The debrief opens when the board has made its last decision, so that the simulation's surprises stay surprises.
Kestle's problem was never profit; it was the timing of cash. Each first-round option fixes that timing in a different part of the business: factoring in finance, just-in-time buying in operations, an investor in the ownership. What followed depended on that choice. The Fellside order is cheap to accept with factored invoices and dangerous without them. A thin stock of parts is cheap until a delivery fails. An investor's money disappears quickly into Fellside's debtors if the order grows. No path meets every director's goals, because the goals pull against each other: growth against liquidity, pay against cash, ownership against safety.
The theory behind it
HL Some of the theory below is HL only, and is hidden while you are viewing SL content.
Profit is not cash
Kestle made a profit in every quarter of 2026 and still came close to its overdraft limit. Profit records sales when they are made; cash arrives when customers pay. Between the two sit debtors, stock and creditors, the working capital cycle. A growing business needs more working capital every quarter, which is why overtrading can sink a profitable business.
3.7 Cash flow
Liquidity ratios, and what they miss
The current ratio looked comfortable throughout, because Kestle's current assets were large. Most of them were stock and money owed by Fellside, which pay no bills this week. The acid test, which leaves stock out, told the truer story. Neither ratio shows timing: a business can have healthy ratios and still be unable to pay on Friday.
3.5 Profitability and liquidity ratio analysis
Stock, debtors and creditors in days HL
Stock turnover, debtor days and creditor days measure how long cash is tied up at each step of the cycle. Cutting stock days or debtor days releases cash; lengthening creditor days borrows it from suppliers. Gearing shows how far long-term finance is borrowed. Insolvency, being unable to pay debts as they fall due, can come before any loss.
3.6 Efficiency ratio analysis
Sources of finance, matched to the need
Factoring, an overdraft, a term loan, a business angel's share capital and the sale of an asset each raise cash with a different cost: fees, interest, ownership, or the asset itself. A permanent need for working capital is better met by long-term finance than by an overdraft the bank can withdraw.
3.2 Sources of finance
Just-in-time and just-in-case HL
Holding less stock frees cash, but leaves no buffer when supply fails. In this simulation the shipping disruption punishes thin stocks and spares the business that kept a buffer. The right stock policy depends on how reliable supply is, not only on the cost of holding stock.
5.6 Production planning
Pay, morale and the workforce
The pay review shows a hygiene factor at work: the freeze saves money and costs goodwill, labour turnover and output, especially in a workshop already on overtime. Profit-related pay makes part of the wage bill rise and fall with the business, which suits a company whose problem is cash.
2.4 Motivation and demotivation
What different paths teach
The figures are the engine's, for each path played from the start. Goals met are out of each director's goals.
The cautious path
Fix the timing of cash first, grow within capacity, and share profit rather than fixing pay. It never breaches the limit and keeps morale healthy; it pays a factoring fee every quarter and gives up some of Fellside's volume.
The growth path
Raise equity, take every order, pay well and sell the building. It grows market share fastest and reports a strong final quarter, partly because of the one-off gain on the sale. The angel's money is swallowed by Fellside's slower payments, the overdraft goes over its limit and the bank tightens its terms.
The lean path
Make the business need less cash: thin stocks, a simpler range and no extra Fellside volume. It ends with the least stock, but the shipping disruption finds the thin shelves and costs sales.
The squeeze
Cut stock, take the big order and freeze pay. Each step saves cash on its own; together they collide. The shipping disruption hits a full order book with no buffer, the freeze lands on a tired workforce, and the bank loses patience.
Every possible board, compared
There are 81 paths through the 4 rounds. The table shows the lowest and highest final figure any of them reaches. Paths that meet every goal of one director: chief executive 14, finance director 63, marketing director 12, operations director 10, HR director 37. Paths that meet every goal of all five: 0.
Misconceptions this tests
-
The claim A profitable business cannot run out of cash.
The correction Kestle was profitable every quarter and still nearly ran out of cash. Profit and cash differ by the money tied up in working capital, and by spending such as investment and loan repayments.
-
The claim A healthy current ratio means a business can pay its bills.
The correction Kestle's current ratio stayed well above 1 while the overdraft neared its limit, because its current assets were mostly stock and debtors. The acid test, and the cash flow itself, gave the warning.
-
The claim Selling more always helps a business with a cash problem.
The correction Each extra Fellside bike was paid for months before Fellside paid for it. Without faster payment, more sales made the cash problem worse: overtrading.
-
The claim The gain on selling the workshop shows the business is doing better.
The correction The gain is a one-off. It raises one quarter's profit, while the rent lowers every quarter's after it.
Exam link and practice
Paper 1 and Paper 2 questions on cash flow ask candidates to distinguish profit from cash, to calculate and interpret liquidity ratios, and to evaluate strategies for dealing with cash flow problems in context. Kestle gives a context for each. HL candidates can extend the analysis with efficiency ratios and stock control.
Source: Original practice question These are the platform's own practice questions, written for this scenario; they are not IB questions.
HL One or more questions are HL only, and are hidden while you are viewing SL content.
- Using Kestle Cycles, explain the difference between profit and cash flow.
[4 marks] Explain
- From the board pack, calculate Kestle's acid test (quick) ratio at the end of 2026, and comment on your answer.
[4 marks] Calculate
- Discuss whether Kestle Cycles should have accepted Fellside Outdoor's expanded order.
[10 marks] Discuss
- Evaluate two strategies Kestle Cycles could use to improve its liquidity.
[10 marks] Evaluate
- Examine the impact of a just-in-time approach to stock on Kestle Cycles.
[10 marks] Examine HL
Key terms
How the figures were made
Kestle Cycles, Fellside Outdoor, Northern Counties Bank, the competitors and every person in this scenario are fictional, and every figure is simulated. The figures come from the Boardroom's model, stated in full on the Boardroom's page: demand follows price, brand and the market; capacity is the lower of the workshop's and the workforce's; working capital follows its days; morale, turnover and productivity follow pay, workload and change. The quarters of 2026 are the model run forward from the start of the year with the changes listed in the history, so the board pack's statements and ratios cannot disagree with the simulation. Tax is a flat simulated 25% of positive profit; real tax rules are more complex.
How the Boardroom's model works: every mechanism and lag