Toolkit
Force field analysis
A weighing of the forces that drive a change against the forces that restrain it, used to plan how to make the change succeed.
Section 01: What it is for
To judge whether a change is likely to succeed, and to find the restraining forces a manager could weaken.
- Class
- Decision-making (the platform's reading; the TSM does not classify this tool)
- Suggested units
- Unit 2, Unit 5 (guide, p. 14)
When to use it
- Before introducing a change in an organization.
- To plan how to reduce resistance to a change that has stalled.
How to build it
- State the change in the centre.
- List the driving forces on one side and the restraining forces on the other.
- Score each force, for example from 1 (weak) to 5 (strong), and support each score with evidence.
- Total each side.
- Decide how to strengthen driving forces or, usually more effective, weaken restraining ones.
The evidence it needs
- Evidence about the people affected, such as their skills, views and interests.
- Evidence about resources, costs and external pressures.
Section 02: What it shows, and what it hides
- Where resistance to a change comes from.
- Which forces a manager can act on, and which are beyond reach.
- An objective measurement. The scores are judgements.
- How long the change will take, or what it will cost.
Limitations
- The scores are subjective, and the totals give a false impression of precision.
- Forces interact, so weakening one can strengthen another.
- It turns a changing situation into a fixed list.
Section 03: Applied: The new system on Halden's night shift
From the case Halden Distribution.
Driving forces include the client's deadline and the system's accurate pick lists. Restraining forces include two hours of training per person, scanners that go flat before the end of the shift, staff who were never consulted, and team leaders new to the role.
Interaction
Forces for and against the new system on the night shift
The builder could not start. The strengths below are the suggested ones.
The change The night shift uses the new warehouse system as designed
On your weighting the restraining forces (15) outweigh the driving forces (14). The change is unlikely to succeed unless some restraining forces are weakened or driving forces strengthened.
Section 04: In the exam
Useful in questions about change, culture and leadership at HL. Credit comes from evidence for each force and from the action the analysis points to.
Common errors
- Treating the totals as the decision.
- Scoring forces without evidence from the case.
- Listing forces without saying how the manager could act on them.
Arjun Agrawal | The Business Brief, https://the-business-brief-dun.vercel.app/toolkit/force-field-analysis/. Original teaching material, not an IB publication. The organizations in the teaching cases are fictional unless a case says otherwise.
Three of the four restraining forces (training, the charging rota and consultation) can be weakened within weeks. The fourth, the team leaders' inexperience, needs coaching over months.