Frameworks ยท Choosing strategy
Circular business models
Five ways for a business to earn money while keeping products and materials in use: circular supply, resource recovery, product life extension, sharing and product service systems.
Section 01: The framework at a glance
Text description
The five circular business models the guide names, around a loop that keeps resources in use. Circular supply: inputs that can be regrown, composted or recycled. Resource recovery: value captured from waste, scraps and by-products. Product life extension: durable design, repair, upgrade and resale. Sharing: many users share one item, often through an app. Product service system: customers pay for use while the business keeps ownership.
Section 02: What it is, and what it is for
The guide names five circular business models. Circular supply models use inputs that are renewable, recycled or biodegradable. Resource recovery models capture value from waste, scraps and by-products. Product life extension models keep products working longer through durable design, repair, upgrades and resale. Sharing models let many users share one item, often through a platform. Product service system models sell the use of a product, such as lighting or mobility, while the business keeps ownership and so has a reason to make it last.
Each model changes where the money comes from, from selling more units to keeping resources in circulation, which puts the key concept of sustainability into practice. Each also needs new capabilities, such as collecting products back, and often a change in what customers are willing to pay for.
What it is for
To find ways for a business to reduce waste and its use of new materials while protecting or raising its profit, and to evaluate whether a circular model suits a particular business. Its full toolkit guide is in preparation.
Section 03: How it is built
The parts of the framework, and what each one holds.
- Circular supply
- Inputs that are renewable, recycled or biodegradable replace new, finite materials, so the product starts its life in the loop.
- Resource recovery
- Value is captured from waste, scraps, by-products and returned goods, by the business itself or by a partner that can use them.
- Product life extension
- Products are designed to last and kept working through repair, upgrades, refurbishment and resale, so each one earns for longer.
- Sharing
- Many users share one item, often through a platform, so fewer items are needed for the same use.
- Product service systems
- The business sells the use or the result of a product, such as lighting or mobility, and keeps ownership, which gives it a reason to make the product last.
- What changes underneath
- Each model moves revenue away from selling more units and towards keeping resources in use, and each needs capabilities a linear business may lack, such as collecting products back.
Section 04: When to use it
The business situations it suits, and where another tool will serve better.
It suits
- A business whose products end up as waste it could collect, repair or resell, such as clothing, electronics, furniture or tyres.
- Customers who pay a premium for durability or would rather pay for use than ownership, such as businesses leasing equipment.
- Rising prices or regulation of a key material, which make recovered or renewable inputs competitive.
Look elsewhere when
- Products that are cheap, used once and hard to collect, where the cost of bringing them back exceeds anything recovered.
- A business without the cash or partners to build reverse logistics, which may need to start with a single pilot rather than a new model.
Section 05: How to use it, step by step
A short method. The toolkit guide gives the full one, with the evidence each step needs.
- Map where the business's products and materials end up after use.
- For each of the five models, ask whether it could apply, and what the business would need to make it work.
- Estimate the effect on costs, revenues and customers for the most promising model.
- Identify the capabilities and partners it would need, such as reverse logistics or a repair network.
- Evaluate the model against the triple bottom line: people, planet and profit.
Section 06: Applied: Stride Footwear closes the loop
Stride Footwear, a fictional maker of running shoes, reviews the five models. It already uses some recycled rubber (circular supply). It considers a take-back scheme that grinds old soles into running track material (resource recovery), and a resoling service for its premium shoes (product life extension).
What it showed
The resoling service fits best: runners who pay a premium value their shoes, the service brings them back to the store, and it extends each pair's life. The take-back scheme needs a partner to process the soles and is planned for a later stage.
Section 07: Reading the result
How to interpret what it shows, and what that does and does not justify deciding.
Read each model as a change to the business model, not as a green addition to it. For the most promising model, ask three things: where the new revenue comes from (repairs, rentals, recovered material), what new costs and capabilities it brings (collection, inspection, refurbishment, a platform), and how customers' behaviour must change for it to work.
The model fits when the value kept in circulation is larger than the cost of keeping it there, and when the business is better placed than anyone else to capture that value. Judge the environmental gain separately and honestly: a model that makes goods cheaper to use can raise total consumption.
What it can justify deciding
- Piloting the one model that fits the business's products and customers best, such as a repair service for premium goods, before redesigning the whole business.
- Redesigning products for repair or disassembly where a life extension or recovery model is chosen.
- Seeking partners for the capabilities the business lacks, such as a processor for recovered material.
What it does not justify on its own
- Claiming an environmental benefit without measuring it against the extra transport, processing and possible rise in use.
- Assuming customers will pay more for circular products because they say they value sustainability.
Section 08: Strengths and limits
Why it helps
- It links sustainability to profit, so circular ideas are judged as business decisions.
- Five distinct models give a structured way to generate options.
- Circular models can cut material costs and risks, and attract customers, staff and investors.
Where it falls short
- Changing a business model takes investment, time and new capabilities.
- Not every customer will pay more, or accept owning less, for environmental reasons.
- Environmental gains can be offset if cheaper second-hand or shared goods raise total consumption.
Section 09: Common mistakes
Errors often made with it, by students and by managers, and how to avoid each.
-
Mistake Treating recycling at the end as the whole of the circular economy.
Instead Look first at keeping products in use, through durability, repair and sharing, which usually keeps more value than recycling materials.
-
Mistake Choosing a model without costing the return flow of products.
Instead Estimate collection, inspection and processing costs per item, and compare them with the value recovered.
-
Mistake Ignoring what the model does to existing sales.
Instead Ask whether repairs and resale take sales from new products, and whether the margin on the service makes up for it.
Section 10: Apply it
The application mode: the platform's tools that apply this framework, and a worksheet for your own case.
Frameworks structure judgement; they do not produce answers. Each one organizes evidence so that you can see it, test it and argue from it, and the decision, and the reasons for it, remain yours.
No interactive tool on the platform applies Circular business models in full yet, so the worksheet below is its application mode, with the tools that help with parts of it.
For part of it
- Entrepreneurship and Innovation Lab Business Model Canvas builder Redraw the canvas for a circular model: take-back, repair or sharing change the key activities, partners, cost structure and revenue streams, and the canvas shows which new assumptions that adds.
- Entrepreneurship and Innovation Lab Start-up feasibility assessment Score the circular idea against weighted criteria, such as demand, cost and the capabilities it needs, before committing to it.
Your worksheet
Work through the framework part by part for a business you know, then say what the result does and does not justify.
Your worksheet could not be restored on this page; you can still fill it in and copy your work.
Kept on this device as you type, and nowhere else. Not saved without JavaScript: print the page or copy your answers before you leave.
The Framework Application Lab: choose a framework by the decision you face.
Section 11: Try it
The platform's own exercise. Write your answer, then open the guidance.
Choose a business that sells physical products, such as a phone retailer, a toy maker or a clothing brand. For each of the five circular business models, give one way it could apply, then evaluate the most promising one for its effect on people, planet and profit.
Kept on this device as you type, and nowhere else. Your answer is not saved without JavaScript; copy it before you leave.
The draft could not be restored on this page; you can still write and copy your answer.
Guidance: what a strong answer does
- Make each example specific to the business, not a definition of the model.
- For the chosen model, consider costs, revenue, customers and the capabilities needed.
- Weigh the environmental gain against the risk to profit, honestly.
- Say what evidence would show the model is working.
Section 12: Related concepts
In the glossary
- Circular business models Ways of organizing a business so that products and materials stay in use for as long as possible and waste is designed out, instead of following a take, make, use and throw away pattern.
- Circular supply model A circular business model built on inputs that can be regrown, composted or recycled, such as plant-based materials or recycled metal, in place of new raw materials taken from the earth.
- Resource recovery model A circular business model that captures value from waste: used products, scraps and by-products are collected and processed into materials or energy that can be used again.
- Product life extension model A circular business model that keeps products in use for longer through durable design, repair, maintenance, upgrading, refurbishment and resale.
- Sharing model A circular business model in which people pay to use, borrow or rent items owned by others, often arranged through an app or website, so that each item serves many users rather than one.
- Product service system model A circular business model in which customers pay for the use or performance of a product, through leasing, renting or paying per use, while the business keeps ownership of the product.
Read with
- The business model canvas Enrichment A one-page template of nine blocks that describes how a business creates value for customers, delivers it and earns money from it. Compare side by side: Circular business models and The business model canvas
- The value chain Enrichment A way of breaking a business down into the activities that create value for its customers, to see where its costs and its advantages really come from. Compare side by side: Circular business models and The value chain
- STEEPLE analysis IB toolkit A scan of seven kinds of external factor, social, technological, economic, environmental, political, legal and ethical, that bear on a business decision. Compare side by side: Circular business models and STEEPLE analysis
- SWOT analysis IB toolkit A summary of a business's internal strengths and weaknesses and the external opportunities and threats it faces, as the starting point for a decision. Compare side by side: Circular business models and SWOT analysis
Compare it with any other framework in the library.
The explanation, method, example and exercise are the platform's own. Statements about the IB course cite the Business management guide; the business in the example is fictional.
Arjun Agrawal | The Business Brief, https://the-business-brief-dun.vercel.app/frameworks/circular-business-models/. Original teaching material, not an IB publication. The organizations in the teaching cases are fictional unless a case says otherwise.