No. 10 The Boardroom Briefings Reputation recovery
How should a company respond to reputational damage?
Rowan & Rill's recycled range turns out to be partly recycled
A Bristol clothing brand built on sustainability has been found to have overstated its green claims. Sales and trust have fallen; the board must decide what kind of company it will be when they recover.
- Company
- Rowan & Rill, Bristol, England
- Industry
- Fashion
- Decision
- Reputation recovery
- Functions
- Marketing, Operations management, Strategy and management
- Key concepts
- Ethics, Sustainability
- Editions
- Student, then Analysis
You are reading the Student edition. The recommendation is withheld.
This briefing has two editions. The Student edition comes first: the case and the questions. The Analysis edition follows it, closed, so that you can decide before you read the recommendation.
The edition switch could not start. Both editions are on the page: the Analysis edition follows the Student edition.
The Student edition
Section 01: Executive summary
The decision in brief. In this edition the summary stops short of a recommendation.
The situation
Rowan & Rill sold its Recloth range as made from 100% recycled materials and carbon neutral. In May 2026 the advertising regulator ruled both claims misleading: tests found the range was on average 61.6% recycled, and the carbon-neutral claim rested on offsets whose benefits could not be verified. Recloth sales fell by 38.0% over the summer, and trust in the brand fell with them.
The decision
How to respond: contest the ruling and defend the brand's record, correct the claims and apologize, rebuild the range so that every claim can be independently verified, or retire the Recloth name and start again.
What is at stake
The brand's promise of sustainability is the reason many customers buy from it. The response decides whether that promise can be trusted again, and what it will cost the company to make it true.
Section 02: Business background
Holly Mercer founded Rowan & Rill in Bristol in 2010, selling jackets and fleeces for walking and everyday wear. It grew online and now has nine shops, 380 employees and revenue of £72.4m, about 70% of it from its website (Exhibit 3). Its customers are loyal and, by its own surveys, chose the brand above all for its values. Holly owns 55% of the company; private investors own the rest.
In 2023 the company launched Recloth, a range it described as made from 100% recycled materials and carbon neutral. It became the brand's best-known line. In 2025 a campaign group, which tests clothing claims, sent Recloth garments to an independent laboratory and complained to the advertising regulator. The tests found recycled content averaging 61.6% across the range, and as little as 48% in jackets (Exhibit 2).
The regulator's ruling, in May 2026, was reported by the national press and shared widely online. Recloth sales from June to September fell from £6,000k a year earlier to £3,720k; the brand's trust score fell from 71 to 48 out of 100 (Exhibit 1); three retailers that stock the brand paused their orders. The company had not checked its suppliers' claims for itself. The board meets next month to agree its response.
- Company
- Rowan & Rill
- Business
- Outdoor and casual clothing
- Based in
- Bristol, England
- Size
- 380 employees, nine shops and revenue of £72.4m in 2025, most of it online
- Ownership
- Privately held company, 55% owned by its founder and 45% by private investors
- Figures in
- GBP, in thousands (£000)
- Status
- A fictional company. Every figure is simulated for teaching and checked for consistency.
Section 03: Strategic context
The industry and the forces on the decision, in general terms. The only figures in this briefing are the company's own.
Claims about sustainability have become central to how many clothing brands compete. Customers who care about them are often willing to pay more and stay loyal, but they rarely have the means to check what they are told, so the claims rest on trust, and on the rules and regulators that police them.
Clothing supply chains are long and spread across many countries: fibre makers, spinners, mills, garment factories and agents. A brand that buys finished garments may know little of what happens in its suppliers' suppliers, unless it pays for audits, certification and tracing.
Damage to a reputation tends to be quick and recovery slow. Customers forgive a mistake more readily than an attempt to hide or excuse it, and they judge a company less by its first statement than by whether its later actions match its words.
Section 04: Relevant evidence
The company's own evidence (simulated), established research (cited, and stated only as its central idea) and how the market works.
-
The company’s own evidence Source: Simulated data
A sharp fall in a strong business
Revenue rose from £64,200k in 2024 to £72,400k in 2025 at a steady operating margin of 9.0%. The forecast for 2026 is £63,900k, down 11.7%, with the margin falling to 4.0% (Exhibit 3).
See Exhibit 3
-
The company’s own evidence Source: Simulated data
Trust fell faster than sales
Between January and September 2026 the brand's trust score fell from 71 to 48, the share of shoppers who would consider buying from it from 44% to 29%, and its net promoter score from +42 to −6 (Exhibit 1).
See Exhibit 1
-
The company’s own evidence Source: Simulated data
What was actually in the range
Weighted by the units sold in 2025, Recloth's recycled content was 61.6%, from 81% in fleeces to 48% in jackets (Exhibit 2). The suppliers' certificates the company relied on covered the fibre, not the finished garments.
See Exhibit 2
-
Established research Cited research
The response should match the responsibility
Situational crisis communication theory holds that the more responsibility the public attributes to an organization for a crisis, the more its response must accept that responsibility, apologize and put things right. For a crisis the organization could have prevented, denial and excuses tend to make the damage worse.
-
Established research Cited research
Reputation is an asset
Corporate reputation can be treated as an intangible asset: the judgements that customers, employees, investors and others form of a company over time, which shape what they are willing to pay it, work for it and invest in it.
Source: Charles J. Fombrun (1996), Reputation: Realizing Value from the Corporate Image
The exhibits
The brand tracker, 2026
Source: Simulated data| Month | Trust score (out of 100) | Would consider buying (%) | Net promoter score |
|---|---|---|---|
| January | 71 | 44 | 42 |
| April | 70 | 43 | 40 |
| June | 52 | 31 | 3 |
| September | 48 | 29 | −6 |
A monthly online survey of 1,000 people who buy outdoor clothing. The net promoter score is the share who would recommend the brand less the share who would warn against it, and runs from −100 to +100.
Recycled content of the Recloth range, as tested
Source: Simulated data| Product family | Units sold in 2025 (000) | Recycled content (%) |
|---|---|---|
| Fleeces | 180 | 81.0 |
| Jackets | 120 | 48.0 |
| T-shirts and tops | 260 | 55.0 |
| Trousers | 90 | 60.0 |
| The whole range, weighted by units sold | 650 | 61.6 |
Recycled content is the share of each garment's fibre by weight that came from recycled sources, from laboratory tests of samples from each family.
Section 05: Financial information
Exhibit 3 gives the company's results for 2024 and 2025 and its forecast for 2026. Exhibit 4 gives the management team's estimates for each response: its one-off cost, any cost that would recur each year, and the revenue and operating profit it would produce in 2027. The forecasts assume the operating margin before those recurring costs returns to 9.0%.
Rowan & Rill's results (£000)
Source: Simulated data| Year | Revenue | Operating profit | Operating profit margin (%) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2024 | 64,200 | 5,778 | 9.0 |
| 2025 | 72,400 | 6,516 | 9.0 |
| 2026 (forecast) | 63,900 | 2,556 | 4.0 |
The forecast for 2026 includes the costs of responding to the ruling so far, but none of the options in Exhibit 4.
The management team's estimates for each response (£000)
Source: Simulated data| Response | One-off cost | Extra cost each year | Revenue in 2027 | Operating profit in 2027 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A. Contest the ruling and defend the record | 400 | 0 | 64,000 | 5,760 |
| B. Correct the claims and apologize | 2,150 | 0 | 70,000 | 6,300 |
| C. Rebuild the range so every claim is verified | 2,500 | 1,500 | 74,500 | 5,205 |
| D. Retire Recloth and relaunch under a new name | 3,900 | 0 | 66,000 | 5,940 |
A's one-off cost is legal fees. B's covers relabelling, withdrawing the claims, refunds for customers who ask and an apology campaign. C adds a platform that traces every garment to its fibre (£350k), and each year independent certification and audits (£900k) and a premium for verified recycled fibre (£2,400k), partly recovered by a 6% price rise on the range (£1,800k). D writes off stock with the old labels and pays for a new brand.
Section 06: Stakeholder implications
Who has a stake in the decision, how much they care and how much they can affect it, what they want, and what the decision would mean for them.
-
Holly Mercer and the investors
- What they want
- A brand that recovers its sales and its standing, and is worth what they built it to be.
- What the decision means for them
- Option C costs the most in the short run, with operating profit of £5,205k in 2027 against £6,300k for option B, and asks them to bet that verified claims will pay back over time.
-
Customers
- What they want
- Clothes that are what the label says, from a company that tells them the truth.
- What the decision means for them
- Many chose the brand for its values and feel misled. A defence of the claims would confirm their doubts; an apology without change may not convince them either.
-
Employees
- What they want
- To be proud of where they work again.
- What the decision means for them
- In the staff survey, 61% said they were proud to work at the company, against 84% before the ruling. Shop and service staff have taken the customers' anger in person.
-
The advertising regulator and the campaign group
- What they want
- Claims that are accurate and can be proved.
- What the decision means for them
- Contesting the ruling would invite closer scrutiny and further complaints; verified claims would end the dispute.
-
Suppliers
- What they want
- Steady orders, and fair terms for any extra checks or materials.
- What the decision means for them
- Option C asks them to trace their fibre, accept audits and switch to verified recycled materials, for which Rowan & Rill would pay a premium.
-
Retailers that stock the brand
- What they want
- Products their own customers trust.
- What the decision means for them
- Three have paused orders. They are likely to return only when the brand's claims are settled and its products can be sold without explanation.
Section 07: The strategic options
The courses of action open to the board. Each is set out on its own terms; the Analysis edition judges them.
Section 08: Evaluation criteria
How the board has said it will judge the options, and how much each criterion counts. The weights add up to 100.
| Criterion | How it is judged | Weight |
|---|---|---|
| Trust and reputation | How far the response is likely to restore customers' and retailers' trust in the brand. | 30% |
| Regulatory and legal risk | The risk of further rulings, complaints or claims. | 20% |
| Financial effect | The cost of the response and the operating profit it leaves in 2027, from Exhibit 4. | 20% |
| Integrity of the brand's claims | Whether the brand's sustainability claims would be true and could be proved. | 15% |
| Employees and partners | The effect on employees' pride and on relations with suppliers and retailers. | 15% |
Section 09: Discussion questions
Answer them before you open the Analysis edition, which has notes on each.
In the style of the IB course
The platform's own questions, written for this briefing; they are not IB examination questions. The marks are each question's own allocation.
-
Using Exhibit 2, calculate the recycled content of the Recloth range as a whole, weighted by the units sold in 2025.
[3 marks]
-
Using Exhibit 3, calculate the percentage change in Rowan & Rill's revenue between 2025 and the forecast for 2026.
[2 marks]
-
Explain why corporate social responsibility claims matter to Rowan & Rill's competitive position.
[4 marks]
-
Explain the effect of the regulator's ruling on Rowan & Rill's brand loyalty and brand value.
[4 marks]
-
Recommend how Rowan & Rill should respond to the damage to its reputation.
[10 marks]
HL-only questions are hidden in the SL view. Choose HL above to see them.
For seminars, beyond the course
For undergraduate, MBA and professional readers. These questions go beyond the IB course and are labelled as enrichment.
- This crisis was preventable. What does that imply for the tone and substance of Rowan & Rill's response?
- Is greenwashing a marketing failure or a supply chain failure?
- Can a brand that has overstated its sustainability ever be trusted on it again? What would it take?
The Analysis edition The worked discussion: the evidence, the assumptions, every option judged and the recommendation. Open it when you have decided. About 6 minutes to read.
The Analysis edition
From here, the page gives the platform's reading of the case: its interpretation of the evidence, its judgement and its recommendation. It adds no new facts, and the same evidence can support other conclusions if they are argued well.
Section A1: Executive summary
Recommended Option C: Rebuild the range so every claim is verified
Correct, apologize and then rebuild, so that every claim can be verified (option C). The failure was preventable, so customers will judge the brand on whether it accepts responsibility and puts things right; an apology alone (B) recovers sales fastest but leaves unchanged the supply chain that let the claims go unchecked. Rebuilding costs £1,500k a year after a modest price rise and leaves less profit in 2027, but it is the only response that makes the brand's promise true, and on the team's assumptions it overtakes the others by 2029.
Section A2: What the evidence shows
The exhibits worked through. Every figure here is recomputed from the exhibits on every build.
- The claims were wrong by a wide margin: 61.6% recycled across the range, against a claim of 100%, and 48% in jackets (Exhibit 2). The company relied on certificates that covered the fibre, not the garments.
- The damage is to trust more than to sales so far: the trust score fell from 71 to 48 and the net promoter score from +42 to −6, while revenue is forecast to fall by 11.7% (Exhibits 3 and 1).
- In 2027, B leaves the most operating profit (£6,300k), then D (£5,940k), A (£5,760k) and C (£5,205k). By 2029, if the premium for verified fibre falls as the team expects, C leaves the most, £6,960k (Exhibit A1).
- The company can afford C: its 2026 forecast still shows an operating profit of £2,556k, and C's one-off cost of £2,500k can be spread across the year of the change.
Operating profit under each response, 2027 and 2029 (£000)
Source: Simulated data| Response | Revenue in 2029 | Extra cost each year by 2029 | Operating profit in 2027 | Operating profit in 2029 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A. Contest the ruling and defend the record | 66,000 | 0 | 5,760 | 5,940 |
| B. Correct the claims and apologize | 74,000 | 0 | 6,300 | 6,660 |
| C. Rebuild the range so every claim is verified | 84,000 | 600 | 5,205 | 6,960 |
| D. Retire Recloth and relaunch under a new name | 70,000 | 0 | 5,940 | 6,300 |
The 2029 revenues are the management team's forecasts. Under C, the premium for verified fibre is assumed to fall as supply grows, leaving an extra cost of £600k a year by 2029.
Section A3: The assumptions
What the analysis takes as given, and how a manager would test it before relying on it.
-
Customers will reward verified claims with loyalty and a 6% higher price on the range.
How to test it Test the new labels and prices in a few products before the whole range, and track the brand's trust score month by month.
-
The premium for verified recycled fibre will fall from £2,400k a year as supply grows, leaving an extra cost of £600k by 2029.
How to test it Ask suppliers for prices fixed for two or three years, and plan for the premium staying high.
-
The operating margin, before the cost of the response, returns to 9.0%.
How to test it It was 9.0% in 2024 and 2025. Watch whether discounts to win customers back eat into it.
-
Suppliers will accept tracing and audits.
How to test it Start with the suppliers of fleeces, where content is already highest, and make continued orders depend on taking part.
Section A4: The trade-offs
What the board gives up to get what it wants. No option avoids all of them.
Speed, or depth
An apology and new labels recover sales soonest. Making the claims true takes two years, and customers will judge the company by whether its later actions match its apology.
Profit now, or the promise later
The verified range costs more and leaves less profit in 2027. Its value lies in a promise that can be proved, which is what customers bought Rowan & Rill for in the first place.
A clean break, or an honest one
Retiring the Recloth name would remove a reminder of the failure, but the failure was the company's, not the name's. Keeping the name and fixing the range is the harder, more credible course.
Section A5: The alternatives, judged
Every option judged against the evidence, then scored against the board's criteria.
The options scored against the board's criteria
Each option is scored from 1 (poor) to 5 (strong) on each criterion. The weighted score is the sum of each weight times its score, divided by 100. The scores are the analysis's judgement; a scoring matrix organizes judgement, it does not replace it.
| Criterion | Weight | Option A | Option B | Option C | Option D |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Trust and reputation | 30% | 1 | 3 | 5 | 2 |
| Regulatory and legal risk | 20% | 1 | 3 | 5 | 3 |
| Financial effect | 20% | 3 | 5 | 3 | 4 |
| Integrity of the brand's claims | 15% | 1 | 3 | 5 | 2 |
| Employees and partners | 15% | 1 | 3 | 5 | 2 |
| Weighted score | 100% | 1.40 | 3.40 | 4.60 (the highest) | 2.60 |
Section A6: The recommended course of action
Option C: Rebuild the range so every claim is verified
Accept the ruling at once. Have the founder apologize without conditions, withdraw the claims, relabel the range with its tested recycled content and offer refunds. Then rebuild Recloth over two years so that every claim is verified: trace every garment to its fibre, pay for independent certification and audits, switch to verified recycled fibre, and publish the results, shortfalls included, every year.
Why
- The failure was preventable, so the response must accept responsibility and fix the cause, not only the labels.
- Verified claims are the only basis on which the brand's promise can be trusted again.
- It brings back the retailers and the regulator's confidence, which a defence or a new name would not.
- On the team's assumptions it leaves the most profit by 2029.
On these conditions
The recommendation depends on customers accepting a 6% higher price for a verified range. If tests show they will not, the company should keep the verification and reduce the range to the products, such as fleeces, where verified content is already high.
Section A7: Implementation
What happens, in what order, and who answers for it.
- Weeks 1 to 2 Accept the ruling; publish an apology from the founder; withdraw the claims from every page, label and advertisement; open refunds. Holly Mercer and the head of communications
- Weeks 1 to 4 Tell staff first, with the facts and the plan; brief the retailers and the regulator on the steps being taken. Head of people and head of sales
- Months 1 to 6 Relabel the range with its tested content; appoint an independent certifier; require suppliers to trace their fibre. Head of sourcing
- Months 6 to 24 Switch the range to verified recycled fibre, family by family, starting with fleeces; raise prices on the range by 6% as each family is verified. Head of product
- Every year Publish the range's verified content and any shortfalls, checked by the certifier. The board
Section A8: Evaluation: how to tell if it is working
The evaluation criteria, applied after the decision: what to measure, what counts as working, and when to look.
| Measure | Target | Reviewed |
|---|---|---|
| Trust | The trust score back above the 70 of early 2026 within two years. | Every month |
| Recommendation | A net promoter score positive again within a year, and back towards +42 within two. | Every month |
| Verified content | Every Recloth family independently verified within two years, with its content on the label. | Every quarter |
| Retailers | All three paused retailers ordering again. | Every quarter |
Section A9: Limitations
What the analysis cannot see, and what would change its recommendation.
The limits of the analysis
- The revenue forecasts for 2027 and 2029 are the management team's judgements about how customers will respond, which no one can know.
- The brand tracker surveys people who buy outdoor clothing in general, not only the brand's own customers.
- The analysis cannot know whether the regulator or the campaign group will examine the brand's other ranges.
What would change the recommendation
- If customers would not pay more for a verified range, a smaller verified range, or option B alone, would be the more affordable choice.
- If new tests found problems beyond Recloth, the response would have to cover the whole brand, and the case for a fresh start under a new name would grow.
- If the premium for verified fibre stayed at £2,400k a year, C would not overtake B by 2029, and its case would rest on trust alone.
Section A10: Notes on the discussion questions
What a strong answer to each discussion question does. Guidance, not a markscheme.
-
Question 1 [3 marks]HL
Multiply each family's recycled content by its units, add them and divide by all the units: (180 × 81 + 120 × 48 + 260 × 55 + 90 × 60) ÷ 650 = 40,040 ÷ 650 = 61.6%. A simple average of the four families, 61.0%, would give too much weight to jackets and trousers.
-
Question 2 [2 marks]
(63,900 − 72,400) ÷ 72,400 × 100 = −11.7%. One mark for the method, one for the answer.
-
Question 3 [4 marks]
Its customers chose it for its values, so its claims are part of what it sells; true claims can justify higher prices and loyalty, while false ones turn that advantage into a liability, as the fall in trust shows. Each point applied to the case.
-
Question 4 [4 marks]
Loyalty: the share of shoppers who would consider buying fell from 44% to 29%, and the net promoter score from +42 to −6. Value: a brand worth a premium because of its values loses that premium when the values are doubted.
-
Question 5 [10 marks]
Strong answers recognize that the crisis was preventable, compare the options on trust and integrity as well as on 2027's profit (where B leads), consider each stakeholder's view, and make a clear recommendation with its conditions.
-
Seminar question 1 Enrichment
Situational crisis communication theory suggests that a preventable crisis calls for accepting responsibility, apologizing and putting things right; defending the record or changing the name looks like evasion.
-
Seminar question 2 Enrichment
Both: marketing made claims the business had not checked, and the business did not know enough about its supply chain to check them. Good answers say which failure the response must fix first.
-
Seminar question 3 Enrichment
Evidence that others can check: independent certification, published data, admitted shortfalls. Good answers note that the brand now carries a burden of proof its competitors do not.
Notes on HL-only questions are hidden in the SL view.
The course and beyond
Where this briefing meets the IB course, and, kept apart and labelled, the ideas it draws on from beyond it.
Subtopics
- 1.3 Business objectives Corporate social responsibility and ethical objectives, and what happens when claims about them are false.
- 1.4 Stakeholders Customers, employees, owners, suppliers and the regulator, and the conflicts between their interests in the response.
- 4.5 The seven Ps of the marketing mix Brand loyalty and brand value, promotion through social media, and the price of a premium range.
- 5.3 Lean production and quality management HL Quality assurance and quality standards: checking what suppliers claim, and independent certification.
- 5.7 Crisis management and contingency planning HL Managing the crisis: transparency, communication, speed and control.
- 2.6 Communication Communicating with staff, customers and partners when the company is at fault.
- 3.3 Costs and revenues Revenue, and the costs a response adds.
Frameworks in the course
- STEEPLE analysis IB toolkit The ecological and ethical factors, and the legal one, explain why the claims mattered so much.
- Circular business models IB toolkit A verified recycled range is a circular supply model; the case shows what it takes to make one real.
- SWOT analysis IB toolkit A strength (loyal, values-led customers) has become a threat now that the values are in doubt.
Course terms
Ideas beyond the course
- Responding to a preventable crisis Situational crisis communication theory distinguishes crises in which an organization is a victim, those that are accidents, and those it could have prevented, and holds that the last call for full acceptance of responsibility. Its reasoning is why defending the record (option A) and changing the name (option D) are the weakest responses here. Source: W. Timothy Coombs (2007), Protecting organization reputations during a crisis: the development and application of situational crisis communication theory
- Reputation as an asset Treating reputation as an asset changes how the board should count the options' costs. Money spent on verified claims is an investment in the asset that lets the brand charge more and keep its customers, not just a cost of the crisis. Source: Charles J. Fombrun (1996), Reputation: Realizing Value from the Corporate Image
Frameworks beyond the course
- Mendelow's matrix Enrichment Decide whom to manage closely through the recovery; customers and the regulator both have high power.
Go further: Advanced Management
- Strategy execution, change and crisis Beyond the IB course Advanced strategy: the module behind this decision, with real organizations, models and a decision exercise.
- Brand strategy and competitive positioning Beyond the IB course Advanced marketing: the module behind this decision, with real organizations, models and a decision exercise.
- Sustainable operations Beyond the IB course Operations and supply chain strategy: the module behind this decision, with real organizations, models and a decision exercise.
Work it through
The platform's tools that apply the briefing's ideas to its figures, or to your own.
- Strategy Studio Stakeholder map Map the stakeholders and plan the communication with each.
- Strategy Studio SWOT builder Rework the brand's SWOT after the ruling.
- IB toolkit guide Circular business models The toolkit guide to circular business models.
- IB toolkit guide Descriptive statistics The toolkit guide to the mean, and why a weighted average differs from a simple one.
Sources and method
- Method How the Boardroom Briefings and their figures were made, Arjun Agrawal | The Business Brief (2026). The platform’s own method.
- Research Protecting organization reputations during a crisis: the development and application of situational crisis communication theory, W. Timothy Coombs, Corporate Reputation Review 10(3) (2007). Cited as a reference; not opened for this release.
- Research Reputation: Realizing Value from the Corporate Image, Charles J. Fombrun, Harvard Business School Press (1996). Cited as a reference; not opened for this release.
Arjun Agrawal | The Business Brief, https://the-business-brief-dun.vercel.app/boardroom-briefings/reputational-damage/. Original teaching material, not an IB publication. The organizations in the teaching cases are fictional unless a case says otherwise.