No. 04 The Boardroom Briefings Operations investment

Should a business automate its operations?

Tasman Loaf Company weighs robots for its packing hall

An Auckland bakery can automate the hardest, most repetitive work on its line. The numbers favour it; the question is how, and what happens to the 38 people who do that work now.

Source: Simulated data Fictional company Updated 16 November 2026
Company
Tasman Loaf Company, Auckland, New Zealand
Industry
Manufacturing and craft
Decision
Operations investment
Functions
Operations management, Human resource management, Finance and accounts
Key concepts
Change, Ethics
Editions
Student, then Analysis
Choose an edition

You are reading the Student edition. The recommendation is withheld.

This briefing has two editions. The Student edition comes first: the case and the questions. The Analysis edition follows it, closed, so that you can decide before you read the recommendation.

The Student edition

The case and the questions, with the recommendation withheld · about 7 minutes to read

Section 01: Executive summary

The decision in brief. In this edition the summary stops short of a recommendation.

The situation

Tasman Loaf Company bakes bread for supermarkets' own labels and under its own name. At the end of its line, 38 people pack loaves into crates and stack the crates onto pallets by hand. The work is repetitive and heavy: there were seven injuries in the palletising area last year, and nearly a quarter of the hall's staff left.

The decision

Whether to automate the packing hall, and how: buy a robotic line with camera inspection, automate only the palletising, lease the robotic line instead of buying it, or keep the manual line and improve it.

What is at stake

Full automation would save about NZ$1.5m a year and cut rejected loaves, but it would replace 38 roles with 12. How the bakery makes the change will decide whether its workforce, its union and its customers trust it afterwards.

Section 02: Business background

The Whitmore family opened its first bakery in Auckland in 1962. Today Tasman Loaf Company runs one large plant in South Auckland with 260 employees on two shifts. It baked 18.2 million loaves in 2025 and sold them for an average of NZ$2.10 each, earning revenue of NZ$38.2m and a profit of NZ$2.7m (Exhibit 2). Anna Whitmore, the third generation of the family, has been managing director since 2021.

The bakery's ovens are modern, but the end of the line is not. Loaves leave the slicers and baggers on a conveyor, and 28 packers place them in crates while 10 palletisers stack the crates, each up to a tonne an hour, onto pallets for the delivery trucks. The 38 roles cost NZ$2,366k a year. In 2025, nine of the hall's staff left, and seven lost time to injuries (Exhibit 1). Rejected and returned loaves, mostly crushed or badly sealed, came to 2.4% of output.

An engineering firm has proposed a robotic packing and palletising line with camera inspection, for NZ$4,200k or for a yearly fee under a lease that the bakery could end after three years. The food workers' union, which represents most of the hall's staff, has asked for a meeting. The board meets in a month.

Company
Tasman Loaf Company
Business
Industrial bakery
Based in
Auckland, New Zealand
Size
260 employees; 18.2 million loaves and revenue of NZ$38.2m in 2025
Ownership
Privately held company, owned by the Whitmore family for three generations
Figures in
NZD, in thousands (NZ$000)
Status
A fictional company. Every figure is simulated for teaching and checked for consistency.

Section 03: Strategic context

The industry and the forces on the decision, in general terms. The only figures in this briefing are the company's own.

Food manufacturing has automated steadily: mixing and baking first, then slicing and wrapping, and now the handling at the end of the line, where robots have become cheaper, faster to install and better at handling soft products. The work that remains manual tends to be the most repetitive and the most physically demanding.

Supermarkets buy own-label bread on price, quality and reliability, and can move a contract to another bakery at the end of its term. A bakery that cannot match its rivals' costs or deliver consistently risks its largest customers, but one that automates takes on higher fixed costs, which have to be paid even if a contract is lost.

Camera inspection using machine learning can check every loaf for shape, colour and seal at line speed. The same systems record how the line runs and who intervenes, which raises questions about how far the data should be used to monitor the people who work beside the machines.

Section 04: Relevant evidence

The company's own evidence (simulated), established research (cited, and stated only as its central idea) and how the market works.

  • The company’s own evidence Source: Simulated data

    A profitable bakery with thin margins

    The bakery made NZ$2,688k of profit on NZ$38,220k of revenue in 2025 (Exhibit 2). Each loaf sold for NZ$2.10 and cost NZ$1.46 in materials and direct labour, a contribution of NZ$0.64 towards fixed costs of NZ$8,960k.

    See Exhibit 2

  • The company’s own evidence Source: Simulated data

    A hard place to work

    Nine of the 38 packing hall staff left in 2025, and there were seven lost-time injuries in palletising (Exhibit 1). High labour turnover means constant recruitment and training, and the injuries carry costs beyond the bakery's accounts.

    See Exhibit 1

  • The company’s own evidence Source: Simulated data

    The cost of each way forward

    The engineering firm and the finance team estimate a net saving of NZ$1,540k a year from buying the full line, after the 12 operators and technicians it needs and its maintenance, and including NZ$320k a year of fewer rejected loaves. Leasing saves less each year, NZ$730k, because of the lease fee, but needs no capital (Exhibit 4).

    See Exhibit 3, Exhibit 4

  • Established research Cited research

    Automation takes tasks, not whole jobs

    Research on workplace automation argues that machines take over particular tasks, usually the routine ones, rather than whole jobs, and that they can make the tasks people keep, such as solving problems and handling exceptions, more valuable. Whether workers gain or lose depends on whether they move to those tasks.

    Source: David H. Autor (2015), Why Are There Still So Many Jobs? The History and Future of Workplace Automation

  • How the market works General context

    How bakeries automate

    Bakeries can buy automated lines outright, lease them, or pay a supplier by the hour or the unit for equipment it owns and maintains. Leasing and paying for use cost more over an asset's life, as a rule, but keep capital free and let the bakery change course if a contract is lost.

The exhibits

Exhibit 1

The packing hall in 2025

Source: Simulated data
Measure 2025
Packing roles28
Palletising roles10
Average number employed in the hall38
Staff who left during the year9
Cost of the 38 roles (NZ$000)2,366
Cost of the 10 palletising roles (NZ$000)620
Lost-time injuries in palletising7
Loaves rejected or returned (% of output)2.4
Source Tasman Loaf Company's personnel and quality records (simulated).

Section 05: Financial information

Exhibit 2 gives the bakery's results for 2025. Exhibit 3 gives the price, variable cost per loaf and fixed costs under each way of running the line, for break-even analysis; buying the line adds depreciation over its seven-year life, the new technicians and a maintenance contract, while leasing adds the fee and the technicians. Exhibit 4 gives each proposal's capital cost, its net saving each year and its one-off cost in the first year. The bakery appraises investments at 8% over seven years.

Exhibit 2

Tasman Loaf Company in 2025

Source: Simulated data
Item 2025
Loaves sold (000)18,200
Average price to retailers (NZ$ a loaf)2.1
Revenue (NZ$000)38,220
Variable cost: ingredients, packaging and direct labour (NZ$ a loaf)1.46
Fixed costs (NZ$000)8,960
Profit (NZ$000)2,688
Source Tasman Loaf Company's management accounts (simulated).
Exhibit 3

Three ways to run the line, for break-even

Source: Simulated data
Line Price (NZ$ a loaf) Variable cost (NZ$ a loaf) Fixed costs (NZ$000 a year)
Manual, as now2.101.468,960
Automated, bought2.101.3310,706
Automated, leased2.101.3310,916

Automation removes the packing hall's labour from the variable cost, NZ$0.13 a loaf. Buying adds NZ$600k of depreciation a year (NZ$4,200k over seven years), NZ$936k for 12 operators and technicians and NZ$210k of maintenance. Leasing adds a fee of NZ$1,020k a year, which includes maintenance, and the same technicians.

Source Engineering firm's proposal and the finance team's estimates (simulated).
Exhibit 4

The four proposals

Source: Simulated data
Proposal Capital cost (NZ$000) Net saving a year (NZ$000) One-off cost in year 1 (NZ$000) Roles removed
A. Buy the full robotic line4,2001,54052026
B. Automate palletising only1,3004941208
C. Lease the full robotic line073052026
D. Improve the manual line15022000

Savings include fewer rejected loaves (NZ$320k a year from the camera inspection under A and C) and, under B, fewer injuries (NZ$90k a year). One-off costs are retraining, redeployment and any voluntary redundancy. B keeps two technicians and a NZ$60k maintenance contract. D trains the hall in lean methods and adds lifting aids, for NZ$150k.

Source Engineering firm's proposal and the finance team's estimates (simulated).

Section 06: Stakeholder implications

Who has a stake in the decision, how much they care and how much they can affect it, what they want, and what the decision would mean for them.

  • Anna Whitmore and the family board

    Stakeholder
    Internal
    Interest
    High
    Power
    High
    What they want
    A bakery that stays competitive for the next generation, and keeps its name as a good employer.
    What the decision means for them
    Buying the line commits NZ$4,200k of the family's capital for seven years; leasing commits a fee that can be ended after three. Either way, the family's reputation rides on how the change is made.
  • The packing hall staff

    Stakeholder
    Internal
    Interest
    High
    Power
    Low
    What they want
    Secure jobs and safer work; some would welcome an end to the heaviest tasks.
    What the decision means for them
    Full automation leaves 12 roles where there are 38. Ten could move to the new sourdough line; the rest of the change would have to come from people leaving.
  • The food workers' union

    Stakeholder
    External
    Interest
    High
    Power
    Medium
    What they want
    No compulsory redundancies, retraining for those who stay, and limits on how the cameras' data is used.
    What the decision means for them
    A dispute could delay the project and damage trust across the plant; an agreement could make the change a model for the industry.
  • Supermarket customers

    Stakeholder
    External
    Interest
    Medium
    Power
    High
    What they want
    Lower prices, consistent quality and reliable deliveries.
    What the decision means for them
    Fewer crushed or badly sealed loaves (rejects falling from 2.4% to 0.8%) would please them; a difficult installation that disrupts deliveries would not.
  • Other employees

    Stakeholder
    Internal
    Interest
    Medium
    Power
    Low
    What they want
    To know whether their own work is next.
    What the decision means for them
    How the bakery treats the packing hall will shape how the rest of the workforce responds to every change after it.
  • The engineering firm

    Stakeholder
    External
    Interest
    High
    Power
    Medium
    What they want
    A sale or a long lease, and a reference customer.
    What the decision means for them
    Under a lease it keeps the risk of the equipment underperforming; under a sale, the bakery does.

Section 07: The strategic options

The courses of action open to the board. Each is set out on its own terms; the Analysis edition judges them.

  1. Option A: Buy the full robotic line

    Buy robotic packing and palletising with camera inspection for NZ$4,200k, install it in one stage, and redeploy or release the staff whose roles disappear.

    What it needs
    NZ$4,200k of capital, 12 operators and technicians, and agreement with the union on the people plan.
    What it could gain
    The largest saving, NZ$1,540k a year, fewer rejects, and the bakery owns the asset.
    What could go wrong
    Higher fixed costs whatever happens to sales; a single installation that could disrupt deliveries; 26 roles removed at once; and the risk that the equipment underperforms falls on the bakery.

    Evidence: Exhibit 3, Exhibit 4

  2. Option B: Automate palletising only

    Automate the heaviest, most dangerous task for NZ$1,300k and keep packing by hand for now.

    What it needs
    NZ$1,300k and two technicians.
    What it could gain
    Most of the injuries removed, eight roles affected rather than 26, and a smaller bet.
    What could go wrong
    A saving of only NZ$494k a year, no camera inspection, and the packing roles' turnover and costs unchanged.

    Evidence: Exhibit 1, Exhibit 4

  3. Option C: Lease the full robotic line

    Take the same line on a lease of NZ$1,020k a year, including maintenance, which the bakery can end after three years; install it in two stages over 18 months.

    What it needs
    The lease contract, the 12 operators and technicians, and the same people plan as A, phased with natural wastage.
    What it could gain
    Almost the same value over seven years as buying, with no capital, maintenance risk carried by the engineering firm, and a way out if a supermarket contract is lost.
    What could go wrong
    A smaller saving each year because of the fee; a long-term relationship with one supplier; the same 26 roles removed in the end.

    Evidence: Exhibit 3, Exhibit 4

  4. Option D: Improve the manual line

    Keep people at the end of the line, add lifting aids, and train the hall in lean methods to cut waste and injuries, for NZ$150k.

    What it needs
    Training and the staff's ideas; no new technology.
    What it could gain
    Jobs kept, a better working environment, and the cheapest option.
    What could go wrong
    A saving of only NZ$220k a year; turnover and repetitive work remain; rivals that automate gain a cost advantage.

    Evidence: Exhibit 1, Exhibit 4

Section 08: Evaluation criteria

How the board has said it will judge the options, and how much each criterion counts. The weights add up to 100.

Criterion How it is judged Weight
Financial return Net present value at 8% over the line's seven-year life, payback and the average rate of return. 25%
People Jobs, safety, and the bakery's relations with its workforce and the union. 25%
Risk The capital at stake, the fixed costs the bakery must carry, and the risk of a difficult installation. 20%
Quality and capacity Fewer rejected loaves, and the line's ability to meet the supermarkets' standards. 15%
Flexibility How easily the bakery could change course if a large contract were lost or a better technology appeared. 15%

Section 09: Discussion questions

Answer them before you open the Analysis edition, which has notes on each.

Source: Original practice question
Show content for

Showing everything. HL-only material is marked HL.

In the style of the IB course

The platform's own questions, written for this briefing; they are not IB examination questions. The marks are each question's own allocation.

  1. Using Exhibit 3, calculate the break-even quantity of loaves for the manual line and for the automated line if it is bought.

    Calculate AO4 5.5 Break-even analysis

    [4 marks]

  2. Using Exhibit 1, calculate the labour turnover in the packing hall in 2025.

    Calculate AO4 2.4 Motivation and demotivation HL

    [2 marks]

  3. Explain two reasons why the packing hall staff might resist the automation.

    Explain AO2 2.1 Introduction to human resource management

    [4 marks]

  4. Discuss the ethical implications of using the camera system's data to monitor the performance of the operators.

    Discuss AO3 5.9 Management information systems HL

    [10 marks]

  5. Evaluate whether Tasman Loaf Company should buy or lease the robotic line.

    Evaluate AO3 3.8 Investment appraisal; 3.2 Sources of finance

    [10 marks]

HL-only questions are hidden in the SL view. Choose HL above to see them.

For seminars, beyond the course

Source: Enrichment

For undergraduate, MBA and professional readers. These questions go beyond the IB course and are labelled as enrichment.

  1. Which tasks in the packing hall would the machines take, and which would they make more valuable? What does your answer mean for training?
  2. Is a promise of no compulsory redundancies a cost to the bakery or an investment by it?
  3. If buying and leasing cost about the same over an asset's life, what should decide between them?
The Analysis edition The worked discussion: the evidence, the assumptions, every option judged and the recommendation. Open it when you have decided. About 7 minutes to read.

The Analysis edition

The worked discussion and the recommendation · about 7 minutes to read

Source: Arjun Agrawal frameworkThe Business Brief's analysis

From here, the page gives the platform's reading of the case: its interpretation of the evidence, its judgement and its recommendation. It adds no new facts, and the same evidence can support other conclusions if they are argued well.

Section A1: Executive summary

Recommended Option C: Lease the full robotic line

Automate the packing hall, but lease the line and install it in two stages over 18 months (option C). Over seven years leasing is worth almost exactly what buying is worth (NZ$3,319.1k against NZ$3,336.2k at 8%), but it needs no capital, leaves the risk of the equipment with its maker, and lets the bakery stop after three years if it loses a large contract. Installing in stages, palletising first, lets the change follow the hall's high labour turnover, so that with 10 people moved to the new sourdough line it should need few compulsory redundancies, and perhaps none.

Section A2: What the evidence shows

The exhibits worked through. Every figure here is recomputed from the exhibits on every build.

  • Automation pays on every measure. Buying the full line has an NPV of NZ$3,336.2k, a payback of 3.1 years and an ARR of 20.6%; leasing it has a present value of NZ$3,319.1k with no capital at all (Exhibit A1). Palletising alone (NZ$1,160.8k) and the lean improvements (NZ$995.4k) are worth much less.
  • Buying and leasing cost almost the same over the line's life: NZ$5,293.3k to buy and maintain against NZ$5,310.4k of lease fees, in present values at 8%. The choice between them is about risk and flexibility, not price.
  • Automation does not make the bakery riskier on its present volumes. Because each loaf contributes more, NZ$0.77 against NZ$0.64, the break-even quantity barely changes: 14,000 thousand loaves for the manual line, 13,903.9 thousand if the line is bought and 14,176.6 thousand if it is leased (Exhibit A2).
  • The people case is easier than it looks. Labour turnover in the hall was 23.7% in 2025, so over 18 months about 13.5 people would leave in the normal course of things. With 10 staff moving to the sourdough line, the 16 other roles that go could largely be met from people who would have left anyway.
Exhibit A1

The proposals appraised at 8% over seven years (NZ$000)

Source: Simulated data
Proposal Payback (years) ARR (%) NPV at 8%
A. Buy the full robotic line3.120.63,336.2
B. Automate palletising only2.922.41,160.8
C. Lease the full robotic lineNo capitalNo capital3,319.1
D. Improve the manual line0.7132.4995.4

Each year's saving is assumed to arrive evenly through the year; year 1 bears the one-off cost. Leasing needs no capital, so it has no payback or ARR; its figure is the present value of its savings. D's payback and ARR are high because it costs so little, but its saving is small.

Source The Business Brief's analysis of Exhibit 4, with the guide's discount factors (simulated data).
Exhibit A2

Break-even under each way of running the line

Source: Simulated data
Line Contribution (NZ$ a loaf) Break-even quantity (000 loaves) Margin of safety at 18.2 million loaves (000) Profit at 18.2 million loaves (NZ$000)
Manual, as now0.6414,000.04,200.02,688
Automated, bought0.7713,903.94,296.13,308
Automated, leased0.7714,176.64,023.43,098

Profit here leaves out the saving from fewer rejected loaves, NZ$320k a year under either automated line.

Source The Business Brief's analysis of Exhibits 2 and 3 (simulated data).

Section A3: The assumptions

What the analysis takes as given, and how a manager would test it before relying on it.

  • The line will save NZ$1,540k a year if bought, or NZ$730k if leased, from the second year.

    How to test it The figures come from the seller and the finance team. Ask for references from bakeries running the same line, and agree performance terms in the lease.

  • Rejected loaves will fall from 2.4% to 0.8% of output.

    How to test it Run a trial of the camera inspection on one product before committing, and measure the rejection rate.

  • Labour turnover in the hall will stay near its 2025 rate of 23.7%.

    How to test it Turnover may fall once staff know their jobs are at risk, since fewer will leave by choice. Plan the stages so that the bakery is not relying on departures that may not come.

  • Volumes will stay near 18.2 million loaves a year.

    How to test it Exhibit A2 shows the margin of safety under each option. Check when each supermarket contract ends.

Section A4: The trade-offs

What the board gives up to get what it wants. No option avoids all of them.

Owning, or the right to stop

Buying the line saves a little money over seven years and gives the bakery an asset; leasing costs a little more and gives it the right to stop after three. For a family business with large customers on fixed-term contracts, the right to stop is worth paying for.

Speed, or the people plan

Installing everything at once brings the savings forward and cuts 26 roles in one step. Installing in stages delays some savings, but lets the change follow natural wastage and earns the cooperation of the staff who remain.

Better data, or more surveillance

The cameras that catch a badly sealed loaf can also time every operator. Using the data to improve the process builds trust; using it to rank people is digital Taylorism, and the union will resist it.

Section A5: The alternatives, judged

Every option judged against the evidence, then scored against the board's criteria.

  1. Option A: Buy the full robotic line

    Defensible if its conditions hold

    Defensible if the bakery wants the asset and is confident in its volumes. It is worth almost exactly what C is worth, but puts NZ$4,200k of the family's capital and the risk of the equipment on the bakery.

  2. Option B: Automate palletising only

    Defensible if its conditions hold

    Defensible as a cautious first step that removes most of the injuries with little disruption, but it captures only a third of the value and leaves the packing hall's turnover and rejects untouched.

  3. Option C: Lease the full robotic line

    Best supported by the evidence

    The best supported. It captures almost all of the value of automation, keeps capital free, moves the equipment risk to its maker and leaves a way out, and its staged installation fits the people plan.

  4. Option D: Improve the manual line

    Weakly supported by the evidence

    Weakly supported as the whole answer. Lean methods and lifting aids help, but they leave the bakery behind rivals that automate, and the work in the hall would stay repetitive and heavy.

The options scored against the board's criteria

Each option is scored from 1 (poor) to 5 (strong) on each criterion. The weighted score is the sum of each weight times its score, divided by 100. The scores are the analysis's judgement; a scoring matrix organizes judgement, it does not replace it.

Criterion Weight Option A Option B Option C Option D
Financial return 25% 5352
People 25% 2425
Risk 20% 2445
Quality and capacity 15% 5352
Flexibility 15% 2454
Weighted score 100% 3.20 3.60 4.05 (the highest) 3.65

Section A6: The recommended course of action

Option C: Lease the full robotic line

Lease the full robotic line, with performance terms in the contract, and install it in two stages: palletising in the first six months, packing and camera inspection by month 18. Agree a people plan with the union before signing: no compulsory redundancies if natural wastage and redeployment allow, retraining for the 12 operator and technician roles, and a written limit on using the cameras' data to monitor individuals.

Why

  • Leasing is worth almost the same as buying over seven years, with no capital at risk.
  • The engineering firm carries the risk of the equipment underperforming, and the bakery can stop after three years.
  • Starting with palletising removes the injuries first, where the case for change is clearest to everyone.
  • Phasing the change over 18 months lets it follow the hall's turnover, which protects the people and the bakery's name.

On these conditions

The recommendation depends on the lease terms. If the engineering firm will not accept performance guarantees or an exit after three years, buying (option A) offers the same value with more control.

Section A7: Implementation

What happens, in what order, and who answers for it.

  1. Months 1 to 2 Meet the union and the hall staff; share the figures; agree the people plan and the limits on the cameras' data. Anna Whitmore and the operations director
  2. Months 2 to 3 Negotiate the lease with performance terms and the option to end it after three years; run a trial of the camera inspection. Finance director
  3. Months 3 to 6 Install robotic palletising; begin training the first operators and technicians from the hall's own staff. Operations director
  4. Months 6 to 18 Install robotic packing and camera inspection; move 10 staff to the sourdough line as it opens; fill no vacancies in the hall. Operations director with the head of people
  5. Month 24 Review the line against the measures below, and decide whether to keep leasing or to buy at the lease's end. The board

Section A8: Evaluation: how to tell if it is working

The evaluation criteria, applied after the decision: what to measure, what counts as working, and when to look.

Measure Target Reviewed
Net saving At least NZ$730k a year once both stages are running, as estimated in Exhibit 4. Every quarter
Rejected loaves Down from 2.4% of output to 0.8%. Every month
Injuries No lost-time injuries in palletising, down from seven in 2025. Every month
People No compulsory redundancies; every operator and technician role filled from the hall's own staff. At each stage

Section A9: Limitations

What the analysis cannot see, and what would change its recommendation.

The limits of the analysis

  • The savings are estimates by the seller and the finance team, and an automated line often runs below its design speed in its first months.
  • The appraisal values cash; it cannot put a figure on the trust the bakery gains or loses with its workforce.
  • Natural wastage is uncertain, and may fall once staff know their roles are changing.

What would change the recommendation

  • If the lease will not include performance terms or an exit, buying (A) becomes the better route to the same line.
  • If a large supermarket contract were lost, the lower fixed costs of B or D would matter more than the savings of C.
  • If the union and the staff would rather take a larger change at once with generous redundancy terms, a one-stage installation would bring the savings forward.

Section A10: Notes on the discussion questions

What a strong answer to each discussion question does. Guidance, not a markscheme.

Source: Assessment explanation
  1. Question 1 [4 marks]

    Break-even quantity = fixed costs ÷ contribution per loaf. Manual: 8,960 ÷ (2.10 − 1.46) = 8,960 ÷ 0.64 = 14,000 thousand loaves, 14.0 million. Bought: 10,706 ÷ (2.10 − 1.33) = 10,706 ÷ 0.77 = 13,903.9 thousand, about 13.9 million. The higher fixed costs are more than offset by the larger contribution per loaf (Exhibit A2).

  2. Question 2 [2 marks]HL

    Labour turnover = staff who left ÷ average number employed × 100 = 9 ÷ 38 × 100 = 23.7%. At that rate about 13.5 people would leave over 18 months, which is why a phased installation could avoid most compulsory redundancies.

  3. Question 3 [4 marks]

    Fear of losing their jobs (26 roles removed under A or C); fear that the remaining work will be watched and paced by the machines; loss of the skills and team they know; distrust of management's promises. Each reason explained in the context of the case.

  4. Question 4 [10 marks]HL

    Strong answers distinguish monitoring the line (to find faults and improve quality) from monitoring people (digital Taylorism), weigh efficiency and safety gains against privacy, trust and stress, consider the union's demand for limits, and reach a judgement, such as using the data for the process but not to rank individuals.

  5. Question 5 [10 marks]

    Good answers compare the appraisal (buying: NPV NZ$3,336.2k, payback 3.1 years, ARR 20.6%; leasing: NZ$3,319.1k with no capital), notice that the costs over seven years are almost the same (NZ$5,293.3k to buy and maintain against NZ$5,310.4k of lease fees), and decide on flexibility, risk and the use of capital. A judgement either way can earn full marks if it is supported.

  6. Seminar question 1 Enrichment

    Placing and stacking go to the robots; fixing jams, changing products, checking quality and maintaining the line grow in value. The answer points to training the people who stay as operators and technicians, not just to reducing headcount.

  7. Seminar question 2 Enrichment

    It costs time, since the change must follow natural wastage, and money, in retraining. It may buy cooperation, a smoother installation and the trust of the rest of the workforce. Good answers estimate both sides from the case.

  8. Seminar question 3 Enrichment

    Who carries the risk of the asset failing or becoming obsolete, the value of being able to stop, the use of the capital elsewhere, and the strength of the relationship with the supplier.

Notes on HL-only questions are hidden in the SL view.

The course and beyond

Where this briefing meets the IB course, and, kept apart and labelled, the ideas it draws on from beyond it.

IB course

Subtopics

Frameworks in the course

Course terms

Source: EnrichmentBeyond the IB course

Ideas beyond the course

Frameworks beyond the course

Go further: Advanced Management

Work it through

The platform's tools that apply the briefing's ideas to its figures, or to your own.

Sources and method