Financial Laboratory · Investment

Payback period

How long does a project take to repay its cost?

Back to 3.8 Investment appraisal

  • IB 3.8 Investment appraisal
  • SL and HL
  • Standard formula: not on the formula sheet
  • Simulated data Example: Emberly Roasters, fictional

The guide’s formula sheet gives no formula for payback, so the standard method is used, assuming each year’s cash arrives evenly through the year.

The calculator

Example figures: Emberly Roasters, a fictional business. Simulated data.

Your project

A negative figure is a year in which more cash goes out than comes in.

Currency

The labels, workings and results use these words. Emberly Roasters’s figures are in dollars.

The figures

Project
Nitrogen-flush packaging line
Capital cost (year 0)
$120,000
Net cash flow, year 1
$22,000
Net cash flow, year 2
$30,000
Net cash flow, year 3
$36,000
Net cash flow, year 4
$38,000
Net cash flow, year 5
$34,000

Changing these figures needs JavaScript. With it switched off, the page shows the full worked example for the figures above.

Result

These results are for the last complete figures. Correct the figure marked in the inputs to update them.

Payback period

3 years and 10.1 months

3.84 years; recovered during year 4

In years, as a decimal
3.84
Cost recovered during
year 4 of 5
Cumulative net cash flow at the end
$40,000year 5
Total returns
$160,000against a cost of $120,000

Section 01: The formula and the working

Each formula in the guide’s words, then the working with the figures above, step by step.

Payback period = years before the cost is recovered + (amount still to recover) ÷ (net cash flow in the payback year) × 12 months

Standard form; the guide gives no formula.

Payback period

Given
  • Capital cost (year 0): $120,000
  • Net cash flow, year 1: $22,000
  • Net cash flow, year 2: $30,000
  • Net cash flow, year 3: $36,000
  • Net cash flow, year 4: $38,000
  • Net cash flow, year 5: $34,000
Formula
Payback period = years before the cost is recovered + (amount still to recover ÷ net cash flow in the payback year) × 12 months
Substitution
= 3 years + (32,000 ÷ 38,000) × 12 months
Working
End of year 1: −$120,000 + $22,000 = −$98,000
End of year 2: −$98,000 + $30,000 = −$68,000
End of year 3: −$68,000 + $36,000 = −$32,000
End of year 4: −$32,000 + $38,000 = $6,000
Still to recover at the start of year 4: $32,000
32,000 ÷ 38,000 = 0.8421 of year 4
0.8421 × 12 = 10.11 months
Answer
3 years and 10.1 months

Assumes the year’s cash arrives evenly through the year. If an answer must be in whole months, round up: the cost is recovered during that month.

Unit
years and months
Interpretation
The project repays its $120,000 cost in 3 years and 10.1 months.
Business implication
After that, the remaining returns, $40,000 by the end of year 5, are what the project adds over its cost, before allowing for the time value of money.

Section 02: The chart

Drawn from the figures above, with every value also in a table.

Cumulative net cash flow: Nitrogen-flush packaging lineNitrogen-flush packaging line: from −$120,000 in year 0 to $40,000 at the end of year 5; pays back in 3 years and 10.1 months.−$150k−$100k−$50k$0$50k012345YearCumulative net cash flowPays back: 3 years and 10.1 months
Chart Cumulative net cash flow from year 0, when the cost is paid. The project pays back where the line crosses zero, marked with a filled dot.
The chart’s figures as a table
Net and cumulative cash flow by year
YearNet cash flowCumulative net cash flow
Year 0−$120,000−$120,000
Year 1$22,000−$98,000
Year 2$30,000−$68,000
Year 3$36,000−$32,000
Year 4$38,000$6,000
Year 5$34,000$40,000

Section 03: If the estimates are wrong

The payback period when every year’s return, or the capital cost, is higher or lower than entered.

Payback period under different estimates
EstimatePayback periodIn years
Returns 20% lower4 years and 8.5 months4.71
Returns 10% lower4 years and 2.6 months4.22
As entered (the figures as entered)3 years and 10.1 months3.84
Returns 10% higher3 years and 6.7 months3.56
Capital cost 10% higher4 years and 2.1 months4.18
Capital cost 10% lower3 years and 6.3 months3.53

Reading. If every return came in 10% lower, payback would stretch to 4 years and 2.6 months (+9.7%). A project whose payback is close to the end of its life can fail to pay back at all on slightly worse figures.

Section 04: What it means

For the figures above: the reading, the comparisons that give it meaning, and what a manager might do.

What the number means

The project repays its $120,000 cost in 3 years and 10.1 months, during year 4 of a 5-year life. Payback measures speed and risk, not profit: it says how long the money is at risk, and nothing about the returns after that.

What to compare it with

Compare the payback period with the maximum the business will accept, with the project’s working life (payback near the end of the life leaves little profit after it), and with other projects competing for the same money. A business short of cash will weigh payback heavily.

Why benchmarks vary

How quick a payback a business wants depends on its industry and its position. In a fast-changing market, such as technology, a business may want its money back within two or three years, before the product dates; one buying long-lived assets, such as buildings or heavy machinery, can accept longer. Higher interest rates and economic uncertainty usually push businesses towards shorter paybacks.

What a manager might do

Options for a manager, not IB requirements; each has a cost or a risk to weigh.

  • Set a maximum payback for the business and compare the project with it, and with the other projects competing for the same money.
  • Payback comes late in the project’s life, leaving little time for profit after it: treat the estimates for the later years with extra care.
  • Reduce the cash at risk: lease rather than buy, or phase the investment so that later stages go ahead only if the first one pays.
  • Use payback alongside the average rate of return and, at HL, net present value.

Section 05: Learn more