel's order?
Atelier Barro sells about 640 hand-thrown mugs a month at €22. From November its electricity costs rise, and a hotel group has offered to buy 300 mugs at €11 each. To decide either question the owner needs to know what each mug really costs, which costs change with output and which do not, and how many mugs the studio must sell to cover its costs.
Inês Carvalho left an architecture practice in 2021 to throw pots in a former printing workshop in Porto's Bonfim district. Atelier Barro now sells about 640 hand-thrown stoneware mugs a month, seven in ten through its own website and the rest in the studio shop, at €22 each. Two throwers make the mugs and are paid €2.40 for each one that passes inspection. A studio manager, Rui Mendes, runs the shop, the website and the dispatch table.
The business pays its way, just. After every cost, including the salary Inês pays herself, the mugs made about €1,600 a month last year. Weekend workshops and firing other potters' work in the kiln bring in more, but Inês keeps those figures separate and does not count on them.
This autumn two letters arrived in the same week. The electricity supplier announced a new tariff from 1 November: the cost of firing the kiln rises from €0.45 to €0.75 a mug, and the monthly standing charge from €260 to €340. And Casa Alfama Hotels, a small group of boutique hotels in Lisbon, asked whether Atelier Barro would make 300 mugs stamped with the hotels' name, for delivery in November, at €11 each.
Inês's first reaction to the hotel was to say no. €11 is half her shop price, and she suspects it is less than a mug costs her to make. Her first reaction to the electricity bill was to raise prices. Rui is less sure on both counts. He points out that most of the studio's costs do not change with the number of mugs, that the throwers are paid by the mug in any case, and that their customer survey (Exhibit 3) suggests some customers would stop buying at a higher price.
Before deciding either question, Inês has asked Rui to put the numbers in front of her.
5 exhibits. Each is labelled with what kind of evidence it is.
| Cost | How it is incurred | Before, € | From November, € |
|---|---|---|---|
| Studio rent | Each month | 1,900 | 1,900 |
| Kiln lease | Each month | 450 | 450 |
| Studio manager's salary | Each month | 2,300 | 2,300 |
| Owner's salary | Each month | 2,400 | 2,400 |
| Insurance | Each month | 150 | 150 |
| Website and software | Each month | 120 | 120 |
| Marketing (social media advertising) | Each month | 480 | 480 |
| Electricity standing charge | Each month | 260 | 340 |
| Electricity for firing | Per mug | 0.45 | 0.75 |
| Clay and glaze | Per mug | 2.30 | 2.30 |
| Thrower's piece rate | Per mug | 2.40 | 2.40 |
| Packaging | Per mug | 0.85 | 0.85 |
| Card and platform fees | Per mug, 4% of the price | 0.88 | 0.88 |
Costs incurred each month total €8,060 before November and €8,140 from November. Costs per mug total €6.88 and €7.18 at a price of €22. The card and platform fee is 4% of the price, so it changes if the price changes. All the studio's monthly costs are counted against the mugs; workshops and firing services are left out.
| Stream | Basis | Revenue, € |
|---|---|---|
| Mug sales, online shop | 5,376 mugs at €22 | 118,272 |
| Mug sales, studio shop | 2,304 mugs at €22 | 50,688 |
| Weekend workshops | 24 sessions, 8 people, €55 each | 10,560 |
| Kiln firing for other potters | Charged per firing | 3,600 |
| Total | 183,120 |
Mug sales were 92% of revenue. The workshops and firing service have costs of their own, which are not in Exhibit 1.
| Price, € | Estimated mugs a month | Basis of the estimate |
|---|---|---|
| 20 | 700 | Survey |
| 22 | 640 | Actual average over the last twelve months |
| 24 | 590 | Survey and a two-week price test on the website |
| 25 | 560 | Survey |
| 27 | 480 | Survey |
Survey of 410 customers in September; price test at €24 for two weeks in October. The estimates assume the mugs and the packaging do not change. Inês believes premium packaging could hold sales nearer 580 at €25, but that has not been tested.
We would like 300 mugs in your Douro glaze, stamped with our name, delivered to Lisbon by 20 November. We can pay €11 a mug, invoiced. We may want more next year.
| Stakeholder | Interest | Influence | Stake | Concern |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Inês Carvalho, owner | A business that pays her a living and keeps its reputation for premium, hand-made work. | High | High | Being forced into a price war, or into making cheap mugs for other brands. |
| Rui Mendes, studio manager | A stable business and a sensible workload in the shop and at dispatch. | Medium | High | A rushed November with the hotel order on top of the busy season. |
| The two throwers | Earnings, which depend on the number of mugs made. | Low | High | Fewer mugs, and so lower pay, if sales fall after a price rise. |
| Online and studio customers | Distinctive, well-made mugs at a price they consider fair. | Medium | Medium | Paying more, or discovering the same mugs in hotel rooms at half the price. |
| Casa Alfama Hotels | Distinctive local mugs for its rooms at a price that suits its budget. | Medium | Low | Delivery on time for its guests' winter season. |
| The electricity supplier | Covering its own higher costs. | Low | Low | None in this decision; its tariff is fixed. |
From data to a recommendation, in the order an examiner rewards. Try your own before you read it.
DataWhat the exhibits say
InsightWhat it means
OptionsWhat each choice does
RecommendationOne defensible answer
One defensible recommendation: raise the price to €24, the option with the strongest evidence behind it, and accept the hotel's order, negotiating only if Inês judges that the hotel would still buy. Ask for the stamp to read "made by Atelier Barro for Casa Alfama", so that the order also advertises the studio. Review the price after three months against actual sales.
CaveatWhen it would change
This depends on the survey being right about customers' response to €24, and on the hotel's order not leading shop customers to expect lower prices. If the hotel wanted its mugs in December, when the kiln is close to full, accepting would displace sales at full price and the answer would change.
Prompts for undergraduate and MBA seminars. They go beyond the IB course and are labelled as enrichment.
Back to the Case Vault: every case, with filters and the Case of the Week.
Arjun Agrawal | The Business Brief, https://the-business-brief-dun.vercel.app/cases/atelier-barro/. Original teaching material, not an IB publication. The organizations in the teaching cases are fictional unless a case says otherwise.