Decision Room
Atelier Barro: price, cost and a half-price order
Respond to an energy price rise, then decide whether to make 300 mugs at half the shop price.
The Decision Room could not start. You can still read every choice and what follows from it below.
- Situation
- Decision
- Consequence
- Implementation
- Outcome
- Debrief
Section 01: The situation
You are Rui Mendes, the studio manager. Inês has asked you to recommend what to do about prices and about the hotel's order.
From 1 November the studio's electricity costs rise. You will choose how to respond on price, and see what your choice does to contribution, the break-even quantity, the margin of safety and profit. Then a hotel group's order arrives. Every figure is calculated from the cost ledger in Exhibit 1, so you can check each one on the Finance Desk.
The evidence pack: 4 exhibits
Cost ledger, before and from 1 November
Source: Simulated data From the case file: Atelier Barro| Cost | How it is incurred | Before, € | From November, € |
|---|---|---|---|
| Studio rent | Each month | 1,900 | 1,900 |
| Kiln lease | Each month | 450 | 450 |
| Studio manager's salary | Each month | 2,300 | 2,300 |
| Owner's salary | Each month | 2,400 | 2,400 |
| Insurance | Each month | 150 | 150 |
| Website and software | Each month | 120 | 120 |
| Marketing (social media advertising) | Each month | 480 | 480 |
| Electricity standing charge | Each month | 260 | 340 |
| Electricity for firing | Per mug | 0.45 | 0.75 |
| Clay and glaze | Per mug | 2.30 | 2.30 |
| Thrower's piece rate | Per mug | 2.40 | 2.40 |
| Packaging | Per mug | 0.85 | 0.85 |
| Card and platform fees | Per mug, 4% of the price | 0.88 | 0.88 |
Costs incurred each month total €8,060 before November and €8,140 from November. Costs per mug total €6.88 and €7.18 at a price of €22. The card and platform fee is 4% of the price, so it changes if the price changes. All the studio's monthly costs are counted against the mugs; workshops and firing services are left out.
Customer survey and price test, estimated mugs sold a month at each price
Source: Simulated data From the case file: Atelier Barro| Price, € | Estimated mugs a month | Basis of the estimate |
|---|---|---|
| 20 | 700 | Survey |
| 22 | 640 | Actual average over the last twelve months |
| 24 | 590 | Survey and a two-week price test on the website |
| 25 | 560 | Survey |
| 27 | 480 | Survey |
Survey of 410 customers in September; price test at €24 for two weeks in October. The estimates assume the mugs and the packaging do not change. Inês believes premium packaging could hold sales nearer 580 at €25, but that has not been tested.
We would like 300 mugs in your Douro glaze, stamped with our name, delivered to Lisbon by 20 November. We can pay €11 a mug, invoiced. We may want more next year.
Capacity, the season and the order
Source: Simulated data From the case file: Atelier Barro- Kiln capacity
- 1,200 mugs a month
- Average monthly sales
- 640 mugs
- November sales
- About 830 mugs Usually 30% above average
- December sales
- About 1,020 mugs Usually 60% above average
- Custom stamp for the hotel
- €150 Once
- Packaging for an invoiced bulk order
- €0.40 a mug Instead of €0.85
- Card and platform fee on an invoiced order
- €0
The board pack
Source: Simulated data| Measure | Now | After your decisions | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shop price per mug | €22 | Not decided | |
| Mugs sold a month (estimate) | 640 | Not decided | |
| Contribution per mug | €15.12 | Not decided | |
| Break-even quantity | 534 mugs a month | Not decided | |
| Margin of safety | 106 mugs a month | Not decided | |
| Profit a month | €1,616.80 | Not decided | |
| Change in November profit from the hotel order | €0 | Not decided | |
| Risk to the price position | Low | Not decided |
Section 02: Respond to the cost rise
How will Atelier Barro respond to the new electricity tariff?
From November, firing costs €0.75 a mug instead of €0.45, and the standing charge is €340 a month instead of €260. The card and platform fee is 4% of the price, so it rises if the price does. The figures in "Now" are before the new tariff.
Section 03: The hotel's order
Commit your first decision to unlock this one.
Casa Alfama Hotels offers to buy 300 mugs at €11 each, for delivery in November. What do you do?
Each hotel mug has a variable cost of €5.85: clay and glaze €2.30, the piece rate €2.40, bulk packaging €0.40 and firing €0.75, with no card or platform fee on an invoiced order. The stamp costs €150, once. November sales are usually about 830 mugs, and the kiln can fire 1,200 a month.
Section 04: Debrief
The debrief opens when you have made every decision.
The trade-offs
- Price against volume. A higher price raises contribution per mug but sells fewer mugs. The best price depends on how sales respond, and the survey's estimate is itself uncertain.
- Fixed costs against revenue. Cutting marketing lowers the break-even quantity but can lower sales by more.
- Contribution now against the price position later. The hotel order adds profit this month and may cost some of the brand's ability to charge €22 or more.
The evidence that matters
- Exhibit 3, the estimated sales at each price. Every pricing outcome rests on it, and it is an estimate from a survey and a short price test.
- Exhibit 1, where the card and platform fee is 4% of the price. Leaving it out overstates the gain from a price rise.
- Exhibit 5, the season. In November there is spare capacity; in December there would not be.
What would change your mind?
- If the survey had shown sales of 520 a month at €24, would you still raise the price?
- If the hotel had wanted its mugs in December, when the kiln is nearly full, what would accepting cost?
- If the hotel offered to order 300 mugs every quarter at €11, would your answer change, and why?
Misconceptions this tests
- Rounding the break-even quantity down. €8,140 ÷ €14.82 is 549.26; at 549 mugs there is a small loss, so the answer is 550.
- Rejecting the hotel order because €11 is below the average cost of a mug. With spare capacity and fixed costs already covered, the comparison is with variable cost.
- Treating the margin of safety as a sum of money. It is a number of mugs, or a share of sales.
Every first decision, side by side
The figures straight after each first-round choice, before any later decision.
| Measure | Now | Keep the price at €22 | Raise the price to €24 | Raise the price to €25 with premium packaging | Keep €22 and cut marketing |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Shop price per mug | €22 | €22 | €24 | €25 | €22 |
| Mugs sold a month (estimate) | 640 | 640 | 590 | 580 | 610 |
| Contribution per mug | €15.12 | €14.82 | €16.74 | €17.10 | €14.82 |
| Break-even quantity | 534 mugs a month | 550 mugs a month | 487 mugs a month | 477 mugs a month | 531 mugs a month |
| Margin of safety | 106 mugs a month | 90 mugs a month | 103 mugs a month | 103 mugs a month | 79 mugs a month |
| Profit a month | €1,616.80 | €1,344.80 | €1,736.60 | €1,778 | €1,180.20 |
| Change in November profit from the hotel order | €0 | €0 | €0 | €0 | €0 |
| Risk to the price position | Low | Low | Low | Low | Low |
Exam link
This is Paper 2 reasoning: calculate, then interpret, then judge. Try the break-even and HL special order practice questions in the Assessment Centre, and check each answer in the Finance Desk's workspace.
Arjun Agrawal | The Business Brief, https://the-business-brief-dun.vercel.app/decision-room/atelier-pricing/. Original teaching material, not an IB publication. The organizations in the teaching cases are fictional unless a case says otherwise.