Case file · Automobile

Quintanilla Autopartes

A family parts maker in Monterrey must choose one investment as the engines its products are made for start to disappear.

Source: Simulated data Fictional organization Advanced Updated 3 November 2026

The decision

Which investment should Quintanilla make, and which way of appraising it should the board trust?

Two thirds of Quintanilla's sales are parts that exist only because cars have combustion engines, and its customers expect to order far fewer of them each year. The board can afford one investment: rebuild a line to make battery-enclosure frames for a nearby carmaker's electric pickup, automate welding to make the combustion business as efficient as possible, or diversify into parts for farm machinery. Payback, the average rate of return and net present value do not agree on which is best, and the project with the highest value carries the most risk.

Organization
Quintanilla Autopartes
Sector
Automotive components (pressed and welded steel parts)
Location
Monterrey, Mexico
Size
One plant with two welding lines and a press shop, 420 employees
Legal form
Privately held company (S.A. de C.V.), owned by the Quintanilla family
Figures in
MXN (MX$), millions of Mexican pesos (MX$m)
Functions
Finance and accounts, Operations management, Strategy and management
For
IB DP SL, IB DP HL, Undergraduate, MBA
Key concepts
Change, Sustainability
Status
Fictional case. An invented organization. Every figure is simulated for teaching and checked for consistency.

Section 01: The story so far

Rodrigo Quintanilla started pressing exhaust brackets in a rented workshop in Apodaca, on the edge of Monterrey, in 1987. Today Quintanilla Autopartes employs 420 people in a plant of its own, making exhaust brackets, heat shields, fuel-tank straps and body stampings for two carmakers and a large parts supplier. Rodrigo's daughter, Ana Sofía, has run the company since 2018. The family owns all of it and has never sold a share.

Most of what Quintanilla makes exists only because cars have engines that burn fuel. Exhaust parts, heat shields and fuel-tank parts were two thirds of sales in 2025, and their sales have fallen in each of the last three years (Exhibit 4). The customers' own forecasts say that their orders for these parts will fall to 40% of the 2025 level by 2031 (Exhibit 6). Profit before interest and tax fell from MX$86.8m to MX$58.0m in 2025 (Exhibit 1).

Norvalia Motors, whose plant forty kilometres away buys more than half of Quintanilla's output, will build an electric pickup there from 2028. It needs a local supplier for the frames that hold the battery pack: large welded structures that must protect the cells in a crash, keep water out and be built to tight tolerances. Norvalia has invited Quintanilla to bid (Exhibit 8). Winning would mean rebuilding Line 2, retraining welders who have worked with steel all their lives, and borrowing more than the company ever has.

Two other projects are on the table. Héctor Salinas, the plant manager, wants to automate welding on both lines. The combustion market is shrinking, he argues, but rivals are leaving it faster, and the last efficient supplier will keep the orders that remain. Ana Sofía's brother, who sits on the board, has found a maker of tractors and farm implements, Agrimaq del Norte, that is looking for a supplier of frames and brackets. Each project would use most of the money the company can raise, so the board can choose only one (Exhibits 3 and 5).

Mónica Treviño, the finance director, has forecast the cash flows of each project, and the board meets in two weeks. Norvalia wants bids within six months. The board has always liked projects that pay back quickly, and Mónica suspects that the three methods she has been asked to use will not agree.

Section 02: The industry

How the industry works and what is changing in it, in general terms. The figures in this case are the business's own, and simulated.

Carmakers are moving from vehicles with combustion engines to electric ones, at a pace that differs from market to market and maker to maker, and that depends on regulation, the cost of batteries and what buyers choose. Parts that exist only in combustion vehicles, such as exhaust systems and fuel tanks, face falling demand over the coming decade, while electric vehicles need new parts, such as battery enclosures, cooling plates and high-voltage cabling.

Carmakers buy through tiers of suppliers. Large first-tier suppliers deliver complete systems; smaller firms supply parts to them or straight to the assembly plant. Contracts are usually awarded for the life of a vehicle programme, the volumes in them are forecasts rather than guarantees, and buyers expect prices to fall a little each year. Winning a new part means passing the carmaker's quality approval, which can take many months.

Many assembly plants work on just-in-time delivery, so suppliers of large, heavy parts are often expected to be close by. A battery enclosure is large, heavy and safety-critical, which calls for precise welding and sealing, often in aluminium rather than steel. Skills and equipment built for steel parts do not transfer automatically.

Section 03: The key challenge

Quintanilla's core products are in decline, and it must choose one investment that decides what kind of company it becomes. The project with the best forecast returns depends on one customer's volumes, which nobody can guarantee, and on skills the workforce does not yet have. The safest project makes the company more efficient at something the market is leaving. The third spreads the risk but barely earns what the money costs. The board has to decide which method of appraisal to trust, and how much risk a family company should take.

Section 04: Financial information

Sales fell by 5.0% in 2025 and the gross profit margin from 19.0% to 17.0%, as lower volumes of combustion parts spread the plant's fixed costs over less output. Profit before interest and tax fell by a third. The balance sheet is strong: borrowing is low and the company holds MX$84.0m of cash, so it can fund one project with a new bank loan. Exhibit 3 gives each project's forecast net cash flows, the figures the board will appraise.

Exhibit 1

Statement of profit or loss, years to 31 December (MX$m)

Source: Simulated data
Item 2024 2025
Sales revenue1,240.01,178.0
Cost of sales1,004.4978.0
Gross profit235.6200.0
Expenses148.8142.0
Profit before interest and tax86.858.0
Interest9.69.6
Profit before tax77.248.4
Tax23.214.5
Profit for the period54.033.9
Dividends20.015.0
Retained profit34.018.9

Tax is charged at 30% of profit before tax, rounded to one decimal place.

Source Simulated teaching data, from Quintanilla's accounts, set out in the layout the IB uses for a profit-making entity.
Exhibit 2

Extract from the statement of financial position at 31 December 2025 (MX$m)

Source: Simulated data
Item MX$m
Cash84.0
Bank loans (non-current)96.0
Total equity612.0
Capital employed708.0

Capital employed is non-current liabilities plus equity, as the IB defines it. The bank loans carry interest at 10% a year.

Source Simulated teaching data, from Quintanilla's accounts.
Exhibit 3

The three projects, forecast net cash flows by year (MX$m)

Source: Simulated data
Year A: battery-enclosure frames B: automated welding C: farm machinery parts
0 (2026)−180.0−90.0−120.0
1 (2027)12.030.014.0
2 (2028)28.028.020.0
3 (2029)42.024.024.0
4 (2030)50.019.026.0
5 (2031)54.014.026.0
6 (2032)54.08.026.0
7 (2033)50.026.0
8 (2034)44.026.0

Year 0 is 2026, when the money is spent. Net cash flows are the extra cash each project brings in, after its own running costs, in each year of its life; Project B's equipment lasts six years. Project A's figures assume Norvalia's forecast volumes and the renewal of its contract after the first five years. The board appraises projects at 10%, close to what the company pays to borrow. Discount factors at 10%, from the IB's table: year 1, 0.9091; year 2, 0.8264; year 3, 0.7513; year 4, 0.6830; year 5, 0.6209; year 6, 0.5645; year 7, 0.5132; year 8, 0.4665.

Source Simulated teaching data, prepared by the finance director.

Section 05: The rest of the evidence

6 exhibits. Each is labelled with what kind of evidence it is.

Exhibit 4

Sales by product family (MX$m)

Source: Simulated data
Product family 2022 2023 2024 2025
Exhaust brackets and heat shields520505470430
Fuel-tank straps and fuel-line clips410400380350
Chassis and body stampings310330350360
Tooling and repairs30324038
Total1,2701,2671,2401,178

The first two families are used only in vehicles with combustion engines. Norvalia Motors bought 55% of the company's output in 2025.

Source Simulated teaching data, from the sales ledger.
Exhibit 5

What each project involves

Source: Simulated data
Project What it involves Money needed and where it comes from Jobs What could go wrong
A: battery-enclosure framesRebuild Line 2 to make the frames for Norvalia's electric pickup, from 2028.MX$180m, of which MX$60m is cash and MX$120m a bank loan at 10%.48 welders retrained for eight weeks each; 20 jobs added.Volumes below Norvalia's forecast; the contract not renewed after five years; failing the quality approval.
B: automated weldingRobotic welding on Lines 1 and 2, to cut the cost of combustion parts and win orders as rivals leave the market.MX$90m, of which MX$30m is cash and MX$60m a bank loan.60 fewer jobs within two years, through retirements and redundancies.Combustion volumes falling faster than forecast; equipment with no use once the parts end.
C: farm machinery partsFrames and brackets for Agrimaq del Norte's tractors and implements, made in a new bay of the plant.MX$120m, of which MX$40m is cash and MX$80m a bank loan.35 jobs added.A new market with a single customer, whose sales rise and fall with harvests and the cost of credit.
Source Simulated teaching data, prepared for the board.
Exhibit 6

The customers' forecast of their orders for combustion parts (index, 2025 = 100)

Source: Simulated data
Year Volume index
2025100
202694
202785
202874
202962
203050
203140

The customers' combined forecast for the exhaust and fuel-tank parts Quintanilla makes. Forecasts like this one have been revised downwards twice in the last three years.

Source Simulated teaching data, from the customers' planning schedules.
Exhibit 7

The workforce

Source: Simulated data
Employees
420
Welders
140
Welders qualified to weld aluminium
6
Training to qualify a welder in aluminium
About eight weeks Off the job
Average age of the welders
47 years
Labour turnover in 2025
6.5%
Source Simulated teaching data, from the personnel records.
Exhibit 8

Norvalia's invitation to bid

Source: Simulated data

Our electric pickup will be built in this plant from 2028. We will award the contract for its battery-enclosure frames to one supplier within 100 kilometres of the plant, for the five years of the first model, after our quality approval, which takes about eighteen months. The volumes in this letter are our forecast, not a commitment: they depend on how many electric pickups our customers buy.

Daniela Ortiz, purchasing director, Norvalia Motors
Source Fictional letter, written for this case.
Exhibit 9

The welders' view

Source: Simulated data

Our welders built this company's name on steel. If the company wants them to learn aluminium, they will learn it, but they need to know that the training leads to a job and not to a robot. Nobody here is against the future. People are against hearing about it last.

Raúl Garza, workers' representative, Quintanilla Autopartes
Source Fictional interview, written for this case.

Section 06: Constraints

  • The company can fund one of the three projects, not two. The bank will lend up to MX$120m at 10% a year.
  • Norvalia wants bids within six months, and its quality approval takes about eighteen months, so a decision on Project A cannot wait a year.
  • The family will not sell shares to an outside investor.
  • Qualifying a welder in aluminium takes about eight weeks off the job.

Section 07: The people with a stake

Stakeholder Interest Influence Stake Concern
Ana Sofía Quintanilla, chief executive A future for the company her father founded, and its independence. High High Betting the company on one customer, or presiding over its slow decline.
The Quintanilla family, shareholders The value of the company and steady dividends. High High A large loan that puts the family's wealth at risk.
Mónica Treviño, finance director A decision based on sound appraisal, with its risks understood. Medium Medium A board that chooses on payback alone.
Héctor Salinas, plant manager An efficient plant that wins orders. Medium High Learning a new product and a new metal while the old lines still need running.
Welders and the workers' representative Secure jobs, and training that leads somewhere. Medium High Being replaced by robots under Project B, or retrained for work that does not last under Project A.
Norvalia Motors A reliable, approved local supplier for its electric pickup. High Medium A supplier without the skills to pass its quality approval in time.
The bank Interest, and repayment of a larger loan. Medium Medium Lending against the forecasts of one customer.
Agrimaq del Norte A local supplier of frames and brackets. Low Medium A supplier whose attention stays on carmakers.

Section 08: Strategic alternatives

Project A: battery-enclosure frames

Rebuild Line 2 to make battery-enclosure frames for Norvalia's electric pickup from 2028.

Requires
MX$180m, a winning bid, quality approval within eighteen months and 48 welders retrained in aluminium.
Upside
The highest ARR and NPV, and a product with a future in a market where demand is growing.
Risks
The value depends on Norvalia's volumes, which are a forecast, not a commitment, and on renewal of the contract after five years.

Evidence: Exhibit 3, Exhibit 5, Exhibit 8, Exhibit 9

Project B: automated welding

Automate welding on both lines to make the combustion business as efficient as possible.

Requires
MX$90m and 60 fewer jobs within two years.
Upside
The fastest payback and the least money at risk.
Risks
Makes the company better at making parts the market is leaving; little to show for the investment once combustion volumes are gone.

Evidence: Exhibit 3, Exhibit 5, Exhibit 6

Project C: farm machinery parts

Diversify into frames and brackets for Agrimaq del Norte's tractors and implements.

Requires
MX$120m, a new bay in the plant and a new customer relationship.
Upside
Spreads the company's risk beyond carmakers, and adds 35 jobs.
Risks
The weakest returns of the three, and a single customer in a market that rises and falls with farming.

Evidence: Exhibit 3, Exhibit 5

Wait a year

Invest in none of the projects this year, keep the cash and decide when the market is clearer.

Requires
Nothing now.
Upside
No new borrowing and no risk taken on forecasts.
Risks
Norvalia's bids close in six months, so waiting gives the electric pickup to another supplier while the combustion business shrinks.

Evidence: Exhibit 6, Exhibit 8

Section 09: Questions for analysis

Original practice questions written for this case, not IB examination questions. The marks are each question's own allocation, set to the size of the task. Answer first, then open the guidance.

Source: Original practice question
Show content for

Showing everything. HL-only material is marked HL.

  1. Define the term payback period.

    Define AO1 3.8 Investment appraisal

    Guidance for a strong answer
    Source: Assessment explanation The platform's guidance, not an official markscheme.

    One mark for the time it takes for a project's net cash flows to repay its capital cost, and one for a complete, precise statement (for example, measured from the start of the project, in years and months). Do not confuse it with the life of the project.

    [2 marks]

  2. Using Exhibit 3, calculate the payback period of Project A and of Project B, in years and months.

    Calculate AO4 Paper 2 style 3.8 Investment appraisal Exhibit 3

    Guidance for a strong answer
    Source: Assessment explanation The platform's guidance, not an official markscheme.

    Project A: cumulative net cash flow is −168, −140, −98 and −48 at the end of years 1 to 4, so MX$48m is still to recover when year 5 brings MX$54m. Payback = 4 years + (48 ÷ 54) × 12 months = 4 years 10.7 months. Project B: cumulative −60, −32 and −8, then MX$19m in year 4. Payback = 3 years + (8 ÷ 19) × 12 months = 3 years 5.1 months.

    Two marks for each project: one for the cumulative cash flow and one for the answer. State the assumption that cash arrives evenly through the year; without it the months cannot be calculated.

    [4 marks]

  3. Using Exhibit 3, calculate the average rate of return (ARR) of Project A and of Project C.

    Calculate AO4 Paper 2 style 3.8 Investment appraisal Exhibit 3

    Guidance for a strong answer
    Source: Assessment explanation The platform's guidance, not an official markscheme.

    Project A: total returns MX$334m, so ARR = ((334 − 180) ÷ 8) ÷ 180 × 100 = 10.7%. Project C: total returns MX$188m, so ARR = ((188 − 120) ÷ 8) ÷ 120 × 100 = 7.1%.

    Two marks for each project, one for the method and one for the answer. Use the guide's formula: the average yearly profit (total returns less the capital cost, divided by the years of use) as a percentage of the capital cost. A common slip is to forget to subtract the capital cost before dividing.

    [4 marks]

  4. Using Exhibit 3 and the discount factors given, calculate the net present value (NPV) of Project A at 10%, and its NPV if every year's net cash flow is 30% lower than forecast.

    Calculate AO4 Paper 2 style 3.8 Investment appraisal Exhibit 3 HL

    Guidance for a strong answer
    Source: Assessment explanation The platform's guidance, not an official markscheme.

    The present values of the returns add up to MX$209.95m, so NPV = 209.95 − 180 = MX$30.0m. If every return is 30% lower, the present values add up to 0.7 × 209.95 = MX$146.97m, so NPV = 146.97 − 180 = −MX$33.0m.

    Two marks for each NPV. Multiply each year's net cash flow by that year's factor, add the present values and subtract the capital cost. For the second part, every present value falls by 30%, so the total can be found in one step. The best answers say what the result means: the project creates value only if volumes come close to the forecast.

    [4 marks]

  5. Using Exhibits 7 and 9, explain two reasons why Quintanilla's welders might resist the plan to rebuild Line 2.

    Explain AO2 2.1 Introduction to human resource management Exhibit 7, Exhibit 9

    Guidance for a strong answer
    Source: Assessment explanation The platform's guidance, not an official markscheme.

    Two reasons, each explained and tied to the case, for two marks each. Strong reasons: fear for their jobs, since the same board is considering robotic welding (Project B); uncertainty about whether experienced steel welders, with an average age of 47, can qualify in aluminium; loss of the status that comes from being the best at the old work; and poor communication, since the workers' representative says people hear about change last. A reason that could apply to any business, without the case, earns one mark at most.

    [4 marks]

  6. Using Exhibits 4 and 6, explain the stage of the product life cycle reached by Quintanilla's combustion parts, and what this means for Project B.

    Explain AO2 4.5 The seven Ps of the marketing mix Exhibit 4, Exhibit 6

    Guidance for a strong answer
    Source: Assessment explanation The platform's guidance, not an official markscheme.

    The combustion parts are in decline: their sales have fallen for three years, and the customers forecast volumes at 40% of the 2025 level by 2031. Two marks for identifying the stage with evidence. Two marks for the implication: Project B invests to cut costs on a product whose market is shrinking, so it earns its returns early and has little value after the products end, which is why its payback is quick and its NPV small.

    [4 marks]

  7. Recommend which of the three projects Quintanilla should invest in.

    Recommend AO3 Paper 2 style 3.8 Investment appraisal; 2.1 Introduction to human resource management; 5.4 Location Exhibit 3, Exhibit 5, Exhibit 6, Exhibit 8, Exhibit 9

    Guidance for a strong answer
    Source: Assessment explanation The platform's guidance, not an official markscheme.

    A strong answer does four things.

    • It uses all three methods and explains why they disagree: B pays back first; A has the highest ARR and NPV.
    • It treats the forecasts as forecasts: A's NPV becomes −MX$33.0m if volumes are 30% lower, and B's returns depend on a declining market.
    • It weighs what the numbers leave out: the welders' retraining, the 60 jobs B would cut, the distance rule in Norvalia's letter, and the company's future after 2031.
    • It makes a clear recommendation, with the conditions under which it holds and what would change it.

    Answers that recommend a project on one method alone, or that list the methods without a judgement, stay in the middle of the range.

    [10 marks]

HL-only questions are hidden in the SL view. Choose HL above to see them.

Section 10: The decision exercise

Decide before you read the debrief. The exercise is the platform's own; it is not an IB task.

Your role

You are Mónica Treviño, Quintanilla's finance director.

The board meets in two weeks and expects a recommendation it can vote on. Ana Sofía wants the company to have a future, Héctor wants the plant to stay efficient, and the family wants its wealth protected. You have the three projects' forecasts, the appraisal methods the board knows, and Norvalia's letter.

The task
Choose one alternative and defend it with the appraisal, the risks behind the forecasts and the people it affects.
What to produce
A recommendation to the board of about 250 words, using payback, ARR and, at HL, NPV, with the condition on which it depends.
Time
40 minutes

Choose one of the strategic alternatives and write down your reasons before you open the debrief below. With JavaScript on, this page keeps your decision on this device and shows how the evidence judges the alternative you chose.

Make your decision

Which alternative do you choose?
The alternative you choose, the evidence for it, its main risk, and what would change your mind, at the length the task asks for. 0 words

Section 11: The debrief

The worked analysis, then every alternative judged against the evidence. One defensible reading, not the only one: try your own first.

Read the debrief
Source: Arjun Agrawal framework

The case turns on two questions: what each appraisal method measures, and how much risk a family company should take with the forecasts of one customer. Payback, ARR and NPV disagree for good reasons. The strongest answers use that disagreement rather than choosing a favourite method, and treat the project with the best forecast as worth having only if its risk can be shared.

The worked analysis

DataWhat the exhibits say

  • Combustion parts were two thirds of sales in 2025 and have fallen for three years; the customers forecast their orders at 40% of the 2025 level by 2031 (Exhibits 4 and 6).
  • Payback favours Project B, at 3 years 5.1 months against 4 years 10.7 months for A and 5 years 4.6 months for C; the average rate of return and net present value favour A, with an ARR of 10.7% and an NPV of MX$30.0m at 10% (Exhibit 3).
  • If Norvalia's volumes are 30% below forecast, Project A's NPV falls to −MX$33.0m; it turns negative once volumes are about 14% short.
  • Six of the 140 welders are qualified in aluminium, and gearing is 13.6% before any new loan (Exhibits 2 and 7).

InsightWhat it means

  • The methods disagree because they measure different things. Payback rewards speed and so favours B's early returns; NPV counts every year and when it arrives, and so favours A's larger, later returns.
  • Project B is efficient harvesting. It pays back fast because it squeezes a shrinking business, and after 2031 there is little left to squeeze.
  • Project A's value rests on one customer's volumes. On the board's own estimate of a 40% chance that volumes are 30% lower, its expected NPV is about MX$4.8m, close to B's MX$4.6m, but with a far wider spread of outcomes.

OptionsWhat each choice does

  • Project A builds the company's future, at the price of a large bet on one customer and a demanding change for the workforce.
  • Project B is safe and quick, and leaves the company smaller and more dependent on a declining product.
  • Project C reduces dependence on carmakers, but with an NPV of MX$1.3m it barely earns the 10% the money costs.
  • Waiting keeps the cash and loses the only contract for an electric-vehicle part on offer.

RecommendationOne defensible answer

One defensible recommendation: bid for the Norvalia contract and rebuild Line 2 (Project A), but only on terms that cut its volume risk, such as a minimum yearly volume or a price that rises if volumes fall short, and with enclosure cells designed so that other electric-vehicle makers could be served too. Start the aluminium training now, with a promise that retrained welders keep their jobs, and agree the plan with the workers' representative before the bid goes in. Keep the combustion lines running without further investment while they still earn cash.

CaveatWhen it would change

If Norvalia will give no protection on volumes, Project A's downside is large for a family company: a 30% shortfall would destroy MX$33.0m of value. In that case Project C, which reduces the dependence on carmakers, would be the more prudent choice, and the family should accept that Quintanilla will be a smaller company in 2031.

Every alternative, judged

  1. Project A: battery-enclosure frames

    Defensible if its conditions hold

    The best on the forecast, with payback in 4 years 10.7 months, an ARR of 10.7% and an NPV of MX$30.0m, and the only project that gives the company a future product. But it is a bet on Norvalia's volumes: 30% below forecast, the NPV becomes −MX$33.0m, and the project stops creating value once volumes are about 14% short. It is the right choice if the contract shares that risk, and a gamble if it does not.

  2. Project B: automated welding

    Weakly supported by the evidence

    The fastest payback, 3 years 5.1 months, and little money at risk in the early years, but an NPV of only MX$4.6m on a product that is disappearing. It cuts 60 jobs to make a shrinking business efficient, and leaves Quintanilla with nothing to make when the combustion parts end.

  3. Project C: farm machinery parts

    Defensible if its conditions hold

    Diversification that reduces the dependence on carmakers, but with the weakest returns: an NPV of MX$1.3m at 10% and payback in 5 years 4.6 months. One customer in a cyclical market replaces one customer in a declining one. Defensible as the prudent choice if Norvalia offers no protection on volumes.

  4. Wait a year

    Weakly supported by the evidence

    It keeps the cash, but the decision cannot wait: Norvalia's approval takes eighteen months and bids close in six. Waiting gives the electric pickup to another supplier and leaves the company riding the combustion decline with nothing to replace it.

The trade-offs

  • Speed against value. B returns its money first; A creates the most value if the forecast holds.
  • A visible decline against an uncertain forecast. B's returns depend on a market everyone can see shrinking; A's depend on volumes nobody can guarantee.
  • Jobs now against jobs later. B cuts 60 jobs; A retrains 48 welders and adds 20.
  • Spreading risk against earning returns. C reduces the dependence on cars but earns least.

The evidence that matters most

  • The volume index, which puts combustion orders at 40% of today's by 2031 (Exhibit 6).
  • Project A's sensitivity, negative once volumes are about 14% short (Exhibit 3, with the discount factors).
  • Norvalia's letter, which calls its volumes a forecast, not a commitment (Exhibit 8).
  • The welders' position, willing to retrain if it leads to a job (Exhibit 9).

What would change the recommendation

  • Norvalia agrees a minimum volume or a price that rises with any shortfall. A's downside shrinks and it becomes the clear choice.
  • Norvalia refuses any protection, or delays its electric pickup. C, or a smaller automation of one line, becomes the safer course.
  • Combustion volumes fall faster than the index. B's returns shrink and its quick payback disappears.

Common errors

  • Treating payback as the answer. It ignores everything after the money is repaid, which is where A earns most.
  • Quoting an NPV without its risk. An NPV on forecast volumes describes one scenario, not the future.
  • Ignoring the people. Retraining 48 welders in aluminium is a condition of Project A, not a detail.
  • Comparing ARRs without noticing that Project B lasts six years and the others eight.

Section 12: Theories and frameworks

The theories and tools this case calls for, each with how it applies here and where the platform teaches it.

HL-only frameworks are hidden in the SL view.

Section 13: For seminar discussion

Prompts for undergraduate and MBA seminars. They go beyond the IB course and are labelled as enrichment.

Source: Enrichment
  1. Payback, ARR and NPV rank the projects differently. Which ranking should a family-owned supplier in a shrinking market trust, and when might a board's preference for quick payback be rational rather than naive?
  2. Project A's NPV turns negative if volumes are about 14% short of Norvalia's forecast. What contract terms, staging of the investment or design choices would reduce that exposure, and what would each one cost?
  3. Is harvesting the combustion business, as Project B does, a legitimate strategy for a company with 420 employees in one city? Weigh the job losses against the risk of investing in a market the company does not control.