Boardroom · Whether to automate production

Kilbrack Bakery: machines, people and the price of bread

A family bakery must double its output for the supermarkets, and decide whether people or machines will make it.

Fictional company Source: Simulated data 4 rounds, one per year SL and HL

Industry
Bread and bakery products
Location
Kilbrack, a fictional market town in County Limerick, Ireland
Founded
1971
Size
63 production staff, and 22 more in sales, delivery and the office
Ownership
The Hartigan family owns every share; three generations sit on the board.
Figures in
Euro (€)

The question for the board Should a family bakery automate production to win the volume its customers want, and what does it owe the people whose jobs the machines would do?

Section 01: The brief

The company, its position, the people with a stake in it, and the years ahead.

Kilbrack Bakery has baked bread in the same market town since 1971. Seamus and Brigid Hartigan started it with one oven and a van; their granddaughter Niamh Hartigan runs it now, and her father and aunt still sit on the board. It bakes sliced pan, soda bread, wholemeal and seeded loaves for two supermarket chains, and fresher, crustier bread for cafés, hotels and delis across the region. It is the largest employer in Kilbrack.

The bakery is full. Its ovens and lines can make about eleven million loaves a year in two shifts, and for two years demand has run past that. The supermarkets have kept asking for more, and each year the bakery has turned away orders from its own cafés and hotels, its best-paying customers, to keep the contracts it signed.

This autumn the larger supermarket chain renewed its contract: nine million loaves in 2027 and nearly ten million in 2028, at €1.06 a loaf instead of €1.10. The board has agreed to it. What it has not agreed is how the bakery will make that much bread.

The simulation runs from 2027 to 2030, one year a round. You take one seat at the board table. The decisions are the whole board's; your seat decides what you are judged on.

The management challenges

  • Capacity. The plant is at its limit and the new contract needs over a million more loaves a year.
  • Price. The supermarket price has fallen to €1.06 a loaf, and the next tender will push it lower.
  • People. Labour is the largest cost the bakery controls, and the workforce is skilled, loyal and unionized.
  • Quality. Running flat out, the bakery scraps or has rejected 7.1% of what it makes, and the supermarkets have noticed.
  • Energy. Gas ovens make the bakery exposed to energy prices, and its customers have started to ask about carbon.

The stakeholders and what they say

  • Niamh Hartigan and the family board

    Owners and directors · High influence

    A bakery that survives and grows, a fair dividend, and the family's name in the town.

    “My grandparents built this with the town. I want it here in fifty years. That may need machines; it does not need us to forget who works here.”

  • The supermarket buyer

    The largest customer · High influence

    Consistent bread, delivered on time, at a falling price.

    “Kilbrack makes good bread. At the next tender we will compare price, reliability and how many loaves we reject, in that order.”

  • The bakery's union branch

    Employees' representatives · Medium influence

    Jobs, pay and a say in how change happens.

    “Nobody here is against machines. We are against finding out about them from the newspaper.”

  • Production staff

    Employees · Medium influence

    Secure work, fair pay and work they can take pride in.

    “Two years of overtime. We want the help; we want to still have jobs when it arrives.”

  • Cafés, hotels and delis

    Food-service customers · Medium influence

    Fresh, distinctive bread every morning.

    “We buy Kilbrack because it does not taste like factory bread. If it starts to, we will buy elsewhere.”

  • The bank

    Lender · Medium influence

    A loan that is serviced and repaid.

    “We would lend against the line. We would want to see the volume that pays for it.”

What it exercises in the IB course

Capacity utilization, productivity and operating leverage (5.6), lean production and quality (5.3), industrial relations (2.7) and net present value (3.8) are HL only. SL students can play every round; those parts of the debrief are marked HL.

Section 02: The board pack

Every figure here is calculated by the Boardroom's model from Kilbrack Bakery's starting position and its history; the simulation continues from the last column.

Exhibit 1

Key figures at the end of 2026

Source: Simulated data
  • Revenue

    €11.98m

    Change from 2025: −⁠€299k Down, worse

    Sales revenue, 2024 to 2026Sales revenue was €11.55m in 2024 and rose to €11.98m in 2026. It ranged from €11.55m to €12.28m.
  • Operating profit

    €429k

    Change from 2025: −⁠€360k Down, worse

    Profit before interest and tax, 2024 to 2026Profit before interest and tax was €875k in 2024 and fell to €429k in 2026.
  • Net cash

    €2.34m

    Change from 2025: +⁠€396k Up, better

    Net cash (cash less overdraft), 2024 to 2026Net cash (cash less overdraft) was €1.46m in 2024 and rose to €2.34m in 2026.
  • Utilization

    100.0%

    Change from 2025: +⁠0.7 pts Up

    Capacity utilization rate, 2024 to 2026Capacity utilization rate was 91.4% in 2024 and rose to 100.0% in 2026.
  • Output per worker

    162,219loaves per worker

    Change from 2025: −⁠6,716 Down, worse

    Labour productivity, 2024 to 2026Labour productivity was 166,414 in 2024 and fell to 162,219 in 2026. It ranged from 162,219 to 168,935.
  • Defect rate

    7.1%

    Change from 2025: +⁠1.4 pts Up, worse

    Defect rate, 2024 to 2026Defect rate was 4.0% in 2024 and rose to 7.1% in 2026.
  • Morale

    58out of 100

    Change from 2025: +⁠2 Up, better

    Morale, 2024 to 2026Morale was 61 in 2024 and fell to 58 in 2026. It ranged from 56 to 61.
  • Workforce

    63people

    Change from 2025: +⁠2 Up

    Operations workforce, 2024 to 2026Operations workforce was 58 in 2024 and rose to 63 in 2026.
  • Brand

    53out of 100

    Change from 2025: −⁠4 Down, worse

    Brand strength, 2024 to 2026Brand strength was 58 in 2024 and fell to 53 in 2026.
  • Carbon per unit

    0.24 kgCO₂e per loaf

    Change from 2025: No change

    Emissions per unit, 2024 to 2026Emissions per unit held at 0.24 kg.
Each line runs from 2024 to 2026; changes are against 2025. The full figures are in Exhibit 6.
Exhibit 2

Statement of profit or loss

Source: Simulated data
Statement of profit or loss, €000
€000 202420252026
Sales revenue 11,54512,28211,984
Cost of sales 5,5306,0116,050
Gross profit 6,0166,2725,934
Expenses 5,1405,4835,504
of which staff costs 2,1482,4752,500
of which overheads, rent and administration 2,3002,3002,300
of which marketing 150150150
of which depreciation 210210210
of which maintenance and other costs 332348344
Profit before interest and tax 875789429
Interest 303030
Profit before tax 845759399
Tax 12711460
Profit for the period 718645339
Dividends 359323170
Retained profit 359323170
In euro, thousands; figures in brackets are negative. Cost of sales is the materials, energy and other inputs bought for each loaf; all staff costs are in expenses.
Exhibit 3

Statement of financial position

Source: Simulated data
Statement of financial position, €000
€000 Start of 2024End of 2024End of 2025End of 2026
Non-current assets (net book value) 3,0002,7902,5802,370
Current assets
Cash 9001,4641,9452,341
Debtors 1,3111,3181,4071,393
Stock 181182198199
Total current assets 2,3922,9643,5493,933
Total assets 5,3925,7546,1296,303
Current liabilities
Bank overdraft 0000
Trade creditors 603606659663
Total current liabilities 603606659663
Non-current liabilities: loans 600600600600
Net assets 4,1894,5484,8715,040
Equity
Share capital 500500500500
Retained earnings 3,6894,0484,3714,540
Total equity 4,1894,5484,8715,040
In euro, thousands. Net assets equal total equity in every column; the tests check it.
Exhibit 4

Ratios

Source: Simulated data
Ratio 202420252026
Gross profit margin Gross profit margin = (gross profit ÷ sales revenue) × 100 52.1%51.1%49.5%
Profit margin Profit margin = (profit before interest and tax ÷ sales revenue) × 100 7.6%6.4%3.6%
Return on capital employed ROCE = (profit before interest and tax ÷ capital employed) × 100, where capital employed = non-current liabilities + equity 17.0%14.4%7.6%
Current ratio Current ratio = current assets ÷ current liabilities 4.895.395.93
Acid test (quick) ratio Acid test (quick) ratio = (current assets − stock) ÷ current liabilities 4.595.095.63
Stock turnover (days) HL Stock turnover (number of days) = (average stock ÷ cost of sales) × 365, here on closing stock 12 days12 days12 days
Debtor days HL Debtor days = (debtors ÷ total sales revenue) × 365 42 days42 days42 days
Creditor days HL Creditor days = (creditors ÷ cost of sales) × 365 40 days40 days40 days
Gearing ratio HL Gearing ratio = (non-current liabilities ÷ capital employed) × 100, where capital employed = non-current liabilities + equity 11.7%11.0%10.6%

HL The efficiency ratios and gearing are HL only, and are hidden while you are viewing SL content.

The guide's formulas (pp. 64 to 65). Stock days use closing stock.
Exhibit 5

Six measures, 2024 to 2026

Source: Simulated data
The figures behind these charts are in Exhibit 6.
Exhibit 6

Key figures by year

Source: Simulated data
Key figures by year
Measure202420252026
Sales revenue€11.55m€12.28m€11.98m
Average price per unit€1.20€1.19€1.17
Units sold (loaves)9.65m10.3m10.2m
Sales lost for lack of capacity (loaves)00594,185
Market share7.9%8.3%8.0%
Brand strength (out of 100)585753
Productive capacity (loaves)10.6m10.4m10.2m
Capacity utilization rate91.4%99.3%100.0%
Labour productivity (loaves per worker)166,414168,935162,219
Defect rate4.0%5.7%7.1%
Operations workforce (people)586163
Morale (out of 100)615658
Labour turnover (annual rate)13.8%14.6%14.6%
Profit before interest and tax€875k€789k€429k
Profit margin7.6%6.4%3.6%
Profit for the period€718k€645k€339k
Net cash (cash less overdraft)€1.46m€1.94m€2.34m
Loans (non-current liabilities)€600k€600k€600k
Emissions per unit (kg CO₂e per loaf)0.24 kg0.24 kg0.24 kg
Total emissions (tonnes CO₂e)2,413 t2,623 t2,640 t
Exhibit 7

The market in 2026

Source: Simulated data

The figures are simulated. Kilbrack sells into the market for bread made in Ireland for supermarkets and food service, about 120 million loaves a year, growing about 2% a year. Supermarkets buy on price and reliability; cafés and hotels buy on freshness and character. Kilbrack's share is 8.0%.

Seller Share of the market Typical price Position
Kilbrack Bakery (fictional) 8.0% €1.17 Average across its channels
Cairnfield Foods (fictional) 22.0% €0.98 National plant bakery, fully automated, supermarket bread
Contract bakeries for supermarket own brands (fictional) 18.0% €0.92 Low-cost own-label loaves
Ardrigh Artisan (fictional) 4.0% €1.65 Premium sourdough for delis and cafés
All other sellers 48.0% Various Smaller firms
  • Supermarkets are consolidating their suppliers and tendering contracts every three years.
  • Demand for sourdough and seeded bread is growing faster than for sliced pan.
  • Large customers are starting to ask suppliers for figures on carbon emissions.
The whole market: 127.3m loaves a year, growing about 2.0% a year. Shares by volume.
Exhibit 8

What happened before the first decision

Source: Simulated data
  1. 2024 A steady year. The plant runs at just over 90% of its capacity, and the family takes half the profit as dividends, as it always has.
  2. 2025 The supermarket contract grows to 7.6 million loaves. Three bakers join; overtime becomes routine and more loaves are rejected.
  3. 2026 The contract reaches 8.1 million loaves. The plant is at its limit, orders from cafés and hotels are turned away, and pay rises 3%.

Section 03: The simulation

4 rounds, one year each, with an event between rounds that the board does not control.

Take a seat at the table

The decisions belong to the whole board. Your seat decides which measures you watch most closely and what you are judged on at the end. Each director's goals pull a different way; no path through this simulation meets every goal of every director.

Choose your role on the board

Judged on

  • Profit after tax of at least €2.0m over the four years
  • Brand strength of 55 or more in 2030
  • A market share no smaller than in 2026

Judged on

  • Return on capital employed of 15% or more in 2030
  • Gearing of 35% or less in 2030
  • Never go over the overdraft limit

Judged on

  • Brand strength of 60 or more in 2030
  • Grow market share by at least half a point
  • Turn away no more than a million loaves in four years

Judged on

  • A defect rate of 3.5% or less in 2030
  • At least 200,000 loaves per worker in 2030
  • Emissions of 0.2 kg CO₂e per loaf or less in 2030

Judged on

  • At least 60 production jobs in 2030
  • Morale of 55 or more in 2030
  • Labour turnover never above 20% a year

This is the casebook version of the simulation: every round and its options, what can happen between rounds, and one path narrated with the engine's figures. With JavaScript you can take a seat at the board and decide each round yourself.

Round 1 · 2027 How to make more bread

This is a decision for operations.

The renewed contract starts in January: nine million loaves this year, nearly ten million next, at €1.06. The plant cannot make that much and still serve the cafés and hotels. The board must choose how the bakery grows its capacity. Whatever it chooses, the machines take a year to arrive; a night shift could start in weeks.

Already agreed: The supermarket contract for 2027, already signed.

  • Supermarket contracts: price to €1.06 a loaf.
  • Supermarket contracts: volume to 9 million loaves a year.

How will Kilbrack make more bread?

Around the table

  • Chief executive

    This is the biggest decision the family has taken since the second oven. I want the bakery that can win the next tender, and I want to be able to walk down the main street afterwards.

  • Finance director

    The line is the cheapest way to make a loaf once it is running, but it is €4.6m, mostly borrowed, and it is paid for by volume. If we lose the contract, its costs stay. A night shift costs nothing to install and stops costing the day we stop it.

  • Marketing director

    The cafés and hotels pay us €1.45 a loaf and we keep turning them away. Whatever we do should give their bread back to them. And they buy us because we are not a factory.

  • Operations director Leads this decision

    We are scrapping 7.1% of what we make because we run flat out. The line would make a loaf with less than half the labour and far less waste. The cells are a smaller step. The night shift keeps everything as it is, including the waste.

  • HR director

    The line means fewer jobs: perhaps half as many bakers per loaf. If we choose it, we must decide now what we owe the people it replaces. The night shift means hiring twenty people who will work nights, and keeping them.

The options

  1. Install a fully automated line

    A new automated line for mixing, dividing, baking and packing, in use from 2028, financed mostly by an equipment loan.

    What it involves

    • Borrow €3.80m at 5.5% a year.
    • Invest €4.60m in automated bread line: in use from next year, written off over 10 years.
    • Once in use: plant capacity up 5 million loaves a year.
    • Once in use: labour time for each loaf down 55%.
    • Once in use: energy down 15% a loaf.
    • Once in use: emissions for each loaf down 12%.
    • Once in use: underlying defect rate down 2.5 points.
    • Once in use: maintenance up €200k a year.
  2. Add robotic cells and retrain

    Robotic cells for dividing and packing, beside the existing ovens, with training for the bakers who will run them, in use from 2028.

    What it involves

    • Training: €120k this year.
    • Borrow €1m at 5.5% a year.
    • Invest €1.60m in robotic dividing and packing cells: in use from next year, written off over 8 years.
    • Once in use: plant capacity up 2 million loaves a year.
    • Once in use: labour time for each loaf down 25%.
    • Once in use: underlying defect rate down 1.0 points.
    • Once in use: maintenance up €60k a year.
  3. Add a night shift

    Run the ovens through the night with twenty newly hired bakers, a night supervisor and a pay premium for unsocial hours, starting this winter.

    What it involves

    • Plant capacity up 2.5 million loaves a year.
    • Overheads up €120k a year.
    • Hire 20 people.
    • Pay up 1.5%.

What can happen before the next round

If the automated line was chosen

The line is commissioned late

The supplier's engineers arrive three months late, and the line spends its first months being tuned. In 2028 it can run at only part of its rated capacity; the supplier says it will be at full speed in 2029.

  • Plant capacity down 2 million loaves a year.
  • Next year: plant capacity up 2 million loaves a year.

If the robotic cells were chosen

The cells take time to bed in

The robotic cells arrive on time but stop often in their first months while the bakers and the supplier learn them. They will lose some of their extra capacity in 2028 and run as planned in 2029.

  • Plant capacity down 500,000 loaves a year.
  • Next year: plant capacity up 500,000 loaves a year.

Otherwise

The night shift is hard to staff

Recruiting for nights takes longer than planned, and the new bakers are slower than the old hands. For 2028 the bakery's output per hour is lower than expected; by 2029 the night shift has found its rhythm.

  • Productivity down 4%.
  • Next year: productivity up 4.2%.

Round 2 · 2028 The workforce plan

This is a decision for human resources.

The contract rises to nearly ten million loaves this year. Whatever the bakery chose last year, it now needs a different number of people from the number it employs, and the union has asked for the plan. The board must decide how the workforce changes over the next three years, and how it tells them.

Already agreed: The supermarket contract for 2028, already signed.

  • Supermarket contracts: volume to 9.9 million loaves a year.

What is Kilbrack's workforce plan?

Around the table

  • Chief executive

    We have never made a compulsory redundancy. I do not want to start, and I do not want to pay people to stand beside machines that do their work. I want to hear the honest version of each plan.

  • Finance director

    People with no work to do are the most expensive cost in the bakery. Redundancy pay is a one-off; idle wages are every year. Natural wastage is cheapest in cash and slowest in savings.

  • Marketing director

    The cafés can taste the difference between bread made by people who care and bread made by people who are frightened. Whatever we do, the bread has to stay good.

  • Operations director

    I need the right people, not just the right number: engineers for the machines, bakers for the bread that the machines cannot make, and enough hands to cover the busy weeks.

  • HR director Leads this decision

    In a normal year about one person in seven leaves. If we stop replacing them, numbers fall without anyone being pushed. If we cut, the people who stay will judge us by how we treat the people who go.

The options

  1. Cut to what the bakery needs now

    Make the posts the bakery no longer needs redundant now, with enhanced redundancy pay, and keep replacing leavers in the posts that remain.

    What it involves

    • Depends on earlier choices: With the automated line chosen, 24 posts are no longer needed: 24 redundancies at €22k each.
    • Depends on earlier choices: With the robotic cells chosen, 8 posts are no longer needed: 8 redundancies at €22k each.
    • Depends on earlier choices: With the night shift chosen, only 3 day-shift posts are no longer needed: 3 redundancies at €22k each.
  2. Retrain and redeploy everyone

    Keep every job. Train bakers as machine operators, maintenance technicians and quality checkers, and bring maintenance in house.

    What it involves

    • Underlying defect rate down 0.8 points.
    • Maintenance down €60k a year.
    • Training: €250k this year.
  3. Let numbers fall through leavers

    Freeze recruitment. As people leave or retire they are not replaced, so the workforce shrinks without redundancies.

    What it involves

    • Stop replacing people who leave.

What can happen before the next round

Whatever the board decided

Wheat and energy prices rise

A poor harvest and a cold winter push up the price of flour by 6% and gas by 30%. Every loaf costs more to make, and the supermarket contract price does not move.

  • Materials up 6% a loaf.
  • Energy up 30% a loaf.

Round 3 · 2029 Use the capacity

This is a decision for marketing.

The bakery has more capacity than it had, or a different kind. The marketing director has two offers on the table: a discount chain wants own-label bread at a low price, and the bakery could launch its own premium sourdough range under the Kilbrack name. Or the bakery can hold, raise café prices a little and look after the customers it has.

How should Kilbrack use its capacity?

Around the table

  • Chief executive

    I want the bakery to be known for something, not just to be busy. But I also know what the bank is waiting to see.

  • Finance director

    The discount chain pays only €0.82 a loaf, but it pays for itself if we have spare capacity, because the fixed costs are already paid. If it pushes out café orders at €1.45, it loses money. Sourdough sells at €2.20 and costs more to make.

  • Marketing director Leads this decision

    Sourdough is growing faster than anything else in the market, and the Kilbrack name means something to people who buy it. Own-label bread for a discounter means nothing to anyone.

  • Operations director

    A long run of identical own-label loaves suits a line. Sourdough suits bakers: long fermentation, hand shaping, small batches. If we chose the automated line, sourdough will be awkward to make on it.

  • HR director

    A premium range gives the best bakers something to be proud of. Own-label work is the work people get bored of.

The options

  1. Supply the discount chain

    A contract for 1.8 million own-label loaves a year at €0.82, delivered to the discounter's depots.

    What it involves

    • New: Discount chain own-label, 1.8 million loaves a year at €0.82 under contract, paid in 30 days.
  2. Launch a Kilbrack sourdough range

    A premium sourdough range under the Kilbrack name, sold to delis and independent shops, with €300k a year of marketing.

    What it involves

    • New: Kilbrack sourdough range, 1 million loaves a year at €2.20, paid in 35 days, with an extra €0.30 of cost for each loaf.
    • Marketing spend up €300k a year.
    • Depends on earlier choices: Because the automated line is built for long runs, sourdough has to be shaped and finished by hand around it, adding €0.15 to the cost of each loaf.
  3. Hold, and look after the customers it has

    No new channel. Raise café and hotel prices by 4%, spend a little more on service, and keep spare capacity for the busy weeks.

    What it involves

    • Cafés, hotels and delis: price up 4% a loaf.
    • Marketing spend up €50k a year.

What can happen before the next round

If defect rate is at most 5.0% at the end of the round and sales lost for lack of capacity is at most 300,000 at the end of the round

Kilbrack wins the supermarket tender

The supermarket re-tenders its bread contract. Kilbrack's defect rate of the figure at the time and its record of full deliveries win it the renewal: a tenth more volume from 2030, at a slightly lower price.

  • Supermarket contracts: price to €1.02 a loaf.
  • Supermarket contracts: volume up 10% loaves a year.

Otherwise

Kilbrack loses part of the supermarket contract

The supermarket re-tenders its bread contract and splits it. With a defect rate of the figure at the time, or orders it could not fill, Kilbrack keeps its price but loses 15% of the volume to a rival from 2030.

  • Supermarket contracts: volume down 15% loaves a year.

Round 4 · 2030 The next five years

This is a decision for the chief executive.

The family board meets to set the course for the next five years. The bakery has cash in the bank, and three claims on it: pay down the loans, invest in solar panels and heat recovery for the ovens, or pay the family a special dividend after four hard years.

Where should Kilbrack's cash go?

Around the table

  • Chief executive Leads this decision

    The family has waited four years for a reward. I also know that the next tender will ask about carbon, and that the bank would sleep better with less debt.

  • Finance director

    Repaying debt saves interest from next year and lowers gearing at once. Solar cuts the energy bill this year and every year after. A dividend pays the owners and does nothing for the business.

  • Marketing director

    The supermarkets now score suppliers on carbon. Lower emissions per loaf are something we can sell.

  • Operations director

    Gas is our most volatile cost. Panels and heat recovery would take a third off the energy bill and more off our emissions.

  • HR director

    If we made people redundant and then pay the family a large dividend, everyone in Kilbrack will notice the order those things happened in.

The options

  1. Pay down the loans

    Use €1.5m of cash to repay loans, starting with the equipment loan.

    What it involves

    • Repay up to €1.50m of loans.
  2. Invest in solar and heat recovery

    A €900k solar array on the bakery roof and heat recovery on the ovens, in use this year.

    What it involves

    • Invest €900k in solar array and oven heat recovery: in use this year, written off over 15 years.
    • Once in use: energy down 30% a loaf.
    • Once in use: emissions for each loaf down 35%.
  3. Pay the family a special dividend

    A special dividend of €800k to the family shareholders, on top of the usual payout.

    What it involves

    • Pay a dividend of €800k.
    • Depends on earlier choices: Staff who saw colleagues made redundant two years ago read about the family's dividend in the local paper: morale falls.

One path, narrated: robotic cells, retraining, a sourdough range, solar

This is one path through the four years, chosen to show how the decisions interact, not as the right answer. At the end of 2026 the plant runs at 100.0% of capacity, 594,185 loaves of orders are being turned away, the defect rate is 7.1% and morale is 58.

Round 1 · 2027: Add robotic cells and retrain

Round 1 of 4 · 2027 · The board chose: Add robotic cells and retrain

A smaller step, and bakers learning to run robots

The cells are ordered and the training starts, but the extra capacity arrives only in 2028. This year the plant is still full and 1.50m loaves of orders go unmet; operating profit is −⁠€475k. Because the bakers who run the cells are the bakers already here, morale holds at 55.

How the decision travelled
  1. Operations Lost sales +⁠907,811, worse
  2. People Morale −⁠3, worse Labour turnover +⁠1.7 pts, worse
  3. Finance Operating profit −⁠€904k, worse Net cash −⁠€837k, worse
  4. Marketing Brand −⁠6, worse
Marketing
Revenue
€11.20m −⁠€783k Down, worse
Units sold
10.1m −⁠74,201 Down, worse
Market share
7.8% −⁠0.2 pts Down, worse
Brand
47 −⁠6 Down, worse
  • Demand rose 7.7% to 11.65 million loaves. In the open channels, brand strength took off about 4.4% and market growth added about 2.0%.
  • Supermarket contracts took 9 million loaves under contract at €1.06.
  • Revenue €11.20m at an average €1.10 a loaf; market share 7.8%.
  • Brand strength went from 53.1 to 47.5: disappointed customers −⁠2.6 and defects −⁠3.0.
Operations
Utilization
100.0% No change
Lost sales
1.50m +⁠907,811 Up, worse
Output per worker
161,041 −⁠1,178 Down, worse
Defect rate
7.8% +⁠0.7 pts Up, worse
  • Demand of 11.65 million outran productive capacity of 10.15 million: 1.5 million sales were lost. The plant was the limit.
  • Normal hours covered 10.49 million loaves; the other 508,321 needed 5,189 hours of overtime, costing €170k.
  • Output per worker: 161,041 loaves.
  • Defect rate 7.8%: 854,397 loaves scrapped or returned, wasting €470k of inputs.
People
Workforce
63 No change
Morale
55 −⁠3 Down, worse
Labour turnover
16.3% +⁠1.7 pts Up, worse
Staff costs
€2.51m +⁠€5.5k Up
  • 10 left and were replaced; the workforce ended the year at 63.
  • Labour turnover ran at 16.3% a year; recruiting and inducting new starters cost €40k.
  • Morale went from 58.3 to 55.5: settling back towards normal +⁠0.6, how the change was received −⁠1.0 and overtime −⁠2.4.
Finance
Operating profit
−⁠€475k −⁠€904k Down, worse
Profit after tax
−⁠€505k −⁠€844k Down, worse
Net cash
€1.50m −⁠€837k Down, worse
Acid test
4.28 −⁠1.35 Down, worse
  • Profit before interest and tax −⁠€475k (−4.2% of revenue); after €30k of interest and €0 of tax, profit for the year was −⁠€505k.
  • Costs of change in the year: training €120k.
  • Net cash went from €2.34m to €1.50m: profit −⁠€505k, depreciation added back +⁠€210k, debtors +⁠€58k, investment −⁠€1.60m and new borrowing +⁠€1m.
  • Current ratio 4.58, acid test 4.28, gearing 26.1%.
Sustainability
Carbon per unit
0.24 kg No change
Emissions
2,640 t No change
  • Emissions 2,640 tonnes of CO₂e: 0.24 kg for each loaf.
How people reacted
  • Production staff Positive See a future in running the new equipment.
  • The supermarket buyer Mixed Wants to know whether it is enough for 2028.
  • The bank Positive Comfortable with a smaller loan.
The theory behind it

Partial automation keeps people in the process while removing its most repetitive tasks. Training existing staff to run new equipment is a strategy for reducing resistance to change, and a smaller capital cost carries less operating leverage and less risk.

How the model treated this round
  • Already agreed: Supermarket contracts: price to €1.06 a loaf.
  • Already agreed: Supermarket contracts: volume to 9 million loaves a year.
  • Training: €120k this year.
  • Morale −1 points at the announcement.
  • Borrow €1m at 5.5% a year.
  • Invest €1.60m in robotic dividing and packing cells: in use from next year, written off over 8 years.
  • Once in use: plant capacity up 2 million loaves a year.
  • Once in use: labour time for each loaf down 25%.
  • Once in use: underlying defect rate down 1.0 points.
  • Once in use: maintenance up €60k a year.

Round 2 · 2028: Retrain and redeploy everyone

Round 2 of 4 · 2028 · The board chose: Retrain and redeploy everyone

Nobody loses a job, and the bakery carries the cost

Every baker is offered a new role and training for it. Quality improves and outside maintenance contracts shrink, but where the new process needs fewer hands the bakery is paying for more people than it needs: output per worker is 187,343 loaves. Morale is 61 (+⁠6). Operating profit, after training, is €596k.

How the decision travelled
  1. People Morale +⁠6, better Labour turnover −⁠1.9 pts, better
  2. Finance Operating profit +⁠€1.07m, better Net cash +⁠€467k, better
  3. Marketing Units sold +⁠1.66m, better Market share +⁠1.1 pts, better
  4. Operations Lost sales −⁠896,737, better Defect rate −⁠2.2 pts, better
Marketing
Revenue
€13.25m +⁠€2.05m Up, better
Units sold
11.8m +⁠1.66m Up, better
Market share
8.9% +⁠1.1 pts Up, better
Brand
44 −⁠4 Down, worse
  • Demand rose 6.5% to 12.41 million loaves. In the open channels, brand strength took off about 7.1% and market growth added about 2.0%.
  • Supermarket contracts took 9.9 million loaves under contract at €1.06.
  • Revenue €13.25m at an average €1.12 a loaf; market share 8.9%.
  • Brand strength went from 47.5 to 43.8: disappointed customers −⁠1.0 and defects −⁠2.7.
Operations
Utilization
100.0% No change
Lost sales
605,259 −⁠896,737 Down, better
Output per worker
187,343 +⁠26,302 Up, better
Defect rate
5.6% −⁠2.2 pts Down, better
  • Demand of 12.41 million outran productive capacity of 11.8 million: 605,259 sales were lost. The plant was the limit.
  • Output per worker: 187,343 loaves.
  • Defect rate 5.6%: 697,367 loaves scrapped or returned, wasting €384k of inputs.
  • Robotic dividing and packing cells came into use.
People
Workforce
63 No change
Morale
61 +⁠6 Up, better
Labour turnover
14.4% −⁠1.9 pts Down, better
Staff costs
€2.34m −⁠€170k Down
  • 9 left and were replaced; the workforce ended the year at 63.
  • Labour turnover ran at 14.4% a year; recruiting and inducting new starters cost €36k.
  • Morale went from 55.5 to 61.1: settling back towards normal +⁠1.6 and how the change was received +⁠4.0.
Finance
Operating profit
€596k +⁠€1.07m Up, better
Profit after tax
€434k +⁠€939k Up, better
Net cash
€1.97m +⁠€467k Up, better
Acid test
4.69 +⁠0.40 Up, better
  • Profit before interest and tax €596k (4.5% of revenue); after €85k of interest and €77k of tax, profit for the year was €434k.
  • Costs of change in the year: training €250k.
  • Net cash went from €1.50m to €1.97m: profit +⁠€434k, depreciation added back +⁠€410k, debtors −⁠€223k, stock −⁠€27k, creditors +⁠€90k and dividends −⁠€217k.
  • Current ratio 4.99, acid test 4.69, gearing 25.2%.
Sustainability
Carbon per unit
0.24 kg No change
Emissions
3,000 t +⁠360 t Up, worse
  • Emissions 3,000 tonnes of CO₂e: 0.24 kg for each loaf.
How people reacted
  • Production staff Positive Relieved, and proud to learn new skills.
  • The bakery's union branch Positive Praises the plan in the local paper.
  • The bank Mixed Asks when the savings from the investment will show.
The theory behind it

Retraining and redeployment reduce resistance to change by giving people a future in the new process. They keep skills and goodwill, at the cost of slower savings. Job enrichment, giving people more varied and responsible work, can raise motivation.

How the model treated this round
  • Before the round (The cells take time to bed in): Plant capacity down 500,000 loaves a year.
  • Before the round (The cells take time to bed in): Next year: plant capacity up 500,000 loaves a year.
  • Already agreed: Supermarket contracts: volume to 9.9 million loaves a year.
  • Underlying defect rate down 0.8 points.
  • Maintenance down €60k a year.
  • Training: €250k this year.
  • Morale +4 points at the announcement.

Round 3 · 2029: Launch a Kilbrack sourdough range

Round 3 of 4 · 2029 · The board chose: Launch a Kilbrack sourdough range

The Kilbrack name on a loaf people choose

The sourdough range launches at €2.20 a loaf with a campaign behind it. Brand strength reaches 50 (+⁠6), and revenue is €13.90m. Sourdough costs more to make and to market, but it earns far more per loaf than the contract bread: the gross profit margin is 44.8%, and operating profit €391k.

How the decision travelled
  1. Marketing Units sold +⁠443,367, better Brand +⁠6, better
  2. Operations Lost sales +⁠834,607, worse Output per worker +⁠7,038, better
  3. Finance Operating profit −⁠€205k, worse Net cash +⁠€540k, better
Marketing
Revenue
€13.90m +⁠€643k Up, better
Units sold
12.2m +⁠443,367 Up, better
Market share
9.1% +⁠0.2 pts Up, better
Brand
50 +⁠6 Up, better
  • Demand rose 10.3% to 13.69 million loaves. In the open channels, brand strength added about 10.0% and market growth added about 2.0%.
  • Supermarket contracts took 9.9 million loaves under contract at €1.06.
  • Revenue €13.90m at an average €1.13 a loaf; market share 9.1%.
  • Brand strength went from 43.8 to 49.8: marketing +⁠9.0, events and decisions +⁠2.0, disappointed customers −⁠2.1 and defects −⁠2.9.
Operations
Utilization
100.0% No change
Lost sales
1.44m +⁠834,607 Up, worse
Output per worker
194,381 +⁠7,038 Up, better
Defect rate
5.8% +⁠0.2 pts Up, worse
  • Demand of 13.69 million outran productive capacity of 12.25 million: 1.44 million sales were lost. The plant was the limit.
  • Output per worker: 194,381 loaves.
  • Defect rate 5.8%: 754,000 loaves scrapped or returned, wasting €445k of inputs.
  • The robotic cells settled down and ran at their planned speed.
People
Workforce
63 No change
Morale
61 No change
Labour turnover
14.6% +⁠0.2 pts Up, worse
Staff costs
€2.34m No change
  • 9 left and were replaced; the workforce ended the year at 63.
  • Labour turnover ran at 14.6% a year; recruiting and inducting new starters cost €36k.
  • Morale went from 61.1 to 60.7: drifting back towards normal −⁠0.4.
Finance
Operating profit
€391k −⁠€205k Down, worse
Profit after tax
€260k −⁠€174k Down, worse
Net cash
€2.51m +⁠€540k Up, better
Acid test
4.91 +⁠0.23 Up, better
  • Profit before interest and tax €391k (2.8% of revenue); after €85k of interest and €46k of tax, profit for the year was €260k.
  • Net cash went from €1.97m to €2.51m: profit +⁠€260k, depreciation added back +⁠€410k, debtors −⁠€62k, stock −⁠€26k, creditors +⁠€87k and dividends −⁠€130k.
  • Current ratio 5.21, acid test 4.91, gearing 24.7%.
Sustainability
Carbon per unit
0.24 kg No change
Emissions
3,120 t +⁠120 t Up, worse
  • Emissions 3,120 tonnes of CO₂e: 0.24 kg for each loaf.
How people reacted
  • Delis and independent shops Positive Stock it and ask for more.
  • Production staff Positive Take pride in bread with their bakery's name on it.
  • The supermarket buyer Mixed Wonders whether Kilbrack is still interested in its contract.
The theory behind it

Differentiation and premium pricing build value through the brand rather than through volume. A premium product needs consistent quality and marketing support, and it suits flexible batch production better than a line built for mass production.

How the model treated this round
  • Before the round (Wheat and energy prices rise): Materials up 6% a loaf.
  • Before the round (Wheat and energy prices rise): Energy up 30% a loaf.
  • New: Kilbrack sourdough range, 1 million loaves a year at €2.20, paid in 35 days, with an extra €0.30 of cost for each loaf.
  • Marketing spend up €300k a year.
  • Brand strength +2 points at once.

Round 4 · 2030: Invest in solar and heat recovery

Round 4 of 4 · 2030 · The board chose: Invest in solar and heat recovery

A smaller energy bill, and a smaller footprint

The panels and heat recovery run from the spring. Energy costs fall by about a third and emissions per loaf to 0.16 kg (−⁠0.08 kg). Operating profit is €1.55m, after depreciation on the new equipment; net cash is €2.50m.

How the decision travelled
  1. Marketing Brand +⁠13, better
  2. Operations Lost sales −⁠476,158, better
  3. Finance Operating profit +⁠€1.16m, better Acid test +⁠0.20, better
  4. Sustainability Carbon per unit −⁠0.08 kg, better
Marketing
Revenue
€14.70m +⁠€802k Up, better
Units sold
12.2m No change
Market share
8.9% −⁠0.2 pts Down, worse
Brand
62 +⁠13 Up, better
  • Demand fell 3.5% to 13.21 million loaves. In the open channels, brand strength added about 16.0%, market growth added about 2.0% and the lower carbon footprint added about 7.0%.
  • Supermarket contracts took 8.42 million loaves under contract at €1.06.
  • Revenue €14.70m at an average €1.20 a loaf; market share 8.9%.
  • Brand strength went from 49.8 to 62.5: marketing +⁠17.0, disappointed customers −⁠1.5 and defects −⁠2.9.
Operations
Utilization
100.0% No change
Lost sales
963,708 −⁠476,158 Down, better
Output per worker
194,381 No change
Defect rate
5.8% No change
  • Demand of 13.21 million outran productive capacity of 12.25 million: 963,708 sales were lost. The plant was the limit.
  • Output per worker: 194,381 loaves.
  • Defect rate 5.8%: 754,000 loaves scrapped or returned, wasting €424k of inputs.
  • Solar array and oven heat recovery came into use.
People
Workforce
63 No change
Morale
60 No change
Labour turnover
14.7% +⁠0.1 pts Up, worse
Staff costs
€2.34m No change
  • 9 left and were replaced; the workforce ended the year at 63.
  • Labour turnover ran at 14.7% a year; recruiting and inducting new starters cost €36k.
  • Morale went from 60.7 to 60.5: drifting back towards normal −⁠0.2.
Finance
Operating profit
€1.55m +⁠€1.16m Up, better
Profit after tax
€1.24m +⁠€984k Up, better
Net cash
€2.50m −⁠€12k Down, worse
Acid test
5.12 +⁠0.20 Up, better
  • Profit before interest and tax €1.55m (10.5% of revenue); after €85k of interest and €220k of tax, profit for the year was €1.24m.
  • Net cash went from €2.51m to €2.50m: profit +⁠€1.24m, depreciation added back +⁠€320k, debtors −⁠€34k, stock +⁠€8.7k, creditors −⁠€29k, investment −⁠€900k and dividends −⁠€622k.
  • Current ratio 5.42, acid test 5.12, gearing 22.5%.
Sustainability
Carbon per unit
0.16 kg −⁠0.08 kg Down, better
Emissions
2,028 t −⁠1,092 t Down, better
  • Emissions 2,028 tonnes of CO₂e: 0.16 kg for each loaf (−⁠0.08 kg).
How people reacted
  • The supermarket buyer Positive Notes the lower carbon figure for the next tender.
  • Niamh Hartigan and the family board Positive Like an investment that pays back and that they can talk about.
  • The bank Mixed Neutral: paid from cash.
The theory behind it

An investment that cuts both cost and emissions shows that sustainability and profit can point the same way. Investment appraisal (payback, average rate of return and, for HL, net present value) judges whether the savings justify the cost.

How the model treated this round
  • Before the round (Kilbrack loses part of the supermarket contract): Supermarket contracts: volume down 15% loaves a year.
  • Invest €900k in solar array and oven heat recovery: in use this year, written off over 15 years.
  • Once in use: energy down 30% a loaf.
  • Once in use: emissions for each loaf down 35%.

By 2030 operating profit is €1.55m, the defect rate 5.8%, morale 60 and the workforce 63. This path gave up the lowest cost per loaf to keep its people and its flexibility, and found its reward in the premium range. The debrief compares it with the fully automated paths.

The dashboard at the end of this path

  • Revenue

    €14.70m

    Change from 2029: +⁠€802k Up, better

    Sales revenue, 2024 to 2030Sales revenue was €11.55m in 2024 and rose to €14.70m in 2030. It ranged from €11.20m to €14.70m.
  • Operating profit

    €1.55m

    Change from 2029: +⁠€1.16m Up, better

    Profit before interest and tax, 2024 to 2030Profit before interest and tax was €875k in 2024 and rose to €1.55m in 2030. It ranged from −⁠€475k to €1.55m.
  • Net cash

    €2.50m

    Change from 2029: −⁠€12k Down, worse

    Net cash (cash less overdraft), 2024 to 2030Net cash (cash less overdraft) was €1.46m in 2024 and rose to €2.50m in 2030. It ranged from €1.46m to €2.51m.
  • Utilization

    100.0%

    Change from 2029: No change

    Capacity utilization rate, 2024 to 2030Capacity utilization rate was 91.4% in 2024 and rose to 100.0% in 2030.
  • Output per worker

    194,381loaves per worker

    Change from 2029: No change

    Labour productivity, 2024 to 2030Labour productivity was 166,414 in 2024 and rose to 194,381 in 2030. It ranged from 161,041 to 194,381.
  • Defect rate

    5.8%

    Change from 2029: No change

    Defect rate, 2024 to 2030Defect rate was 4.0% in 2024 and rose to 5.8% in 2030. It ranged from 4.0% to 7.8%.
  • Morale

    60out of 100

    Change from 2029: No change

    Morale, 2024 to 2030Morale was 61 in 2024 and fell to 60 in 2030. It ranged from 55 to 61.
  • Workforce

    63people

    Change from 2029: No change

    Operations workforce, 2024 to 2030Operations workforce was 58 in 2024 and rose to 63 in 2030.
  • Brand

    62out of 100

    Change from 2029: +⁠13 Up, better

    Brand strength, 2024 to 2030Brand strength was 58 in 2024 and rose to 62 in 2030. It ranged from 44 to 62.
  • Carbon per unit

    0.16 kgCO₂e per loaf

    Change from 2029: −⁠0.08 kg Down, better

    Emissions per unit, 2024 to 2030Emissions per unit was 0.24 kg in 2024 and fell to 0.16 kg in 2030.

How each director's goals came out on this path

Chief executive: 2 of 3 goals met
  • Missed Profit after tax of at least €2.0m over the four years €1.43m
  • Met Brand strength of 55 or more in 2030 62
  • Met A market share no smaller than in 2026 +⁠0.9 pts
Finance director: 3 of 3 goals met
  • Met Return on capital employed of 15% or more in 2030 21.8%
  • Met Gearing of 35% or less in 2030 22.5%
  • Met Never go over the overdraft limit Never over the limit
Marketing director: 2 of 3 goals met
  • Met Brand strength of 60 or more in 2030 62
  • Met Grow market share by at least half a point +⁠0.9 pts
  • Missed Turn away no more than a million loaves in four years 4.51m loaves
Operations director: 1 of 3 goals met
  • Missed A defect rate of 3.5% or less in 2030 5.8%
  • Missed At least 200,000 loaves per worker in 2030 194,381
  • Met Emissions of 0.2 kg CO₂e per loaf or less in 2030 0.16 kg
HR director: 3 of 3 goals met
  • Met At least 60 production jobs in 2030 63 people
  • Met Morale of 55 or more in 2030 60
  • Met Labour turnover never above 20% a year 16.3%

The board memo

It is the end of 2030. Write to the family board as the director whose seat you took: what Kilbrack should do in the next five years, on the evidence of the last four, and what it owes the town.

  1. Recommendation. One or two sentences: the bakery's direction for the next five years.
  2. The evidence. The figures that matter most from 2027 to 2030, and what they show about the choice between people and machines.
  3. Trade-offs and risks. What your recommendation costs, and what could go wrong, including operating leverage.
  4. Stakeholders. The family, the staff and the union, the supermarket, the cafés and the town: who gains and who loses?
  5. What would change your mind. The figure or event that would make you recommend something else.
  6. The first ninety days. Three things you would do first, in order.

Write it on paper or in a document; with JavaScript the simulation gives you a form for it, keeps it on this device and lets you print, copy or download it.

Section 04: The debrief

What happened, the theory behind it, and what the different paths teach.

The debrief opens when the board has made its last decision, so that the simulation's surprises stay surprises.

Automation is not one decision but a chain of them. The line makes the cheapest loaf once it runs, but it arrives a year after it is paid for, it raises fixed costs, and it only pays if the bakery either cuts the labour it replaces or finds the volume to fill it. The workforce plan decides which, and how the town remembers it. The night shift keeps people and flexibility at a higher cost per loaf; the robotic cells sit between. Later decisions depend on the first: a premium range suits bakers better than a line, and the supermarket tender rewards the consistency that machines bring. No path meets every director's goals, because the goals pull against each other: cost per loaf against jobs, return on capital against risk, volume against brand.

The theory behind it

HL Some of the theory below is HL only, and is hidden while you are viewing SL content.

Operations methods

The automated line moves the bakery towards mass (flow) production: long runs of standard loaves at low unit cost. Batch production, which the craft bakery and the sourdough range rely on, makes varied products in smaller runs. The choice between them depends on volume, variety and how standard the product is.

5.2 Operations methods

Fixed costs, variable costs and break-even

Machines replace a variable cost (labour per loaf) with fixed costs (depreciation, maintenance, interest). The contribution per loaf rises and so does the break-even output. Above break-even, profit grows faster; below it, losses grow faster.

5.5 Break-even analysis

Capacity, productivity and operating leverage HL

Labour productivity and capacity utilization show how well the bakery uses its people and its plant. Running close to full capacity raises defects and overtime; spare capacity wastes fixed costs. Operating leverage measures how strongly profit responds to a change in sales, and automation raises it.

5.6 Production planning

Investment appraisal

Payback and the average rate of return (and, for HL, net present value) judge an investment on the cash it returns. The line's returns depend on the workforce plan and on volume, which is why an appraisal is only as good as the assumptions behind it.

3.8 Investment appraisal

Resistance to change and industrial relations

People resist change they fear, do not understand or were not consulted about. Retraining, redeployment, natural wastage and honest communication reduce resistance; compulsory redundancy can provoke conflict. For HL, collective bargaining and conciliation are the tools for resolving it.

2.1 Introduction to human resource management 2.7 Industrial/employee relations

Lean production and quality HL

Scrapped loaves are waste in the lean sense: materials, energy and labour for nothing. Automation and trained quality checkers both cut the defect rate, and the supermarket tender shows that quality is a source of competitive advantage, not just a cost.

5.3 Lean production and quality management

What different paths teach

The figures are the engine's, for each path played from the start. Goals met are out of each director's goals.

Named paths compared
PathProfit after tax, all roundsOperating profit, finalNet cash, finalBrand, finalMorale, finalMarket share, finalCarbon per unit, finalGoals met
The craft pathAdd robotic cells and retrain, then retrain and redeploy everyone, then launch a Kilbrack sourdough range, then invest in solar and heat recovery€1.43m€1.55m€2.50m62608.9%0.16 kgCEO 2 of 3 FD 3 of 3 MD 2 of 3 OD 1 of 3 HRD 3 of 3
The factory pathInstall a fully automated line, then cut to what the bakery needs now, then supply the discount chain, then pay the family a special dividend€2.24m€1.35m€3.61m38389.1%0.21 kgCEO 2 of 3 FD 1 of 3 MD 1 of 3 OD 2 of 3 HRD 0 of 3
The automated, people-first pathInstall a fully automated line, then let numbers fall through leavers, then launch a Kilbrack sourdough range, then invest in solar and heat recovery€5.11m€3.12m€4.67m674911.0%0.14 kgCEO 3 of 3 FD 2 of 3 MD 2 of 3 OD 2 of 3 HRD 0 of 3
The night-shift pathAdd a night shift, then retrain and redeploy everyone, then hold, and look after the customers it has, then pay down the loans€941k−⁠€396k€2.61m52629.1%0.24 kgCEO 1 of 3 FD 2 of 3 MD 1 of 3 OD 0 of 3 HRD 3 of 3

The craft path

Partial automation, everyone retrained, a premium range and solar panels. It keeps the most jobs and the highest morale, and wins its reward in the brand, at a higher cost per loaf than the line.

The factory path

The line, cuts to match it, own-label volume and a dividend for the family. It makes the cheapest loaf and fills the line, and it pays for that in morale, in the brand and in the town's view of the family.

The automated, people-first path

The line, with the workforce reduced through leavers rather than redundancies, a premium range and solar panels. It earns the most profit of these paths: the savings arrive more slowly than with redundancies, but without the cost to morale.

The night-shift path

A night shift, everyone kept, steady prices and less debt. It is the lowest-risk path and keeps the most jobs, and its high cost per loaf leaves little profit when wheat and energy prices rise.

Every possible board, compared

There are 81 paths through the 4 rounds. The table shows the lowest and highest final figure any of them reaches. Paths that meet every goal of one director: chief executive 9, finance director 18, marketing director 0, operations director 5, HR director 26. Paths that meet every goal of all five: 0.

The range of final figures across every path
MeasureBefore round 1Lowest finalHighest final
Sales revenue€11.98m€9.82m€18.26m
Profit before interest and tax€429k−⁠€1.55m€3.12m
Net cash (cash less overdraft)€2.34m−⁠€350k€4.68m
Capacity utilization rate100.0%85.2%100.0%
Labour productivity162,219139,897419,411
Defect rate7.1%1.0%8.0%
Morale583362
Operations workforce633383
Brand strength532969
Emissions per unit0.24 kg0.14 kg0.24 kg

Misconceptions this tests

  • The claim Automation always cuts costs.

    The correction

    It cuts the variable cost of each unit and raises fixed costs. If the labour it replaces is still paid, or volume falls, total costs can rise.

  • The claim The investment with the highest profit is always the best choice.

    The correction

    The line's higher profit comes with higher fixed costs, more debt and fewer jobs. Which path is best depends on the objectives, the risks a business will accept and its responsibilities to its stakeholders.

  • The claim Natural wastage is a painless way to cut a workforce.

    The correction

    It avoids redundancies, but the business cannot choose who leaves, savings come slowly, and those who stay can be overstretched.

Exam link and practice

Paper 2 and Paper 1 questions on operations ask candidates to compare methods of production, to analyse the effect of capital-intensive production on costs and break-even, and to evaluate the human resource consequences of change. HL candidates can extend the analysis with capacity utilization, productivity, operating leverage and net present value.

Source: Original practice question These are the platform's own practice questions, written for this scenario; they are not IB questions.

HL One or more questions are HL only, and are hidden while you are viewing SL content.

  1. Distinguish between batch production and mass production, using Kilbrack Bakery as an example. [4 marks] Distinguish
  2. Explain how installing the automated line would affect Kilbrack's break-even output. [4 marks] Explain
  3. Discuss whether Kilbrack Bakery should have automated its production. [10 marks] Discuss
  4. Evaluate the workforce plans available to Kilbrack after automation. [10 marks] Evaluate
  5. Examine the impact of automation on Kilbrack's operating leverage and capacity utilization. [10 marks] Examine HL

Key terms

How the figures were made

Kilbrack Bakery, its customers, competitors and every person in this scenario are fictional, and every figure is simulated. The figures come from the Boardroom's model, stated in full on the Boardroom's page. The years 2024 to 2026 are the model run forward from the start of 2024 with the changes listed in the history, so the board pack's statements and ratios cannot disagree with the simulation. The family takes half of each year's profit as dividends. Tax is a flat simulated 15% of positive profit; real tax rules are more complex.

How the Boardroom's model works: every mechanism and lag