Round 1 of 4 · 2027 · The board chose: Add robotic cells and retrain
A smaller step, and bakers learning to run robots
The cells are ordered and the training starts, but the extra capacity arrives only in 2028. This year the plant is still full and 1.50m loaves of orders go unmet; operating profit is −€475k. Because the bakers who run the cells are the bakers already here, morale holds at 55.
How the decision travelled
- Operations Lost sales +907,811, worse
- People Morale −3, worse Labour turnover +1.7 pts, worse
- Finance Operating profit −€904k, worse Net cash −€837k, worse
- Marketing Brand −6, worse
Marketing
- Revenue
- €11.20m −€783k Down, worse
- Units sold
- 10.1m −74,201 Down, worse
- Market share
- 7.8% −0.2 pts Down, worse
- Brand
- 47 −6 Down, worse
- Demand rose 7.7% to 11.65 million loaves. In the open channels, brand strength took off about 4.4% and market growth added about 2.0%.
- Supermarket contracts took 9 million loaves under contract at €1.06.
- Revenue €11.20m at an average €1.10 a loaf; market share 7.8%.
- Brand strength went from 53.1 to 47.5: disappointed customers −2.6 and defects −3.0.
Operations
- Utilization
- 100.0% No change
- Lost sales
- 1.50m +907,811 Up, worse
- Output per worker
- 161,041 −1,178 Down, worse
- Defect rate
- 7.8% +0.7 pts Up, worse
- Demand of 11.65 million outran productive capacity of 10.15 million: 1.5 million sales were lost. The plant was the limit.
- Normal hours covered 10.49 million loaves; the other 508,321 needed 5,189 hours of overtime, costing €170k.
- Output per worker: 161,041 loaves.
- Defect rate 7.8%: 854,397 loaves scrapped or returned, wasting €470k of inputs.
People
- Workforce
- 63 No change
- Morale
- 55 −3 Down, worse
- Labour turnover
- 16.3% +1.7 pts Up, worse
- Staff costs
- €2.51m +€5.5k Up
- 10 left and were replaced; the workforce ended the year at 63.
- Labour turnover ran at 16.3% a year; recruiting and inducting new starters cost €40k.
- Morale went from 58.3 to 55.5: settling back towards normal +0.6, how the change was received −1.0 and overtime −2.4.
Finance
- Operating profit
- −€475k −€904k Down, worse
- Profit after tax
- −€505k −€844k Down, worse
- Net cash
- €1.50m −€837k Down, worse
- Acid test
- 4.28 −1.35 Down, worse
- Profit before interest and tax −€475k (−4.2% of revenue); after €30k of interest and €0 of tax, profit for the year was −€505k.
- Costs of change in the year: training €120k.
- Net cash went from €2.34m to €1.50m: profit −€505k, depreciation added back +€210k, debtors +€58k, investment −€1.60m and new borrowing +€1m.
- Current ratio 4.58, acid test 4.28, gearing 26.1%.
Sustainability
- Carbon per unit
- 0.24 kg No change
- Emissions
- 2,640 t No change
- Emissions 2,640 tonnes of CO₂e: 0.24 kg for each loaf.
How people reacted
- Production staff Positive See a future in running the new equipment.
- The supermarket buyer Mixed Wants to know whether it is enough for 2028.
- The bank Positive Comfortable with a smaller loan.
The theory behind it
Partial automation keeps people in the process while removing its most repetitive tasks. Training existing staff to run new equipment is a strategy for reducing resistance to change, and a smaller capital cost carries less operating leverage and less risk.
How the model treated this round
- Already agreed: Supermarket contracts: price to €1.06 a loaf.
- Already agreed: Supermarket contracts: volume to 9 million loaves a year.
- Training: €120k this year.
- Morale −1 points at the announcement.
- Borrow €1m at 5.5% a year.
- Invest €1.60m in robotic dividing and packing cells: in use from next year, written off over 8 years.
- Once in use: plant capacity up 2 million loaves a year.
- Once in use: labour time for each loaf down 25%.
- Once in use: underlying defect rate down 1.0 points.
- Once in use: maintenance up €60k a year.