Boardroom · Profitability versus sustainability

Hotel Mareluce: full rooms or a future

A family resort hotel on a small island must choose between filling every room and protecting the place its guests come for.

Fictional company Source: Simulated data 4 rounds, one per year SL and HL

Industry
Resort hotel and hospitality
Location
Isola Brezza, a fictional island in the Mediterranean
Founded
1988
Size
140 rooms, open from April to October, with 46 staff in the season
Ownership
The Serra family owns every share; Giulia Serra is the second generation to run the hotel.
Figures in
Euro (€)

The question for the board Can a resort hotel grow its profit and cut its footprint at the same time, and which should it put first when it cannot?

Section 01: The brief

The company, its position, the people with a stake in it, and the years ahead.

Hotel Mareluce stands above the only sandy bay on Isola Brezza, a small island an hour by ferry from the mainland. Paolo and Lucia Serra opened it in 1988 with forty rooms; it now has 140, open from April to October. Their daughter Giulia runs it, with her brother Marco in charge of the building and the grounds. Two-thirds of its staff are islanders.

For years the hotel has filled its rooms two ways: guests who book directly, often returning families who pay full price, and a block of rooms sold in advance to a tour operator at a discount. The block guarantees occupancy in the shoulder months and brings the hotel guests it would never reach on its own.

Profit has stopped growing. Operating profit fell to €591k in 2026, from €672k the year before: food and energy cost more, a new resort on the other side of the island has pulled prices down, and in the busiest weeks the pool is crowded and reviews mention it. The island has its own limits too: its electricity comes from diesel generators, and in dry summers its water is trucked in.

Now the tour operator wants a bigger block for the next three years, a sustainability certifier has approached the hotel, and the island council is talking about a levy on high-emission hotels. The simulation runs from 2027 to 2030, one season a round. You take one seat at the board table; your seat decides what you are judged on.

The management challenges

  • Margins. The profit margin fell to 13.0% in 2026 as costs rose and a new competitor pulled prices down.
  • The block. The tour operator wants 14,000 room nights a year for three years, at €128.
  • Footprint. Each room night emits 38.0 kg of CO₂e, mostly from diesel-generated electricity.
  • People. Seasonal staff turn over quickly, and service suffers in the busiest weeks.
  • The island. Water, energy and the council's patience are all limited.

The stakeholders and what they say

  • Giulia Serra and the Serra family

    Owners and directors · High influence

    A hotel that stays in the family, earns enough to reinvest, and is still welcome on the island.

    “My parents built this for people who love the island. I will not turn it into a place that uses the island up.”

  • The tour operator

    Largest single customer · High influence

    Guaranteed rooms at a price it can package.

    “We filled your shoulder months for twenty years. Give us more rooms and we will fill them.”

  • Returning guests

    Direct customers · Medium influence

    The quiet bay, good food and staff who know them.

    “We come back for how it feels. Last August it felt like an airport.”

  • Island staff and seasonal workers

    Employees · Medium influence

    Fair pay, secure seasons and somewhere to live.

    “The islanders come back every year. The agency staff come once.”

  • Isola Brezza council

    Local government · High influence

    Jobs, a living island, and limits on water and energy use.

    “Tourism keeps this island alive. It must not drink it dry.”

  • The sustainability certifier

    External body · Low influence

    Hotels that meet and prove its standards.

    “Certification is earned with meters and invoices, not with brochures.”

What it exercises in the IB course

Capacity utilization (5.6) and dynamic pricing (4.5) are HL only. SL students can play every round; those parts of the debrief are marked HL.

Section 02: The board pack

Every figure here is calculated by the Boardroom's model from Hotel Mareluce's starting position and its history; the simulation continues from the last column.

Exhibit 1

Key figures at the end of 2026

Source: Simulated data
  • Revenue

    €4.53m

    Change from 2025: −⁠€26k Down, worse

    Sales revenue, 2024 to 2026Sales revenue was €4.37m in 2024 and rose to €4.53m in 2026. It ranged from €4.37m to €4.55m.
  • Operating profit

    €591k

    Change from 2025: −⁠€81k Down, worse

    Profit before interest and tax, 2024 to 2026Profit before interest and tax was €593k in 2024 and fell to €591k in 2026. It ranged from €591k to €672k.
  • Net cash

    €1.88m

    Change from 2025: +⁠€483k Up, better

    Net cash (cash less overdraft), 2024 to 2026Net cash (cash less overdraft) was €883k in 2024 and rose to €1.88m in 2026.
  • Utilization

    82.7%

    Change from 2025: −⁠1.7 pts Down

    Capacity utilization rate, 2024 to 2026Capacity utilization rate was 79.5% in 2024 and rose to 82.7% in 2026. It ranged from 79.5% to 84.4%.
  • Average price

    €183

    Change from 2025: −⁠€0.20 Down

    Average price per unit, 2024 to 2026Average price per unit was €186 in 2024 and fell to €183 in 2026.
  • Brand

    65out of 100

    Change from 2025: No change

    Brand strength, 2024 to 2026Brand strength was 64 in 2024 and rose to 65 in 2026.
  • Morale

    64out of 100

    Change from 2025: +⁠3 Up, better

    Morale, 2024 to 2026Morale was 61 in 2024 and rose to 64 in 2026. It ranged from 61 to 64.
  • Labour turnover

    18.7%

    Change from 2025: −⁠2.6 pts Down, better

    Labour turnover (annual rate), 2024 to 2026Labour turnover (annual rate) was 21.0% in 2024 and fell to 18.7% in 2026. It ranged from 18.7% to 21.3%.
  • Carbon per unit

    38.0 kgCO₂e per room night

    Change from 2025: No change

    Emissions per unit, 2024 to 2026Emissions per unit held at 38.0 kg.
  • Market share

    3.8%

    Change from 2025: −⁠0.1 pts Down, worse

    Market share, 2024 to 2026Market share was 3.8% in 2024 and fell to 3.8% in 2026. It ranged from 3.8% to 3.9%.
Each line runs from 2024 to 2026; changes are against 2025. The full figures are in Exhibit 6.
Exhibit 2

Statement of profit or loss

Source: Simulated data
Statement of profit or loss, €000
€000 202420252026
Sales revenue 4,3694,5544,528
Cost of sales 1,2181,3241,345
Gross profit 3,1503,2293,183
Expenses 2,5572,5572,592
of which staff costs 1,2421,2421,279
of which overheads, rent and administration 650650650
of which marketing 220220220
of which depreciation 220220220
of which maintenance and other costs 225225223
Profit before interest and tax 593672591
Interest 999999
Profit before tax 494573492
Tax 119138118
Profit for the period 376436374
Dividends 113131112
Retained profit 263305262
In euro, thousands; figures in brackets are negative. Cost of sales is the materials, energy and other inputs bought for each room night; all staff costs are in expenses.
Exhibit 3

Statement of financial position

Source: Simulated data
Statement of financial position, €000
€000 Start of 2024End of 2024End of 2025End of 2026
Non-current assets (net book value) 5,3005,0804,8604,640
Current assets
Cash 4008831,3981,881
Debtors 245246262261
Stock 33333637
Total current assets 6771,1621,6962,179
Total assets 5,9776,2426,5566,819
Current liabilities
Bank overdraft 0000
Trade creditors 98100109111
Total current liabilities 98100109111
Non-current liabilities: loans 2,2002,2002,2002,200
Net assets 3,6793,9424,2474,509
Equity
Share capital 1,0001,0001,0001,000
Retained earnings 2,6792,9423,2473,509
Total equity 3,6793,9424,2474,509
In euro, thousands. Net assets equal total equity in every column; the tests check it.
Exhibit 4

Ratios

Source: Simulated data
Ratio 202420252026
Gross profit margin Gross profit margin = (gross profit ÷ sales revenue) × 100 72.1%70.9%70.3%
Profit margin Profit margin = (profit before interest and tax ÷ sales revenue) × 100 13.6%14.8%13.0%
Return on capital employed ROCE = (profit before interest and tax ÷ capital employed) × 100, where capital employed = non-current liabilities + equity 9.7%10.4%8.8%
Current ratio Current ratio = current assets ÷ current liabilities 11.6115.5819.71
Acid test (quick) ratio Acid test (quick) ratio = (current assets − stock) ÷ current liabilities 11.2715.2519.38
Stock turnover (days) HL Stock turnover (number of days) = (average stock ÷ cost of sales) × 365, here on closing stock 10 days10 days10 days
Debtor days HL Debtor days = (debtors ÷ total sales revenue) × 365 21 days21 days21 days
Creditor days HL Creditor days = (creditors ÷ cost of sales) × 365 30 days30 days30 days
Gearing ratio HL Gearing ratio = (non-current liabilities ÷ capital employed) × 100, where capital employed = non-current liabilities + equity 35.8%34.1%32.8%

HL The efficiency ratios and gearing are HL only, and are hidden while you are viewing SL content.

The guide's formulas (pp. 64 to 65). Stock days use closing stock.
Exhibit 5

Six measures, 2024 to 2026

Source: Simulated data
The figures behind these charts are in Exhibit 6.
Exhibit 6

Key figures by year

Source: Simulated data
Key figures by year
Measure202420252026
Sales revenue€4.37m€4.55m€4.53m
Average price per unit€186€183€183
Units sold (room nights)23,42724,85924,743
Sales lost for lack of capacity (room nights)000
Market share3.8%3.9%3.8%
Brand strength (out of 100)646465
Productive capacity (room nights)29,47629,45029,926
Capacity utilization rate79.5%84.4%82.7%
Labour productivity (room nights per worker)509540538
Operations workforce (people)464646
Morale (out of 100)616164
Labour turnover (annual rate)21.0%21.3%18.7%
Profit before interest and tax€593k€672k€591k
Profit margin13.6%14.8%13.0%
Profit for the period€376k€436k€374k
Net cash (cash less overdraft)€883k€1.40m€1.88m
Loans (non-current liabilities)€2.20m€2.20m€2.20m
Emissions per unit (kg CO₂e per room night)38.0 kg38.0 kg38.0 kg
Total emissions (tonnes CO₂e)890 t945 t940 t
Exhibit 7

The market in 2026

Source: Simulated data

The figures are simulated. Isola Brezza sells about 600,000 room nights a year across hotels, resorts and rentals, growing about 3% a year. Guests booking directly compare reviews, the setting and, increasingly, a hotel's footprint; tour operators compare price. Mareluce's share is 3.8%.

Seller Share of the market Typical price Position
Hotel Mareluce (fictional) 3.8% €183 Average across its channels
Grand Hotel Brezza (fictional) 6.0% €290 Luxury hotel in the island's harbour town
Club Sole resort (fictional) 14.0% €150 Large all-inclusive resort, sold mostly through tour operators
Holiday apartments and rentals (various, fictional) 38.0% €120 Self-catering, booked online
All other sellers 38.2% Various Smaller firms
  • More guests say they choose hotels partly on their environmental record, and certification schemes are spreading.
  • Tour operators are buying larger blocks from fewer hotels, at lower prices.
  • Small islands are putting limits and levies on water and energy use in the peak season.
The whole market: 655,636 room nights a year, growing about 3.0% a year. Shares by volume.
Exhibit 8

What happened before the first decision

Source: Simulated data
  1. 2024 A good season. The hotel sells about 23,400 room nights, four in five of its rooms, and the family takes 30% of the profit as dividends.
  2. 2025 The tour operator enlarges its block to 10,500 room nights at €126, and food prices rise 4%.
  3. 2026 Diesel and electricity rise 12%, pay rises 3%, and a new resort opens across the island, pulling prices down about 3%.

Section 03: The simulation

4 rounds, one year each, with an event between rounds that the board does not control.

Take a seat at the table

The decisions belong to the whole board. Your seat decides which measures you watch most closely and what you are judged on at the end. Each director's goals pull a different way; no path through this simulation meets every goal of every director.

Choose your role on the board

Judged on

  • Profit after tax of at least €2.0m over the four seasons
  • Brand strength of 66 or more in 2030
  • Emissions below the council's limit of 25 kg per room night

Judged on

  • Return on capital employed of 8% or more in 2030
  • Gearing of 45% or less in 2030
  • Never go over the overdraft limit

Judged on

  • Brand strength of 68 or more in 2030
  • An average price of €195 or more per room night in 2030
  • A market share no smaller than in 2026

Judged on

  • Never more than 92% full over the season
  • Emissions of 20 kg per room night or less in 2030
  • At least 540 room nights per member of staff in 2030

Judged on

  • Morale of 62 or more in 2030
  • Labour turnover never above 20% a year
  • At least 46 staff in the 2030 season

This is the casebook version of the simulation: every round and its options, what can happen between rounds, and one path narrated with the engine's figures. With JavaScript you can take a seat at the board and decide each round yourself.

Round 1 · 2027 What kind of hotel?

This is a decision for marketing.

The tour operator's contract is up for renewal, and it wants 14,000 room nights a year for three years at €128, nearly two in three of the hotel's busiest-season rooms. A sustainability certifier has shown Giulia what it would take to qualify. And the bank's relationship manager has suggested simply cutting costs. The board must decide what kind of hotel Mareluce is going to be.

Which direction should Mareluce take?

Around the table

  • Chief executive

    I want a hotel that is still full and still welcome on this island in twenty years. I do not want to choose between them if I can help it, and I do not want to pretend we have not chosen if we must.

  • Finance director

    The bigger block is guaranteed income at a fair price; in a bad year that matters. Certification costs money up front and gives up guaranteed rooms for guests we hope will come. Cost cutting is the quickest gain, and the least certain to last.

  • Marketing director Leads this decision

    Every room we give the tour operator at €128 is a room a returning family cannot book at €225. Our direct guests pay more, come back and tell their friends. Certification gives them another reason to choose us.

  • Operations director

    At 14,000 block nights we will be full from June to September: more laundry, more water, more crowding round the pool. The retrofit would cut our energy and water bills, and our diesel use, for good.

  • HR director

    A fuller hotel needs more staff, and we already struggle to find and keep good people for the peak. If we cut costs, cut them somewhere other than the people guests see.

The options

  1. Expand the tour-operator block

    Sign a three-year contract for 14,000 room nights a year at €128, and hire six more staff for the season.

    What it involves

    • Tour operator block: price to €128 a room night.
    • Tour operator block: volume to 14,000 room nights a year.
    • Hire 6 people.
  2. Reposition as an eco-certified hotel

    Halve the block to 6,000 room nights, invest €750k in solar hot water, water recycling and insulation, seek certification and raise direct prices 6%.

    What it involves

    • Direct and online bookings: price up 6% a room night.
    • Tour operator block: volume to 6,000 room nights a year.
    • Marketing spend up €80k a year.
    • Overheads up €60k a year.
    • Invest €750k in solar hot water, water recycling and insulation: in use this year, written off over 12 years.
    • Once in use: energy down 25% a room night.
    • Once in use: other inputs down €2 a room night.
    • Once in use: emissions for each room night down 30%.
  3. Keep the mix, and cut costs

    Renew the block at its present size, outsource the laundry, switch energy contract and defer some maintenance.

    What it involves

    • Materials down €3 a room night.
    • Energy down 5% a room night.
    • Maintenance down €40k a year.

What can happen before the next round

Whatever the board decided

Fuel and electricity prices rise sharply

Diesel prices rise, and the island's electricity tariff with them: energy costs about 30% more per room night from the 2028 season. Hotels that use less energy feel it less.

  • Energy up 30% a room night.

Round 2 · 2028 Who serves the guests?

This is a decision for human resources.

Every spring Mareluce recruits for the season, and every year it finds it harder. Island families want secure work; seasonal workers from the mainland want somewhere affordable to live. Service in the peak weeks is the first thing reviews mention. The board must decide how to staff the hotel from now on.

How should Mareluce staff the season?

Around the table

  • Chief executive

    Guests remember people, not policies. I want the staff who serve them to want to be here.

  • Finance director

    Agency staff cost less per hour and nothing in the winter. Year-round contracts and training cost more, and pay back only if people stay and service improves. A profit share costs money only in a good year.

  • Marketing director

    Our reviews rise and fall with service. A guest who is remembered by name books again; one served by a stranger who leaves in July does not.

  • Operations director

    New staff need time to learn the hotel. With high turnover we spend every June training people who will be gone by September.

  • HR director Leads this decision

    Island staff come back year after year if we give them a reason to. Agency workers are cheaper and do not stay. Housing is the biggest reason mainland staff turn us down.

The options

  1. Staff the season through an agency

    Fill most seasonal posts through a staffing agency, at lower cost per hour and with no commitment beyond the season.

    What it involves

    • Labour time for each room night up 5%.
    • Pay down 6%.
  2. Hire locally and train year-round

    Offer islanders year-round contracts, raise pay 5%, and train every new member of staff before the season.

    What it involves

    • Pay up 5%.
    • Training: €60k this year.
    • Next year: productivity up 4%.
  3. A profit share and staff housing

    Share 6% of profit before interest and tax with the staff, and rent apartments in the village for seasonal workers.

    What it involves

    • Overheads up €80k a year.
    • Staff share 6% of profit before interest and tax.

What can happen before the next round

If the hotel was repositioned as eco-certified

A dry summer, and the hotel recycles its water

The island has its driest summer in years and the council restricts water use. Mareluce's recycling covers most of its needs, so it trucks in only a little water, at a small extra cost per room night.

  • Other inputs up €1 a room night.

Otherwise

A dry summer, and water by the truckload

The island has its driest summer in years and the council restricts water use. Mareluce must truck water in at about €6 a room night, and the pool closes for six weeks at the height of the season.

  • Brand strength −2 points at once.
  • Other inputs up €6 a room night.

Round 3 · 2029 Power for the hotel

This is a decision for operations.

The hotel's electricity comes from the island grid, which is fed by diesel generators, backed by the hotel's own generator. Energy is now one of its largest costs, and the council has announced a levy, from 2030, on hotels that emit more than 25 kg of CO₂e per room night. The board must decide where the hotel's power comes from.

Where should Mareluce's power come from?

Around the table

  • Chief executive

    Energy is our biggest uncontrolled cost and our biggest footprint. I want a decision that settles both for a decade.

  • Finance director

    The solar farm is the largest investment we have made since the new wing, mostly borrowed. It pays for itself if energy stays expensive. The generators are cheap and buy us little. The tariff costs more every year and nothing up front.

  • Marketing director

    A hotel that runs on its own sunshine is a story guests tell their friends. A green tariff is a line in a brochure.

  • Operations director Leads this decision

    Solar with batteries would cover most of our daytime load and cut our diesel use by half. New generators burn less fuel, but still burn it.

  • HR director

    Whatever we choose, the people who maintain it will be ours to train.

The options

  1. Build a solar farm with batteries

    A solar farm and battery store on the hotel's land, €1.3m, mostly financed by a loan.

    What it involves

    • Borrow €1m at the bank’s rate for new loans.
    • Invest €1.30m in solar farm and batteries: in use this year, written off over 20 years.
    • Once in use: energy down 55% a room night.
    • Once in use: emissions for each room night down 45%.
    • Once in use: maintenance up €20k a year.
  2. Upgrade the diesel generators

    Replace the hotel's generator with a more efficient one, €350k from cash.

    What it involves

    • Invest €350k in upgraded diesel generators: in use this year, written off over 10 years.
    • Once in use: energy down 12% a room night.
    • Once in use: emissions for each room night down 8%.
  3. Buy certified renewable electricity

    Switch to a certified renewable tariff from the island's new solar cooperative, at a premium over the diesel tariff.

    What it involves

    • Energy up 12% a room night.
    • Emissions for each room night down 35%.

What can happen before the next round

If emissions per unit is at most 25 at the end of the round

The council's levy, and Mareluce is exempt

The council's levy on high-emission hotels takes effect in 2030. With emissions of the figure at the time kg per room night, Mareluce is below the limit, pays nothing and is named in the council's list of approved hotels.

  • Brand strength +1 points at once.

Otherwise

The council's levy, and Mareluce pays it

The council's levy on high-emission hotels takes effect in 2030. With emissions of the figure at the time kg per room night, Mareluce is above the limit and pays €3 for every room night it sells.

  • Other inputs up €3 a room night.

Round 4 · 2030 The hotel's next decade

This is a decision for the chief executive.

The family board meets before the 2030 season. The hotel can grow, give back to the island, or reward the family after a decade of reinvestment. Each is a claim on the same cash, and each says something about what the hotel is for.

What should Mareluce do with its next decade?

Around the table

  • Chief executive Leads this decision

    My parents never took much out. I want my children to inherit a hotel the island is glad of, and a business that can pay for its own future.

  • Finance director

    The villas earn the highest prices on the island and need a large loan. The community programme costs money every year. A dividend costs the business cash and nothing else.

  • Marketing director

    Twenty eco-villas would put us at the top of the market. Local sourcing and staff housing are what guests and the council will talk about.

  • Operations director

    The villas add twenty units to clean, light and supply. Local sourcing means smaller deliveries and more suppliers to manage, and food that has not crossed the sea.

  • HR director

    Staff housing would end our hardest recruitment problem. A dividend in a year of rising pay demands would be noticed.

The options

  1. Build twenty eco-villas

    Twenty eco-villas on the hillside, €2.4m with a €1.8m loan, sold at premium prices from this season.

    What it involves

    • New: Eco-villa stays, 3,000 room nights a year at €320, paid in 5 days, with an extra €10 of cost for each room night.
    • Borrow €1.80m at the bank’s rate for new loans.
    • Invest €2.40m in twenty eco-villas: in use this year, written off over 30 years.
    • Once in use: plant capacity up 4,280 room nights a year.
  2. Invest in the island

    Buy food from island farms and fishers, and fund housing for island staff, at about €60k a year plus a higher cost per room night.

    What it involves

    • Materials up €2 a room night.
    • Emissions for each room night down 5%.
    • Overheads up €60k a year.
  3. Pay the family a special dividend

    A special dividend of €500k to the Serra family, on top of the usual payout.

    What it involves

    • Pay a dividend of €500k.

One path, narrated: certification, island staff, solar, investing in the island

This is one path through the four seasons, chosen to show how the decisions interact, not as the right answer. At the end of 2026 the hotel runs at 82.7% of capacity, emits 38.0 kg kg of CO₂e per room night, and earns operating profit of €591k.

Round 1 · 2027: Reposition as an eco-certified hotel

Round 1 of 4 · 2027 · The board chose: Reposition as an eco-certified hotel

Fewer guests, paying more, for a smaller footprint

The retrofit is finished before the season and the hotel is certified in June. Emissions fall to 26.6 kg kg per room night (−⁠11.4 kg), and guests who choose hotels on their footprint start to find Mareluce. With half the block gone, occupancy falls: the hotel sells 21,470 room nights at 71.9% of capacity, at an average €207. Operating profit, after the certification costs and the relaunch, is €581k.

How the decision travelled
  1. Marketing Units sold −⁠3,273, worse Brand +⁠4, better
  2. Operations Utilization −⁠10.7 pts Output per worker −⁠71, worse
  3. People Morale −⁠2, worse Labour turnover +⁠1.2 pts, worse
  4. Finance Net cash −⁠€139k, worse Acid test +⁠2.41, better
  5. Sustainability Carbon per unit −⁠11.4 kg, better
Marketing
Revenue
€4.45m −⁠€82k Down, worse
Units sold
21,470 −⁠3,273 Down, worse
Market share
3.2% −⁠0.6 pts Down, worse
Brand
69 +⁠4 Up, better
  • Demand fell 13.2% to 21,470 room nights. In the open channels, price against competitors took off about 7.8%, brand strength added about 5.0%, market growth added about 3.0% and the lower carbon footprint added about 9.0%.
  • Tour operator block took 6,000 room nights under contract at €126.
  • Revenue €4.45m at an average €207 a room night; market share 3.2%.
  • Brand strength went from 64.6 to 68.8: marketing +⁠0.9, events and decisions +⁠3.0 and service from staff +⁠0.3.
Operations
Utilization
71.9% −⁠10.7 pts Down
Lost sales
0 No change
Output per worker
467 −⁠71 Down, worse
  • The business made 21,470 room nights, using 71.9% of productive capacity.
  • Staff had work for 81% of their normal hours: paid time the business could not use.
  • Output per worker: 467 room nights.
  • Solar hot water, water recycling and insulation came into use.
People
Workforce
46 No change
Morale
63 −⁠2 Down, worse
Labour turnover
19.8% +⁠1.2 pts Up, worse
Staff costs
€1.28m No change
  • 9 left and were replaced; the workforce ended the year at 46.
  • Labour turnover ran at 19.8% a year; recruiting and inducting new starters cost €23k.
  • Morale went from 64.1 to 62.6: drifting back towards normal −⁠1.5 and idle time and job worries −⁠0.1.
Finance
Operating profit
€581k −⁠€9.6k Down, worse
Profit after tax
€366k −⁠€7.3k Down, worse
Net cash
€1.74m −⁠€139k Down, worse
Acid test
21.79 +⁠2.41 Up, better
  • Profit before interest and tax €581k (13.1% of revenue); after €99k of interest and €116k of tax, profit for the year was €366k.
  • Net cash went from €1.88m to €1.74m: profit +⁠€366k, depreciation added back +⁠€283k, debtors +⁠€87k, stock +⁠€7.5k, creditors −⁠€23k, investment −⁠€750k and dividends −⁠€110k.
  • Current ratio 22.12, acid test 21.79, gearing 31.6%.
Sustainability
Carbon per unit
26.6 kg −⁠11.4 kg Down, better
Emissions
571 t −⁠369 t Down, better
  • Emissions 571 tonnes of CO₂e: 26.6 kg for each room night (−⁠11.4 kg).
How people reacted
  • Returning guests Positive Like the quieter summer and the solar panels on the roof.
  • The tour operator Negative Takes its other rooms to Club Sole.
  • The sustainability certifier Positive Certifies the hotel, and will audit it every year.
The theory behind it

Repositioning towards a niche of guests who value sustainability uses differentiation and premium pricing. Corporate social responsibility can be a source of competitive advantage, but it costs money before it earns any, and claims must be backed by evidence to avoid accusations of greenwashing.

How the model treated this round
  • Direct and online bookings: price up 6% a room night.
  • Tour operator block: volume to 6,000 room nights a year.
  • Marketing spend up €80k a year.
  • Brand strength +3 points at once.
  • Overheads up €60k a year.
  • Invest €750k in solar hot water, water recycling and insulation: in use this year, written off over 12 years.
  • Once in use: energy down 25% a room night.
  • Once in use: other inputs down €2 a room night.
  • Once in use: emissions for each room night down 30%.

Round 2 · 2028: Hire locally and train year-round

Round 2 of 4 · 2028 · The board chose: Hire locally and train year-round

Staff who come back, and guests who notice

Islanders take the year-round contracts and the training. Staff costs rise to €1.34m, but morale reaches 73 (+⁠10) and labour turnover falls to 11.9% a year. Brand strength is 73. Operating profit is €639k, and the training pays off in next season's productivity.

How the decision travelled
  1. People Morale +⁠10, better Labour turnover −⁠8.0 pts, better
  2. Finance Operating profit +⁠€57k, better Net cash +⁠€572k, better
  3. Marketing Units sold +⁠1,180, better Brand +⁠4, better
  4. Operations Utilization +⁠3.7 pts Output per worker +⁠26, better
Marketing
Revenue
€4.73m +⁠€281k Up, better
Units sold
22,650 +⁠1,180 Up, better
Market share
3.3% +⁠0.1 pts Up, better
Brand
73 +⁠4 Up, better
  • Demand rose 5.5% to 22,650 room nights. In the open channels, brand strength added about 4.5% and market growth added about 3.0%.
  • Tour operator block took 6,000 room nights under contract at €126.
  • Revenue €4.73m at an average €209 a room night; market share 3.3%.
  • Brand strength went from 68.8 to 72.8: marketing +⁠1.7, events and decisions +⁠1.0 and service from staff +⁠1.3.
Operations
Utilization
75.6% +⁠3.7 pts Up
Lost sales
0 No change
Output per worker
492 +⁠26 Up, better
  • The business made 22,650 room nights, using 75.6% of productive capacity.
  • Staff had work for 80% of their normal hours: paid time the business could not use.
  • Output per worker: 492 room nights.
People
Workforce
46 No change
Morale
73 +⁠10 Up, better
Labour turnover
11.9% −⁠8.0 pts Down, better
Staff costs
€1.34m +⁠€64k Up
  • 5 left and were replaced; the workforce ended the year at 46.
  • Labour turnover ran at 11.9% a year; recruiting and inducting new starters cost €13k.
  • Morale went from 62.6 to 72.5: drifting back towards normal −⁠0.9, how the change was received +⁠5.0, pay +⁠6.0 and idle time and job worries −⁠0.1.
Finance
Operating profit
€639k +⁠€57k Up, better
Profit after tax
€410k +⁠€44k Up, better
Net cash
€2.31m +⁠€572k Up, better
Acid test
25.69 +⁠3.90 Up, better
  • Profit before interest and tax €639k (13.5% of revenue); after €99k of interest and €129k of tax, profit for the year was €410k.
  • Costs of change in the year: training €60k.
  • Net cash went from €1.74m to €2.31m: profit +⁠€410k, depreciation added back +⁠€283k, debtors −⁠€3.9k, stock −⁠€3.0k, creditors +⁠€9.1k and dividends −⁠€123k.
  • Current ratio 26.02, acid test 25.69, gearing 30.3%.
Sustainability
Carbon per unit
26.6 kg No change
Emissions
602 t +⁠31 t Up, worse
  • Emissions 602 tonnes of CO₂e: 26.6 kg for each room night.
How people reacted
  • Island staff and seasonal workers Positive Have secure work on their own island.
  • Isola Brezza council Positive Praises a business that keeps young islanders on the island.
  • The bank Mixed Asks when higher costs turn into higher income.
The theory behind it

Investing in people (secure contracts, fair pay, training) raises morale and cuts labour turnover. In Herzberg's terms it removes sources of dissatisfaction and adds motivators such as growth and recognition. Its return comes through service and retention, and takes time.

How the model treated this round
  • Before the round (Fuel and electricity prices rise sharply): Energy up 30% a room night.
  • Brand strength +1 points at once.
  • Pay up 5%.
  • Training: €60k this year.
  • Morale +5 points at the announcement.
  • Next year: productivity up 4%.

Round 3 · 2029: Build a solar farm with batteries

Round 3 of 4 · 2029 · The board chose: Build a solar farm with batteries

The hotel makes most of its own power

The solar farm runs from the start of the season. Energy costs fall by more than half and emissions to 14.6 kg kg per room night (−⁠12.0 kg). Loans rise to €3.20m and gearing to 36.0%. Operating profit is €1.28m.

How the decision travelled
  1. Operations Utilization +⁠8.2 pts Output per worker +⁠53, better
  2. People Morale −⁠4, worse Labour turnover +⁠3.6 pts, worse
  3. Finance Operating profit +⁠€638k, better Net cash +⁠€567k, better
  4. Sustainability Carbon per unit −⁠12.0 kg, better
  5. Marketing Units sold +⁠2,452, better Brand +⁠2, better
Marketing
Revenue
€5.31m +⁠€585k Up, better
Units sold
25,102 +⁠2,452 Up, better
Market share
3.5% +⁠0.2 pts Up, better
Brand
75 +⁠2 Up, better
  • Demand rose 10.8% to 25,102 room nights. In the open channels, brand strength added about 2.5%, market growth added about 3.0% and the lower carbon footprint added about 8.7%.
  • Tour operator block took 6,000 room nights under contract at €126.
  • Revenue €5.31m at an average €212 a room night; market share 3.5%.
  • Brand strength went from 72.8 to 75.1: marketing +⁠1.5 and service from staff +⁠0.8.
Operations
Utilization
83.8% +⁠8.2 pts Up
Lost sales
0 No change
Output per worker
546 +⁠53 Up, better
  • The business made 25,102 room nights, using 83.8% of productive capacity.
  • Output per worker: 546 room nights.
  • Trained, returning staff work faster and better in their second season.
  • Solar farm and batteries came into use.
People
Workforce
46 No change
Morale
68 −⁠4 Down, worse
Labour turnover
15.5% +⁠3.6 pts Up, worse
Staff costs
€1.34m No change
  • 7 left and were replaced; the workforce ended the year at 46.
  • Labour turnover ran at 15.5% a year; recruiting and inducting new starters cost €18k.
  • Morale went from 72.5 to 68.1: drifting back towards normal −⁠4.4.
Finance
Operating profit
€1.28m +⁠€638k Up, better
Profit after tax
€895k +⁠€485k Up, better
Net cash
€2.88m +⁠€567k Up, better
Acid test
31.16 +⁠5.47 Up, better
  • Profit before interest and tax €1.28m (24.0% of revenue); after €99k of interest and €283k of tax, profit for the year was €895k.
  • Net cash went from €2.31m to €2.88m: profit +⁠€895k, depreciation added back +⁠€248k, debtors −⁠€8.0k, creditors +⁠€1.4k, investment −⁠€1.30m, new borrowing +⁠€1m and dividends −⁠€268k.
  • Current ratio 31.49, acid test 31.16, gearing 36.0%.
Sustainability
Carbon per unit
14.6 kg −⁠12.0 kg Down, better
Emissions
367 t −⁠235 t Down, better
  • Emissions 367 tonnes of CO₂e: 14.6 kg for each room night (−⁠12.0 kg).
How people reacted
  • Isola Brezza council Positive Holds the hotel up as an example.
  • Returning guests Positive Ask for a tour of the panels.
  • The bank Mixed Lends, and watches gearing.
The theory behind it

Investment appraisal compares the cost of the solar farm with the energy savings it brings over its life. Payback and the average rate of return judge it on cash; for HL, net present value allows for the timing of the savings. Lower emissions are a benefit that the cash figures alone do not show.

How the model treated this round
  • Before the round (A dry summer, and the hotel recycles its water): Other inputs up €1 a room night.
  • Borrow €1m at the bank’s rate for new loans.
  • Invest €1.30m in solar farm and batteries: in use this year, written off over 20 years.
  • Once in use: energy down 55% a room night.
  • Once in use: emissions for each room night down 45%.
  • Once in use: maintenance up €20k a year.

Round 4 · 2030: Invest in the island

Round 4 of 4 · 2030 · The board chose: Invest in the island

The hotel spends more of its money on the island

Island farms and fishers supply the kitchen and the staff housing fund opens. Each room night costs more to serve, but brand strength reaches 81 (+⁠6) and morale 69. Emissions fall to 13.9 kg kg per room night. Operating profit is €1.54m.

How the decision travelled
  1. Marketing Units sold +⁠1,980, better Brand +⁠6, better
  2. Operations Utilization +⁠6.6 pts Output per worker +⁠43, better
  3. People Labour turnover −⁠0.9 pts, better
  4. Finance Operating profit +⁠€264k, better Net cash +⁠€989k, better
  5. Sustainability Carbon per unit −⁠0.7 kg, better
Marketing
Revenue
€5.78m +⁠€472k Up, better
Units sold
27,082 +⁠1,980 Up, better
Market share
3.7% +⁠0.2 pts Up, better
Brand
81 +⁠6 Up, better
  • Demand rose 7.9% to 27,082 room nights. In the open channels, brand strength added about 6.6% and market growth added about 3.0%.
  • Tour operator block took 6,000 room nights under contract at €126.
  • Revenue €5.78m at an average €214 a room night; market share 3.7%.
  • Brand strength went from 75.1 to 81.3: marketing +⁠1.3, events and decisions +⁠4.0 and service from staff +⁠0.9.
Operations
Utilization
90.4% +⁠6.6 pts Up
Lost sales
0 No change
Output per worker
589 +⁠43 Up, better
  • The business made 27,082 room nights, using 90.4% of productive capacity.
  • Output per worker: 589 room nights.
People
Workforce
46 No change
Morale
69 +⁠1 Up, better
Labour turnover
14.6% −⁠0.9 pts Down, better
Staff costs
€1.34m No change
  • 7 left and were replaced; the workforce ended the year at 46.
  • Labour turnover ran at 14.6% a year; recruiting and inducting new starters cost €18k.
  • Morale went from 68.1 to 69.3: drifting back towards normal −⁠2.8 and how the change was received +⁠4.0.
Finance
Operating profit
€1.54m +⁠€264k Up, better
Profit after tax
€1.06m +⁠€162k Up, better
Net cash
€3.87m +⁠€989k Up, better
Acid test
36.72 +⁠5.56 Up, better
  • Profit before interest and tax €1.54m (26.6% of revenue); after €149k of interest and €334k of tax, profit for the year was €1.06m.
  • Net cash went from €2.88m to €3.87m: profit +⁠€1.06m, depreciation added back +⁠€248k, debtors −⁠€6.5k, stock −⁠€4.1k, creditors +⁠€12k and dividends −⁠€317k.
  • Current ratio 37.05, acid test 36.72, gearing 33.3%.
Sustainability
Carbon per unit
13.9 kg −⁠0.7 kg Down, better
Emissions
376 t +⁠9 t Up, worse
  • Emissions 376 tonnes of CO₂e: 13.9 kg for each room night (−⁠0.7 kg).
How people reacted
  • Isola Brezza council Positive Names the hotel a partner of the island.
  • Island staff and seasonal workers Positive Have homes they can afford.
  • Giulia Serra and the Serra family Positive Accept a lower margin for a hotel they are proud of.
The theory behind it

Corporate social responsibility goes beyond what the law requires, and spends shareholders' money on other stakeholders. It can strengthen the brand and staff commitment; whether it pays depends on whether customers and staff value it.

How the model treated this round
  • Before the round (The council's levy, and Mareluce is exempt): Brand strength +1 points at once.
  • Brand strength +3 points at once.
  • Materials up €2 a room night.
  • Emissions for each room night down 5%.
  • Overheads up €60k a year.
  • Morale +4 points at the announcement.

By 2030 operating profit is €1.54m, emissions are 13.9 kg kg per room night, brand strength is 81 and morale 69. This path earned less than the others in its first season and more in its last: the debrief compares it with the paths that kept the tour operator's block.

The dashboard at the end of this path

  • Revenue

    €5.78m

    Change from 2029: +⁠€472k Up, better

    Sales revenue, 2024 to 2030Sales revenue was €4.37m in 2024 and rose to €5.78m in 2030.
  • Operating profit

    €1.54m

    Change from 2029: +⁠€264k Up, better

    Profit before interest and tax, 2024 to 2030Profit before interest and tax was €593k in 2024 and rose to €1.54m in 2030. It ranged from €581k to €1.54m.
  • Net cash

    €3.87m

    Change from 2029: +⁠€989k Up, better

    Net cash (cash less overdraft), 2024 to 2030Net cash (cash less overdraft) was €883k in 2024 and rose to €3.87m in 2030.
  • Utilization

    90.4%

    Change from 2029: +⁠6.6 pts Up

    Capacity utilization rate, 2024 to 2030Capacity utilization rate was 79.5% in 2024 and rose to 90.4% in 2030. It ranged from 71.9% to 90.4%.
  • Average price

    €214

    Change from 2029: +⁠€1.97 Up

    Average price per unit, 2024 to 2030Average price per unit was €186 in 2024 and rose to €214 in 2030. It ranged from €183 to €214.
  • Brand

    81out of 100

    Change from 2029: +⁠6 Up, better

    Brand strength, 2024 to 2030Brand strength was 64 in 2024 and rose to 81 in 2030.
  • Morale

    69out of 100

    Change from 2029: +⁠1 Up, better

    Morale, 2024 to 2030Morale was 61 in 2024 and rose to 69 in 2030. It ranged from 61 to 73.
  • Labour turnover

    14.6%

    Change from 2029: −⁠0.9 pts Down, better

    Labour turnover (annual rate), 2024 to 2030Labour turnover (annual rate) was 21.0% in 2024 and fell to 14.6% in 2030. It ranged from 11.9% to 21.3%.
  • Carbon per unit

    13.9 kgCO₂e per room night

    Change from 2029: −⁠0.7 kg Down, better

    Emissions per unit, 2024 to 2030Emissions per unit was 38.0 kg in 2024 and fell to 13.9 kg in 2030.
  • Market share

    3.7%

    Change from 2029: +⁠0.2 pts Up, better

    Market share, 2024 to 2030Market share was 3.8% in 2024 and fell to 3.7% in 2030. It ranged from 3.2% to 3.9%.

How each director's goals came out on this path

Chief executive: 3 of 3 goals met
  • Met Profit after tax of at least €2.0m over the four seasons €2.73m
  • Met Brand strength of 66 or more in 2030 81
  • Met Emissions below the council's limit of 25 kg per room night 13.9 kg
Finance director: 3 of 3 goals met
  • Met Return on capital employed of 8% or more in 2030 16.0%
  • Met Gearing of 45% or less in 2030 33.3%
  • Met Never go over the overdraft limit Never over the limit
Marketing director: 2 of 3 goals met
  • Met Brand strength of 68 or more in 2030 81
  • Met An average price of €195 or more per room night in 2030 €214
  • Missed A market share no smaller than in 2026 −⁠0.1 pts
Operations director: 3 of 3 goals met
  • Met Never more than 92% full over the season 90.4%
  • Met Emissions of 20 kg per room night or less in 2030 13.9 kg
  • Met At least 540 room nights per member of staff in 2030 589
HR director: 3 of 3 goals met
  • Met Morale of 62 or more in 2030 69
  • Met Labour turnover never above 20% a year 19.8%
  • Met At least 46 staff in the 2030 season 46 people

The board memo

The 2030 season is over. Write to the Serra family board as the director whose seat you took: what Mareluce should do in the next decade, on the evidence of the last four seasons, and how it should balance profit against the island it depends on.

  1. Recommendation. One or two sentences: the hotel's direction for the next decade.
  2. The evidence. The figures that matter most, including profit, the brand and the footprint, and what they show.
  3. Trade-offs and risks. Where profit and sustainability pulled apart, and how you would weigh them.
  4. Stakeholders. The family, guests, staff, the tour operator and the island: who gains and who loses?
  5. What would change your mind. The figure or event that would make you recommend something else.
  6. The first ninety days. Three things you would do first, in order.

Write it on paper or in a document; with JavaScript the simulation gives you a form for it, keeps it on this device and lets you print, copy or download it.

Section 04: The debrief

What happened, the theory behind it, and what the different paths teach.

The debrief opens when the board has made its last decision, so that the simulation's surprises stay surprises.

Profit and sustainability pulled apart in the first season and came back together later. Repositioning cost the guaranteed block and the money for the retrofit, so the eco-certified hotel earned less in 2027 than the full one. Then fuel prices, a drought and the council's levy each cost the high-footprint hotel more than the low-footprint one, and the brand built by certification and island staff kept direct bookings rising. That is a feature of this simulation's events, not a law: in a world of cheap fuel and plentiful water the full hotel would have kept its lead. No path meets every director's goals, because occupancy, price, footprint, jobs and returns pull against each other.

The theory behind it

HL Some of the theory below is HL only, and is hidden while you are viewing SL content.

Objectives, CSR and stakeholders

A hotel's objectives can include profit, growth and ethical objectives at once, and they conflict. Corporate social responsibility spends money on stakeholders beyond the shareholders. The Serra family, the guests, the staff, the tour operator and the council want different things, and each round favours some of them over others.

1.3 Business objectives 1.4 Stakeholders

Positioning, niche and mass markets

The tour operator's block is mass-market positioning: volume at a lower price. Eco-certification is a niche position: fewer guests who pay more for a difference they value. A position map of price against footprint would place Mareluce's options far apart.

4.2 Marketing planning

Price, people, process and physical evidence

In a service business the marketing mix extends to people (the staff guests meet), processes (how a stay is delivered) and physical evidence (the rooms, the pool, the solar panels guests can see). Crowding, tired rooms and changing staff each weakened the brand in the simulation; certification and trained island staff strengthened it.

4.5 The seven Ps of the marketing mix

Investment appraisal for sustainability

The retrofit and the solar farm can be judged by payback and average rate of return on their energy savings, and for HL by net present value. Their benefits also include protection from fuel prices, droughts and levies, which appraisals based on today's prices leave out.

3.8 Investment appraisal

Motivation and service

Agency staff, island contracts with training, and a profit share with housing are different mixes of financial and non-financial rewards. In a service business the effect on morale reaches the customer.

2.4 Motivation and demotivation

Capacity utilization in a hotel HL

Occupancy is a hotel's capacity utilization. Above about nine in ten rooms, crowding and strain begin to cost reviews; well below it, fixed costs are spread thinly. The right occupancy depends on the price of each room filled.

5.6 Production planning

What different paths teach

The figures are the engine's, for each path played from the start. Goals met are out of each director's goals.

Named paths compared
PathProfit after tax, all roundsOperating profit, finalNet cash, finalBrand, finalMorale, finalMarket share, finalCarbon per unit, finalGoals met
The green pathReposition as an eco-certified hotel, then hire locally and train year-round, then build a solar farm with batteries, then invest in the island€2.73m€1.54m€3.87m81693.7%13.9 kgCEO 3 of 3 FD 3 of 3 MD 2 of 3 OD 3 of 3 HRD 3 of 3
The full-house pathExpand the tour-operator block, then staff the season through an agency, then upgrade the diesel generators, then pay the family a special dividend€1.52m€509k€2.79m55503.9%35.0 kgCEO 0 of 3 FD 2 of 3 MD 1 of 3 OD 1 of 3 HRD 1 of 3
The careful-cost pathKeep the mix, and cut costs, then hire locally and train year-round, then buy certified renewable electricity, then build twenty eco-villas€2.74m€1.56m€3.97m65584.3%24.7 kgCEO 2 of 3 FD 3 of 3 MD 2 of 3 OD 1 of 3 HRD 1 of 3
The full-and-green pathExpand the tour-operator block, then hire locally and train year-round, then build a solar farm with batteries, then invest in the island€1.97m€767k€3.71m67694.1%19.9 kgCEO 2 of 3 FD 3 of 3 MD 1 of 3 OD 2 of 3 HRD 3 of 3

The green path

Certification, island staff, solar and investment in the island. It earns the least of these paths in its first season and close to the most by its last, with the strongest brand and the smallest footprint.

The full-house path

The bigger block, agency staff, a cheaper generator and a dividend. It fills the most rooms and spends the least, and it pays the drought, the levy and the crowding in its reviews.

The careful-cost path

Cost cuts, island staff, a green tariff and the villas. It shows that a hotel can cut its footprint without repositioning, and that growth funded by debt raises gearing.

The full-and-green path

The bigger block, with island staff, solar and investment in the island. It keeps the guaranteed income and still cuts emissions, but the crowded peak and the drought cost it more than the green path paid for its certification.

Every possible board, compared

There are 81 paths through the 4 rounds. The table shows the lowest and highest final figure any of them reaches. Paths that meet every goal of one director: chief executive 28, finance director 63, marketing director 6, operations director 10, HR director 20. Paths that meet every goal of all five: 0.

The range of final figures across every path
MeasureBefore round 1Lowest finalHighest final
Sales revenue€4.53m€4.65m€7.17m
Profit before interest and tax€591k€505k€2.50m
Net cash (cash less overdraft)€1.88m€2.74m€4.26m
Capacity utilization rate82.7%82.1%100.0%
Average price per unit€183€178€230
Brand strength655581
Morale644369
Labour turnover (annual rate)18.7%14.5%29.9%
Emissions per unit38.0 kg13.9 kg35.0 kg
Market share3.8%3.2%4.6%

Misconceptions this tests

  • The claim A full hotel is a profitable hotel.

    The correction

    Occupancy counts rooms, not money. Filling rooms at a discount can push out guests who would have paid full price, and crowding can cost future bookings.

  • The claim Sustainability is always a cost to profit.

    The correction

    Here it cost money first and then saved it, because energy, water and regulation cost a high-footprint hotel more. Whether it pays depends on prices, events and what customers value.

  • The claim Sustainability always pays.

    The correction

    In this simulation the events favoured the low-footprint hotel. With cheap fuel, plentiful water and no levy, the full hotel would have kept its profit lead. Claims about sustainability must be tested, not assumed.

Exam link and practice

Paper 1 and Paper 2 questions on objectives and stakeholders ask candidates to analyse conflict between stakeholders and to evaluate CSR in context; marketing questions ask about positioning and the extended marketing mix for services. Mareluce gives a context for each. HL candidates can extend the analysis with capacity utilization and dynamic pricing.

Source: Original practice question These are the platform's own practice questions, written for this scenario; they are not IB questions.

HL One or more questions are HL only, and are hidden while you are viewing SL content.

  1. Explain one advantage and one disadvantage for Hotel Mareluce of selling a block of rooms to a tour operator. [4 marks] Explain
  2. Analyse the conflict between two of Hotel Mareluce's stakeholders over the tour operator's contract. [6 marks] Analyse
  3. Discuss whether Hotel Mareluce should reposition itself as an eco-certified hotel. [10 marks] Discuss
  4. Evaluate the importance of people, processes and physical evidence in Hotel Mareluce's marketing mix. [10 marks] Evaluate
  5. Using the board pack, calculate Hotel Mareluce's capacity utilization rate in 2026, and comment on your answer. [4 marks] Calculate HL

Key terms

How the figures were made

Hotel Mareluce, Isola Brezza, the tour operator, the competitors and every person in this scenario are fictional, and every figure is simulated. A unit is one room night: a room sold for one night, with breakfast and dinner. The figures come from the Boardroom's model, stated in full on the Boardroom's page; in a service business the model lets morale move the brand, because staff are part of the product. The seasons 2024 to 2026 are the model run forward from the start of 2024 with the changes listed in the history, so the board pack's statements cannot disagree with the simulation. The family takes 30% of each year's profit as dividends. Tax is a flat simulated 24% of positive profit; real tax rules are more complex.

How the Boardroom's model works: every mechanism and lag