Investment appraisal
Payback period
Formula
Payback period = years before the cost is recovered + (amount still to recover ÷ net cash flow in the payback year) × 12 months
- C
- Capital cost, paid in year 0 (currency)
- R
- Net cash flow in each year of use (currency)
Unit. years and months
How long the project takes to return its cost in cash. Quicker payback means less time exposed to risk and earlier cash, which matters most to a business that is short of it.
Worked example: from the case Halden Distribution
Halden Distribution: payback on the pack-and-label line (Project A)
- Given
- Capital cost (year 0): £600,000
- Net cash flow, year 1: £90,000
- Net cash flow, year 2: £150,000
- Net cash flow, year 3: £180,000
- Net cash flow, year 4: £180,000
- Net cash flow, year 5: £180,000
- Net cash flow, year 6: £150,000
- Formula
- Payback period = years before the cost is recovered + (amount still to recover ÷ net cash flow in the payback year) × 12 months
- Substitution
- = 4 years: the cumulative net cash flow reaches zero exactly at the end of year 4
- Working
- End of year 1: −£600,000 + £90,000 = −£510,000End of year 2: −£510,000 + £150,000 = −£360,000End of year 3: −£360,000 + £180,000 = −£180,000End of year 4: −£180,000 + £180,000 = £0
- Answer
- 4 years
- Unit
- years and months
- Interpretation
The line pays for itself in exactly four years, two years before the end of its expected life.
- Business implication
Four years is a long wait for a business with £17,000 in the bank, which is why voice picking's faster payback is tempting.
Errors that cost marks
- Working out the months without assuming the year's cash arrives evenly, or without saying so.
- Choosing between projects on payback alone, ignoring the returns after payback.
3.8: Payback is in the syllabus (p. 30); the guide's formula sheet gives no formula for it, so the method here is the standard one.