How should the new site manager lead in her first ninety days, and should she lead both shifts the same way?
Halden's warehouse was run for fifteen years by a founder who decided everything himself and looked after his staff. Since a new scanning system arrived, dispatch has fallen, errors have doubled and nearly half the night shift has left. The largest client has set a deadline. The new site manager must decide how to lead.
Organization
Halden Distribution
Sector
Warehousing and order fulfilment for online retailers
Location
Leeds, United Kingdom
Size
One warehouse, 140 employees on a day shift and a night shift
Fictional case. An invented organization. Every figure is simulated for teaching and checked for consistency.
01
Section 01: The story so far
For fifteen years Halden Distribution's warehouse on the edge of Leeds was run by the man who founded it. Graham Pell knew every picker by name, decided everything himself, handed out a bonus before Christmas and was, by most accounts, liked. When he retired in the spring, Halden's owners did not promote anyone from inside. They hired Amara Osei, an operations manager from a national retailer's distribution centre, who started in July.
She inherited a problem that had begun before her. Last December, under pressure from its largest client, Halden had introduced a warehouse management system with handheld scanners that tell pickers what to pick and in what order. The day shift, most of whom had been at Halden for years, were trained for six hours each and adapted. The night shift, younger, newer and led by two team leaders promoted in the spring, were trained for two. Since then, on-time dispatch has fallen from 98% to 91.4%, picking errors have more than doubled, and over half of the night shift has left within the year.
In July, in Amara's first week, Lumen Home, an online homeware retailer whose orders fill a third of the warehouse, set a deadline: on-time dispatch back above 97% by the first week of November, when its peak season begins, or it will move its contract when the current year ends. That gives Amara about four months.
Her own experience is of large sites where targets were set centrally and enforced. The team leaders she inherited expect something closer to Graham. The survey she ran in her third week (Exhibit 3) suggests that the night shift's problem is not effort. It is that nobody asked them how the system should work, and nobody showed them.
Amara has to decide how to lead: what to decide herself, what to delegate, whom to consult and how much, and whether to lead both shifts in the same way.
02
Section 02: The evidence
6 exhibits. Each is labelled with what kind of evidence it is.
Exhibit 1
Site performance over the last year
Source: Simulated data
Month
On-time dispatch (%)
Picking errors per 1,000 orders
Absence rate (%)
August 2025
98.1
2.1
3.1
October 2025
97.6
2.3
3.4
December 2025
96.0
3.4
4.2
February 2026
94.2
4.0
4.9
April 2026
92.7
4.6
5.3
June 2026
91.4
5.2
5.8
The warehouse management system went live in December 2025.
SourceSimulated teaching data, from the site's monthly reports.
Exhibit 2
People, by shift, over the last twelve months
Source: Simulated data
Measure
Day shift
Night shift
Whole site
Employees now
82
58
140
Average number of employees in the year
81
54
135
Employees who left in the year
18
28
46
Labour turnover (%)
22.2
51.9
34.1
Average length of service (years)
7.4
2.9
5.5
Team leaders' average experience as team leaders (years)
9.1
0.6
Training on the new system (hours per person)
6
2
Labour turnover is the number of employees who left divided by the average number of employees, multiplied by 100. Two years ago it was 18.9% for the whole site.
SourceSimulated teaching data, from the site's personnel records.
Exhibit 3
Staff survey, July 2026 (112 of 140 responded)
Source: Simulated data
Statement
Day shift agreeing (%)
Night shift agreeing (%)
I know what is expected of me
81
54
I am consulted about changes that affect my work
38
21
I have had the training I need to use the new system
72
33
My team leader helps me solve problems
74
48
I would recommend Halden as a place to work
58
29
66 day-shift and 46 night-shift employees responded. Across both shifts, the average share agreeing with the five statements is 53%, the engagement score used in the Decision Room.
SourceSimulated teaching data.
Exhibit 4
The client's deadline
Source: Simulated data
Our customers were promised next-day delivery. Since the spring, nearly one order in eleven from your site has missed its truck. We need on-time dispatch back above 97% by the first week of November, when our peak season starts. If it is not, we will move our contract when the current year ends.
SourceFictional email, written for this case.
Exhibit 5
Why night-shift leavers left (exit interviews with 24 of the 28)
Source: Simulated data
Nobody explained the new scanners properly
11
Targets changed without warning
7
Better pay elsewhere
4
The shift pattern
2
SourceSimulated teaching data, from exit interview notes. Each leaver gave one main reason.
Exhibit 6
How the previous manager led
Source: Simulated data
Graham knew everyone's kids' names. He decided everything himself, but you always felt looked after. When the scanners came in, he just told us they were coming.
SourceFictional interview, written for this case.
03
Section 03: Constraints
Four months to the client's deadline.
Pay is set by the owners and can change only at the annual review in April.
The system's supplier will train up to twenty people a week on site, at no extra cost under the contract.
Recruiting a new team leader takes about two months.
04
Section 04: The people with a stake
Stakeholder
Interest
Influence
Stake
Concern
Amara Osei, site manager
Restoring performance, keeping the client and establishing her authority.
High
High
Failing in her first role at Halden, in front of owners who hired her from outside.
Night-shift pickers (58)
Being trained, consulted and treated fairly.
Medium
High
More pressure without more support.
Day-shift pickers (82)
Stability and fair treatment.
Medium
Medium
Being blamed or burdened for the night shift's problems.
Team leaders
Authority to run their teams, and support when they need it.
Medium
High
Being bypassed by the new manager, or left alone with problems they cannot solve.
Lumen Home
On-time dispatch above 97%.
High
Medium
Its own customers' next-day promise.
Halden's owners
Keeping the client and the site's profitability.
High
High
A third of the warehouse's work leaving at the end of the year.
05
Section 05: Strategic alternatives
Autocratic turnaround
Set targets, enforce the system and discipline repeated errors; decide everything centrally.
Requires
Clear standards, daily monitoring and the authority to enforce them.
Upside
Fast, visible change in effort and compliance.
Risks
Treats a skills gap as a discipline problem; more night-shift staff may leave.
From data to a recommendation, in the order an examiner rewards. Try your own before you read it.
Show the worked analysis
Source: Arjun Agrawal framework
DataWhat the exhibits say
On-time dispatch has fallen from 98.1% to 91.4% since the system went live, and errors have risen from 2.1 to 5.2 per 1,000 orders (Exhibit 1).
Labour turnover is 34.1% for the site, but 51.9% on nights against 22.2% on days (Exhibit 2).
Night-shift staff had two hours of training on the system against six on days, and their team leaders have less than a year's experience (Exhibit 2).
Only 21% of the night shift feel consulted and 33% feel trained (Exhibit 3). Eleven of the twenty-four leavers interviewed blamed the scanners (Exhibit 5).
InsightWhat it means
The problem is concentrated on one shift. It is mainly a problem of skill and of how the change was introduced, not of effort. That points away from a single style for the whole site.
The day shift is capable and settled. The night shift is new to its work, and its leaders are new to theirs. The two need different things from a leader.
The deadline is four months away. That is long enough to consult and train, and too short to let things drift.
OptionsWhat each choice does
Autocratic control would raise effort quickly, but it leaves the skills gap and loses more night-shift staff.
Paternalistic care would rebuild loyalty, but not capability.
A democratic redesign uses the night shift's knowledge of the system's faults, but starts slowly.
Laissez-faire suits the day shift and fails the night shift.
A situational approach combines direction and training for nights, delegation for days and consultation on the system.
RecommendationOne defensible answer
One defensible recommendation: lead situationally. Be directive with the night shift for the first six weeks, with daily coaching on the floor and full training on the system for every picker. Delegate to the experienced day-shift team leaders. Run a joint working group on how the system is used, and promise to act on what it finds. Explain openly why the two shifts are being led differently, and move the night shift towards more consultation as its skills grow.
CaveatWhen it would change
The recommendation rests on reading the problem as one of skill rather than effort. If the exit interviews and the survey had pointed mainly to pay or to the shift pattern, the answer would be different: no leadership style fixes a wage that is below the market.
Prompts for undergraduate and MBA seminars. They go beyond the IB course and are labelled as enrichment.
Source: Enrichment
Situational leadership assumes that a leader can read a team's readiness accurately. What evidence would you collect in Amara's first two weeks to test her reading of each shift, and what would make her change it?
Halden's owners hired a site manager from outside rather than promoting a team leader. Weigh the case for external succession in a business that one founder ran for fifteen years.
Suppose dispatch recovers but Lumen Home leaves anyway. What does that suggest about the limits of leadership as an explanation of a site's performance?
Arjun Agrawal | The Business Brief, https://the-business-brief-dun.vercel.app/cases/halden-distribution/. Original teaching material, not an IB publication.
The organizations in the teaching cases are fictional unless a case says otherwise.