Frameworks ยท Measuring performance

The balanced scorecard

A way to measure performance against a strategy from four perspectives, financial, customer, internal processes, and learning and growth, rather than by profit alone.

Enrichment: beyond the IB course UndergraduateMBAProfessional

Section 01: The framework at a glance

The balanced scorecardFour perspectives around the vision and strategy, each with its own objectives and measures. Financial: how the business should appear to its owners, measured for example by return on capital employed and revenue growth. Customer: how customers should see it, measured by the repeat purchase rate and a satisfaction score. Internal processes: which processes it must excel at, measured by order lead time and the defect rate. Learning and growth: how its people and systems must develop, measured by training hours per employee and staff retention. Read upwards for cause and effect: people and systems improve processes, which win customers, which deliver the financial results.FinancialTo succeed financially, how should weappear to our owners?EXAMPLE MEASURESReturn on capital employed; revenue growthCustomerTo achieve our vision, how shouldcustomers see us?EXAMPLE MEASURESRepeat purchase rate; customersatisfaction scoreInternal processesTo satisfy customers, whichprocesses must we excel at?EXAMPLE MEASURESOrder lead time; defect rateLearning and growthTo keep improving, how must our people andsystems develop?EXAMPLE MEASURESTraining hours per employee; staffretentionVision and strategyRead upwards for cause and effect: people and systems improve processes, which win customers, which deliver the financial results.
The balanced scorecardFour perspectives around the vision and strategy, each with its own objectives and measures. Financial: how the business should appear to its owners, measured for example by return on capital employed and revenue growth. Customer: how customers should see it, measured by the repeat purchase rate and a satisfaction score. Internal processes: which processes it must excel at, measured by order lead time and the defect rate. Learning and growth: how its people and systems must develop, measured by training hours per employee and staff retention. Read upwards for cause and effect: people and systems improve processes, which win customers, which deliver the financial results.Vision and strategyEach perspective sets objectivesand measures for itFinancialTo succeed financially, how shouldwe appear to our owners? Measures:Return on capital employed; revenuegrowth.CustomerTo achieve our vision, how shouldcustomers see us? Measures: Repeatpurchase rate; customersatisfaction score.Internal processesTo satisfy customers, whichprocesses must we excel at?Measures: Order lead time; defectrate.Learning and growthTo keep improving, how must ourpeople and systems develop?Measures: Training hours peremployee; staff retention.Read upwards for cause and effect:people and systems improve processes,which win customers, which deliver thefinancial results.

The balanced scorecard Four perspectives on performance, linked to the strategy.
Text description

Four perspectives around the vision and strategy, each with its own objectives and measures. Financial: how the business should appear to its owners, measured for example by return on capital employed and revenue growth. Customer: how customers should see it, measured by the repeat purchase rate and a satisfaction score. Internal processes: which processes it must excel at, measured by order lead time and the defect rate. Learning and growth: how its people and systems must develop, measured by training hours per employee and staff retention. Read upwards for cause and effect: people and systems improve processes, which win customers, which deliver the financial results.

Section 02: What it is, and what it is for

Financial results show how a business has done, but they arrive late and say little about why. The balanced scorecard adds three more perspectives. The customer perspective asks how customers see the business; the internal process perspective asks which processes it must excel at; and the learning and growth perspective asks whether its people, systems and culture can keep improving.

Each perspective has a few objectives, measures, targets and initiatives, all derived from the strategy. The perspectives are linked by cause and effect, often drawn as a strategy map: skilled, motivated people and good systems improve processes, better processes win and keep customers, and loyal customers produce the financial results. Balance means covering all four, and mixing leading measures that predict with lagging measures that confirm.

What it is for

To translate a strategy into a small set of measures that managers can track, so that short-term financial pressure does not crowd out the things that build long-term success, such as training, quality and customer loyalty.

Section 03: How it is built

The parts of the framework, and what each one holds.

Financial perspective
How the strategy should show in the accounts and to the owners: measures such as revenue growth, profit margin, cost per unit or return on capital employed.
Customer perspective
How the organization must look to the customers it targets: satisfaction, retention, share of the target segment, complaints or delivery on time.
Internal process perspective
The few processes it must excel at to deliver the customer and financial results: cycle times, defect rates, waiting times or the share of products launched on schedule.
Learning and growth perspective
The people, systems and culture the processes depend on: skills, training, staff turnover, information systems and engagement.
The chain of cause and effect
The scorecard's logic: learning and growth improve the processes, better processes win and keep customers, and customers drive the financial results. Each link is a claim to be tested, not a fact.
Objectives, measures, targets and initiatives
For each perspective, a few objectives; for each objective, one measure with a definition and a target; and the initiatives that should move it, each with an owner.

Section 04: When to use it

The business situations it suits, and where another tool will serve better.

It suits

  • Turning an agreed strategy into a handful of measures people can act on, before targets are set for the year.
  • Organizations whose financial results lag months behind the work that produces them, such as hospitals, schools or software firms, where training or new processes take time to show.
  • Correcting a reporting system that tracks only profit or only activity, and so rewards short-term cuts.

Look elsewhere when

  • A start-up still searching for its business model, whose strategy will change before the measures settle.
  • A one-off decision, such as whether to accept an order or enter a market: the scorecard monitors a strategy rather than choosing one.

Section 05: How to use it, step by step

  1. Start from the vision and strategy: what the organization is trying to achieve, and how.
  2. Set two or three strategic objectives in each of the four perspectives.
  3. Choose a measure for each objective, with a clear definition and data source, and a target.
  4. Link the objectives in a chain of cause and effect from learning and growth to financial results, and check the chain makes sense.
  5. Name the initiatives that will move each measure, and who owns them.
  6. Review the scorecard regularly, and change measures that encourage the wrong behaviour.

Section 06: Applied: Brookfield's first scorecard

Fictional business

Brookfield Community Hospital, a fictional hospital whose strategy is to cut waiting times without raising costs, builds a scorecard with one measure in each perspective to start:

  • Financial: cost per patient treated, against last year's.
  • Customer: the share of patients who rate their care as good or very good.
  • Internal processes: the average wait from referral to treatment.
  • Learning and growth: training hours per member of staff in the new booking system.

What it showed

The scorecard shows the chain the strategy relies on: training in the new system should cut waiting times, which should raise patient ratings without extra cost. When waiting times fall in two wards but not a third, the training measure shows the third ward had not yet been trained, which points the board to the cause rather than the symptom.

Section 07: Reading the result

How to interpret what it shows, and what that does and does not justify deciding.

Read a scorecard across and down. Across: are the measures in each perspective moving towards their targets? Down: does the chain hold, so that the learning and process measures that improved are followed, some months later, by the customer and financial measures they were meant to move?

A lagging financial measure with improving leading measures may simply need time. Leading measures that improve for a long period while results stay flat suggest that the strategy's assumed links are wrong. A measure that hits its target while the measure above it stalls is a warning that people may be managing the number rather than the work.

What it can justify deciding

  • Deciding where to look when results fall short: the scorecard points to the perspective, and the link in the chain, where the strategy is breaking down.
  • Replacing a measure that encourages the wrong behaviour, or an initiative that has not moved its measure after a fair trial.
  • Revisiting the strategy when a link it assumed, such as training shortening waiting times, turns out not to hold.

What it does not justify on its own

  • Judging a person or a department on one measure taken out of the chain.
  • Concluding that the strategy is right because every measure is on target: the measures test the strategy only if they were chosen to test its assumptions.
  • Adding a measure for everything; a scorecard of forty measures directs attention to none of them.

Section 08: Strengths and limits

Why it helps

  • It links measures to strategy, so managers track what matters rather than what is easy to count.
  • It balances financial results with the drivers of future performance, which discourages short-termism.
  • The chain of cause and effect makes the strategy's assumptions explicit and testable.

Where it falls short

  • Choosing a few good measures is hard; scorecards often swell into long lists that no one uses.
  • The assumed links between perspectives may not hold, and testing them takes time and data.
  • Measures that become targets can be gamed, which distorts behaviour.

Section 09: Common mistakes

Errors often made with it, by students and by managers, and how to avoid each.

  1. Mistake Starting from the measures already collected rather than from the strategy.

    Instead Write the strategic objectives first, then find or build a measure for each, even if that means collecting new data.

  2. Mistake Filling each perspective with as many measures as possible.

    Instead Keep to a few objectives in each perspective, each with one measure, and drop any measure that no decision would follow from.

  3. Mistake Treating the four perspectives as four separate lists.

    Instead Draw the chain of cause and effect between them, and say which measure is expected to move which, and how soon.

  4. Mistake Setting targets with no owner and no initiative.

    Instead Give each measure an owner and name the initiative that should move it; otherwise the scorecard only reports.

Section 10: Apply it

The application mode: the platform's tools that apply this framework, and a worksheet for your own case.

Frameworks structure judgement; they do not produce answers. Each one organizes evidence so that you can see it, test it and argue from it, and the decision, and the reasons for it, remain yours.

No interactive tool on the platform applies the balanced scorecard in full yet, so the worksheet below is its application mode, with the tools that help with parts of it.

For part of it

  • Finance Desk Ratio desk Work the measures of the financial perspective, profitability, liquidity and, at HL, efficiency and gearing, from two years of accounts in the IB layout.
  • Market Studio Marketing campaign planner Practise the discipline every scorecard measure needs: a starting figure, a target, a deadline and a key performance indicator that actually measures the objective.
  • Strategy Studio Strategic fit check Test the learning and growth perspective against the strategy: the fit check rates the capabilities the strategy needs against the ones the organization has.

Your worksheet

Work through the framework part by part for a business you know, then say what the result does and does not justify.

Kept on this device as you type, and nowhere else. Not saved without JavaScript: print the page or copy your answers before you leave.

For example: Are we on track with our strategy, and will our results last?
Who it is, what it sells, to whom, and what has changed.
Part by part

For each part, write what you find for this business and the evidence for it. Leave a part blank only if you can say why it does not apply.

What the framework shows when the parts are read together, and how sure you are of it.
The decision the result supports, what else you would need to know, and what would change your mind.

The Framework Application Lab: choose a framework by the decision you face.

Section 11: Try it

The platform's own exercise. Write your answer, then open the guidance.

Design a balanced scorecard for a school canteen that wants to serve healthier food without losing money. Give one objective and one measure in each of the four perspectives, and explain the chain of cause and effect that links them.

Kept on this device as you type, and nowhere else. Your answer is not saved without JavaScript; copy it before you leave.

Guidance: what a strong answer does
  • Make sure each measure can actually be collected, with a source and a frequency.
  • Include at least one leading measure, such as staff trained in new recipes, as well as lagging ones such as profit.
  • Explain the links in order, from learning and growth through processes and customers to the financial result.
  • Name one way a measure could be gamed, and how you would guard against it.

In the glossary

  • Balanced scorecard Beyond IB A performance management framework that measures an organization against its strategy from four perspectives: financial, customer, internal business processes, and learning and growth.
  • Key performance indicator (KPI) Beyond IB A measure that an organization chooses to track its progress towards an objective that matters to its strategy.
  • Strategic objective A long-term objective for the organization as a whole, set by senior management, that shapes its overall direction.
  • Leading indicator Beyond IB A measure that tends to change before the outcome it predicts, giving managers early warning, such as enquiries before sales or staff engagement before labour turnover.
  • Lagging indicator Beyond IB A measure that records an outcome after it has happened, such as profit, market share or labour turnover, confirming results but too late to change them.

Read with

Compare it with any other framework in the library.

Published works behind it

Cited as bibliographic references in the platform's source register; the explanations on this page are the platform's own.

The explanation, method, example and exercise are the platform's own, written as enrichment beyond the IB course. The business in the example is fictional.