Framework comparison
The Ansoff matrix against the BCG matrix
Where should the business grow next, or which of its products deserve the cash?
Two matrices from the toolkit that look alike and answer different questions: the Ansoff matrix maps routes to growth, the BCG matrix maps the products a business already sells.
Standing in the IB course
IB toolkit One of the tools of the business management toolkit, SL and HL; Business management guide, p. 14. The toolkit guide.
The Ansoff matrix in the frameworks library
1.5 Growth and evolution, 4.2 Marketing planning
Key terms: Ansoff matrix, Market penetration, Product development, Market development, Diversification
IB toolkit One of the tools of the business management toolkit, SL and HL; Business management guide, p. 14. The toolkit guide.
The Boston Consulting Group matrix in the frameworks library
4.5 The seven Ps of the marketing mix
Key terms: Boston Consulting Group (BCG) matrix, Star (BCG matrix), Cash cow (BCG matrix), Question mark (BCG matrix), Dog (BCG matrix)
Purpose
To lay out the directions in which a business could grow, and compare how far each takes it from what it already knows, before it commits to one.
To judge a portfolio of products the business already sells, and decide which should receive cash, which should provide it, and which to rethink.
Structure
Two axes, products and markets, each split into existing and new, give four cells: market penetration, product development, market development and diversification. Risk usually rises from penetration to diversification.
Products are placed by the growth of their market and their market share relative to the largest rival. The four cells are stars, cash cows, question marks and dogs.
The context it suits
A business that wants to grow and has several routes open, such as a regional brand weighing a new range against a new region. It looks forward, at options that do not exist yet.
A business with several products or brands competing for limited money, such as a drinks company deciding where next year's marketing budget should go. It looks at the present portfolio.
Strengths
- Makes managers consider all four directions, not just the obvious one.
- Shows the relative risk of each route before any figures are worked out.
- Links growth to marketing planning and to the evidence each route needs.
- Shows the balance of a portfolio at a glance, and where cash comes from and goes.
- Uses figures (growth and relative share) rather than opinion alone.
- Links the product portfolio to the product life cycle and to cash flow.
Limitations
- The line between existing and new is a judgement, and many options sit between cells.
- It says nothing about profit, competitors or the cash each route needs.
- The usual risk of a cell can mislead in a particular case.
- Market share is not the same as profit; a dog can still earn a little.
- Defining the market changes every product's share, and so its cell.
- It assumes each product stands alone, though products often sell together.
Common mistakes
- Placing an option by whether it is new to the industry rather than new to the business.
- Confusing the direction of growth (market development) with its method (franchising, a joint venture).
- Treating the cell's usual risk as the option's actual risk.
- Using market share instead of relative market share, the product's share divided by the largest rival's.
- Deciding to drop every dog without asking whether it still earns cash or supports the range.
- Treating the four labels as instructions rather than prompts for a judgement.
A business application
Fictional Harbourside Preserves
A maker of jams sold in its own country lists four ideas: a loyalty offer for current stockists, a range of chutneys, selling its jams abroad online, and a café. Mapping them shows that only the café is new on both counts; the board shortlists the chutneys and the online exports and asks for evidence on each.
Fictional Harbourside Preserves
Five years later the business sells four products. Its strawberry jam leads a slow-growing market (a cash cow); its chutneys trail the leader in a fast-growing one (a question mark). The matrix shows the jam's cash funding the chutneys, if the business believes they can win share.
In an examination answer
Recommended strategy
Name the cell for each option the case offers and explain why it sits there, using the case's own products and markets. Then judge the route: the matrix ranks risk, so add the evidence it leaves out, such as cost, competition and the business's skills, before recommending one.
Recommended strategy
Calculate relative market share where the data allows, place each product, and say what the placing means for cash. A strong answer goes beyond the labels: it asks whether a question mark can really win share and whether the cash cow's market is about to decline.
Section 01: The difference, in a paragraph
The Ansoff matrix is about the future: which new combination of products and markets to grow into, and how risky each is. The BCG matrix is about the present: how the products a business already sells are placed by market growth and share, and so where its cash should go. One generates growth options; the other allocates money between existing products.
Section 02: Which to use when
-
The owners want growth and are weighing a new product, a new market or both.
Use The Ansoff matrix
The question is which direction to take, which the Ansoff matrix sets out with the risk of each.
-
Several existing products compete for a limited marketing budget.
Use The BCG matrix
The question is which products deserve cash, which the BCG matrix answers from growth and relative share.
-
A product is ageing and the business must decide whether to replace it or reposition it.
Use The BCG matrix
Its place in the portfolio, and the cash it earns, come first; the Ansoff matrix can then frame what replaces it.
Section 03: Using them together
Used in turn they make a plan: the BCG matrix shows which products earn the cash and which need it, and the Ansoff matrix shows where that cash could take the business next. A question mark backed by a cash cow is often a product development or a market development in Ansoff's terms.
Section 04: Read more
In the frameworks library
- The Ansoff matrix Its page also says when to look elsewhere and what to read with it.
- The Boston Consulting Group matrix Its page also says when to look elsewhere and what to read with it.
Statements about the course come from the curriculum file, checked against the Business management guide (first assessment 2024); exam advice is the platform's own, labelled Recommended strategy; every business in the applications is fictional. Compare any two frameworks in the library.
Arjun Agrawal | The Business Brief, https://the-business-brief-dun.vercel.app/frameworks/compare/ansoff-matrix-vs-bcg-matrix/. Original teaching material, not an IB publication. The organizations in the teaching cases are fictional unless a case says otherwise.