Strategy Studio · Stage 4 of 4: Plan

Force field builder

Set out the forces driving a change and the forces holding it back, score each with evidence and an action, and test what weakening a restraining force would do.

Section 01: Build your analysis

The tool opens on a worked example. Change anything: the analysis follows, and your work is kept on this device.

Scripts are off, so this is the worked example as a finished analysis. Every part of it can be read; to build your own, turn scripts on.

Your work is kept on this device as you type.

Your inputs

Driving forces Pushing for the change
Restraining forces Holding it back
Test a weaker restraining force

The analysis

Worked example Northvale Cycles is fictional and its figures are simulated. Change anything and this becomes your own analysis.

The force field

Northvale Cycles. Change: Add a second assembly shift and a fleet sales team for business cargo bikes

Force field: Add a second assembly shift and a fleet sales team for business cargo bikesForce field for Add a second assembly shift and a fleet sales team for business cargo bikes. Driving forces: Fleet orders waiting from three delivery firms 4, Fleet bikes earn a higher margin 4, The owners want profit restored 3, Van charges pushing firms towards bikes 4; total 15. Restraining forces: Dealers fear being bypassed 4, Staff reluctant to work a late shift 3, Cash needed for tooling and stock 4, Motor lead times of up to 20 weeks 3; total 14. On your weighting the driving forces (15) outweigh the restraining forces (14). The change looks achievable, but the restraining forces have not gone away: each still needs a plan.Add a second assembly shift and a fleet sales team for business cargo bikesDRIVINGRESTRAININGFleet orders waiting from three delivery firms4Fleet bikes earn a higher margin4The owners want profit restored3Van charges pushing firms towards bikes4Dealers fear being bypassed4Staff reluctant to work a late shift3Cash needed for tooling and stock4Motor lead times of up to 20 weeks3Total 15Total 14
Driving
154 forces
Restraining
144 forces
Balance
Driving leads

On your weighting the driving forces (15) outweigh the restraining forces (14). The change looks achievable, but the restraining forces have not gone away: each still needs a plan.

Weakening a restraining force

If "Dealers fear being bypassed" fell from 4 to 2, the restraining total would fall from 14 to 12, against 15 driving. The driving forces would lead by more. Your plan: Pay dealers a commission on fleet sales in their area and use them for servicing.

The action plan

Each force, its strength, the evidence and the action planned
ForceSideStrengthEvidenceAction
Fleet orders waiting from three delivery firmsDriving4Three firms have asked for quotes for fleets of 30 to 60 bikes.Turn the strongest inquiry into a paid trial with a firm order.
Fleet bikes earn a higher marginDriving4A fleet bike with a service contract earns about €400 more contribution than a cargo bike sold through a dealer.Show the margin in the board paper, net of the dealer commission.
The owners want profit restoredDriving3The family board has asked for a plan to return to €3m of operating profit.Agree review dates so the board sees progress.
Van charges pushing firms towards bikesDriving4Three nearby cities will charge vans to enter their low-emission zones from 2027.Time the launch for the year before the charges start.
Dealers fear being bypassedRestraining4Dealers sell four in five Northvale bikes, and several have said they will stock rivals if sales go direct.Pay dealers a commission on fleet sales in their area and use them for servicing.
Staff reluctant to work a late shiftRestraining3In an informal poll, half the assembly staff said they would not work evenings.Consult the staff council, ask for volunteers first and pay a shift premium.
Cash needed for tooling and stockRestraining4The plan needs €2m, and cash is tight after two years of falling profit.Phase the investment behind the trial, and use the bank loan only once orders are firm.
Motor lead times of up to 20 weeksRestraining3Lead times for cargo-rated motors reached 20 weeks in 2024.Qualify a second motor supplier before the second shift starts.
TotalsDriving 15; restraining 14

The scores are judgements, so the totals are not a measurement. Two forces with the same score may need very different effort to change.

Checks

No problems found: the change is stated, both sides have forces with evidence, and the strong restraining forces have a plan.

Section 02: About this tool

What it is for, how to use it, what it cannot do, and where it stands in the IB course.

Purpose

To judge whether a change is likely to succeed and to plan how to make it succeed, usually by finding the restraining forces that can be weakened.

IB syllabus status

IB toolkit tool HL only

Force field analysis is an HL-only toolkit tool, suggested for units 2 and 5 (Business management guide, p. 14), and taught at AO2 and AO4 alongside the syllabus content (p. 13). It fits subtopic 2.1, on resistance to change in the workplace and strategies for reducing it. SL students can skip this tool or use it as enrichment.

Serves 2.1 Introduction to human resource management

How to use it

  1. State the change in a sentence.
  2. Add the driving forces and the restraining forces, each with its evidence.
  3. Score each force from 1 (weak) to 5 (very strong). The tool totals each side and says which way the balance falls.
  4. For each force, write the action: how a driving force could be strengthened, or a restraining force weakened, and at what cost.
  5. Choose a restraining force to test. The tool shows what weakening it would do to the balance.
  6. Carry the actions into the implementation steps of the recommendation memo.

Limitations

  • The scores are judgements, not measurements. Adding them up gives a prompt for discussion, not a forecast.
  • Two forces with the same score may need very different effort and money to change.
  • Forces interact. Weakening one can strengthen another, as when a shift premium wins over staff but adds to the cash needed.
  • It shows the forces at one moment. The balance shifts as the change goes ahead.

A model is an aid to judgement, not a universal answer. Use what it shows, then decide, and say why.

Section 03: Using what it shows

Recommended use

The recommended use is to plan, not to total. The driving forces lead by one point, 15 to 14, which says the change is possible, not that it will happen. Name the restraining force worth weakening first, here the dealers' fear, and say how and at what cost.

Read alongside