Boardroom · A liquidity crisis

Kestle Cycles: the cash runs out first

A profitable, growing e-bike maker has a year to stop its overdraft swallowing the business.

Fictional company Source: Simulated data 4 rounds, one per quarter SL and HL

Industry
Electric bicycle design and assembly
Location
Sheffield, United Kingdom
Founded
2016
Size
46 assembly staff, and 14 more in design, sales and administration
Ownership
The two founders, Hannah Kestle and Dev Malhotra, own every share.
Figures in
Pounds sterling (£)

The question for the board How does a profitable business that is running out of cash get through the next year without giving up what made it profitable?

Section 01: The brief

The company, its position, the people with a stake in it, and the quarters ahead.

Kestle Cycles designs and assembles electric bicycles in a workshop on the edge of Sheffield. Hannah Kestle and Dev Malhotra, two engineers who met at a car parts maker, started it in 2016 to build city e-bikes for people who commute up hills. Frames, motors and batteries come from suppliers in Asia; Kestle designs the bikes, assembles them, tests every one and sells them through about 120 independent bike shops, which have done most of its marketing for it.

In 2026 the business changed shape. Fellside Outdoor, a national chain of outdoor stores, began selling two Kestle models under a contract: 250 bikes in the first quarter, rising to 650 a quarter by the end of the year. Fellside pays less than the shops do and pays later, 90 days after delivery against the shops' 30. To keep up, Kestle took on twelve assemblers, and after a shortage of motors in the spring it began holding much more stock of parts.

On paper 2026 was Kestle's best year: sales up by about a third, and a profit in every quarter. In the bank account it was the worst. Money went out to suppliers months before it came back from Fellside, and the overdraft that used to be a cushion ended the year close to its £1m limit. The bank has asked for a plan.

This simulation is Kestle's next year, one quarter at a time: four decisions for the board, with an event after each that nobody on the board controls. You take one seat at the table. The decisions are the whole board's; your seat decides what you are judged on.

The management challenges

  • Liquidity. The overdraft stands at £992k against a £1m limit, and the bank reviews the account every quarter.
  • Working capital. Kestle holds 112 days of parts, and its customers owe it £1.41m, most of it Fellside's.
  • Capacity. The workshop runs at 80.5% of capacity; a bigger Fellside order would push it towards its limit.
  • People. The annual pay review falls in the third quarter, and staff expect a rise in line with living costs.
  • Ownership. The founders have never given up a share of the company, and say they would rather not.

The stakeholders and what they say

  • Hannah Kestle and Dev Malhotra

    Founders and owners · High influence

    A company that survives, stays theirs and keeps its name for quality.

    “We built this on the shops. Fellside got us noticed, but I did not start a company to work for one customer.”

  • Northern Counties Bank

    Lender · High influence

    Interest, and an overdraft that comes back down.

    “The business is profitable, but profit does not repay an overdraft. We need to see the balance falling, not a forecast that says it will.”

  • Fellside Outdoor

    The largest customer · High influence

    Reliable supply of bikes it can sell at a good margin.

    “Kestle sells well in our stores. We would like more, and we would like it at a better price.”

  • Independent bike shops

    The established channel · Medium influence

    A brand they can recommend without being undercut down the road.

    “When a customer has seen the same bike cheaper at Fellside, the conversation in the shop gets harder.”

  • Assembly staff

    Employees · Medium influence

    Fair pay, manageable hours and secure jobs.

    “Last year was flat out. People will put up with overtime in a busy spring; they will not put up with it for ever.”

  • Component suppliers

    Suppliers · Medium influence

    Prompt payment and steady orders.

    “Small, frequent orders cost us more to pack and ship, and we will charge for it.”

What it exercises in the IB course

Efficiency ratios and insolvency (3.6), and just-in-time, just-in-case and capacity utilization (5.6), are HL only. SL students can play every round; the parts of the debrief that depend on them are marked HL.

Section 02: The board pack

Every figure here is calculated by the Boardroom's model from Kestle Cycles's starting position and its history; the simulation continues from the last column.

Exhibit 1

Key figures at the end of Q4 2026

Source: Simulated data
  • Revenue

    £2.56m

    Change from Q3 2026: +⁠£92k Up, better

    Sales revenue, Q1 2026 to Q4 2026Sales revenue was £1.95m in Q1 2026 and rose to £2.56m in Q4 2026.
  • Operating profit

    £211k

    Change from Q3 2026: +⁠£42k Up, better

    Profit before interest and tax, Q1 2026 to Q4 2026Profit before interest and tax was £63k in Q1 2026 and rose to £211k in Q4 2026.
  • Net cash

    −⁠£992k

    Change from Q3 2026: −⁠£94k Down, worse

    Net cash (cash less overdraft), Q1 2026 to Q4 2026Net cash (cash less overdraft) was −⁠£148k in Q1 2026 and fell to −⁠£992k in Q4 2026.
  • Acid test

    0.99

    Change from Q3 2026: −⁠0.03 Down, worse

    Acid test (quick) ratio, Q1 2026 to Q4 2026Acid test (quick) ratio was 1.60 in Q1 2026 and fell to 0.99 in Q4 2026.
  • Utilization

    80.5%

    Change from Q3 2026: +⁠0.4 pts Up

    Capacity utilization rate, Q1 2026 to Q4 2026Capacity utilization rate was 75.9% in Q1 2026 and rose to 80.5% in Q4 2026.
  • Morale

    63out of 100

    Change from Q3 2026: No change

    Morale, Q1 2026 to Q4 2026Morale was 64 in Q1 2026 and fell to 63 in Q4 2026.
  • Brand

    56out of 100

    Change from Q3 2026: No change

    Brand strength, Q1 2026 to Q4 2026Brand strength held at 56.
  • Market share

    4.2%

    Change from Q3 2026: +⁠0.1 pts Up, better

    Market share, Q1 2026 to Q4 2026Market share was 3.2% in Q1 2026 and rose to 4.2% in Q4 2026.
  • Stock days

    112 days

    Change from Q3 2026: +⁠7 days Up, worse

    Stock turnover (days), Q1 2026 to Q4 2026Stock turnover (days) was 95 days in Q1 2026 and rose to 112 days in Q4 2026.
  • Debtor days

    50 days

    Change from Q3 2026: +⁠1 days Up, worse

    Debtor days, Q1 2026 to Q4 2026Debtor days was 40 days in Q1 2026 and rose to 50 days in Q4 2026.
Each line runs from Q1 2026 to Q4 2026; changes are against Q3 2026. The full figures are in Exhibit 6.
Exhibit 2

Statement of profit or loss

Source: Simulated data
Statement of profit or loss, £000
£000 Q1 2026Q2 2026Q3 2026Q4 2026Year to Q4 2026
Sales revenue 1,9522,2432,4672,5589,221
Cost of sales 1,1811,3751,5241,5835,663
Gross profit 7728689439753,558
Expenses 7097547757643,002
of which staff costs 3143553803801,427
of which overheads, rent and administration 2902902902901,160
of which marketing 60606060240
of which depreciation 1616161663
of which maintenance and other costs 30333019111
Profit before interest and tax 63115168211556
Interest 710212765
Profit before tax 56104147183491
Tax 14263746123
Profit for the period 4278111138368
Dividends 00000
Retained profit 4278111138368
In pounds sterling, thousands; figures in brackets are negative. Cost of sales is the materials, energy and other inputs bought for each bike; all staff costs are in expenses.
Exhibit 3

Statement of financial position

Source: Simulated data
Statement of financial position, £000
£000 Start of 2026End of Q4 2026
Non-current assets (net book value) 1,020957
Current assets
Cash 3000
Debtors 5251,410
Stock 9811,944
Total current assets 1,8063,353
Total assets 2,8264,310
Current liabilities
Bank overdraft 0992
Trade creditors 310434
Total current liabilities 3101,426
Non-current liabilities: loans 400400
Net assets 2,1162,484
Equity
Share capital 300300
Retained earnings 1,8162,184
Total equity 2,1162,484
In pounds sterling, thousands. Net assets equal total equity in every column; the tests check it.
Exhibit 4

Ratios

Source: Simulated data
Ratio Q1 2026Q2 2026Q3 2026Q4 2026
Gross profit margin Gross profit margin = (gross profit ÷ sales revenue) × 100 39.5%38.7%38.2%38.1%
Profit margin Profit margin = (profit before interest and tax ÷ sales revenue) × 100 3.2%5.1%6.8%8.2%
Return on capital employed ROCE = (profit before interest and tax ÷ capital employed) × 100, where capital employed = non-current liabilities + equity 9.8%17.4%24.5%29.2%
Current ratio Current ratio = current assets ÷ current liabilities 3.902.552.352.35
Acid test (quick) ratio Acid test (quick) ratio = (current assets − stock) ÷ current liabilities 1.601.061.020.99
Stock turnover (days) HL Stock turnover (number of days) = (average stock ÷ cost of sales) × 365, here on closing stock 95 days105 days105 days112 days
Debtor days HL Debtor days = (debtors ÷ total sales revenue) × 365 40 days46 days49 days50 days
Creditor days HL Creditor days = (creditors ÷ cost of sales) × 365 30 days30 days25 days25 days
Gearing ratio HL Gearing ratio = (non-current liabilities ÷ capital employed) × 100, where capital employed = non-current liabilities + equity 15.6%15.2%14.6%13.9%

HL The efficiency ratios and gearing are HL only, and are hidden while you are viewing SL content.

The guide's formulas (pp. 64 to 65). Return on capital employed uses each quarter’s profit at an annual rate; stock, debtor and creditor days use the days in the quarter.
Exhibit 5

Six measures, Q1 2026 to Q4 2026

Source: Simulated data
The figures behind these charts are in Exhibit 6.
Exhibit 6

Key figures by quarter

Source: Simulated data
Key figures by quarter
MeasureQ1 2026Q2 2026Q3 2026Q4 2026
Sales revenue£1.95m£2.24m£2.47m£2.56m
Average price per unit£1,484£1,464£1,453£1,450
Units sold (bikes)1,3161,5321,6981,764
Sales lost for lack of capacity (bikes)0000
Market share3.2%3.7%4.1%4.2%
Brand strength (out of 100)56565656
Productive capacity (bikes)1,7331,9502,1192,191
Capacity utilization rate75.9%78.5%80.1%80.5%
Labour productivity (bikes per worker)35363738
Defect rate2.5%2.5%2.5%2.5%
Operations workforce (people)38434646
Morale (out of 100)64636363
Labour turnover (annual rate)12.8%13.1%13.3%13.5%
Profit before interest and tax£63k£115k£168k£211k
Profit margin3.2%5.1%6.8%8.2%
Profit for the period£42k£78k£111k£138k
Net cash (cash less overdraft)−⁠£148k−⁠£613k−⁠£898k−⁠£992k
Loans (non-current liabilities)£400k£400k£400k£400k
Exhibit 7

The market in Q4 2026

Source: Simulated data

The figures are simulated. Kestle competes in the market for mid-priced electric bicycles, which in this simulation grows about 1.5% a quarter. Buyers compare price, range, reliability and the advice of the shop that sells it. Kestle's share is 4.2% of the market by volume.

Seller Share of the market Typical price Position
Kestle Cycles (fictional) 4.2% £1,450 Average across its channels
Brightline E-Bikes (fictional) 9.0% £1,350 Mass market, sold through national chains
Strata Electric (fictional) 6.0% £1,750 Premium, sold online direct to riders
Moorland Mobility (fictional) 3.5% £1,450 Regional, sold through independent shops
All other sellers 77.3% Various Smaller firms
  • Commuters are replacing second cars with e-bikes, which keeps the market growing even when spending is tight.
  • National chains are pressing suppliers for lower prices and longer payment terms.
  • Shipping times from Asia have become less predictable, so assemblers hold more stock than they used to.
The whole market: 42,455 bikes a quarter, growing about 1.5% a quarter. Shares by volume.
Exhibit 8

What happened before the first decision

Source: Simulated data
  1. Q1 2026 Fellside Outdoor's first order arrives, 250 bikes on 90-day terms. Kestle hires four assemblers.
  2. Q2 2026 Fellside raises its order to 450 bikes. After a shortage of motors, Kestle holds 105 days of parts instead of 95, and hires five more assemblers.
  3. Q3 2026 Fellside takes 600 bikes. Suppliers, facing higher shipping costs, ask to be paid in 25 days instead of 30. Three more assemblers join.
  4. Q4 2026 Fellside takes 650 bikes. Stock of parts reaches 112 days, and the overdraft ends the year close to its limit.

Section 03: The simulation

4 rounds, one quarter each, with an event between rounds that the board does not control.

Take a seat at the table

The decisions belong to the whole board. Your seat decides which measures you watch most closely and what you are judged on at the end. Each director's goals pull a different way; no path through this simulation meets every goal of every director.

Choose your role on the board

Judged on

  • Stay within the overdraft limit at every quarter end
  • Profit after tax of at least £550k over the four quarters
  • Hold market share at least where it was
  • Keep the company wholly owned by its founders

Judged on

  • Stay within the overdraft limit at every quarter end
  • End the year with an overdraft of no more than £150k
  • Gearing of 30% or less at the year end

Judged on

  • Grow market share by at least 0.2 points
  • Brand strength of 56 or more at the year end
  • Turn away no more than 100 orders in the year

Judged on

  • Never run above 92% of capacity
  • A defect rate of 3% or less at the year end
  • Hold no more than 90 days of stock at the year end

Judged on

  • Morale of 60 or more at the year end
  • Labour turnover never above 16% a year
  • Morale never below 52 in any quarter

This is the casebook version of the simulation: every round and its options, what can happen between rounds, and one path narrated with the engine's figures. With JavaScript you can take a seat at the board and decide each round yourself.

Round 1 · Q1 2027 Find the cash

This is a decision for finance.

The bank will not raise the overdraft limit, and the new season's parts must be paid for this quarter. The board needs cash quickly, and there are three ways to find it: turn what Fellside owes into money now, hold less stock, or bring in an investor. Each solves the same problem in a different part of the business, and each has a price.

How will Kestle find the cash it needs this quarter?

Around the table

  • Chief executive

    I want the business through the year and still ours at the end of it. I will listen to any option, but I need to know what each one costs us next year, not just this quarter.

  • Finance director Leads this decision

    Our customers owe us £1.41m, most of it Fellside's, and Fellside pays in 90 days. A factor would pay us most of Fellside's share now. It costs nearly 3% of every Fellside invoice, but it scales with the contract, and it is the one fix that grows with the problem.

  • Marketing director

    Whatever we do, it must not reach the customer. The shops already feel undercut by Fellside. If the cure for cash is running short of popular models, we will pay for it in sales.

  • Operations director

    We hold 112 days of parts. The spring shortage scared us into it. Ordering little and often would free a lot of cash, but the suppliers will charge more for small shipments, and we lose our buffer if shipping goes wrong again.

  • HR director

    The team worked flat out last year. A business angel or a factor does not change their week; running short of parts means stop-start days on the line, and that is when mistakes and resentment start.

The options

  1. Factor Fellside's invoices

    Sell Fellside's invoices to a factoring company, which pays most of their value straight away and collects the money from Fellside itself.

    What it involves

    • Factor Fellside Outdoor’s invoices: cash in 25 days on average, for a fee of 2.8% of their value.
    • One-off cost: factoring set-up fee, £8.0k.
  2. Order parts little and often

    Move towards just-in-time buying, cutting the stock of parts from 112 days to 90 now and 75 next quarter, accepting higher prices for smaller shipments.

    What it involves

    • Materials up 2% a bike.
    • Stock held to 90 days’ worth.
    • Next quarter: stock held to 75 days’ worth.
  3. Bring in a business angel

    Sell 20% of the company to a business angel for £600k, who joins the board.

    What it involves

    • Overheads up £6.0k a quarter.
    • Sell 20% of the company for £600k.

What can happen before the next round

If the board chose to factor invoices

Fellside moves its suppliers to 120-day terms

Fellside writes to every supplier: from now on it will pay in 120 days, not 90. Because Kestle's invoices go to the factor, the factor waits instead, and raises its fee to reflect the longer wait.

  • Factor Fellside Outdoor’s invoices: cash in 30 days on average, for a fee of 3.2% of their value.

Otherwise

Fellside moves its suppliers to 120-day terms

Fellside writes to every supplier: from now on it will pay in 120 days, not 90. Kestle now waits four months for Fellside's money, and every bike it sends Fellside ties up cash for a month longer.

  • Fellside Outdoor: payment to 120 days.

Round 2 · Q2 2027 The Fellside offer

This is a decision for marketing.

Fellside's buyer wants more: half as many bikes again, 975 a quarter, at £1,290 instead of £1,330. It would make Kestle bigger, fill the workshop, and put Kestle in front of many more riders. It would also deepen Kestle's dependence on one customer that pays late, and the shops have started to complain about being undercut.

How should Kestle answer Fellside?

Around the table

  • Chief executive

    One customer already takes more than a third of our bikes. I am tempted by the scale, and frightened by what happens to us if Fellside changes its mind next year.

  • Finance director

    Every extra Fellside bike is cash out now and cash in months later. Unless the invoices are factored, the full order needs hundreds of thousands more in working capital, and we do not have it. If we take more, I want better payment terms in exchange.

  • Marketing director Leads this decision

    Fellside puts us in front of riders the shops never reach. But the shops are our brand: if they stop recommending us because the same bike is cheaper at Fellside, we lose more than we gain. I would rather spend on the shops.

  • Operations director

    At 975 a quarter we would run close to the limit of the workshop, on overtime. Quality slips when we rush. Part of the order we can build in normal hours; all of it we cannot.

  • HR director

    People will do overtime for a busy season. Built into every quarter, it will wear them down, and in the third quarter the pay review lands on top of it.

The options

  1. Accept the full order

    Supply 975 bikes a quarter at £1,290, on Fellside's standard terms.

    What it involves

    • Fellside Outdoor: price to £1,290 a bike.
    • Fellside Outdoor: volume to 975 bikes a quarter.
  2. Take part of it, on better terms

    Offer 800 bikes a quarter at £1,305, if Fellside pays in 90 days.

    What it involves

    • Fellside Outdoor: price to £1,305 a bike.
    • Fellside Outdoor: volume to 800 bikes a quarter.
    • Fellside Outdoor: payment to 90 days.
  3. Decline, and invest in the shops

    Keep Fellside at 650 bikes, and spend more on supporting the independent shops, with a demonstration fleet and joint promotions.

    What it involves

    • Marketing spend up £45k a quarter.
    • One-off cost: demonstration fleet for the shops, £30k.

What can happen before the next round

If stock turnover (days) is below 80 days at the end of the round

A shipping disruption, and the shelves are thin

A disruption in container shipping adds six weeks to deliveries from Asia. With only the figure at the time of parts in hand, Kestle runs out of motors: for a quarter it can build only part of its usual output, and it flies some parts in at a premium.

  • Plant capacity down 500 bikes a quarter.
  • Materials up £25 a bike.
  • Next quarter: plant capacity up 500 bikes a quarter. materials down £25 a bike.

Otherwise

A shipping disruption, and the buffer holds

A disruption in container shipping adds six weeks to deliveries from Asia. Kestle's stock of parts carries it through, though it pays more for freight for a quarter.

  • Other inputs up £12 a bike.
  • Next quarter: other inputs down £12 a bike.

Round 3 · Q3 2027 The pay review

This is a decision for human resources.

Kestle reviews pay once a year, in the third quarter. Living costs have risen about 5%, and the assemblers expect their pay to keep up. Every option costs something: money now, money later, or goodwill. Whatever the board decides lands on a workforce that may already be tired.

What will Kestle do about pay this year?

Around the table

  • Chief executive

    I want a decision we can explain to the staff face to face. Whatever we give, or do not give, they should see why.

  • Finance director

    A 5% rise is a permanent cost of about £19k a quarter. A freeze saves it. A share of profit costs money only when we make money, which is exactly when we can afford it.

  • Marketing director

    The people who build the bikes are the people the shops phone with problems. A tired, resentful workshop shows up in the warranty returns, and the returns show up in the reviews.

  • Operations director

    If people leave, we lose more than a wage. A new assembler takes a quarter to reach full speed, and every leaver costs us recruitment and training.

  • HR director Leads this decision

    Pay is a hygiene factor: a fair rise will not make anyone love the job, but a freeze after the year they have had will make some of them leave. A profit share tells them they are part of the recovery.

The options

  1. Freeze pay this year

    No rise this year, with a promise to look again when the cash position recovers.

    What it involves

    • Pay stays where it is: no rise.
  2. A small rise and a profit share

    A 2% rise now, and 8% of each quarter's profit before interest and tax shared among the staff.

    What it involves

    • Pay up 2%.
    • Staff share 8% of profit before interest and tax.
  3. Match living costs, and cross-train

    A 5% rise, and £20k of training so that assemblers can cover each other's stations.

    What it involves

    • Pay up 5%.
    • Training: £20k this quarter.
    • Next quarter: productivity up 3%.

What can happen before the next round

If the overdraft has gone over its limit at any quarter end or acid test (quick) ratio is below 0.75 at the end of the round

The bank moves Kestle to its business support team

At its quarterly review the bank sees an acid test of the figure at the time and net cash of the figure at the time, and a history that worries it. It cuts the overdraft limit to £600k from next quarter, raises the overdraft rate by three points, and says any new loan will cost 10.5% a year.

  • Overdraft limit to £600k.
  • Overdraft interest up 3.0 points.
  • New loans cost to 10.5% a year.

Otherwise

The bank offers to help

At its quarterly review the bank sees an acid test of the figure at the time and net cash of the figure at the time. Reassured, it offers to convert part of any overdraft into a five-year loan at 7.5% a year.

  • New loans cost to 7.5% a year.

Round 4 · Q4 2027 A long-term fix

This is a decision for the chief executive.

The year is nearly over. Whatever happened in the first three quarters, the board wants a structure that will not put the company back in the same position next year. There are three ideas on the table: restructure the debt, sell the workshop and rent it back, or make the business itself need less cash by cutting its range.

What is Kestle's long-term fix?

Around the table

  • Chief executive Leads this decision

    I want the next spring to start with headroom, not a phone call from the bank. I also want us to still own the things that make us Kestle.

  • Finance director

    An overdraft is short-term money that can be withdrawn. Turning it into a term loan moves the debt from current to non-current liabilities. Selling the workshop raises the most cash, and the gain on the sale will flatter this quarter's profit; do not mistake that for a better business.

  • Marketing director

    Nine models are too many for the shops to stock and too many for riders to choose between. Five well-chosen models would be easier to sell. Cut the wrong ones and we lose customers.

  • Operations director

    Fewer models means fewer different parts, smaller stocks and longer runs on the line. It is the only option that makes the business itself need less cash.

  • HR director

    Selling the building worries people: it feels like a business selling the furniture. Whatever we choose, explain it.

The options

  1. Convert the overdraft into a term loan

    Convert up to £600k of the overdraft into a five-year loan at the bank's current rate for new loans.

    What it involves

    • Convert up to £600k of the overdraft into a loan at the bank’s rate for new loans.
    • Depends on earlier choices: There was no overdraft to convert, so the bank's loan was not needed and nothing changed.
  2. Sell the workshop and lease it back

    Sell the freehold workshop to a property investor for £950k and rent it back at £19k a quarter.

    What it involves

    • Sell the freehold workshop for £950k and lease it back at £19k a quarter.
    • One-off cost: legal and survey fees, £15k.
  3. Cut the range from nine models to five

    Drop the four slowest-selling models, clear their parts, and buy the remaining parts in larger batches.

    What it involves

    • Independent bike shops: volume down 4% bikes a quarter.
    • Materials down 1.5% a bike.
    • Stock held down 25 days’ worth.
    • One-off cost: parts for discontinued models written off, £70k.

One path, narrated: factor, take part of the order, share the profit, refinance

This is one path through the year, chosen to show how the decisions interact, not as the right answer. At the start, net cash is −⁠£992k against a £1m overdraft limit, the acid test is 0.99, and the workshop runs at 80.5% of capacity.

Round 1 · Q1 2027: Factor Fellside's invoices

Round 1 of 4 · Q1 2027 · The board chose: Factor Fellside's invoices

The factor pays now, and takes a slice of every Fellside sale

The factor advances most of the value of each Fellside invoice within days and collects the rest from Fellside. What Fellside owes Kestle stops piling up on the balance sheet: debtor days fall to 28 days, and net cash moves to −⁠£263k (+⁠£729k). The cost is permanent while the agreement lasts: a fee on every Fellside invoice, so operating profit for the quarter is £189k.

How the decision travelled
  1. Finance Operating profit −⁠£22k, worse Net cash +⁠£729k, better
  2. Operations Utilization +⁠0.8 pts
Marketing
Revenue
£2.58m +⁠£25k Up, better
Units sold
1,781 +⁠17 Up, better
Market share
4.1% No change
Brand
56 No change
  • Demand rose 0.9% to 1,781 bikes. In the open channels, market growth added about 1.5%.
  • Fellside Outdoor took 650 bikes under contract at £1,330.
  • Revenue £2.58m at an average £1,451 a bike; market share 4.1%.
Operations
Utilization
81.3% +⁠0.8 pts Up
Lost sales
0 No change
Output per worker
39 No change
Defect rate
2.5% No change
  • The business made 1,827 bikes, using 81.3% of productive capacity.
  • Output per worker: 39 bikes.
  • Defect rate 2.5%: 46 bikes scrapped or returned, wasting £40k of inputs.
People
Workforce
46 No change
Morale
62 No change
Labour turnover
13.6% +⁠0.1 pts Up, worse
Staff costs
£380k No change
  • 2 left and were replaced; the workforce ended the quarter at 46.
  • Labour turnover ran at 13.6% a year; recruiting and inducting new starters cost £7.0k.
  • Morale went from 62.6 to 62.5: drifting back towards normal −⁠0.2.
Finance
Operating profit
£189k −⁠£22k Down, worse
Profit after tax
£120k −⁠£18k Down, worse
Net cash
−⁠£263k +⁠£729k Up, better
Acid test
1.14 +⁠0.16 Up, better
  • Profit before interest and tax £189k (7.3% of revenue); after £29k of interest and £40k of tax, profit for the quarter was £120k.
  • Costs of change in the quarter: factoring set-up fee £8.0k and factoring fees £24k.
  • Net cash went from −⁠£992k to −⁠£263k: profit +⁠£120k, depreciation added back +⁠£16k, debtors +⁠£607k, stock −⁠£18k and creditors +⁠£4.1k.
  • The overdraft stood at £263k against a limit of £1m.
  • Current ratio 3.94, acid test 1.14, gearing 13.3%.
How people reacted
  • Northern Counties Bank Positive Relieved to see the overdraft fall within a quarter.
  • Hannah Kestle and Dev Malhotra Mixed Glad to keep every share, uneasy about paying a fee on their biggest customer for as long as the contract runs.
  • Fellside Outdoor Mixed Pays the factor instead of Kestle, and notices.
The theory behind it

Debt factoring turns debtors into cash at a price. It does not make the business more profitable: it changes when cash arrives, and the fee lowers the profit margin. It suits a business whose problem is the timing of cash rather than its profitability, and its cost grows with the sales it is attached to.

How the model treated this round
  • Factor Fellside Outdoor’s invoices: cash in 25 days on average, for a fee of 2.8% of their value.
  • One-off cost: factoring set-up fee, £8.0k.

Round 2 · Q2 2027: Take part of it, on better terms

Round 2 of 4 · Q2 2027 · The board chose: Take part of it, on better terms

A bigger contract on terms Kestle can carry

Fellside agrees to 800 bikes a quarter and to pay in 90 days. Kestle sells 1,934 bikes; the workshop runs at 88.4% of capacity, mostly in normal hours. Operating profit is £225k and net cash −⁠£327k. The shops grumble, but less than they would have.

How the decision travelled
  1. Marketing Units sold +⁠153, better
  2. Operations Utilization +⁠7.0 pts Output per worker +⁠3, better
  3. Finance Operating profit +⁠£36k, better Net cash −⁠£64k, worse
Marketing
Revenue
£2.77m +⁠£184k Up, better
Units sold
1,934 +⁠153 Up, better
Market share
4.4% +⁠0.3 pts Up, better
Brand
55 −⁠1 Down, worse
  • Demand rose 8.6% to 1,934 bikes. In the open channels, brand strength took off about 1.2% and market growth added about 1.5%.
  • Fellside Outdoor took 800 bikes under contract at £1,305.
  • Revenue £2.77m at an average £1,431 a bike; market share 4.4%.
  • Brand strength went from 56.0 to 55.0: events and decisions −⁠1.0.
Operations
Utilization
88.4% +⁠7.0 pts Up
Lost sales
0 No change
Output per worker
42 +⁠3 Up, better
Defect rate
2.5% No change
  • The business made 1,984 bikes, using 88.4% of productive capacity.
  • Normal hours covered 1,952 bikes; the other 32 needed 342 hours of overtime, costing £9.3k.
  • Output per worker: 42 bikes.
  • Defect rate 2.5%: 50 bikes scrapped or returned, wasting £43k of inputs.
People
Workforce
46 No change
Morale
61 −⁠1 Down, worse
Labour turnover
13.7% +⁠0.1 pts Up, worse
Staff costs
£389k +⁠£9.3k Up
  • 2 left and were replaced; the workforce ended the quarter at 46.
  • Labour turnover ran at 13.7% a year; recruiting and inducting new starters cost £7.0k.
  • Morale went from 62.5 to 61.4: drifting back towards normal −⁠0.1 and overtime −⁠1.0.
Finance
Operating profit
£225k +⁠£36k Up, better
Profit after tax
£159k +⁠£40k Up, better
Net cash
−⁠£327k −⁠£64k Down, worse
Acid test
1.13 −⁠0.01 Down, worse
  • Profit before interest and tax £225k (8.1% of revenue); after £13k of interest and £53k of tax, profit for the quarter was £159k.
  • Costs of change in the quarter: factoring fees £33k.
  • Net cash went from −⁠£263k to −⁠£327k: profit +⁠£159k, depreciation added back +⁠£16k, debtors −⁠£108k, stock −⁠£169k and creditors +⁠£38k.
  • The overdraft stood at £327k against a limit of £1m.
  • Current ratio 3.79, acid test 1.13, gearing 12.6%.
How people reacted
  • Fellside Outdoor Mixed Gets more bikes, though not all it wanted.
  • Northern Counties Bank Positive Approves of the shorter payment terms.
  • Independent bike shops Mixed Notice Fellside's bigger range, and live with it.
The theory behind it

Negotiating payment terms is a working capital decision as much as a sales one: the same order financed in 90 days instead of 120 ties up a quarter less cash. Growth matched to capacity avoids the cost of overtime and the quality problems of running flat out.

How the model treated this round
  • Before the round (Fellside moves its suppliers to 120-day terms): Factor Fellside Outdoor’s invoices: cash in 30 days on average, for a fee of 3.2% of their value.
  • Fellside Outdoor: price to £1,305 a bike.
  • Fellside Outdoor: volume to 800 bikes a quarter.
  • Fellside Outdoor: payment to 90 days.
  • Brand strength −1 points at once.

Round 3 · Q3 2027: A small rise and a profit share

Round 3 of 4 · Q3 2027 · The board chose: A small rise and a profit share

Pay that rises and falls with the business

Pay rises 2%, and the staff now share in each quarter's profit: the profit share paid out depends on how the business does. Morale moves to 66 (+⁠4); labour turnover runs at 10.9% a year. Operating profit, after the profit share, is £198k.

How the decision travelled
  1. People Morale +⁠4, better Labour turnover −⁠2.9 pts, better
  2. Finance Operating profit −⁠£27k, worse Net cash +⁠£108k, better
  3. Operations Utilization −⁠1.1 pts
Marketing
Revenue
£2.79m +⁠£26k Up, better
Units sold
1,951 +⁠17 Up, better
Market share
4.4% No change
Brand
55 No change
  • Demand rose 0.9% to 1,951 bikes. In the open channels, market growth added about 1.5%.
  • Fellside Outdoor took 800 bikes under contract at £1,305.
  • Revenue £2.79m at an average £1,432 a bike; market share 4.4%.
Operations
Utilization
87.2% −⁠1.1 pts Down
Lost sales
0 No change
Output per worker
42 No change
Defect rate
2.5% No change
  • The business made 2,001 bikes, using 87.2% of productive capacity.
  • Normal hours covered 1,995 bikes; the other 6 needed 68 hours of overtime, costing £1.9k.
  • Output per worker: 42 bikes.
  • Defect rate 2.5%: 50 bikes scrapped or returned, wasting £44k of inputs.
People
Workforce
46 No change
Morale
66 +⁠4 Up, better
Labour turnover
10.9% −⁠2.9 pts Down, better
Staff costs
£406k +⁠£17k Up
  • 1 left and were replaced; the workforce ended the quarter at 46.
  • Labour turnover ran at 10.9% a year; recruiting and inducting new starters cost £3.5k.
  • Morale went from 61.4 to 65.7: settling back towards normal +⁠0.2, how the change was received +⁠2.0, pay +⁠2.4 and overtime −⁠0.2.
  • The profit share paid £17k.
Finance
Operating profit
£198k −⁠£27k Down, worse
Profit after tax
£138k −⁠£22k Down, worse
Net cash
−⁠£220k +⁠£108k Up, better
Acid test
1.30 +⁠0.17 Up, better
  • Profit before interest and tax £198k (7.1% of revenue); after £14k of interest and £46k of tax, profit for the quarter was £138k.
  • Costs of change in the quarter: factoring fees £33k.
  • Net cash went from −⁠£327k to −⁠£220k: profit +⁠£138k, depreciation added back +⁠£16k, debtors −⁠£8.5k, stock −⁠£48k and creditors +⁠£11k.
  • The overdraft stood at £220k against a limit of £1m.
  • Current ratio 4.39, acid test 1.30, gearing 12.1%.
How people reacted
  • Assembly staff Positive Like seeing the link between their effort and the results.
  • Hannah Kestle and Dev Malhotra Positive Prefer a cost that falls when profit does.
  • Northern Counties Bank Mixed Neutral: the cost moves with profit.
The theory behind it

Profit-related pay is a financial reward that links part of pay to the organization's results. It makes staff costs partly variable, which protects cash when profit falls, and it can strengthen commitment. Its weakness is the weak link between one person's effort and the whole company's profit.

How the model treated this round
  • Before the round (A shipping disruption, and the buffer holds): Other inputs up £12 a bike.
  • Before the round (A shipping disruption, and the buffer holds): Next quarter: other inputs down £12 a bike.
  • Pay up 2%.
  • Staff share 8% of profit before interest and tax.
  • Morale +2 points at the announcement.

Round 4 · Q4 2027: Convert the overdraft into a term loan

Round 4 of 4 · Q4 2027 · The board chose: Convert the overdraft into a term loan

Short-term debt becomes long-term debt

The term loan replaces as much of the overdraft as there is to replace, up to £600k. Loans now stand at £620k and gearing at 16.8%; net cash is £174k. The current ratio is 6.75, because a loan due in five years is not a current liability. Operating profit is £223k.

How the decision travelled
  1. Operations Utilization +⁠1.1 pts
  2. People Morale −⁠2, worse Labour turnover +⁠0.9 pts, worse
  3. Finance Operating profit +⁠£25k, better Net cash +⁠£394k, better
Marketing
Revenue
£2.82m +⁠£26k Up, better
Units sold
1,969 +⁠17 Up, better
Market share
4.4% No change
Brand
55 No change
  • Demand rose 0.9% to 1,969 bikes. In the open channels, market growth added about 1.5%.
  • Fellside Outdoor took 800 bikes under contract at £1,305.
  • Revenue £2.82m at an average £1,433 a bike; market share 4.4%.
Operations
Utilization
88.3% +⁠1.1 pts Up
Lost sales
0 No change
Output per worker
43 No change
Defect rate
2.5% No change
  • The business made 2,019 bikes, using 88.3% of productive capacity.
  • Normal hours covered 1,988 bikes; the other 31 needed 325 hours of overtime, costing £9.0k.
  • Output per worker: 43 bikes.
  • Defect rate 2.5%: 50 bikes scrapped or returned, wasting £44k of inputs.
  • Freight costs returned to normal.
People
Workforce
46 No change
Morale
64 −⁠2 Down, worse
Labour turnover
11.8% +⁠0.9 pts Up, worse
Staff costs
£416k +⁠£9.3k Up
  • 1 left and were replaced; the workforce ended the quarter at 46.
  • Labour turnover ran at 11.8% a year; recruiting and inducting new starters cost £3.5k.
  • Morale went from 65.7 to 63.9: drifting back towards normal −⁠0.9 and overtime −⁠0.9.
  • The profit share paid £19k.
Finance
Operating profit
£223k +⁠£25k Up, better
Profit after tax
£159k +⁠£21k Up, better
Net cash
£174k +⁠£394k Up, better
Acid test
2.27 +⁠0.97 Up, better
  • Profit before interest and tax £223k (7.9% of revenue); after £12k of interest and £53k of tax, profit for the quarter was £159k.
  • Costs of change in the quarter: factoring fees £33k.
  • Net cash went from −⁠£220k to £174k: profit +⁠£159k, depreciation added back +⁠£16k, debtors −⁠£8.6k, stock +⁠£10k, creditors −⁠£2.3k and new borrowing +⁠£220k.
  • Current ratio 6.75, acid test 2.27, gearing 16.8%.
How people reacted
  • Northern Counties Bank Positive Prefers a scheduled loan to a hard-core overdraft.
  • Hannah Kestle and Dev Malhotra Positive Sleep better with the overdraft headroom restored.
  • The finance team Mixed Note that the debt has moved, not gone.
The theory behind it

Matching finance to its use: an overdraft is short-term finance for short-term needs, and a permanent need for working capital is better financed long term. Refinancing improves the current ratio by moving debt out of current liabilities, while gearing rises. The debt still has to be repaid.

How the model treated this round
  • Before the round (The bank offers to help): New loans cost to 7.5% a year.
  • Convert up to £600k of the overdraft into a loan at the bank’s rate for new loans.

By the end of the year net cash is £174k, the acid test 2.27 and morale 64. The crisis was eased in the first quarter, and every later decision was easier because of it. The cost is a factoring fee on every Fellside invoice for as long as the agreement runs, which the debrief weighs against the other routes.

The dashboard at the end of this path

  • Revenue

    £2.82m

    Change from Q3 2027: +⁠£26k Up, better

    Sales revenue, Q1 2026 to Q4 2027Sales revenue was £1.95m in Q1 2026 and rose to £2.82m in Q4 2027.
  • Operating profit

    £223k

    Change from Q3 2027: +⁠£25k Up, better

    Profit before interest and tax, Q1 2026 to Q4 2027Profit before interest and tax was £63k in Q1 2026 and rose to £223k in Q4 2027. It ranged from £63k to £225k.
  • Net cash

    £174k

    Change from Q3 2027: +⁠£394k Up, better

    Net cash (cash less overdraft), Q1 2026 to Q4 2027Net cash (cash less overdraft) was −⁠£148k in Q1 2026 and rose to £174k in Q4 2027. It ranged from −⁠£992k to £174k.
  • Acid test

    2.27

    Change from Q3 2027: +⁠0.97 Up, better

    Acid test (quick) ratio, Q1 2026 to Q4 2027Acid test (quick) ratio was 1.60 in Q1 2026 and rose to 2.27 in Q4 2027. It ranged from 0.99 to 2.27.
  • Utilization

    88.3%

    Change from Q3 2027: +⁠1.1 pts Up

    Capacity utilization rate, Q1 2026 to Q4 2027Capacity utilization rate was 75.9% in Q1 2026 and rose to 88.3% in Q4 2027. It ranged from 75.9% to 88.4%.
  • Morale

    64out of 100

    Change from Q3 2027: −⁠2 Down, worse

    Morale, Q1 2026 to Q4 2027Morale was 64 in Q1 2026 and rose to 64 in Q4 2027. It ranged from 61 to 66.
  • Brand

    55out of 100

    Change from Q3 2027: No change

    Brand strength, Q1 2026 to Q4 2027Brand strength was 56 in Q1 2026 and fell to 55 in Q4 2027.
  • Market share

    4.4%

    Change from Q3 2027: No change

    Market share, Q1 2026 to Q4 2027Market share was 3.2% in Q1 2026 and rose to 4.4% in Q4 2027. It ranged from 3.2% to 4.4%.
  • Stock days

    112 days

    Change from Q3 2027: No change

    Stock turnover (days), Q1 2026 to Q4 2027Stock turnover (days) was 95 days in Q1 2026 and rose to 112 days in Q4 2027.
  • Debtor days

    30 days

    Change from Q3 2027: No change

    Debtor days, Q1 2026 to Q4 2027Debtor days was 40 days in Q1 2026 and fell to 30 days in Q4 2027. It ranged from 28 days to 50 days.

How each director's goals came out on this path

Chief executive: 4 of 4 goals met
  • Met Stay within the overdraft limit at every quarter end Never over the limit
  • Met Profit after tax of at least £550k over the four quarters £575k
  • Met Hold market share at least where it was +⁠0.2 pts
  • Met Keep the company wholly owned by its founders 100.0%
Finance director: 3 of 3 goals met
  • Met Stay within the overdraft limit at every quarter end Never over the limit
  • Met End the year with an overdraft of no more than £150k £174k
  • Met Gearing of 30% or less at the year end 16.8%
Marketing director: 2 of 3 goals met
  • Met Grow market share by at least 0.2 points +⁠0.2 pts
  • Missed Brand strength of 56 or more at the year end 55
  • Met Turn away no more than 100 orders in the year 0 bikes
Operations director: 2 of 3 goals met
  • Met Never run above 92% of capacity 88.4%
  • Met A defect rate of 3% or less at the year end 2.5%
  • Missed Hold no more than 90 days of stock at the year end 112 days
HR director: 3 of 3 goals met
  • Met Morale of 60 or more at the year end 64
  • Met Labour turnover never above 16% a year 13.7%
  • Met Morale never below 52 in any quarter 61

The board memo

The year is over. Write to the board as the director whose seat you took: what Kestle should do next year, on the evidence of this one. Use the figures on the dashboard, and say what you would watch.

  1. Recommendation. One or two sentences: what should Kestle do next year about cash, Fellside and the shops?
  2. The evidence. The two or three figures that matter most, and what they show. Quote them from the dashboard.
  3. Trade-offs and risks. What your recommendation costs, and what could go wrong.
  4. Stakeholders. Who gains, who loses, and how you would handle the bank, Fellside, the shops and the staff.
  5. What would change your mind. The figure or event that would make you recommend something else.
  6. The first ninety days. Three things you would do first, in order.

Write it on paper or in a document; with JavaScript the simulation gives you a form for it, keeps it on this device and lets you print, copy or download it.

Section 04: The debrief

What happened, the theory behind it, and what the different paths teach.

The debrief opens when the board has made its last decision, so that the simulation's surprises stay surprises.

Kestle's problem was never profit; it was the timing of cash. Each first-round option fixes that timing in a different part of the business: factoring in finance, just-in-time buying in operations, an investor in the ownership. What followed depended on that choice. The Fellside order is cheap to accept with factored invoices and dangerous without them. A thin stock of parts is cheap until a delivery fails. An investor's money disappears quickly into Fellside's debtors if the order grows. No path meets every director's goals, because the goals pull against each other: growth against liquidity, pay against cash, ownership against safety.

The theory behind it

HL Some of the theory below is HL only, and is hidden while you are viewing SL content.

Profit is not cash

Kestle made a profit in every quarter of 2026 and still came close to its overdraft limit. Profit records sales when they are made; cash arrives when customers pay. Between the two sit debtors, stock and creditors, the working capital cycle. A growing business needs more working capital every quarter, which is why overtrading can sink a profitable business.

3.7 Cash flow

Liquidity ratios, and what they miss

The current ratio looked comfortable throughout, because Kestle's current assets were large. Most of them were stock and money owed by Fellside, which pay no bills this week. The acid test, which leaves stock out, told the truer story. Neither ratio shows timing: a business can have healthy ratios and still be unable to pay on Friday.

3.5 Profitability and liquidity ratio analysis

Stock, debtors and creditors in days HL

Stock turnover, debtor days and creditor days measure how long cash is tied up at each step of the cycle. Cutting stock days or debtor days releases cash; lengthening creditor days borrows it from suppliers. Gearing shows how far long-term finance is borrowed. Insolvency, being unable to pay debts as they fall due, can come before any loss.

3.6 Efficiency ratio analysis

Sources of finance, matched to the need

Factoring, an overdraft, a term loan, a business angel's share capital and the sale of an asset each raise cash with a different cost: fees, interest, ownership, or the asset itself. A permanent need for working capital is better met by long-term finance than by an overdraft the bank can withdraw.

3.2 Sources of finance

Just-in-time and just-in-case HL

Holding less stock frees cash, but leaves no buffer when supply fails. In this simulation the shipping disruption punishes thin stocks and spares the business that kept a buffer. The right stock policy depends on how reliable supply is, not only on the cost of holding stock.

5.6 Production planning

Pay, morale and the workforce

The pay review shows a hygiene factor at work: the freeze saves money and costs goodwill, labour turnover and output, especially in a workshop already on overtime. Profit-related pay makes part of the wage bill rise and fall with the business, which suits a company whose problem is cash.

2.4 Motivation and demotivation

What different paths teach

The figures are the engine's, for each path played from the start. Goals met are out of each director's goals.

Named paths compared
PathProfit after tax, all roundsOperating profit, finalNet cash, finalBrand, finalMorale, finalMarket share, finalGoals met
The cautious pathFactor Fellside's invoices, then take part of it, on better terms, then a small rise and a profit share, then convert the overdraft into a term loan£575k£223k£174k55644.4%CEO 4 of 4 FD 3 of 3 MD 2 of 3 OD 2 of 3 HRD 3 of 3
The growth pathBring in a business angel, then accept the full order, then match living costs, and cross-train, then sell the workshop and lease it back£716k£425k−⁠£28k53534.7%CEO 2 of 4 FD 2 of 3 MD 2 of 3 OD 0 of 3 HRD 1 of 3
The lean pathOrder parts little and often, then decline, and invest in the shops, then a small rise and a profit share, then cut the range from nine models to five£316k£144k£91k63664.2%CEO 3 of 4 FD 3 of 3 MD 1 of 3 OD 2 of 3 HRD 3 of 3
The squeezeOrder parts little and often, then accept the full order, then freeze pay this year, then cut the range from nine models to five£254k£117k−⁠£433k49494.5%CEO 2 of 4 FD 1 of 3 MD 1 of 3 OD 1 of 3 HRD 0 of 3

The cautious path

Fix the timing of cash first, grow within capacity, and share profit rather than fixing pay. It never breaches the limit and keeps morale healthy; it pays a factoring fee every quarter and gives up some of Fellside's volume.

The growth path

Raise equity, take every order, pay well and sell the building. It grows market share fastest and reports a strong final quarter, partly because of the one-off gain on the sale. The angel's money is swallowed by Fellside's slower payments, the overdraft goes over its limit and the bank tightens its terms.

The lean path

Make the business need less cash: thin stocks, a simpler range and no extra Fellside volume. It ends with the least stock, but the shipping disruption finds the thin shelves and costs sales.

The squeeze

Cut stock, take the big order and freeze pay. Each step saves cash on its own; together they collide. The shipping disruption hits a full order book with no buffer, the freeze lands on a tired workforce, and the bank loses patience.

Every possible board, compared

There are 81 paths through the 4 rounds. The table shows the lowest and highest final figure any of them reaches. Paths that meet every goal of one director: chief executive 14, finance director 63, marketing director 12, operations director 10, HR director 37. Paths that meet every goal of all five: 0.

The range of final figures across every path
MeasureBefore round 1Lowest finalHighest final
Sales revenue£2.56m£2.68m£3m
Profit before interest and tax£211k£48k£466k
Net cash (cash less overdraft)−⁠£992k−⁠£433k£825k
Acid test (quick) ratio0.992.075.02
Capacity utilization rate80.5%83.9%100.0%
Morale633967
Brand strength564865
Market share4.2%4.2%4.7%
Stock turnover (days)112 days50 days112 days
Debtor days50 days30 days70 days

Misconceptions this tests

  • The claim A profitable business cannot run out of cash.

    The correction

    Kestle was profitable every quarter and still nearly ran out of cash. Profit and cash differ by the money tied up in working capital, and by spending such as investment and loan repayments.

  • The claim A healthy current ratio means a business can pay its bills.

    The correction

    Kestle's current ratio stayed well above 1 while the overdraft neared its limit, because its current assets were mostly stock and debtors. The acid test, and the cash flow itself, gave the warning.

  • The claim Selling more always helps a business with a cash problem.

    The correction

    Each extra Fellside bike was paid for months before Fellside paid for it. Without faster payment, more sales made the cash problem worse: overtrading.

  • The claim The gain on selling the workshop shows the business is doing better.

    The correction

    The gain is a one-off. It raises one quarter's profit, while the rent lowers every quarter's after it.

Exam link and practice

Paper 1 and Paper 2 questions on cash flow ask candidates to distinguish profit from cash, to calculate and interpret liquidity ratios, and to evaluate strategies for dealing with cash flow problems in context. Kestle gives a context for each. HL candidates can extend the analysis with efficiency ratios and stock control.

Source: Original practice question These are the platform's own practice questions, written for this scenario; they are not IB questions.

HL One or more questions are HL only, and are hidden while you are viewing SL content.

  1. Using Kestle Cycles, explain the difference between profit and cash flow. [4 marks] Explain
  2. From the board pack, calculate Kestle's acid test (quick) ratio at the end of 2026, and comment on your answer. [4 marks] Calculate
  3. Discuss whether Kestle Cycles should have accepted Fellside Outdoor's expanded order. [10 marks] Discuss
  4. Evaluate two strategies Kestle Cycles could use to improve its liquidity. [10 marks] Evaluate
  5. Examine the impact of a just-in-time approach to stock on Kestle Cycles. [10 marks] Examine HL

Key terms

How the figures were made

Kestle Cycles, Fellside Outdoor, Northern Counties Bank, the competitors and every person in this scenario are fictional, and every figure is simulated. The figures come from the Boardroom's model, stated in full on the Boardroom's page: demand follows price, brand and the market; capacity is the lower of the workshop's and the workforce's; working capital follows its days; morale, turnover and productivity follow pay, workload and change. The quarters of 2026 are the model run forward from the start of the year with the changes listed in the history, so the board pack's statements and ratios cannot disagree with the simulation. Tax is a flat simulated 25% of positive profit; real tax rules are more complex.

How the Boardroom's model works: every mechanism and lag