Toolkit
Ansoff matrix
A two-by-two matrix of growth directions, existing or new products in existing or new markets, with the risk each direction usually carries.
Section 01: What it is for
To classify the direction of a growth option and the level of risk that usually comes with it.
- Class
- Decision-making (IB teacher support material, p. 26)
- Suggested units
- Unit 1, Unit 4 (guide, p. 14)
When to use it
- When comparing growth options.
- To show how far an option takes the business from the products and customers it knows.
How to build it
- Draw a two-by-two grid, with products (existing, new) across the top and markets (existing, new) down the side.
- Label the cells. Market penetration is existing products in existing markets; product development is new products in existing markets; market development is existing products in new markets; diversification is new products in new markets.
- Place each option in a cell, with a reason that says what counts as new.
- Note the usual risk, which rises from market penetration to diversification.
- Use the placement to discuss what the business would need in order to succeed.
The evidence it needs
- What the business sells now, and to whom.
- What each option would sell, and to whom.
Section 02: What it shows, and what it hides
- How far an option takes the business from its existing knowledge of products and customers.
- The level of risk usually associated with that distance.
- How to grow. Franchising, a joint venture and an acquisition are methods, and any of them can serve any direction.
- Whether the option is profitable or affordable.
Limitations
- Real options rarely fit one cell neatly, so the placement needs an argument.
- Risk depends on the business's capabilities, not only on the cell.
- It ignores how competitors will respond.
Section 03: Applied: Marigold's routes on the matrix
From the case Marigold Kitchens.
Most of Marigold's options are market development: the same food in new places. Buying Tiffin Lane is partly market penetration, because it raises Marigold's share in Pune. The office lunch service can be argued as product development, market development or related diversification, depending on what you treat as new.
Interaction
Place Marigold's options on the Ansoff matrix
This exercise could not start. Each item's answer is in the "Answer and explanation" section below it.
Choose a direction for each option. Your placements appear on the matrix as you go.
Market penetration
Existing products, existing markets. Lowest risk.
Product development
New products, existing markets.
Market development
Existing products, new markets.
Diversification
New products, new markets. Highest risk.
-
Open company-owned restaurants in Mumbai
The same menu in a new city.
Answer and explanation
Placement: Market development.
An existing product taken to a new market (a new city). Organic growth is the method; market development is the direction.
-
Franchise Marigold in Mumbai and Bengaluru
The same menu, run by franchisees in new cities.
Answer and explanation
Placement: Market development.
Franchising is a method of growth, not a direction. The direction is still an existing product in new markets. Placing "franchising" in the matrix as if it were a strategy is a common error.
-
Open in malls through a joint venture
The same menu, for mall shoppers in three cities.
Answer and explanation
Placement: Market development.
New cities and a new kind of customer, the mall shopper, for the existing product. The joint venture is the method.
-
Buy Tiffin Lane and convert its restaurants
Rival restaurants in Pune and Mumbai, converted to Marigold.
Answer and explanation
Placement: Market penetration. Also arguable: market development.
In Pune, buying a rival raises Marigold's share of a market it already serves: market penetration. The Mumbai restaurants add market development, so the acquisition does both. Say which part your argument is about.
-
A weekday lunch service for offices
Lunches from the existing kitchens, delivered on subscription.
Answer and explanation
Placement: Product development. Also arguable: market development, diversification.
It depends on what you treat as new. If the delivered subscription is a new product for Marigold's existing customers, it is product development. If offices are a new market for food Marigold already sells, it is market development. If both are new, it is related diversification. Any of the three can be argued; the argument has to say which.
-
Packaged spice blends in supermarkets
Marigold's spice mixes sold in shops.
Answer and explanation
Placement: Diversification. Also arguable: product development.
A new product (a packaged good) in a new market (supermarket shoppers), so diversification, though related to what Marigold knows. Some would argue product development if the buyers are mainly existing customers.
-
A loyalty card for Pune customers
A free dessert after ten visits.
Answer and explanation
Placement: Market penetration.
More sales of the existing product to the existing market. This is the lowest-risk direction in the matrix.
-
A restaurant in Dubai
The same menu for a new country.
Answer and explanation
Placement: Market development.
An existing product in a new, international market. The risk is higher than a new Indian city because the market is less familiar.
Section 04: In the exam
A common tool in questions on growth. Credit comes from a placement with a reason, and from using the matrix's logic of risk in the evaluation.
Common errors
- Placing a method, such as franchising, in the matrix as if it were a direction.
- Treating the risk ranking as a rule rather than a tendency.
- Placing an option without explaining why the product or the market counts as new.
Arjun Agrawal | The Business Brief, https://the-business-brief-dun.vercel.app/toolkit/ansoff-matrix/. Original teaching material, not an IB publication. The organizations in the teaching cases are fictional unless a case says otherwise.
Because four of the five routes are market development, the choice between them is really about method and control, not about direction.