Decision Room

Atelier Barro: price, cost and a half-price order

Respond to an energy price rise, then decide whether to make 300 mugs at half the shop price.

Source: Simulated data Case file: Atelier Barro
  1. Situation
  2. Decision
  3. Consequence
  4. Implementation
  5. Outcome
  6. Debrief

Section 01: The situation

You are Rui Mendes, the studio manager. Inês has asked you to recommend what to do about prices and about the hotel's order.

From 1 November the studio's electricity costs rise. You will choose how to respond on price, and see what your choice does to contribution, the break-even quantity, the margin of safety and profit. Then a hotel group's order arrives. Every figure is calculated from the cost ledger in Exhibit 1, so you can check each one on the Finance Desk.

Read the full case: Atelier Barro

The evidence pack: 4 exhibits
Exhibit 1

Cost ledger, before and from 1 November

Source: Simulated data From the case file: Atelier Barro
Cost How it is incurred Before, € From November, €
Studio rentEach month1,9001,900
Kiln leaseEach month450450
Studio manager's salaryEach month2,3002,300
Owner's salaryEach month2,4002,400
InsuranceEach month150150
Website and softwareEach month120120
Marketing (social media advertising)Each month480480
Electricity standing chargeEach month260340
Electricity for firingPer mug0.450.75
Clay and glazePer mug2.302.30
Thrower's piece ratePer mug2.402.40
PackagingPer mug0.850.85
Card and platform feesPer mug, 4% of the price0.880.88

Costs incurred each month total €8,060 before November and €8,140 from November. Costs per mug total €6.88 and €7.18 at a price of €22. The card and platform fee is 4% of the price, so it changes if the price changes. All the studio's monthly costs are counted against the mugs; workshops and firing services are left out.

Source Simulated teaching data, from the studio's accounts and the supplier's letter.
Exhibit 3

Customer survey and price test, estimated mugs sold a month at each price

Source: Simulated data From the case file: Atelier Barro
Price, € Estimated mugs a month Basis of the estimate
20700Survey
22640Actual average over the last twelve months
24590Survey and a two-week price test on the website
25560Survey
27480Survey

Survey of 410 customers in September; price test at €24 for two weeks in October. The estimates assume the mugs and the packaging do not change. Inês believes premium packaging could hold sales nearer 580 at €25, but that has not been tested.

Source Simulated teaching data. Survey estimates are judgements about behaviour, not records of it.
Exhibit 4

The hotel's request

Source: Simulated data From the case file: Atelier Barro

We would like 300 mugs in your Douro glaze, stamped with our name, delivered to Lisbon by 20 November. We can pay €11 a mug, invoiced. We may want more next year.

Marta Sousa, purchasing manager, Casa Alfama Hotels
Source Fictional email, written for this case.
Exhibit 5

Capacity, the season and the order

Source: Simulated data From the case file: Atelier Barro
Kiln capacity
1,200 mugs a month
Average monthly sales
640 mugs
November sales
About 830 mugs Usually 30% above average
December sales
About 1,020 mugs Usually 60% above average
Custom stamp for the hotel
€150 Once
Packaging for an invoiced bulk order
€0.40 a mug Instead of €0.85
Card and platform fee on an invoiced order
€0
Source Simulated teaching data.

The board pack

Source: Simulated data
Measure Now After your decisions Change
Shop price per mug€22Not decided
Mugs sold a month (estimate)640Not decided
Contribution per mug€15.12Not decided
Break-even quantity534 mugs a monthNot decided
Margin of safety106 mugs a monthNot decided
Profit a month€1,616.80Not decided
Change in November profit from the hotel order€0Not decided
Risk to the price positionLowNot decided

Section 02: Respond to the cost rise

How will Atelier Barro respond to the new electricity tariff?

From November, firing costs €0.75 a mug instead of €0.45, and the standing charge is €340 a month instead of €260. The card and platform fee is 4% of the price, so it rises if the price does. The figures in "Now" are before the new tariff.

How will Atelier Barro respond to the new electricity tariff?
See what happens

Consequence

The price holds, and the margin shrinks

Variable cost per mug rises to €7.18 and monthly costs to €8,140. Contribution per mug falls from €15.12 to €14.82, so the studio now needs 550 mugs a month to break even instead of 534 (€8,140 ÷ €14.82 = 549.26, rounded up). Sales stay at 640, the margin of safety narrows to 90 mugs, and profit falls from €1,616.80 to €1,344.80 a month.

How people react

  • Customers Positive See no change.
  • Inês Carvalho Negative Has a thinner cushion against a slow month.
  • The throwers Positive Keep making 640 mugs a month.

Risks now

  • A margin of safety of 90 mugs, 14% of sales, leaves little room for a slow month.

The theory behind it

A rise in variable cost per unit lowers contribution per unit and raises the break-even quantity. A rise in fixed costs raises it further. Holding the price means the business absorbs both.

The figures after this choice
Shop price per mug €22 No change
Mugs sold a month (estimate) 640 No change
Contribution per mug €14.82 −€0.30 on now
Break-even quantity 550 mugs a month +16 mugs a month on now
Margin of safety 90 mugs a month −16 mugs a month on now
Profit a month €1,344.80 −€272 on now
Risk to the price position Low No change
See what happens

Consequence

A modest rise that most customers accept

At €24 the card and platform fee is €0.96 a mug, so variable cost is €7.26 and contribution is €16.74. The survey and price test suggest about 590 mugs a month. The break-even quantity falls to 487 mugs, the margin of safety is 103 mugs, and profit rises to €1,736.60, above where it was before the energy rise. Fifty fewer mugs are made each month, which also saves clay, labour and kiln time.

How people react

  • Customers Mixed Most keep buying; about fifty a month stop.
  • The throwers Negative Make fifty fewer mugs a month and earn €120 less between them.
  • Inês Carvalho Positive Has profit and a margin of safety back where she wants them.

Risks now

  • The estimate of 590 mugs comes from a survey and a two-week test. If sales fall further, so does the gain.

The theory behind it

Raising the price raises contribution per unit and lowers the break-even quantity. Whether profit rises depends on how many sales are lost, which is a question about demand, not about costs.

The figures after this choice
Shop price per mug €24 +€2 on now
Mugs sold a month (estimate) 590 −50 on now
Contribution per mug €16.74 +€1.62 on now
Break-even quantity 487 mugs a month −47 mugs a month on now
Margin of safety 103 mugs a month −3 mugs a month on now
Profit a month €1,736.60 +€119.80 on now
Risk to the price position Low No change
See what happens

Consequence

The best result on paper, resting on an untested assumption

With packaging at €1.45 and a 4% fee of €1.00, variable cost is €7.90 and contribution is €17.10. The break-even quantity falls to 477. The survey suggested 560 mugs at €25 without new packaging; Inês assumed the packaging would hold sales at 580, and in this simulation it does. Profit is €1,778.00 a month, the highest of the four. If sales had been the survey's 560, profit would have been €1,436.00, below the €24 option.

How people react

  • Gift buyers Positive Like the new packaging.
  • Regular customers Mixed Some feel the mugs have become a luxury.
  • Inês Carvalho Mixed Likes the premium position; knows she was lucky with the estimate.

Risks now

  • The gain over €24 depends entirely on the untested estimate of 580 mugs.

The theory behind it

A decision that is best only under its most favourable assumption is a risky decision. Sensitivity analysis asks what happens to the result if the assumption is wrong.

The figures after this choice
Shop price per mug €25 +€3 on now
Mugs sold a month (estimate) 580 −60 on now
Contribution per mug €17.10 +€1.98 on now
Break-even quantity 477 mugs a month −57 mugs a month on now
Margin of safety 103 mugs a month −3 mugs a month on now
Profit a month €1,778 +€161.20 on now
Risk to the price position Low No change
See what happens

Consequence

A lower break-even quantity, and lower profit

Cutting €280 of advertising lowers monthly costs to €7,860 and the break-even quantity to 531 mugs. But online sales depend on the advertising, and over the following quarter they fall to 610 mugs a month. The margin of safety shrinks to 79 mugs and profit falls to €1,180.20, the lowest of the four.

How people react

  • Online customers Mixed See the studio less often in their feeds.
  • The throwers Negative Make thirty fewer mugs a month.
  • Inês Carvalho Negative Saves money and loses sales.

Risks now

  • The fall in sales was larger than the saving. Marketing is a fixed cost that brings in revenue.

The theory behind it

Cutting a fixed cost lowers the break-even quantity only if sales hold. When the cost drives sales, cutting it can lower the break-even quantity and profit at the same time.

The figures after this choice
Shop price per mug €22 No change
Mugs sold a month (estimate) 610 −30 on now
Contribution per mug €14.82 −€0.30 on now
Break-even quantity 531 mugs a month −3 mugs a month on now
Margin of safety 79 mugs a month −27 mugs a month on now
Profit a month €1,180.20 −€436.60 on now
Risk to the price position Low No change
Optional. Saved on this device only.

Section 03: The hotel's order

Casa Alfama Hotels offers to buy 300 mugs at €11 each, for delivery in November. What do you do?

Each hotel mug has a variable cost of €5.85: clay and glaze €2.30, the piece rate €2.40, bulk packaging €0.40 and firing €0.75, with no card or platform fee on an invoiced order. The stamp costs €150, once. November sales are usually about 830 mugs, and the kiln can fire 1,200 a month.

Casa Alfama Hotels offers to buy 300 mugs at €11 each, for delivery in November. What do you do?
See what happens

Outcome

€1,395 of extra profit from mugs at half the shop price

Each hotel mug adds €5.15 of contribution (€11.00 − €5.85). Three hundred add €1,545, and after the €150 stamp the order raises November's profit by €1,395. The order is profitable even though €11 is well below the average cost of a shop mug, about €20 to €22 depending on your pricing decision, because the studio's monthly costs are already covered by its regular sales. The hotel order only has to cover its own variable costs. The kiln runs at 94% of capacity in November.

How people react

  • Casa Alfama Hotels Positive Gets its mugs on time.
  • The throwers Positive Earn €720 more between them in November.
  • Inês Carvalho Mixed Welcomes the cash; worries about her mugs in hotel rooms at half the price.
  • Shop customers Mixed A few notice the hotel mugs and ask about trade prices.

Risks now

  • Customers who see the mugs in hotel rooms may wonder why they pay twice as much.
  • At 94% of capacity in November, a failed firing leaves no slack.

The theory behind it

Contribution analysis: with spare capacity, accept an order whose price is above its variable cost, unless it harms regular sales or uses capacity needed for more profitable work. Average cost is the wrong benchmark when the fixed costs are already covered.

The figures after this choice
Change in November profit from the hotel order €1,395 +€1,395 on now
Risk to the price position Medium Was Low on now
See what happens

Outcome

The hotel meets you at €12.50

The hotel's buyer replies with €12.50. At that price each mug adds €6.65 of contribution, and the order raises November's profit by €1,845. In this simulation the order survived the negotiation, but it could have gone the other way. If you had thought there was a one-in-three chance of losing the order, the expected gain from negotiating would have been two-thirds of €1,845, which is €1,230, less than the €1,395 from accepting.

How people react

  • Casa Alfama Hotels Mixed Agrees, and will remember the negotiation next year.
  • Inês Carvalho Positive Pleased with the higher price.

Risks now

  • The simulation shows one outcome of a negotiation. Another buyer might simply have bought elsewhere.

The theory behind it

An expected value weighs a certain gain against an uncertain larger one. Here (2/3 × €1,845) + (1/3 × €0) = €1,230, so negotiating was worth it only if the risk of losing the order was smaller than one in three.

The figures after this choice
Change in November profit from the hotel order €1,845 +€1,845 on now
Risk to the price position Medium Was Low on now
See what happens

Outcome

The price position holds, and so does November's profit

Atelier Barro declines, explaining that its mugs are sold only at its own prices. November's profit is unchanged and the kiln has spare capacity for the Christmas rush. The decision gives up €1,395 of certain profit to protect a price position that Inês has spent five years building.

How people react

  • Casa Alfama Hotels Negative Buys mugs elsewhere.
  • Inês Carvalho Positive Is confident in the decision.
  • The throwers Negative Miss out on extra work.

Risks now

  • The hotel may not ask again, and a competitor may take the relationship.

The theory behind it

Declining a profitable order can be right when the order threatens the price position that earns the business its regular contribution. The cost of the decision is the contribution given up.

The figures after this choice
Change in November profit from the hotel order €0 No change
Risk to the price position Low No change
Optional. Saved on this device only.

Section 04: Debrief

The debrief opens when you have made every decision.

The trade-offs

  • Price against volume. A higher price raises contribution per mug but sells fewer mugs. The best price depends on how sales respond, and the survey's estimate is itself uncertain.
  • Fixed costs against revenue. Cutting marketing lowers the break-even quantity but can lower sales by more.
  • Contribution now against the price position later. The hotel order adds profit this month and may cost some of the brand's ability to charge €22 or more.

The evidence that matters

  • Exhibit 3, the estimated sales at each price. Every pricing outcome rests on it, and it is an estimate from a survey and a short price test.
  • Exhibit 1, where the card and platform fee is 4% of the price. Leaving it out overstates the gain from a price rise.
  • Exhibit 5, the season. In November there is spare capacity; in December there would not be.

What would change your mind?

  • If the survey had shown sales of 520 a month at €24, would you still raise the price?
  • If the hotel had wanted its mugs in December, when the kiln is nearly full, what would accepting cost?
  • If the hotel offered to order 300 mugs every quarter at €11, would your answer change, and why?

Misconceptions this tests

  • Rounding the break-even quantity down. €8,140 ÷ €14.82 is 549.26; at 549 mugs there is a small loss, so the answer is 550.
  • Rejecting the hotel order because €11 is below the average cost of a mug. With spare capacity and fixed costs already covered, the comparison is with variable cost.
  • Treating the margin of safety as a sum of money. It is a number of mugs, or a share of sales.

Every first decision, side by side

The figures straight after each first-round choice, before any later decision.

Measure Now Keep the price at €22Raise the price to €24Raise the price to €25 with premium packagingKeep €22 and cut marketing
Shop price per mug €22 €22€24€25€22
Mugs sold a month (estimate) 640 640590580610
Contribution per mug €15.12 €14.82€16.74€17.10€14.82
Break-even quantity 534 mugs a month 550 mugs a month487 mugs a month477 mugs a month531 mugs a month
Margin of safety 106 mugs a month 90 mugs a month103 mugs a month103 mugs a month79 mugs a month
Profit a month €1,616.80 €1,344.80€1,736.60€1,778€1,180.20
Change in November profit from the hotel order €0 €0€0€0€0
Risk to the price position Low LowLowLowLow

Exam link

This is Paper 2 reasoning: calculate, then interpret, then judge. Try the break-even and HL special order practice questions in the Assessment Centre, and check each answer in the Finance Desk's workspace.