Entrepreneurship and Innovation LabTool 03 of 06

Does each customer pay back what it costs to win them?

A start-up can grow quickly and still be getting poorer with every customer it wins. Unit economics asks the question one customer at a time: what does it cost to win them, what do they contribute each month, how long do they stay, and is the contribution over that time worth the cost of winning them?

Back to 5.5 Break-even analysis Also for 3.8 Investment appraisal and 4.5 The seven Ps of the marketing mix

Tool
Unit economics calculator
IB status
Enrichment; builds on 5.5, 3.8, 4.5
Example
Refill Round, fictional; figures simulated
Saved
On this device only

Section 01: Unit economics calculator

Source: Enrichment Source: Simulated data

The example. Refill Round, the fictional subscription refill service, spent $1,800 last month on social media advertising and referral credits and won 45 new subscribers. A box costs $24 a month and $9.10 to fill, wash and deliver. From a pilot, the founders estimate that 8% of subscribers cancel each month. All figures are simulated.

Without JavaScript the figures below are for Refill Round's example, and changing an input does not recalculate them. Every working is shown in full.

Inputs
Advertising, referral rewards, events, sales commission.
Count only customers won in the period the spending covers.
Materials, delivery, payment fees: costs that rise with each customer. Leave out rent and salaries.
From a pilot if you have one; otherwise a cautious estimate.
Stops a very low churn rate promising customers for decades.
Try a scenario

Each scenario changes one input of Refill Round's example.

Results

Customer acquisition cost
$40.00to win one customer
Contribution per customer
$14.90a month, 62.1% of revenue
Expected lifetime
12.5 months1 ÷ monthly churn
Lifetime value
$186.25contribution over the lifetime
LTV to CAC
4.7 to 1Above the 3 to 1 rule of thumb
CAC payback
2.7 monthsmonths of contribution to earn it back

Reading. Winning a customer costs $40.00. Each one contributes $14.90 a month and stays about 12.5 months, so a customer is worth $186.25 in contribution: 4.7 times the cost of winning them. The acquisition cost is earned back in 2.7 months.

Implication. On these figures, spending to win customers pays. The weakest input is usually churn: a new business rarely has a year of data on how long customers stay, so test how the ratio changes if churn is higher than hoped.

Your inputs are kept on this device only.

Contribution from one customer against the cost of winning themOne customer who stays the expected lifetime contributes $14.90 a month. Winning them cost $40.00. The cost of winning the customer is earned back after 2.7 months; by the time the customer leaves, after about 12.5 months, they have contributed $186.25.$0$50$100$150$20003691215Months since the customer joinedContribution so far, $Cost to win the customer $40.00Leaves after 12.5 months: $186.25Paid back after 2.7 months
One customer who stays the expected lifetime: contribution so far (blue line) against the cost of winning them (red dashed line). Redrawn from the inputs above.
The chart's figures as a table
Contribution from one customer so far, and the position after the cost of winning them, month by month
MonthContribution so farAfter the acquisition cost
0$0.00−$40.00
1$14.90−$25.10
2$29.80−$10.20
3$44.70$4.70
4$59.60$19.60
5$74.50$34.50
6$89.40$49.40
7$104.30$64.30
8$119.20$79.20
9$134.10$94.10
10$149.00$109.00
11$163.90$123.90
12$178.80$138.80
13$186.25$146.25

The workings

Customer acquisition cost
Given
  • Marketing and sales spending: $1,800
  • New customers won: 45
Formula
Customer acquisition cost (CAC) = marketing and sales spending ÷ new customers won
Substitution
= $1,800 ÷ 45
Working
1,800 ÷ 45 = 40.00
Answer
$40.00

A standard start-up measure. It is not on the IB formula list, so treat it as enrichment.

Unit
$ per new customer
Interpretation
On average, each new customer cost $40.00 in marketing and selling.
Business implication
Compare it with what a customer is worth, not with the price: a customer who pays little each month can still be worth winning if they stay.
Contribution per customer
Given
  • Average revenue per customer per month: $24
  • Variable cost of serving a customer for a month: $9.10
Formula
Contribution per customer per month = revenue per customer − variable cost per customer
Substitution
= $24 − $9.10
Working
24 − 9.10 = 14.90
As a share of revenue: 14.90 ÷ 24 × 100 = 62.1%
Answer
$14.90

The IB’s contribution per unit (5.5), with one customer for one month as the unit.

Unit
$ per customer per month
Interpretation
Each customer adds $14.90 a month towards the fixed costs and profit.
Business implication
Every month a customer stays adds this much; keeping customers is worth as much as winning them.
Expected lifetime
Given
  • Monthly churn: 8%
  • Cap on lifetime: 36 months
Formula
Expected lifetime = 1 ÷ monthly churn rate (as a decimal), up to the cap
Substitution
= 1 ÷ 0.0800
Working
1 ÷ 0.0800 = 12.50 months
Answer
12.5 months

Assumes the same share of customers leaves every month.

Unit
months a customer stays, on average
Interpretation
A customer stays about 12.5 months on average.
Business implication
Churn is the input a new business knows least about. Measure it in a pilot before relying on it.
Lifetime value
Given
  • Contribution per customer per month: $14.90
  • Expected lifetime: 12.50 months
Formula
Lifetime value (LTV) = contribution per customer per month × expected lifetime in months
Substitution
= $14.90 × 12.50
Working
14.90 × 12.50 = 186.25
Answer
$186.25

Measured on contribution, not revenue: revenue × lifetime would give $300.00, which ignores the cost of serving the customer. Undiscounted.

Unit
$ of contribution per customer
Interpretation
Over that time, a customer is worth $186.25 in contribution.
Business implication
This is the most the business could spend to win a customer and still break even on them, before any fixed costs.
LTV to CAC ratio
Given
  • Lifetime value: $186.25
  • Customer acquisition cost: $40.00
Formula
LTV to CAC ratio = lifetime value ÷ customer acquisition cost
Substitution
= $186.25 ÷ $40.00
Working
186.25 ÷ 40.00 = 4.66
Answer
4.7 to 1

Many investors quote 3 to 1 as a healthy ratio for a subscription business: a rule of thumb, not a law.

Unit
contribution earned for each unit of currency spent winning a customer
Interpretation
Each customer returns 4.7 times what it cost to win them.
Business implication
The ratio says winning customers pays eventually; it says nothing about fixed costs or about when the cash arrives.
CAC payback period
Given
  • Customer acquisition cost: $40.00
  • Contribution per customer per month: $14.90
Formula
CAC payback period = customer acquisition cost ÷ contribution per customer per month
Substitution
= $40.00 ÷ $14.90
Working
40.00 ÷ 14.90 = 2.68 months
Answer
2.7 months

The payback idea of investment appraisal (3.8) applied to one customer. Under 12 months is a commonly quoted rule of thumb.

Unit
months
Interpretation
The cost of winning a customer is earned back after 2.7 months of their contribution.
Business implication
The shorter the payback, the less cash growth ties up: the business recovers its spending quickly and can spend it again.

Section 02: How to use it, and what to watch for

Steps

  1. Enter what was spent on marketing and selling in a period, and the new customers it won in the same period.
  2. Enter the average revenue per customer per month and the variable cost of serving a customer for a month. Leave out fixed costs such as rent.
  3. Enter the share of customers who leave each month, and the longest lifetime you are prepared to count.
  4. Read the figures and the chart, then try the scenarios to see which input the conclusion depends on.

Section 03: What the terms mean here

Customer acquisition cost (CAC)

What it costs to win one new customer: marketing and sales spending in a period divided by the new customers won in that period.

Contribution per customer

What a customer pays each month minus the variable cost of serving them: the IB’s contribution per unit with a customer-month as the unit.

Churn rate

The share of customers who leave in a period, usually a month.

Expected lifetime

How long a customer stays on average. With a constant monthly churn rate it is 1 ÷ churn: 8% churn gives 12.5 months.

Lifetime value (LTV)

The total contribution a customer is expected to bring over the time they stay.

LTV to CAC ratio

Lifetime value divided by acquisition cost. Below 1, each customer loses money; many investors look for 3 or more in a subscription business, as a rule of thumb.

CAC payback period

The months of contribution needed to earn back the cost of winning a customer.

Section 04: Where it sits in the IB course

Customer acquisition cost, lifetime value and their ratio are standard start-up measures, but none is in the guide or on its formula list, so this tool is enrichment. Two of its ideas are IB content in another form: contribution per customer is the contribution per unit of break-even analysis (5.5) with a customer-month as the unit, and CAC payback asks the payback question of investment appraisal (3.8) about the cost of winning one customer.

The ideas behind the tool are in the briefing Pricing a start-up and its unit economics.