Frameworks · Managing change

Force field analysis

A way of weighing the forces driving a change against the forces resisting it, to judge whether it will succeed and how to help it.

An IB toolkit tool, guide p. 14 HL only IB DiplomaUndergraduateMBAProfessional

Section 01: The framework at a glance

Force field analysisA fictional design agency considers a proposed change: move to a four-day working week. Driving forces push for it: better staff retention, scored 4; easier recruitment, scored 3; fewer sick days, scored 2, a total of 9. Restraining forces push against it: clients expect five-day cover, scored 4; rota and scheduling costs, scored 2; managers’ doubts, scored 2, a total of 8. Arrow lengths match the scores. The scores are judgements; the driving forces narrowly win, so the plan would weaken the strongest restraint before going ahead.Move to afour-dayworking weekDRIVING FORCESRESTRAINING FORCES4Better staff retention3Easier recruitment2Fewer sick days4Clients expect five-day cover2Rota and scheduling costs2Managers’ doubtsTotal 9Total 8Each force is scored from 1 (weak) to 5 (strong); the scores are judgements. Here the driving forces narrowly outweighthe restraining ones, so the plan would weaken the strongest restraint, client cover, before going ahead.
Force field analysisA fictional design agency considers a proposed change: move to a four-day working week. Driving forces push for it: better staff retention, scored 4; easier recruitment, scored 3; fewer sick days, scored 2, a total of 9. Restraining forces push against it: clients expect five-day cover, scored 4; rota and scheduling costs, scored 2; managers’ doubts, scored 2, a total of 8. Arrow lengths match the scores. The scores are judgements; the driving forces narrowly win, so the plan would weaken the strongest restraint before going ahead.Move to a four-day working weekDRIVING FORCES, TOTAL 9Better staff retention4Easier recruitment3Fewer sick days2RESTRAINING FORCES, TOTAL 8Clients expect five-day cover4Rota and scheduling costs2Managers’ doubts2Scores run from 1 (weak) to 5 (strong)and are judgements. The plan wouldweaken the strongest restraint, clientcover, before going ahead.

Force field analysis HL Driving and restraining forces, scored and weighed.
Text description

A fictional design agency considers a proposed change: move to a four-day working week. Driving forces push for it: better staff retention, scored 4; easier recruitment, scored 3; fewer sick days, scored 2, a total of 9. Restraining forces push against it: clients expect five-day cover, scored 4; rota and scheduling costs, scored 2; managers’ doubts, scored 2, a total of 8. Arrow lengths match the scores. The scores are judgements; the driving forces narrowly win, so the plan would weaken the strongest restraint before going ahead.

Section 02: What it is, and what it is for

The analysis lists the driving forces that push for a change and the restraining forces that resist it, and gives each a score, commonly from 1 (weak) to 5 (strong). Comparing the totals suggests whether the change is likely to succeed as planned. The more useful step is planning: a change can be helped by strengthening the driving forces or, often more effectively, by weakening the restraining forces, because pushing harder can simply increase resistance.

It is the practical tool behind the unfreezing stage of Lewin's change model, and it links to the guide's reasons for resistance to change and the strategies for reducing it.

What it is for

To analyse a planned change before committing to it, and to decide where effort will do most good. The toolkit guide sets out the method in full, with an interaction for weighting the forces.

Section 03: How it is built

The parts of the framework, and what each one holds.

The change
A precise statement of the change proposed and of the current state it would replace.
Driving forces
The pressures pushing for the change, such as cost savings, new technology, customer demand or staff support, each with evidence.
Restraining forces
The pressures holding the present state in place, such as cost, fear of job loss, habit, skills gaps or customer expectations.
Scores
Each force scored, usually from 1 to 5, for its strength, with the reason recorded.
The balance
The totals for and against, read together with the strongest single forces, which can matter more than the totals.
Actions
Plans to weaken the key restraining forces or strengthen the driving ones, and their expected effect on the balance.

Section 04: When to use it

The business situations it suits, and where another tool will serve better.

It suits

  • Planning a change at work that people may resist, such as a new shift pattern, a new system or a relocation.
  • Deciding which barrier to tackle first, when time and money allow only one or two actions before the change.
  • Explaining to a team why a change has stalled, by naming the forces that hold it back.

Look elsewhere when

  • Choosing between several different options; the analysis weighs one change against the present state.
  • A change blocked by a single absolute constraint, such as the law, which no total can outweigh.

Section 05: How to use it, step by step

A short method. The toolkit guide gives the full one, with the evidence each step needs.

  1. State the change precisely, and the current state it would replace.
  2. List the driving and restraining forces, with evidence for each.
  3. Score each force, from 1 to 5, and record why.
  4. Compare the totals, but look most closely at the strongest single forces.
  5. Plan actions to weaken the key restraining forces or strengthen the driving ones, and check their effect on the scores.

Section 06: Applied: Fernhill Printing weighs a four-day week

Fictional business

Fernhill Printing, a fictional print works, considers a four-day working week of longer days. Driving forces: staff demand for it (4), lower energy costs from closing on Fridays (3) and an easier time recruiting (3), total 10. Restraining forces: customers who want Friday deliveries (4), supervisors worried about cover (3) and the cost of new scheduling software (2), total 9.

What it showed

The totals are close, so the change is not safe as planned. The strongest restraining force is customers' Friday deliveries; a rota that keeps one dispatch team in on Fridays would weaken it from 4 to perhaps 1, which shifts the balance clearly towards the change.

Section 07: Reading the result

How to interpret what it shows, and what that does and does not justify deciding.

Read the totals as a rough guide and the strongest forces as the real message. A change with a narrow lead in the totals is not safe; a change behind on the totals can be made safe if its strongest restraining force can be weakened.

The most useful reading is the action test: if a restraining force within the manager's reach were weakened, how far would the balance move? Reducing resistance usually works better than adding pressure, because pushing harder can provoke stronger resistance.

What it can justify deciding

  • Going ahead when the driving forces clearly outweigh the restraining ones and no single restraining force is decisive.
  • Spending effort first on the restraining force whose weakening would shift the balance most.
  • Delaying or redesigning a change whose strongest restraining force cannot be weakened.

What it does not justify on its own

  • Treating a lead of a point or two in the totals as proof that the change will succeed.
  • Assuming forces stay fixed: weakening one force can strengthen another.

Section 08: Strengths and limits

Why it helps

  • It makes the forces for and against a change explicit and open to discussion.
  • It points to specific actions, especially weakening resistance.
  • It involves the people affected, which can itself reduce resistance.

Where it falls short

  • The scores are subjective, and the totals can give a false sense of precision.
  • A single strong force, such as a legal barrier, can outweigh any total.
  • It describes forces at one moment; they change as the change proceeds.

Section 09: Common mistakes

Errors often made with it, by students and by managers, and how to avoid each.

  1. Mistake Listing forces without evidence or scores.

    Instead Give a reason and evidence for each score, so that others can challenge it.

  2. Mistake Deciding on the totals alone.

    Instead Look at the strongest single forces, which may decide the outcome whatever the totals.

  3. Mistake Planning only to add driving forces.

    Instead Plan at least one action that reduces a restraining force, which usually meets less resistance than pressure does.

Section 10: Apply it

The application mode: the platform's tools that apply this framework, and a worksheet for your own case.

Frameworks structure judgement; they do not produce answers. Each one organizes evidence so that you can see it, test it and argue from it, and the decision, and the reasons for it, remain yours.

The tool that applies it in full

  • Strategy Studio IB toolkit Force field builder List and score the driving and restraining forces for your own change, and test what weakening one restraining force would do to the balance.

For part of it

  • People and Culture Change management planner At HL the change planner weighs the forces as well, then maps the people the change affects, the resistance to expect and why, and the steps that answer each reason.

Your worksheet

The tool is the fuller application. Use the worksheet for a quick pass, or to apply the framework to a second case, part by part.

Kept on this device as you type, and nowhere else. Not saved without JavaScript: print the page or copy your answers before you leave.

For example: What is pushing for this change, what is holding it back, and which force should we work on?
Who it is, what it sells, to whom, and what has changed.
Part by part

For each part, write what you find for this business and the evidence for it. Leave a part blank only if you can say why it does not apply.

What the framework shows when the parts are read together, and how sure you are of it.
The decision the result supports, what else you would need to know, and what would change your mind.

The Framework Application Lab: choose a framework by the decision you face.

Section 11: Try it

The platform's own exercise. Write your answer, then open the guidance.

Your school plans to start lessons an hour later each day. Carry out a force field analysis with at least three driving and three restraining forces, scored from 1 to 5, and recommend two actions that would most improve the chance of success.

Kept on this device as you type, and nowhere else. Your answer is not saved without JavaScript; copy it before you leave.

Guidance: what a strong answer does
  • Base each force on evidence or a stakeholder's view, not a guess.
  • Explain the score for the strongest forces.
  • Do not rely on the totals alone: identify the force that could block the change on its own.
  • Prefer actions that weaken resistance, and say how each would change a score.

In the glossary

  • Force field analysis A tool that weighs the forces driving a change against the forces restraining it, to plan how to make the change succeed.
  • Resistance to change Employees' reluctance to accept, or active opposition to, a change in how they work, such as new technology, a restructuring or a move to a new site.
  • Change management Planning and leading a change so that people accept it and its harmful effects on them are kept small, mainly through communication, involvement, training and support.
  • Lewin's change model Beyond IB A model of organizational change in three stages: unfreezing the current state, moving to a new one, and refreezing so that the new way becomes stable.

Read with

Compare it with any other framework in the library.

Published works behind it

Cited as bibliographic references in the platform's source register; the explanations on this page are the platform's own.

The explanation, method, example and exercise are the platform's own. Statements about the IB course cite the Business management guide; the business in the example is fictional.