Finance Desk · HL

Contribution decisions

An order priced below the average cost of a unit can still add profit, when the business has spare capacity and its fixed costs are already covered. This desk shows why, and shows the conditions under which the order loses money after all.

Show content for

Showing everything. HL-only material is marked HL.

Section 01: The special order panel

Interaction

The hotel's order, judged on contribution

Source: Simulated data HL only
The order
Clay, the thrower's piece rate, firing and bulk packaging. No card fee on an invoiced order.
€14.82, the contribution of a shop mug at €22 from November (Exhibit 1).
Total cost divided by mugs sold, at 640 mugs a month. It includes fixed costs.
Try a scenario

Each scenario changes only what it names, starting from the offer.

Results

Contribution per mug on the order
€5.15
Contribution from the order
€1,545.00
Spare capacity before the order
370 mugs
Regular sales displaced
0 mugsnone
Change in profit
+€1,395.00
Lowest price that does not reduce profit
€6.35average cost is €19.90

Reading. The price is €8.90 below the average cost of a mug, yet the order adds €1,395.00. Regular sales already cover the fixed costs, so each mug on the order only has to cover its own variable cost of €5.85.

Implication. On these figures the lowest price that does not reduce profit is €6.35 a mug. Before accepting, weigh what the figures leave out: whether regular customers would expect the same price, and what the order does to the brand.

The working: change in profit

Given
  • Price offered per mug: €11.00
  • Variable cost per mug: €5.85
  • Order size: 300 mugs
  • Extra costs caused only by the order: €150
Formula
Change in profit = (order price − variable cost per unit) × order size − extra fixed costs
Substitution
= (€11.00 − €5.85) × 300 − €150
Working
Contribution per unit on the order = 11.00 − 5.85 = 5.15
5.15 × 300 = 1,545.00
1,545.00 − 150.00 = 1,395.00
Answer
€1,395

Valid only if there is spare capacity and the lower price does not change what regular customers pay or buy.

Unit
€, change in profit for the month
Interpretation
The price is €8.90 below the average cost of a mug, yet the order adds €1,395.00. Regular sales already cover the fixed costs, so each mug on the order only has to cover its own variable cost of €5.85.
Business implication
On these figures the lowest price that does not reduce profit is €6.35 a mug. Before accepting, weigh what the figures leave out: whether regular customers would expect the same price, and what the order does to the brand.

Think it through

  1. Why does the order add profit when its price is below the average cost of a mug?
  2. What would accepting the order cost if it were for December, when regular sales are about 1,020 mugs?
  3. What could the order cost the studio that this calculation does not show?

Section 02: The calculation

Contribution

Special order (contribution)

HL only Verification: Verified IB 5.5

Formula

Change in profit = (order price − variable cost per unit) × order size − extra fixed costs caused by the order

P₀
Price offered for the order (currency)
AVC
Variable cost per unit (currency)
Q₀
Order size (units)

Unit. currency

If there is spare capacity and regular sales are unaffected, an order priced above variable cost adds to profit, even when its price is below the full cost per unit.

Worked example: from the case Atelier Barro

Atelier Barro: the hotel's order of 300 mugs at €11, in November

Given
  • Price offered per mug: €11.00
  • Variable cost per mug: €5.85
  • Order size: 300 mugs
  • Extra costs caused only by the order: €150
Formula
Change in profit = (order price − variable cost per unit) × order size − extra fixed costs
Substitution
= (€11.00 − €5.85) × 300 − €150
Working
Contribution per unit on the order = 11.00 − 5.85 = 5.15
5.15 × 300 = 1,545.00
1,545.00 − 150.00 = 1,395.00
Answer
€1,395

Valid only if there is spare capacity and the lower price does not change what regular customers pay or buy.

Unit
€, change in profit for the month
Interpretation

The order adds €1,395 to November's profit, although €11 is far below the average cost of a shop mug.

Business implication

On the numbers, accept. The judgement is whether the order harms the price position, and whether the kiln can take it.

Errors that cost marks
  • Rejecting an order because its price is below average total cost, when fixed costs are already covered by regular sales.
  • Ignoring the effect on regular customers, who may ask for the same price.

5.5: HL toolkit: contribution costing (guide, p. 14)

HL This desk is HL-only material, hidden while you are viewing SL content. Switch to HL above to see it.

Back: break-even