Decision Room
Marigold Kitchens: which way to grow?
Five routes, four aims, and a decision that changes what the business is.
The Decision Room could not start. You can still read every choice and what follows from it below.
- Situation
- Decision
- Consequence
- Implementation
- Outcome
- Debrief
Section 01: The situation
You are advising Meera Rao, the founder. She wants a recommendation she can defend to her bank, a possible investor and her own staff.
Marigold Kitchens has four profitable restaurants in Pune, ₹20m of cash and five ways forward. Read the evidence, choose a route, and then decide how to make it work. The forecasts below each choice come from the finance manager's model; what happens after that is one simulation of how the route might go. Commit before you read the debrief.
The evidence pack: 5 exhibits
Restaurant economics, last financial year (one restaurant)
Source: Simulated data From the case file: Marigold Kitchens| Item | ₹m a year | Share of revenue (%) |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue | 24.00 | 100 |
| Food and packaging | 7.68 | 32 |
| Staff | 6.00 | 25 |
| Rent | 3.60 | 15 |
| Utilities and maintenance | 1.20 | 5 |
| Other costs | 1.20 | 5 |
| Restaurant profit | 4.32 | 18 |
Food and packaging rise and fall with sales. Staff, rent, utilities and other costs do not change with the number of meals within a restaurant's normal range.
The five routes, as forecast by the finance manager
Source: Simulated data From the case file: Marigold Kitchens| Route | What it involves | Money needed and where it comes from | Key terms and forecast assumptions |
|---|---|---|---|
| Organic growth | Four company-owned restaurants in Mumbai, opened over two years. | ₹72m (₹18m a restaurant). ₹20m from cash and a ₹52m bank loan at 11% a year. | Mumbai rent ₹5.4m a year; other restaurant costs as in Pune. Sales ₹26m a restaurant when mature, about 85% of that in the first full year. Central costs rise to ₹7.0m for an area manager and training. |
| Franchising | Twelve franchised restaurants over two years, mainly in Mumbai and Bengaluru. | ₹10m from cash for a training academy, an operations manual and franchise recruitment. | Fee ₹1.5m a franchise, once. Royalty 6% of the franchisee's sales; marketing levy 2%, spent on marketing for the whole network. Franchisees' sales about ₹19m each in year two, ₹21m when mature. Support team ₹6.0m a year; academy ₹1.5m a year. |
| Joint venture | A company owned 50:50 with Sterling Malls, opening six restaurants in its malls in Pune, Mumbai and Bengaluru. | ₹45m from each partner (₹15m a restaurant). Marigold's share from ₹15m of cash and a ₹30m loan at 11%. | Rent 15% of sales. Staff ₹6.6m and utilities and other costs ₹2.4m a restaurant. Sales ₹25.2m a restaurant in year two, ₹28m when mature. Joint venture overheads ₹2.0m a year; Marigold's oversight ₹0.5m a year. |
| Acquisition | Buy Tiffin Lane's nine restaurants. Convert the six best to the Marigold format; close the three weakest. | ₹120m from Banyan Growth Partners for 30% of Marigold (₹96m price, ₹24m for conversions). Closures ₹6m from cash, once. | Buying for the whole group lowers food and packaging to 30% of sales. Converted restaurants sell ₹20m in year two and ₹23m when mature, with costs of ₹11m a year each besides food. Central costs ₹8.0m a year. |
| Stay focused | Stay at four restaurants and add a weekday lunch service for offices in Pune, cooked in the existing kitchens. | ₹3m from cash for vans and equipment. | Sales ₹6m in year two, ₹9m when mature. Food and packaging 36% of sales; delivery and selling costs ₹1.2m a year. |
Tiffin Lane, last financial year
Source: Simulated data From the case file: Marigold Kitchens| Item | One restaurant, ₹m | Nine restaurants, ₹m |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue | 16.00 | 144.00 |
| Food and packaging (34% of sales) | 5.44 | 48.96 |
| Other restaurant costs | 9.80 | 88.20 |
| Restaurant profit | 0.76 | 6.84 |
| Central costs | 3.00 | |
| Operating profit | 3.84 |
The asking price is ₹96m, twenty-five times Tiffin Lane's operating profit.
Four things matter to me. The food stays as good as it is now: people come back because it tastes like home. Marigold should be known in at least three cities within five years. I will not give up control of what I built. And the people who grew with us should grow with the business.
Who wants a Marigold franchise?
Source: Simulated data From the case file: Marigold Kitchens- Franchise inquiries
- 41 In the last twelve months
- From Mumbai
- 17
- From Bengaluru
- 9
- From other cities
- 15
- With restaurant experience
- 9
- Able to fund a restaurant without a loan
- 4 A franchised restaurant costs its owner about ₹16m to open
The board pack
Source: Simulated data| Measure | Now | After your decisions | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Restaurants under the Marigold name by year two | 4 | Not decided | |
| Marigold's own recurring revenue, year twoFranchisees' and the joint venture's sales are not Marigold's revenue | ₹96m | Not decided | |
| Founder's share of profit after interest, year two | ₹12.78m | Not decided | |
| Founder's share of profit after interest, year four | ₹12.78m | Not decided | |
| New money committed | ₹0m | Not decided | |
| New borrowing | ₹0m | Not decided | |
| Founder's ownership of Marigold | 100% | Not decided | |
| Control of the kitchens | Full | Not decided | |
| Risk to the brand and the food | Low | Not decided |
Section 02: Choose the route
Which route do you recommend to Meera?
Before you choose, decide which of the four aims matters most to you, and why. You will be asked about it in the debrief.
Section 03: Make it work
Commit your first decision to unlock this one.
How will you implement the route you chose?
Implementation decides whether the forecast happens. Each choice changes the risk, the profit or both.
Section 04: Debrief
The debrief opens when you have made every decision.
The trade-offs
- Speed against control. The routes that grow fastest, franchising and the acquisition, are the ones that loosen control of the kitchen, which is Marigold's advantage.
- This year against later years. Organic growth lowers profit in year two and raises it by year four; light-touch franchising does the reverse.
- Money against ownership. The acquisition is paid for with 30% of the company. Meera keeps a majority, but gains a partner who expects to sell.
- Reach against the aims. Only the joint venture and the acquisition reach three cities quickly, and both strain the aim of keeping control.
The evidence that matters
- Exhibit 7. Four of forty-one franchise inquirers could fund a restaurant. A plan for twelve franchises in two years depends on people the evidence does not show.
- Exhibits 4 and 5. Tiffin Lane's rating and staff turnover. Buying the restaurants means buying the reasons they underperform.
- Exhibit 6. The founder's aims. A recommendation that ignores them will not be carried out, however good its numbers.
What would change your mind?
- If Mumbai sales in the first year were 30% below forecast, which route would you choose?
- If Banyan offered the same money for 20% of Marigold instead of 30%, would the acquisition become the best route?
- If Sterling Malls offered control of the menu and an exit after three years, what would change?
Misconceptions this tests
- Counting franchisees' sales (₹228m in year two) as Marigold's revenue. Marigold's revenue from franchising is the royalties and fees.
- Assuming an acquisition brings economies of scale automatically. The purchasing savings depend on integrating menus, suppliers and systems, and integration can raise costs before it lowers them.
- Treating the route with the highest forecast profit as the answer, without asking whose profit it is and what was given up for it.
Every first decision, side by side
The figures straight after each first-round choice, before any later decision.
| Measure | Now | Organic growth in Mumbai | Franchising | Joint venture with Sterling Malls | Acquire Tiffin Lane | Stay focused |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Restaurants under the Marigold name by year two | 4 | 8 | 16 | 10 | 10 | 4 |
| Marigold's own recurring revenue, year two | ₹96m | ₹184.40m | ₹109.68m | ₹96m | ₹216m | ₹102m |
| Founder's share of profit after interest, year two | ₹12.78m | ₹9.47m | ₹18.96m | ₹21.05m | ₹20.44m | ₹15.42m |
| Founder's share of profit after interest, year four | ₹12.78m | ₹20.08m | ₹20.40m | ₹25.50m | ₹29.26m | ₹17.34m |
| New money committed | ₹0m | ₹72m | ₹10m | ₹45m | ₹126m | ₹3m |
| New borrowing | ₹0m | ₹52m | ₹0m | ₹30m | ₹0m | ₹0m |
| Founder's ownership of Marigold | 100% | 100% | 100% | 100% | 70% | 100% |
| Control of the kitchens | Full | Full | Low | Shared | Full | Full |
| Risk to the brand and the food | Low | Medium | High | Medium | High | Low |
Exam link
This is the reasoning a Discuss or Recommend question on growth asks for: a route chosen against the organization's own aims, with the trade-offs weighed and the conditions stated. Try the practice questions for 1.5 in the Assessment Centre.
Arjun Agrawal | The Business Brief, https://the-business-brief-dun.vercel.app/decision-room/marigold-growth/. Original teaching material, not an IB publication. The organizations in the teaching cases are fictional unless a case says otherwise.