Decision Room

Marigold Kitchens: which way to grow?

Five routes, four aims, and a decision that changes what the business is.

Source: Simulated data Case file: Marigold Kitchens
  1. Situation
  2. Decision
  3. Consequence
  4. Implementation
  5. Outcome
  6. Debrief

Section 01: The situation

You are advising Meera Rao, the founder. She wants a recommendation she can defend to her bank, a possible investor and her own staff.

Marigold Kitchens has four profitable restaurants in Pune, ₹20m of cash and five ways forward. Read the evidence, choose a route, and then decide how to make it work. The forecasts below each choice come from the finance manager's model; what happens after that is one simulation of how the route might go. Commit before you read the debrief.

Read the full case: Marigold Kitchens

The evidence pack: 5 exhibits
Exhibit 1

Restaurant economics, last financial year (one restaurant)

Source: Simulated data From the case file: Marigold Kitchens
Item ₹m a year Share of revenue (%)
Revenue24.00100
Food and packaging7.6832
Staff6.0025
Rent3.6015
Utilities and maintenance1.205
Other costs1.205
Restaurant profit4.3218

Food and packaging rise and fall with sales. Staff, rent, utilities and other costs do not change with the number of meals within a restaurant's normal range.

Source Simulated teaching data, prepared by the finance manager from the four restaurants' accounts. The four restaurants are assumed identical.
Exhibit 3

The five routes, as forecast by the finance manager

Source: Simulated data From the case file: Marigold Kitchens
Route What it involves Money needed and where it comes from Key terms and forecast assumptions
Organic growthFour company-owned restaurants in Mumbai, opened over two years.₹72m (₹18m a restaurant). ₹20m from cash and a ₹52m bank loan at 11% a year.Mumbai rent ₹5.4m a year; other restaurant costs as in Pune. Sales ₹26m a restaurant when mature, about 85% of that in the first full year. Central costs rise to ₹7.0m for an area manager and training.
FranchisingTwelve franchised restaurants over two years, mainly in Mumbai and Bengaluru.₹10m from cash for a training academy, an operations manual and franchise recruitment.Fee ₹1.5m a franchise, once. Royalty 6% of the franchisee's sales; marketing levy 2%, spent on marketing for the whole network. Franchisees' sales about ₹19m each in year two, ₹21m when mature. Support team ₹6.0m a year; academy ₹1.5m a year.
Joint ventureA company owned 50:50 with Sterling Malls, opening six restaurants in its malls in Pune, Mumbai and Bengaluru.₹45m from each partner (₹15m a restaurant). Marigold's share from ₹15m of cash and a ₹30m loan at 11%.Rent 15% of sales. Staff ₹6.6m and utilities and other costs ₹2.4m a restaurant. Sales ₹25.2m a restaurant in year two, ₹28m when mature. Joint venture overheads ₹2.0m a year; Marigold's oversight ₹0.5m a year.
AcquisitionBuy Tiffin Lane's nine restaurants. Convert the six best to the Marigold format; close the three weakest.₹120m from Banyan Growth Partners for 30% of Marigold (₹96m price, ₹24m for conversions). Closures ₹6m from cash, once.Buying for the whole group lowers food and packaging to 30% of sales. Converted restaurants sell ₹20m in year two and ₹23m when mature, with costs of ₹11m a year each besides food. Central costs ₹8.0m a year.
Stay focusedStay at four restaurants and add a weekday lunch service for offices in Pune, cooked in the existing kitchens.₹3m from cash for vans and equipment.Sales ₹6m in year two, ₹9m when mature. Food and packaging 36% of sales; delivery and selling costs ₹1.2m a year.
Source Simulated teaching data. Year two is the first full year after the decision; mature means year four. Taxes, depreciation and inflation are left out.
Exhibit 4

Tiffin Lane, last financial year

Source: Simulated data From the case file: Marigold Kitchens
Item One restaurant, ₹m Nine restaurants, ₹m
Revenue16.00144.00
Food and packaging (34% of sales)5.4448.96
Other restaurant costs9.8088.20
Restaurant profit0.766.84
Central costs3.00
Operating profit3.84

The asking price is ₹96m, twenty-five times Tiffin Lane's operating profit.

Source Simulated teaching data, from the information pack supplied by Tiffin Lane's owner.
Exhibit 6

What the founder wants

Source: Simulated data From the case file: Marigold Kitchens

Four things matter to me. The food stays as good as it is now: people come back because it tastes like home. Marigold should be known in at least three cities within five years. I will not give up control of what I built. And the people who grew with us should grow with the business.

Meera Rao, founder, in a note to the board
Source Fictional note, written for this case.
Exhibit 7

Who wants a Marigold franchise?

Source: Simulated data From the case file: Marigold Kitchens
Franchise inquiries
41 In the last twelve months
From Mumbai
17
From Bengaluru
9
From other cities
15
With restaurant experience
9
Able to fund a restaurant without a loan
4 A franchised restaurant costs its owner about ₹16m to open
Source Simulated teaching data, from the inquiries log.

The board pack

Source: Simulated data
Measure Now After your decisions Change
Restaurants under the Marigold name by year two4Not decided
Marigold's own recurring revenue, year twoFranchisees' and the joint venture's sales are not Marigold's revenue₹96mNot decided
Founder's share of profit after interest, year two₹12.78mNot decided
Founder's share of profit after interest, year four₹12.78mNot decided
New money committed₹0mNot decided
New borrowing₹0mNot decided
Founder's ownership of Marigold100%Not decided
Control of the kitchensFullNot decided
Risk to the brand and the foodLowNot decided

Section 02: Choose the route

Which route do you recommend to Meera?

Before you choose, decide which of the four aims matters most to you, and why. You will be asked about it in the debrief.

Which route do you recommend to Meera?
See what happens

Consequence

Eight restaurants, a loan to repay, and profit that dips before it climbs

The Mumbai restaurants open one by one over two years, and each takes most of a year to find its regulars. In year two they average ₹22.1m of sales, against ₹26m when mature, and each earns only ₹1.23m after Mumbai's higher rent. With ₹5.72m of interest on the loan and central costs up to ₹7.0m for an area manager and training, profit falls to ₹9.47m in year two, below today's ₹12.78m. If the restaurants mature as forecast, it climbs to ₹20.08m by year four.

How people react

  • Meera Rao Mixed Keeps full control and the recipes, but the debt keeps her awake.
  • Staff Positive Senior cooks see a path to running a kitchen of their own.
  • The bank Mixed Earns interest, and watches a new city's sales closely.
  • Mumbai customers Positive Find the food as good as its reputation; it takes time for word to spread.

Risks now

  • If Mumbai demand is weaker than forecast, interest and rent are still due. The loan magnifies the downside.
  • Committing to all four openings at once gives up the option to stop after the first two.

The theory behind it

Internal (organic) growth is slower and is financed here by retained profit and debt. It keeps control and culture, and it raises gearing. At eight restaurants the economies of scale are modest; the main gain is reach.

The figures after this choice
Restaurants under the Marigold name by year two 8 +4 on now
Marigold's own recurring revenue, year two ₹184.40m +₹88.40m on now
Founder's share of profit after interest, year two ₹9.47m −₹3.31m on now
Founder's share of profit after interest, year four ₹20.08m +₹7.30m on now
New money committed ₹72m +₹72m on now
New borrowing ₹52m +₹52m on now
Founder's ownership of Marigold 100% No change
Control of the kitchens Full No change
Risk to the brand and the food Medium Was Low on now
See what happens

Consequence

Sixteen Marigold restaurants, twelve of them run by people Meera did not hire

Twelve franchises open within two years, most of them in Mumbai and Bengaluru. Their restaurants sell ₹228m in year two, but that is the franchisees' revenue, not Marigold's. Marigold earns a 6% royalty, ₹13.68m, and after the support team (₹6.0m) and the academy (₹1.5m), recurring profit rises to ₹18.96m in year two and ₹20.40m when the franchises mature. Franchise fees add ₹9.0m in year two, but they stop when the network stops growing, so they are left out of the recurring figures. Only four inquirers had the capital, so eight franchisees were approved with bank loans.

How people react

  • Meera Rao Mixed The brand reaches two new cities fast; she no longer knows every kitchen.
  • Franchisees Mixed Gain a known brand; most carry heavy loans.
  • Customers Mixed Find Marigold in more places; some say it is not the same everywhere.
  • Staff Positive A few join the new support team; the kitchens carry on as before.

Risks now

  • Quality now depends on twelve owners following the recipes. One bad restaurant damages the brand everywhere.
  • The plan assumes twelve capable franchisees in two years; the evidence shows four with the means.

The theory behind it

Franchising is external growth without ownership: fast and light on capital, it trades control for reach. The franchisor's revenue is fees and royalties, not the network's sales.

The figures after this choice
Restaurants under the Marigold name by year two 16 +12 on now
Marigold's own recurring revenue, year two ₹109.68m +₹13.68m on now
Founder's share of profit after interest, year two ₹18.96m +₹6.18m on now
Founder's share of profit after interest, year four ₹20.40m +₹7.62m on now
New money committed ₹10m +₹10m on now
New borrowing ₹0m No change
Founder's ownership of Marigold 100% No change
Control of the kitchens Low Was Full on now
Risk to the brand and the food High Was Low on now
See what happens

Consequence

Marigold in six malls across three cities, run by a company it owns half of

Six mall restaurants open by the end of year two, with high footfall: ₹25.2m of sales each in year two and ₹28m when mature, but rent is 15% of sales. The joint venture earns ₹24.14m in year two. Marigold's half, ₹12.07m, lifts its profit to ₹21.05m after interest and oversight, and to ₹25.50m by year four. The joint venture's sales of ₹151.2m belong to the joint venture company, so Marigold's own revenue is still ₹96m.

How people react

  • Meera Rao Mixed Three cities in two years; now every decision in the malls needs a partner's agreement.
  • Sterling Malls Positive Gets a restaurant that draws shoppers.
  • Staff Positive New roles in three cities.
  • Customers Mixed Convenient, but a mall food court is faster and noisier than a Marigold dining room.

Risks now

  • In the joint venture, menu and pricing decisions need the partner's agreement.
  • Exit terms decide what happens if the partners disagree, and standard terms often favour the partner that owns the sites.

The theory behind it

A joint venture is external growth through a new, jointly owned business. It shares cost and risk, and it shares control. It suits a market the business cannot easily enter alone, here the malls.

The figures after this choice
Restaurants under the Marigold name by year two 10 +6 on now
Marigold's own recurring revenue, year two ₹96m No change
Founder's share of profit after interest, year two ₹21.05m +₹8.27m on now
Founder's share of profit after interest, year four ₹25.50m +₹12.72m on now
New money committed ₹45m +₹45m on now
New borrowing ₹30m +₹30m on now
Founder's ownership of Marigold 100% No change
Control of the kitchens Shared Was Full on now
Risk to the brand and the food Medium Was Low on now
See what happens

Consequence

Ten restaurants after integration, and an investor at the table

₹96m buys Tiffin Lane and ₹24m converts its six best restaurants to the Marigold format; the three weakest close at a one-off cost of ₹6m. Buying for ten restaurants, Marigold negotiates food and packaging down from 32% to 30% of sales, a purchasing economy of scale. The converted restaurants sell ₹20m each in year two. Group profit reaches ₹29.2m in year two and ₹41.8m by year four, but Meera now owns 70%, so her share is ₹20.44m and ₹29.26m.

How people react

  • Meera Rao Mixed Runs the largest business in this decision, and now answers to an investor.
  • Banyan Growth Partners Positive Has growth it can one day sell.
  • Tiffin Lane staff Negative Three restaurants close; the rest work to new rules.
  • Marigold staff Mixed Promotions to run converted kitchens, and the strain of integration.

Risks now

  • The savings depend on merging menus, suppliers and systems, and on Tiffin Lane's staff staying.
  • Banyan will expect to sell its stake in five to seven years, which may mean selling the whole business.

The theory behind it

An acquisition is external growth by buying control of another business. It is the fastest route to scale and can bring purchasing and managerial economies of scale. It also brings the risks of overpaying, culture clash and diseconomies of scale while the two businesses are combined.

The figures after this choice
Restaurants under the Marigold name by year two 10 +6 on now
Marigold's own recurring revenue, year two ₹216m +₹120m on now
Founder's share of profit after interest, year two ₹20.44m +₹7.66m on now
Founder's share of profit after interest, year four ₹29.26m +₹16.48m on now
New money committed ₹126m +₹126m on now
New borrowing ₹0m No change
Founder's ownership of Marigold 70% −30% on now
Control of the kitchens Full No change
Risk to the brand and the food High Was Low on now
See what happens

Consequence

Four restaurants, a new lunch service, and a business that stays Meera's

Marigold stays at four restaurants and uses its kitchens' quiet mornings to cook weekday lunches for offices in Pune, delivered in its own vans. The service sells ₹6m in year two, rising to ₹9m. After food and packaging at 36% and ₹1.2m of delivery and selling costs, it adds ₹2.64m, lifting profit to ₹15.42m in year two and ₹17.34m by year four. Outside Pune, Marigold is no better known than it was.

How people react

  • Meera Rao Mixed Keeps control and quality; her aim of three cities has not moved.
  • Sunil Patil, head chef Positive Sees his proposal adopted.
  • Staff Mixed Stability, and fewer chances of promotion.
  • Customers Positive Keep the restaurants they know.

Risks now

  • Tiffin Lane, the mall sites and the franchise inquirers may go to a competitor.
  • A business that does not grow may lose its most ambitious staff to one that does.

The theory behind it

Staying small is a strategic choice, not a failure to grow. It avoids diseconomies of scale and protects quality and control. The lunch service is growth too, but internal and small.

The figures after this choice
Restaurants under the Marigold name by year two 4 No change
Marigold's own recurring revenue, year two ₹102m +₹6m on now
Founder's share of profit after interest, year two ₹15.42m +₹2.64m on now
Founder's share of profit after interest, year four ₹17.34m +₹4.56m on now
New money committed ₹3m +₹3m on now
New borrowing ₹0m No change
Founder's ownership of Marigold 100% No change
Control of the kitchens Full No change
Risk to the brand and the food Low No change
Optional. Saved on this device only.

Section 03: Make it work

How will you implement the route you chose?

Implementation decides whether the forecast happens. Each choice changes the risk, the profit or both.

How will you implement the route you chose?
See what happens

Outcome

Mumbai finds its feet faster, under a manager the kitchens did not choose

The new area manager's systems help the Mumbai restaurants reach 90% of mature sales in year two instead of 85%, worth about ₹0.88m more profit for each restaurant. Profit in year two is ₹11.81m instead of ₹9.47m. The extra salary is still paid when the restaurants mature, so profit by year four is ₹18.88m rather than ₹20.08m. Two of Meera's longest-serving supervisors, passed over for the job, start looking elsewhere.

How people react

  • Supervisors Negative Feel overlooked.
  • Meera Rao Mixed Pleased with the speed, uneasy about the culture.

Risks now

  • An outsider's methods may not fit kitchens built on the head chef's training.

The theory behind it

Recruiting from outside brings skills quickly; promoting from inside motivates and keeps the culture. A growth decision contains human resource decisions.

The figures after this choice
Founder's share of profit after interest, year two ₹11.81m −₹0.97m on now
Founder's share of profit after interest, year four ₹18.88m +₹6.10m on now
Risk to the brand and the food Medium Was Low on now
See what happens

Outcome

Slower openings, and kitchens that taste like Pune

Training slows the start: the Mumbai restaurants reach only 80% of mature sales in year two, so profit falls to ₹5.54m, the lowest of any path. But the food is right from the first day, two supervisors become managers, and by year four profit reaches ₹19.68m, more than with the outside hire, because there is no premium salary to pay.

How people react

  • Senior cooks Positive Promoted, and proud of it.
  • The bank Mixed Concerned by the slow first year.

Risks now

  • The low year-two profit leaves little margin if anything else goes wrong.

The theory behind it

Internal recruitment preserves culture and motivates staff, at the cost of speed. It also serves the founder's fourth aim.

The figures after this choice
Founder's share of profit after interest, year two ₹5.54m −₹7.24m on now
Founder's share of profit after interest, year four ₹19.68m +₹6.90m on now
Risk to the brand and the food Low No change
See what happens

Outcome

Fewer surprises, thinner profit

Every franchise uses the same sauces and spice blends, made in Marigold's central kitchen, and auditors visit each one every quarter. One franchisee is warned in year three and improves. Franchise sales mature at ₹21m, as forecast. The system costs ₹5.2m a year, so profit is ₹13.76m in year two and ₹15.20m by year four.

How people react

  • Franchisees Mixed Grumble about the audits, and keep their customers.
  • Customers Positive Find the food the same in every city.

Risks now

  • The central kitchen adds debt, and a single point of failure for the whole network.

The theory behind it

A franchisor protects its brand by controlling inputs and inspecting outputs. Control costs money, which is the price of reach without ownership.

The figures after this choice
Founder's share of profit after interest, year two ₹13.76m +₹0.98m on now
Founder's share of profit after interest, year four ₹15.20m +₹2.42m on now
New money committed ₹30m +₹30m on now
New borrowing ₹20m +₹20m on now
Control of the kitchens Low, with audit rights Was Full on now
Risk to the brand and the food Medium Was Low on now
See what happens

Outcome

Year two looks excellent; year three does not

Profit in year two is ₹18.96m. In year three two franchisees fail hygiene inspections and close, a third quietly changes the recipes, and online reviews start to mention "the Marigold that isn't". By year four ten franchises remain, selling ₹18.5m each, and sales in Marigold's own Pune restaurants are 5% lower. Profit by year four is ₹13.12m, barely above today's ₹12.78m.

How people react

  • Customers Negative Some stop trusting the name.
  • Franchisees who closed Negative Lose their investment.

Risks now

  • Damage to a brand lands on every restaurant that carries it, including the ones Marigold owns.

The theory behind it

The benefits of light-touch franchising arrive first and its costs arrive later. Judging the route on year two alone hides that.

The figures after this choice
Restaurants under the Marigold name by year two 16 +12 on now
Founder's share of profit after interest, year two ₹18.96m +₹6.18m on now
Founder's share of profit after interest, year four ₹13.12m +₹0.34m on now
Risk to the brand and the food High Was Low on now
See what happens

Outcome

Four mall restaurants in year two instead of six, on terms Marigold can live with

Sterling agrees after months of negotiation. The delay means only four mall restaurants trade through year two, so Marigold's share of the joint venture's profit is ₹7.71m and its profit is ₹16.69m. The other two open in year three. By year four profit reaches ₹25.50m, as forecast, and Marigold decides what is served.

How people react

  • Sterling Malls Mixed Accepts the terms, and remembers the delay.
  • Meera Rao Positive Has the protection she wanted.

Risks now

  • Six months of negotiation is six months in which a competitor could take the mall sites.

The theory behind it

The terms of a joint venture matter as much as the decision to form one. A veto and an exit right turn shared control into protected control.

The figures after this choice
Founder's share of profit after interest, year two ₹16.69m +₹3.91m on now
Founder's share of profit after interest, year four ₹25.50m +₹12.72m on now
Control of the kitchens Shared, with a veto on menu and brand Was Full on now
Risk to the brand and the food Low No change
See what happens

Outcome

Fast growth, and a menu that is no longer only Marigold's

All six restaurants open on schedule and profit reaches ₹21.05m in year two. In year three Sterling adds cheaper "value meals" to raise footfall, and customers begin to say the mall Marigolds are not the real thing. Sales in Marigold's own restaurants slip by 3%, and profit by year four is ₹23.54m instead of ₹25.50m. The agreement cannot be ended for seven years.

How people react

  • Sterling Malls Positive Gets the footfall it wanted.
  • Meera Rao Negative Cannot change what is served under her name.

Risks now

  • Seven years is a long time to share a brand with a partner whose priorities differ.

The theory behind it

Speed in a joint venture can be bought with control. The cost appears later, in the brand.

The figures after this choice
Founder's share of profit after interest, year two ₹21.05m +₹8.27m on now
Founder's share of profit after interest, year four ₹23.54m +₹10.76m on now
Control of the kitchens Shared, partner controls the malls Was Full on now
Risk to the brand and the food High Was Low on now
See what happens

Outcome

The savings arrive early, and so does the exodus

The purchasing savings arrive within months. But four in ten Tiffin Lane employees leave in the first year, and recruiting and training replacements costs ₹2.5m. Group profit in year two is ₹26.7m, of which Meera's 70% is ₹18.69m. By year four the converted restaurants reach maturity and her share is ₹29.26m, if the new teams hold.

How people react

  • Tiffin Lane staff Negative Many leave rather than adapt to a new culture overnight.
  • Banyan Growth Partners Positive Pleased with the early savings.

Risks now

  • New teams in six restaurants at once, trained in a hurry.

The theory behind it

Rapid integration captures economies of scale sooner and raises the risk of culture clash, a source of diseconomies.

The figures after this choice
Founder's share of profit after interest, year two ₹18.69m +₹5.91m on now
Founder's share of profit after interest, year four ₹29.26m +₹16.48m on now
Risk to the brand and the food High Was Low on now
See what happens

Outcome

A calmer year, and savings that take longer

Most Tiffin Lane staff stay. But with two brands and two menus for a year, food and packaging fall only to 31% of sales, and the six restaurants still trading as Tiffin Lane sell ₹18m each. Group profit in year two is ₹21.16m, of which Meera's share is ₹14.81m. By year four, with the conversions complete, her share reaches ₹29.26m.

How people react

  • Tiffin Lane staff Positive Have time to learn the Marigold way.
  • Banyan Growth Partners Mixed Impatient with the slower savings.

Risks now

  • Running two brands for a year confuses suppliers and customers.

The theory behind it

Phased integration trades early savings for a lower risk of losing the people who make the restaurants work.

The figures after this choice
Founder's share of profit after interest, year two ₹14.81m +₹2.03m on now
Founder's share of profit after interest, year four ₹29.26m +₹16.48m on now
Risk to the brand and the food Medium Was Low on now
See what happens

Outcome

Fewer leavers, and the same four restaurants

Staff turnover falls from 18% towards 11% over two years, and the restaurants keep their best cooks. Profit is ₹14.46m in year two and ₹16.38m by year four, about ₹1m a year below the plain version of this route. The business is no bigger, but it is harder to copy.

How people react

  • Cooks Positive Better paid and better trained.
  • Meera Rao Mixed Proud of the kitchens, and still not in three cities.

Risks now

  • The pay rise is permanent; the competitive advantage it buys has to keep paying for it.

The theory behind it

Investing in people can protect the source of a competitive advantage, here the cooking, even when it lowers profit in the short run.

The figures after this choice
Founder's share of profit after interest, year two ₹14.46m +₹1.68m on now
Founder's share of profit after interest, year four ₹16.38m +₹3.60m on now
Risk to the brand and the food Low No change
See what happens

Outcome

A small step towards a second city, taken when the business is ready

The lunch service runs as planned and the cash reserve grows. In year three a single Mumbai restaurant opens, paid for from cash, with ₹0.5m a year of extra management cost. By year four it reaches 85% of mature sales and earns ₹1.23m, so profit is ₹18.07m. Meera now has evidence of how Marigold does in Mumbai before she decides anything bigger.

How people react

  • Meera Rao Positive Moves towards her second aim without risking the first.
  • Staff Positive See a first promotion to a new city.

Risks now

  • Opportunities that will not wait, such as Tiffin Lane, are given up.

The theory behind it

Sequencing a decision keeps options open. A small test buys evidence before a large, hard-to-reverse commitment.

The figures after this choice
Founder's share of profit after interest, year two ₹15.42m +₹2.64m on now
Founder's share of profit after interest, year four ₹18.07m +₹5.29m on now
Risk to the brand and the food Low No change
Optional. Saved on this device only.

Section 04: Debrief

The debrief opens when you have made every decision.

The trade-offs

  • Speed against control. The routes that grow fastest, franchising and the acquisition, are the ones that loosen control of the kitchen, which is Marigold's advantage.
  • This year against later years. Organic growth lowers profit in year two and raises it by year four; light-touch franchising does the reverse.
  • Money against ownership. The acquisition is paid for with 30% of the company. Meera keeps a majority, but gains a partner who expects to sell.
  • Reach against the aims. Only the joint venture and the acquisition reach three cities quickly, and both strain the aim of keeping control.

The evidence that matters

  • Exhibit 7. Four of forty-one franchise inquirers could fund a restaurant. A plan for twelve franchises in two years depends on people the evidence does not show.
  • Exhibits 4 and 5. Tiffin Lane's rating and staff turnover. Buying the restaurants means buying the reasons they underperform.
  • Exhibit 6. The founder's aims. A recommendation that ignores them will not be carried out, however good its numbers.

What would change your mind?

  • If Mumbai sales in the first year were 30% below forecast, which route would you choose?
  • If Banyan offered the same money for 20% of Marigold instead of 30%, would the acquisition become the best route?
  • If Sterling Malls offered control of the menu and an exit after three years, what would change?

Misconceptions this tests

  • Counting franchisees' sales (₹228m in year two) as Marigold's revenue. Marigold's revenue from franchising is the royalties and fees.
  • Assuming an acquisition brings economies of scale automatically. The purchasing savings depend on integrating menus, suppliers and systems, and integration can raise costs before it lowers them.
  • Treating the route with the highest forecast profit as the answer, without asking whose profit it is and what was given up for it.

Every first decision, side by side

The figures straight after each first-round choice, before any later decision.

Measure Now Organic growth in MumbaiFranchisingJoint venture with Sterling MallsAcquire Tiffin LaneStay focused
Restaurants under the Marigold name by year two 4 81610104
Marigold's own recurring revenue, year two ₹96m ₹184.40m₹109.68m₹96m₹216m₹102m
Founder's share of profit after interest, year two ₹12.78m ₹9.47m₹18.96m₹21.05m₹20.44m₹15.42m
Founder's share of profit after interest, year four ₹12.78m ₹20.08m₹20.40m₹25.50m₹29.26m₹17.34m
New money committed ₹0m ₹72m₹10m₹45m₹126m₹3m
New borrowing ₹0m ₹52m₹0m₹30m₹0m₹0m
Founder's ownership of Marigold 100% 100%100%100%70%100%
Control of the kitchens Full FullLowSharedFullFull
Risk to the brand and the food Low MediumHighMediumHighLow

Exam link

This is the reasoning a Discuss or Recommend question on growth asks for: a route chosen against the organization's own aims, with the trade-offs weighed and the conditions stated. Try the practice questions for 1.5 in the Assessment Centre.