People and Culture: Planner
Change management planner
Changes at work usually fail on people rather than plans. Describe a change, weigh the forces for and against it, and list the people it affects, with their power, their interest and why they might resist. The tool maps them, ranks the resistance to expect and sets out the steps to take, naming the model behind each one.
Section 01: How to use it
-
Describe the change in a line.
-
At HL, list the driving and restraining forces and score each from 1 to 5 on the evidence, then choose a restraining force within the manager's reach to see what weakening it would do.
-
List the stakeholders the change affects. For each, judge their power over the change, their interest in it, their likely stance and, if they do not support it, their main reason.
-
Read the map, the resistance to expect and the steps to take, then write your own plan. Your work is kept on this device; download it as JSON or CSV, or print it.
Where it sits in the course. Subtopic 2.1, Introduction to human resource management (guide, p. 25), for SL and HL: the reasons for resistance to change in the workplace (AO2), and human resource strategies for reducing the impact of change and resistance to change (AO3). Force field analysis is in the guide's toolkit for HL only. Stakeholder mapping and Kotter and Schlesinger's six approaches to resistance are not named in the guide: they are enrichment, used here to organize the strategies.
Showing everything. HL-only material is marked HL.
Planner
Wenlow Care, a fictional group of care homes
Wenlow Care, the group in the workforce planning tool, plans to move its care staff from three 8-hour shifts a day to two 12-hour shifts. The change, the forces, the stakeholders and every judgement are invented for teaching.
The tool could not start in this browser. Everything below is the worked example as it was prepared, with its results.
The plan
Reading. Three stakeholders are expected to oppose the change, and two of them have the power to block it. The restraining forces (14) outweigh the driving forces (13).
Implication. Plan for the reasons behind the opposition: disagreement with the plan itself; a threat to jobs, pay or status; routines and arrangements disrupted. Each calls for a different approach, so a single announcement will not be enough.
Force field analysis HL
On your weighting the restraining forces (14) outweigh the driving forces (13). The change is unlikely to succeed unless some restraining forces are weakened or driving forces strengthened.
Weakening one force. If "Staff told, not consulted" were weakened from 3 to 1, the totals would be 13 driving against 12 restraining: the driving forces would lead.
The model is Kurt Lewin's (1951). The scores are judgements, so the totals show where the weight of the argument lies, not a measurement.
Who it affects: a stakeholder map Enrichment
Manage closely
High power, high interest
- Senior carers who lead each shift opposes
- Union branch opposes
- Home managers supports
Consult early and involve in the decision.
Keep satisfied
High power, low interest
- Care regulator neutral
Make sure the change does not provoke them.
Keep informed
Low power, high interest
- Care workers with young children opposes
- Night staff neutral
- Residents' families neutral
Explain the change and listen.
Monitor
Low power, low interest
Nobody here.
Little effort is needed, but watch for changes.
Mapping by power and interest is a widely used planning tool, but the guide does not name it, so use it to organize an answer rather than as a requirement.
The resistance to expect
The reasons are those the platform's notes give for resistance to change (subtopic 2.1, AO2). The level of risk follows the platform's rule: opposition matters most where there is the power to act on it.
Senior carers who lead each shift High: could block the change
Main reason: disagreement with the plan itself. On the map: manage closely.
Approaches that fit: participation and involvement.
Union branch High: could block the change
Main reason: a threat to jobs, pay or status. On the map: manage closely.
Approaches that fit: negotiation and agreement, education and communication, participation and involvement.
Care workers with young children Medium: could slow it, and could gain power by acting together
Main reason: routines and arrangements disrupted. On the map: keep informed.
Approaches that fit: facilitation and support, participation and involvement.
Night staff Watch: could turn against it
Main reason: fear of the unknown. On the map: keep informed.
Approaches that fit: education and communication, facilitation and support.
Residents' families Watch: could turn against it
Main reason: poor communication, not consulted. On the map: keep informed.
Approaches that fit: education and communication, participation and involvement.
Care regulator Watch: could turn against it
No particular reason given. On the map: keep satisfied.
Approaches that fit: education and communication.
The steps to take
Human resource strategies for reducing the impact of change and resistance to it are AO3 in subtopic 2.1. Where a step uses one of Kotter and Schlesinger's six approaches to resistance (1979), it names it. The guide does not name the model, so it is enrichment.
Explain the change and the reasons for it, early
For: everyone affected
Tell everyone affected what will change, why and when, before rumours do it for you. Take particular care to explain it to Union branch, Night staff, Residents' families and Care regulator. Ask Home managers to help make the case.
Education and communication. Its drawback: it takes time when many people are involved, and it does not work if they distrust the message.
Involve the people who can shape or block it
For: Senior carers who lead each shift, Union branch, Care workers with young children, Residents' families
Ask them to help design how the change is made, and act on what they find. They may see flaws in the plan that managers have missed.
Participation and involvement. Its drawback: it is slow, and the people involved may shape the change in ways managers did not intend.
Negotiate where people stand to lose
For: Union branch
Agree what they will get in return, such as protected pay for a period, a guarantee of no compulsory redundancies or a bonus for adopting the change.
Negotiation and agreement. Its drawback: it can be expensive, and other groups may then expect to negotiate too.
Train and support people through it
For: Care workers with young children, Night staff
Give training in the new ways of working, time to adjust and help with what the change disrupts, such as flexible hours or redeployment.
Facilitation and support. Its drawback: training, time off and support cost money, and they may still not be enough.
Pilot it before making it everywhere
For: everyone affected
The restraining forces are at least as strong as the driving forces, and powerful stakeholders oppose it. Try the change in one place, learn from it, then introduce it in stages.
Review it, and keep what works
For: everyone affected
Set a date to check how the change is going against what it was meant to achieve, listen to the people it affects, and adjust the plan before treating it as settled.
The two approaches the plan never suggests
- Manipulation and co-optation. Used when: other approaches have failed or cost too much. People who feel manipulated stop trusting managers, which makes the next change harder. It raises ethical questions.
- Explicit and implicit coercion. Used when: speed is essential and the managers making the change hold great power. It is quick, but it breeds resentment, and people may leave or resist in quieter ways.
Section 02: What it leaves out
Every model simplifies. Say so in an answer, and say what else you would want to know.
- Every score, stance and reason is a judgement. The plan is only as good as the evidence behind them, and people's views shift as a change unfolds.
- The force totals add up judgements, so a difference of a point or two says little. Forces also interact: weakening one can strengthen another.
- Which approach fits which reason, the levels of risk and the order of the steps are the platform's teaching model. Real plans mix approaches and adapt them as they go.
- A stakeholder group is rarely of one mind. Splitting a group, such as staff with and without young children, often explains resistance better.
- The tool says nothing about cost or timing. A real plan weighs the cost of each step against the deadline for the change.
Section 03: Read and practise next
Arjun Agrawal | The Business Brief, https://the-business-brief-dun.vercel.app/people-and-culture/change-planner/. Original teaching material, not an IB publication. The organizations in the teaching cases are fictional unless a case says otherwise.