Framework comparison
Gantt chart against critical path analysis
Should the project be shown as bars against time, or as a network that finds what cannot slip?
Two HL toolkit tools for planning projects: a Gantt chart shows the schedule at a glance; critical path analysis works out the shortest duration and the float.
Standing in the IB course
IB toolkit One of the tools of the business management toolkit, HL only; Business management guide, p. 14. The toolkit guide.
Gantt charts in the frameworks library
5.1 Introduction to operations management, 4.5 The seven Ps of the marketing mix
Key terms: Gantt chart
IB toolkit One of the tools of the business management toolkit, HL only; Business management guide, pp. 14 to 15. The toolkit guide.
Critical path analysis in the frameworks library
5.1 Introduction to operations management, 5.6 Production planning HL
Key terms: Critical path analysis (CPA), Critical path, Total float, Free float
Purpose
To show a project's tasks against time, so everyone can see when each happens and whether the project is on schedule.
To find the shortest time a project can take, the activities that cannot slip without delaying it, and the float in the others.
Structure
A bar for each task along a time scale, placed after the tasks it depends on; milestones mark key dates, and progress can be shaded in.
A network of activities and their dependencies; earliest start and latest finish times give each activity's total and free float, and the activities with no float form the critical path.
The context it suits
Communicating a schedule to a team, monitoring progress week by week, and projects with few tasks and simple dependencies, such as a product launch.
Projects with many activities and complex dependencies, such as a refit or a construction project, especially when a deadline is tight and resources must be moved to where they matter.
Strengths
- Easy to read: the schedule is visible at a glance.
- Good for monitoring progress against the plan.
- Shows which tasks overlap and when resources are needed.
- Identifies the activities that decide the finishing date.
- Float shows where resources can be moved without delaying the project.
- Shows the effect of a delay or of speeding up an activity.
Limitations
- Dependencies can be hard to see on a large chart.
- Does not calculate float or identify the critical path directly.
- Needs redrawing when the plan changes.
- More complex to build and to read than a Gantt chart.
- Rests on estimated durations, which may be wrong.
- Shows timing, not cost or quality.
Common mistakes
- Drawing bars without respecting the dependencies between tasks.
- Reading the chart's end as certain when the durations are estimates.
- Using it alone on a complex project where the critical path matters.
- Speeding up an activity that has float, which does not shorten the project.
- Confusing total float with free float.
- Forgetting that the critical path can change when durations change.
A business application
Fictional Wrenfold Audio
A headphone maker plans the launch of its first wireless earbuds for a trade fair. The Gantt chart shows design, testing, packaging, advertising and the first production run across fourteen weeks, and the team shades in progress every Friday.
Fictional Wrenfold Audio
The firm's new factory line has nineteen activities. The network shows a critical path of 46 days through the electrical work and the safety checks; adding a second electrical team saves four days, while speeding up the furniture delivery saves none.
In an examination answer
Recommended strategy
HL only, so it will not be needed in Paper 1 (guide, p. 43). Construct or read the chart from the task data, label the time scale, and say what it shows about the deadline and the risks; a strong answer can compare its usefulness with critical path analysis.
Recommended strategy
HL only, so it will not be needed in Paper 1 (guide, p. 43). The guide expects a network to be completed and analysed rather than drawn, the critical path identified and total and free float calculated (pp. 14 to 15): show every earliest start and latest finish, then interpret the float for the decision in the case.
Section 01: The difference, in a paragraph
Both plan the same project. The Gantt chart lays tasks against time, so the schedule is easy to see and to monitor. Critical path analysis works out the shortest possible duration and the float of each activity, so it shows which activities cannot slip and where effort would shorten the project. One communicates the plan; the other analyses it.
Section 02: Which to use when
-
A team needs to see and follow a simple schedule week by week.
Use Gantt chart
The bars make the plan visible and progress easy to track.
-
A deadline is tight and the business must decide which activities to speed up.
Use Critical path analysis
Only the critical path and the float show which activities decide the finish.
-
A large project with many activities that depend on one another.
Use Critical path analysis
The network handles complex dependencies that a chart makes hard to see.
Section 03: Using them together
Use critical path analysis to find the critical path and the float, then draw the result as a Gantt chart to communicate and monitor it. The scenario generator has cases on a launch schedule and on a refit that practise each.
Section 04: Read more
In the frameworks library
- Gantt charts Its page also says when to look elsewhere and what to read with it.
- Critical path analysis Its page also says when to look elsewhere and what to read with it.
In the course
Related comparisons
Statements about the course come from the curriculum file, checked against the Business management guide (first assessment 2024); exam advice is the platform's own, labelled Recommended strategy; every business in the applications is fictional. Compare any two frameworks in the library.
Arjun Agrawal | The Business Brief, https://the-business-brief-dun.vercel.app/frameworks/compare/gantt-chart-vs-critical-path-analysis/. Original teaching material, not an IB publication. The organizations in the teaching cases are fictional unless a case says otherwise.