No. 06 The Boardroom Briefings Growth and funding
Should a start-up prioritize growth or profitability?
Mãozinha's founders choose between more cities and a profit
A São Paulo marketplace for home repairs has nearly doubled its bookings every year and lost money every year. Investors will pay for more growth; the numbers ask whether more of the same is worth buying.
- Company
- Mãozinha, São Paulo, Brazil
- Industry
- E-commerce
- Decision
- Growth and funding
- Functions
- Strategy and management, Finance and accounts, Marketing
- Key concepts
- Change, Creativity
- Editions
- Student, then Analysis
You are reading the Student edition. The recommendation is withheld.
This briefing has two editions. The Student edition comes first: the case and the questions. The Analysis edition follows it, closed, so that you can decide before you read the recommendation.
The edition switch could not start. Both editions are on the page: the Analysis edition follows the Student edition.
The Student edition
Section 01: Executive summary
The decision in brief. In this edition the summary stops short of a recommendation.
The situation
Mãozinha connects households with electricians, plumbers, cleaners and painters, and keeps 18% of each booking. The value of bookings rose from R$22.0m in 2023 to R$96.0m in 2025 across four cities, but the company lost R$15.4m last year and has R$31.0m in the bank.
The decision
Whether to take R$60m from a growth fund and open in six more cities; to stop spending on growth and reach a profit with the money it has; to raise a smaller sum and fix the business before growing again; or to sell to a larger platform.
What is at stake
At its present rate of loss the company has about two years of cash. The choice decides how fast it can grow, how much of it the founders keep, and whether the business it scales is one that makes money.
Section 02: Business background
Beatriz Lima and Rafael Souza, two engineers who had both waited weeks for a reliable plumber, founded Mãozinha in São Paulo in 2022. Households book a vetted professional through the app, pay through it, and can rate the work; the professionals, who are self-employed, get a steady flow of jobs and payment within days. Mãozinha keeps 18% of each booking. The company opened in Campinas in 2023, Rio de Janeiro in 2024 and Belo Horizonte in 2025, and now has 85 employees and 6,200 professionals using the platform.
Growth has been fast and expensive. Bookings grew by 131.8% in 2024 and by 88.2% in 2025, but marketing, mostly online advertising to win new customers, cost R$14.4m last year, and the company's operating loss widened from R$7.0m in 2023 to R$15.4m (Exhibit 2). It ended 2025 with R$31.0m in cash from its last funding round.
Three proposals are on the table. A growth fund has offered R$60m for 35.1% of the company, on the condition that it opens in six more cities in 2026. The early investors would put in R$20m if the company first proved its numbers. And a large delivery app, which has added home services in two cities, has offered R$140m for the whole business.
- Company
- Mãozinha
- Business
- Online marketplace for home services
- Based in
- São Paulo, Brazil
- Size
- 85 employees, 6,200 professionals using the platform and bookings worth R$96.0m in 2025
- Ownership
- Privately held company, 52% owned by its two founders and 48% by early investors
- Figures in
- BRL, in thousands (R$000)
- Status
- A fictional company. Every figure is simulated for teaching and checked for consistency.
Section 03: Strategic context
The industry and the forces on the decision, in general terms. The only figures in this briefing are the company's own.
Marketplaces grow by bringing together two sides, here households and professionals, and each side is more useful the more of the other it finds. That rewards being first and biggest in a city, and many marketplaces spend heavily on growth in the belief that the leader in each city will eventually earn the profits.
The belief holds only if customers keep coming back. A household that books once, after an advertisement, and never returns costs more to win than it pays back; one that books again and again is worth winning even at a high cost. The economics of each customer, and of each city, decide whether growth creates value or destroys it.
Investors' appetite for growth at any cost rises and falls. When money is easy to raise, start-ups are rewarded for growing fast; when it is scarce, they are asked to show a path to profit, and those that cannot may not survive to the next round.
Section 04: Relevant evidence
The company's own evidence (simulated), established research (cited, and stated only as its central idea) and how the market works.
-
The company’s own evidence Source: Simulated data
Faster growth, larger losses
The value of bookings rose from R$22,000k in 2023 to R$96,000k in 2025, and the operating loss from R$7,020k to R$15,360k (Exhibit 2). Each year the company spent more on marketing than it earned in contribution: R$14,400k against R$8,640k in 2025.
See Exhibit 2
-
The company’s own evidence Source: Simulated data
Two cities pay back, two do not
Winning a customer cost R$90.00 in São Paulo but R$210.00 in Belo Horizonte, and 65% of São Paulo's customers booked again the next year against 45% in Belo Horizonte (Exhibit 1). A customer contributes about R$72 a year, so the cities differ greatly in how much each new customer is worth.
See Exhibit 1
-
The company’s own evidence Source: Simulated data
Three plans for 2026 and 2027
The finance team has forecast three plans (Exhibit 3). Growth with the fund's money would still lose R$21,000k in 2027. Focusing on São Paulo and Campinas would break even in 2027. Fixing the economics first, with R$20m from the early investors, would cut the loss to R$3,500k in 2027.
See Exhibit 3
-
Established research Cited research
Firms can grow only as fast as their managers can learn
Penrose argued that a firm's rate of growth is limited by its managers' capacity to plan and absorb expansion: new managers take time to learn how the firm works, so a firm that tries to grow faster than its management can adapt runs into rising costs and mistakes.
Source: Edith Penrose (1959), The Theory of the Growth of the Firm
-
How the market works General context
What investors look for in a marketplace
Investors in marketplaces watch how much it costs to win a customer, how many customers come back, and how long a customer takes to repay the cost of winning them. Growth that improves those measures is valued highly; growth that worsens them is not.
The exhibits
Winning and keeping customers, city by city, 2025
Source: Simulated data| City | New customers | Marketing (R$000) | Cost to win a customer (R$) | Customers who book again the next year (%) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| São Paulo (since 2022) | 62,000 | 5,580 | 90.00 | 65 |
| Campinas (since 2023) | 18,000 | 1,980 | 110.00 | 60 |
| Rio de Janeiro (since 2024) | 26,000 | 3,900 | 150.00 | 50 |
| Belo Horizonte (since 2025) | 14,000 | 2,940 | 210.00 | 45 |
| All four cities | 120,000 | 14,400 | 120.00 |
The share of customers who book again is the share of 2024's customers who booked at least once in 2025; for Belo Horizonte, the first months' rate. Across the four cities, winning a customer cost R$120.00 on average.
Section 05: Financial information
Exhibit 2 gives three years of results, from the value of bookings to the operating result. Exhibit 1 shows, for each city, how many new customers were won in 2025, at what marketing cost, and how many customers book again. Exhibit 3 gives the finance team's forecasts for the three plans that involve keeping the company, with the cash each would leave at the end of 2027. A customer contributes about R$72 a year: 3.2 bookings of R$250, at 18% commission and a 50% contribution margin.
Mãozinha's growth and losses, 2023 to 2025 (R$000)
Source: Simulated data| Year | Value of bookings | Revenue (18% commission) | Contribution | Marketing | Fixed costs | Operating result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 | 22,000 | 3,960 | 1,980 | 4,800 | 4,200 | −7,020 |
| 2024 | 51,000 | 9,180 | 4,590 | 9,600 | 6,900 | −11,910 |
| 2025 | 96,000 | 17,280 | 8,640 | 14,400 | 9,600 | −15,360 |
Contribution is revenue less payment fees, insurance for each job and customer support, which together take half of revenue. Fixed costs are salaries, technology and offices.
The three plans to keep the company, 2026 and 2027 (R$000)
Source: Simulated data| Plan | New money raised | Value of bookings 2026 | Operating result 2026 | Value of bookings 2027 | Operating result 2027 | Cash at the end of 2027 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A. Raise R$60m and open six more cities | 60,000 | 180,000 | −22,200 | 300,000 | −21,000 | 47,800 |
| B. Focus on São Paulo and Campinas until profitable | 0 | 115,200 | −1,872 | 138,240 | 202 | 29,330 |
| C. Raise R$20m and fix the economics before growing | 20,000 | 130,000 | −5,600 | 180,000 | −3,500 | 41,900 |
A spends R$24.0m on marketing and R$14.4m on fixed costs in 2026, rising to R$30.0m and R$18.0m. B cuts marketing to R$3.6m a year, spent on keeping existing customers, and fixed costs by 10%, and grows bookings by 20% a year. C raises the commission to 20% with a guarantee on every job, stops marketing in Belo Horizonte, spends R$9.0m and then R$11.0m on marketing, and keeps fixed costs at R$9.6m, then R$10.5m.
Section 06: Stakeholder implications
Who has a stake in the decision, how much they care and how much they can affect it, what they want, and what the decision would mean for them.
-
Beatriz Lima and Rafael Souza, the founders
- What they want
- A business that lasts and leads its market, and enough of it to keep control of its direction.
- What the decision means for them
- The fund's money would cut their 52% to 33.8%; the sale would pay them R$72.8m and end their control; the other two plans keep more of the company but grow it more slowly.
-
The early investors
- What they want
- A return on their 48%, sooner rather than later.
- What the decision means for them
- They would be diluted by the fund but paid out by the sale; their R$20m offer under plan C shows they believe in the business if it proves its numbers.
-
The professionals on the platform
- What they want
- A steady flow of jobs, fair commission and prompt payment; most depend on the platform for much of their income.
- What the decision means for them
- Expansion brings more jobs only where demand grows; plan C's higher commission takes more of each job, though with a guarantee that protects them in disputes.
-
Households
- What they want
- A reliable professional, quickly, at a fair price.
- What the decision means for them
- They notice service quality more than the number of cities. A company stretched across ten cities may serve each one less well.
-
Employees
- What they want
- Secure jobs and shares that might one day be worth something.
- What the decision means for them
- Plan A would mean rapid hiring; plan B a 10% cut in fixed costs, some of it in jobs; a sale an uncertain future inside a larger company.
-
The growth fund and the delivery app
- What they want
- The fund wants fast growth to justify its valuation; the app wants a business it can fold into its own.
- What the decision means for them
- Each offer comes with conditions that would shape the company for years: six cities in a year, or the end of its independence.
Section 07: The strategic options
The courses of action open to the board. Each is set out on its own terms; the Analysis edition judges them.
Section 08: Evaluation criteria
How the board has said it will judge the options, and how much each criterion counts. The weights add up to 100.
| Criterion | How it is judged | Weight |
|---|---|---|
| Value creation | Whether the plan builds a business whose customers are worth more than they cost to win, with a path to profit. | 25% |
| Survival | The cash left at the end of 2027 and how far the plan depends on raising more. | 25% |
| Market position | How strong the company would be against rivals in the cities that matter. | 20% |
| Control | How much of the company, and of its direction, the founders keep. | 15% |
| Professionals and employees | The effect on the professionals' work and income, and on the company's staff. | 15% |
Section 09: Discussion questions
Answer them before you open the Analysis edition, which has notes on each.
In the style of the IB course
The platform's own questions, written for this briefing; they are not IB examination questions. The marks are each question's own allocation.
-
Using Exhibit 2 and the cash figure in the background, calculate how many months Mãozinha's cash would last at its 2025 rate of loss.
[3 marks]
-
Using Exhibit 2, calculate the growth in the value of bookings in 2025.
[2 marks]
-
Explain one advantage and one disadvantage to the founders of raising share capital from the growth fund.
[4 marks]
-
Discuss the advantages and disadvantages, for the professionals and for Mãozinha, of a business model built on self-employed workers.
[10 marks]
-
Recommend whether Mãozinha should pursue growth or profitability over the next two years.
[10 marks]
For seminars, beyond the course
For undergraduate, MBA and professional readers. These questions go beyond the IB course and are labelled as enrichment.
- Penrose argued that growth is limited by managers' capacity to absorb it. What would that limit look like at Mãozinha if it opened six cities in a year?
- When does it make sense for a start-up to grow faster than its unit economics justify?
- Is R$140m a good price for Mãozinha? What would you need to know to decide?
The Analysis edition The worked discussion: the evidence, the assumptions, every option judged and the recommendation. Open it when you have decided. About 6 minutes to read.
The Analysis edition
From here, the page gives the platform's reading of the case: its interpretation of the evidence, its judgement and its recommendation. It adds no new facts, and the same evidence can support other conclusions if they are argued well.
Section A1: Executive summary
Recommended Option C: Raise R$20m and fix the economics before growing
Neither growth at any cost nor profit at any cost: fix the economics, then grow (option C). The city figures show that Mãozinha's growth creates value where customers come back, in São Paulo and Campinas, and destroys it where they do not: in Belo Horizonte a customer is worth R$130.9 over their time with the company and costs R$210.00 to win. Taking R$60m to open six more cities would scale the losses before the model works; stopping growth altogether would hand the market to rivals. With R$20m from its early investors, Mãozinha can prove the economics in a year and then grow where they work.
Section A2: What the evidence shows
The exhibits worked through. Every figure here is recomputed from the exhibits on every build.
- Unit economics vary by city. A customer is worth R$205.7 over their time with Mãozinha in São Paulo, 2.29 times the R$90.00 it costs to win them; in Belo Horizonte, R$130.9, only 0.62 times the R$210.00 it costs (Exhibit A1).
- Each year's growth has cost more than it earned: R$14,400k of marketing against R$8,640k of contribution in 2025 (Exhibit 2). At the 2025 rate of loss the company has 24.2 months of cash.
- Plan A still loses R$21,000k in 2027 and depends on raising again; plan B breaks even in 2027 but grows only 20% a year; plan C loses R$3,500k in 2027 but leaves R$41,900k in cash, enough to grow from (Exhibit 3).
- Raising the commission to 20% lifts a customer's yearly contribution from R$72 to R$80, which, with better repeat bookings, is what turns Rio from a borderline city into a profitable one.
What a customer is worth in each city, 2025 (R$)
Source: Simulated data| City | Cost to win a customer | Lifetime value of a customer | Lifetime value ÷ cost to win | Months to repay the cost to win |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| São Paulo (since 2022) | 90.00 | 205.7 | 2.29 | 15.0 |
| Campinas (since 2023) | 110.00 | 180.0 | 1.64 | 18.3 |
| Rio de Janeiro (since 2024) | 150.00 | 144.0 | 0.96 | 25.0 |
| Belo Horizonte (since 2025) | 210.00 | 130.9 | 0.62 | 35.0 |
Lifetime value is the yearly contribution of R$72 times the expected number of years a customer stays, 1 ÷ (1 − the share who book again). It is not discounted. These are measures beyond the IB course, used by investors in start-ups.
Section A3: The assumptions
What the analysis takes as given, and how a manager would test it before relying on it.
-
New cities would behave like the newest existing ones, not like São Paulo.
How to test it Belo Horizonte and Rio are the best evidence of what a new city costs. If the fund believes otherwise, ask why, and test it in one city before six.
-
A customer's value can be estimated from one year's repeat rate.
How to test it Repeat rates for new cities are early figures. Track each city's customers month by month for a year before relying on them.
-
Professionals will accept a 20% commission in return for a guarantee on every job.
How to test it Pilot the new terms in one city and watch how many professionals stay active.
-
Rivals will not take an unassailable lead during the year Mãozinha spends fixing its economics.
How to test it Watch rivals' activity city by city. A marketplace's lead is hardest to overturn where customers rebook through habit.
Section A4: The trade-offs
What the board gives up to get what it wants. No option avoids all of them.
Speed, or soundness
The fund offers speed, and asks for six cities in a year. The figures say the model is sound in two cities and unsound in one. Speed now multiplies whichever is true of the new cities.
Control, or capital
Each round of money buys growth with a share of the company. The fund's R$60m costs the founders more than a third of their stake; the early investors' R$20m costs less and comes with patience.
The professionals' income, or the company's margin
A higher commission improves the company's economics at the professionals' expense. The guarantee on every job is what makes the trade fair, and it must be real.
Section A5: The alternatives, judged
Every option judged against the evidence, then scored against the board's criteria.
The options scored against the board's criteria
Each option is scored from 1 (poor) to 5 (strong) on each criterion. The weighted score is the sum of each weight times its score, divided by 100. The scores are the analysis's judgement; a scoring matrix organizes judgement, it does not replace it.
| Criterion | Weight | Option A | Option B | Option C | Option D |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Value creation | 25% | 2 | 4 | 5 | 3 |
| Survival | 25% | 3 | 5 | 4 | 5 |
| Market position | 20% | 5 | 2 | 4 | 3 |
| Control | 15% | 2 | 5 | 4 | 1 |
| Professionals and employees | 15% | 3 | 2 | 4 | 2 |
| Weighted score | 100% | 3.00 | 3.70 | 4.25 (the highest) | 3.05 |
Section A6: The recommended course of action
Option C: Raise R$20m and fix the economics before growing
Take R$20m from the early investors and spend 2026 fixing the economics: raise the commission to 20% with a real guarantee on every job, stop paid marketing in Belo Horizonte while serving its existing customers, work on repeat bookings, and keep Rio under review. Open a new city only when the existing ones show that a customer is worth at least twice what it costs to win.
Why
- Growth creates value only where customers come back, and the city figures show where that is.
- It cuts the loss to R$3,500k by 2027 and leaves R$41,900k of cash, so the company can grow again from strength.
- It keeps the founders in control and the early investors on side.
- It keeps the option to raise from the fund, or to sell, on better terms once the economics are proven.
On these conditions
The recommendation depends on the professionals accepting the new commission. If many leave, the company should hold the commission at 18% and find the improvement in repeat bookings and lower marketing costs instead.
Section A7: Implementation
What happens, in what order, and who answers for it.
- Months 1 to 2 Agree the R$20m round with the early investors, with milestones for repeat bookings and the cost of winning customers. The founders and the finance director
- Months 1 to 3 Pilot the 20% commission with the job guarantee in Campinas; stop paid marketing in Belo Horizonte. Head of marketplace
- Months 3 to 9 Build repeat-booking features (saved professionals, reminders for regular jobs) and roll out the new terms if the pilot holds. Head of product
- Month 12 Review each city against the rule of a customer worth at least twice what it costs to win; choose the next city, or reopen talks with the fund. The board
Section A8: Evaluation: how to tell if it is working
The evaluation criteria, applied after the decision: what to measure, what counts as working, and when to look.
| Measure | Target | Reviewed |
|---|---|---|
| Lifetime value against the cost to win a customer | At least two times in every city where Mãozinha advertises, from 2.29 in São Paulo and 0.62 in Belo Horizonte today. | Every quarter, city by city |
| Repeat bookings | The share of customers booking again rising in every city, towards São Paulo's 65%. | Every month |
| Professionals | Active professionals holding at about 6,200 or more after the commission change. | Every month |
| Cash | At or above the plan's path to R$41,900k at the end of 2027. | Every month |
Section A9: Limitations
What the analysis cannot see, and what would change its recommendation.
The limits of the analysis
- Repeat rates in the newer cities are early figures, and lifetime values built on them are rough.
- The forecasts for each plan are the finance team's, and growth rates two years out are guesses.
- The analysis treats a customer's value as contribution over an expected lifetime and does not discount it; a stricter measure would lower every city's figure.
What would change the recommendation
- If a rival began to dominate São Paulo, the company's strongest city, holding back would be riskier than growing.
- If new evidence showed that customers in the newer cities come back more as the service matures, the case for growth would strengthen.
- If the early investors would not put in R$20m, plan B becomes the safer route to survival.
Section A10: Notes on the discussion questions
What a strong answer to each discussion question does. Guidance, not a markscheme.
-
Question 1 [3 marks]
Monthly loss = 15,360 ÷ 12 = R$1,280k. Cash ÷ monthly loss = 31,000 ÷ 1,280 = 24.2 months. The answer assumes the loss stays at 2025's rate; under plan A it would grow.
-
Question 2 [2 marks]
Growth = (96,000 − 51,000) ÷ 51,000 × 100 = 88.2%. One mark for the method, one for the answer.
-
Question 3 [4 marks]
Advantage: R$60m that never has to be repaid, with no interest, to fund growth. Disadvantage: the founders' share falls from 52% to 33.8%, so they give up control and part of any future profit. Each point applied to the case.
-
Question 4 [10 marks]
Strong answers weigh flexibility and low fixed costs for the company, and independence and a flow of jobs for the professionals, against insecurity, the lack of benefits and dependence on one platform's commission, which plan C would raise. They reach a judgement on whether the model is fair and sustainable.
-
Question 5 [10 marks]
The best answers use the city figures to show that the answer differs by city, test each plan's results and cash against the objective of survival, weigh the founders' control, and make a clear recommendation with its conditions. Answers that simply prefer growth or profit without the unit economics miss the case's central evidence.
-
Seminar question 1 Enrichment
Ten cities at once means hiring city managers who do not yet know how the business works, while the founders cannot attend to each launch. Good answers predict where the strain would show first: vetting professionals, service quality and the cost of winning customers.
-
Seminar question 2 Enrichment
When being first in a market gives a lasting advantage, as network effects can, and when the economics are likely to improve with scale. Neither is shown by Belo Horizonte's figures. Good answers name the evidence that would change the conclusion.
-
Seminar question 3 Enrichment
The price is about 8.1 times 2025 revenue, a figure that means little on its own. Good answers ask what the business would be worth if plan C succeeded, how certain that is, and what the founders and investors want beyond money.
The course and beyond
Where this briefing meets the IB course, and, kept apart and labelled, the ideas it draws on from beyond it.
Subtopics
- 1.3 Business objectives Growth and profit as competing objectives, and the strategic and tactical objectives that follow from each.
- 1.5 Growth and evolution Reasons for businesses to grow, and to stay small, applied to a start-up choosing its pace.
- 3.2 Sources of finance Share capital from investors, and which source of finance suits each plan.
- 3.7 Cash flow Cash flow and liquidity: how long the cash lasts while the business makes a loss.
- 2.1 Introduction to human resource management The gig economy: a business built on self-employed professionals.
- 4.1 Introduction to marketing Market growth and market share in a market with network effects.
- 3.3 Costs and revenues Revenue streams (the commission) and costs, fixed and variable.
Frameworks in the course
- The Ansoff matrix IB toolkit Opening in new cities is market development; better repeat bookings in existing cities is market penetration.
Course terms
Ideas beyond the course
- Unit economics and the limits to growth Investors in start-ups judge growth by the economics of each customer: what it costs to win one, what they contribute and how long they stay. Penrose's older argument adds that a firm also cannot grow faster than its managers can learn to run it. Together they explain why the fastest growth is not always the most valuable.
- Unit economics
- Customer acquisition cost (CAC)
- Customer lifetime value (CLV)
- Churn rate
- Burn rate
- Runway
- Network effects
- Dilution
- Venture capital
Frameworks beyond the course
- The business model canvas Enrichment Map how Mãozinha creates value for two customer groups, households and professionals, and where its costs and revenue come from.
- SMART objectives Enrichment Turn "fix the economics" into measurable targets for repeat bookings and the cost of winning customers.
- The balanced scorecard Enrichment Judge progress on customers and professionals as well as on the finances.
Go further: Advanced Management
- Unit economics and entrepreneurial finance Beyond the IB course Entrepreneurship and innovation: the module behind this decision, with real organizations, models and a decision exercise.
- Funding strategy and venture capital Beyond the IB course Entrepreneurship and innovation: the module behind this decision, with real organizations, models and a decision exercise.
- Scaling, innovation management, failure and recovery Beyond the IB course Entrepreneurship and innovation: the module behind this decision, with real organizations, models and a decision exercise.
- Customer economics: segmentation, acquisition and lifetime value Beyond the IB course Advanced marketing: the module behind this decision, with real organizations, models and a decision exercise.
Work it through
The platform's tools that apply the briefing's ideas to its figures, or to your own.
- Entrepreneurship and Innovation Lab Unit economics calculator Work a customer's lifetime value and the cost of winning them for each city.
- Entrepreneurship and Innovation Lab Start-up cost calculator Test how long the cash lasts under different rates of loss.
- Entrepreneurship and Innovation Lab Scaling, failure and exit The Lab's briefing on when to scale, when to stop and when to sell.
- Financial Laboratory Cash flow forecast Build a month-by-month forecast for plan C.
- IB toolkit guide Ansoff matrix The toolkit guide to the directions of growth.
Sources and method
- Method How the Boardroom Briefings and their figures were made, Arjun Agrawal | The Business Brief (2026). The platform’s own method.
- Research The Theory of the Growth of the Firm, Edith Penrose, Basil Blackwell (1959). Cited as a reference; not opened for this release.
Arjun Agrawal | The Business Brief, https://the-business-brief-dun.vercel.app/boardroom-briefings/growth-or-profitability/. Original teaching material, not an IB publication. The organizations in the teaching cases are fictional unless a case says otherwise.