Toolkit
Contribution
The use of contribution per unit and total contribution to make decisions, such as whether to accept a special order.
Section 01: What it is for
To judge a decision by what it adds to profit, comparing the revenue it brings with the costs it causes.
- Class
- Decision-making (the platform's reading; the TSM does not classify this tool)
- Suggested units
- Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5 (guide, p. 14)
- The guide includes
- Make or buy analysis; Contribution costing; Absorption costing
When to use it
- Deciding whether to accept an order at a lower price than usual.
- Comparing products, to decide which to promote or drop.
- Deciding whether to make a component or buy it in.
How to build it
- Identify the variable cost per unit of what the decision involves.
- Calculate contribution per unit, the price minus the variable cost per unit.
- Multiply by the quantity to find the total contribution.
- Subtract any fixed costs caused only by the decision.
- Check the conditions. Is there spare capacity? Will regular sales or prices be affected? Is there a better use for the capacity?
The evidence it needs
- Variable cost per unit, from the cost ledger.
- The price and quantity of the order or product.
- Capacity and regular sales in the period concerned.
Section 02: What it shows, and what it hides
- Whether a decision adds to profit in the short run.
- Why an order priced below average cost can still be worth taking.
- The long-run effects on the price position and on regular customers.
- The opportunity cost of the capacity used, unless it is included.
Limitations
- It is a short-run tool. In the long run every cost has to be covered.
- It depends on separating fixed and variable costs correctly.
- It assumes the decision does not change what regular customers pay or buy.
Section 03: Applied: The hotel's order for 300 mugs at €11
From the case Atelier Barro.
Each hotel mug has a variable cost of €5.85, so it contributes €5.15. Three hundred contribute €1,545, and after the €150 stamp the order adds (€11.00 − €5.85) × 300 − €150 = €1,395 to November's profit.
Interaction
The hotel's order, judged on contribution
The panel could not start. The figures below are for the order as offered.
Results
- Contribution per mug on the order
- €5.15
- Contribution from the order
- €1,545.00
- Spare capacity before the order
- 370 mugs
- Regular sales displaced
- 0 mugsnone
- Change in profit
- +€1,395.00
- Lowest price that does not reduce profit
- €6.35average cost is €19.90
Reading. The price is €8.90 below the average cost of a mug, yet the order adds €1,395.00. Regular sales already cover the fixed costs, so each mug on the order only has to cover its own variable cost of €5.85.
Implication. On these figures the lowest price that does not reduce profit is €6.35 a mug. Before accepting, weigh what the figures leave out: whether regular customers would expect the same price, and what the order does to the brand.
The working: change in profit
- Given
- Price offered per mug: €11.00
- Variable cost per mug: €5.85
- Order size: 300 mugs
- Extra costs caused only by the order: €150
- Formula
- Change in profit = (order price − variable cost per unit) × order size − extra fixed costs
- Substitution
- = (€11.00 − €5.85) × 300 − €150
- Working
- Contribution per unit on the order = 11.00 − 5.85 = 5.155.15 × 300 = 1,545.001,545.00 − 150.00 = 1,395.00
- Answer
- €1,395
Valid only if there is spare capacity and the lower price does not change what regular customers pay or buy.
- Unit
- €, change in profit for the month
- Interpretation
- The price is €8.90 below the average cost of a mug, yet the order adds €1,395.00. Regular sales already cover the fixed costs, so each mug on the order only has to cover its own variable cost of €5.85.
- Business implication
- On these figures the lowest price that does not reduce profit is €6.35 a mug. Before accepting, weigh what the figures leave out: whether regular customers would expect the same price, and what the order does to the brand.
Think it through
- Why does the order add profit when its price is below the average cost of a mug?
- What would accepting the order cost if it were for December, when regular sales are about 1,020 mugs?
- What could the order cost the studio that this calculation does not show?
Section 04: In the exam
At HL, contribution questions ask for the calculation and for a recommendation that weighs the non-financial factors alongside it.
Common errors
- Rejecting an order because its price is below the average total cost of a unit.
- Forgetting costs caused only by the order, such as the custom stamp.
- Ignoring capacity. In a full month the order would displace sales at the full price.
Arjun Agrawal | The Business Brief, https://the-business-brief-dun.vercel.app/toolkit/contribution/. Original teaching material, not an IB publication. The organizations in the teaching cases are fictional unless a case says otherwise.
On contribution, accept. The owner's judgement about the brand decides whether she should.