Decision Room

Halden Distribution: how to lead in the first ninety days

Choose how to lead a warehouse in trouble, then lead it through a crisis two weeks before peak season.

Source: Simulated data Case file: Halden Distribution
  1. Situation
  2. Decision
  3. Consequence
  4. Implementation
  5. Outcome
  6. Debrief

Section 01: The situation

You are Amara Osei, the new site manager. The owners want the client kept; the staff want to know what kind of manager you are.

On-time dispatch is 91.4% and the client needs 97% by the first week of November. Read the evidence by shift before you choose: the two shifts are not in the same position. Your first decision sets your approach for the next ninety days. Your second is about a single night.

Read the full case: Halden Distribution

The evidence pack: 4 exhibits
Exhibit 1

Site performance over the last year

Source: Simulated data From the case file: Halden Distribution
Month On-time dispatch (%) Picking errors per 1,000 orders Absence rate (%)
August 202598.12.13.1
October 202597.62.33.4
December 202596.03.44.2
February 202694.24.04.9
April 202692.74.65.3
June 202691.45.25.8

The warehouse management system went live in December 2025.

Source Simulated teaching data, from the site's monthly reports.
Exhibit 2

People, by shift, over the last twelve months

Source: Simulated data From the case file: Halden Distribution
Measure Day shift Night shift Whole site
Employees now8258140
Average number of employees in the year8154135
Employees who left in the year182846
Labour turnover (%)22.251.934.1
Average length of service (years)7.42.95.5
Team leaders' average experience as team leaders (years)9.10.6
Training on the new system (hours per person)62

Labour turnover is the number of employees who left divided by the average number of employees, multiplied by 100. Two years ago it was 18.9% for the whole site.

Source Simulated teaching data, from the site's personnel records.
Exhibit 3

Staff survey, July 2026 (112 of 140 responded)

Source: Simulated data From the case file: Halden Distribution
Statement Day shift agreeing (%) Night shift agreeing (%)
I know what is expected of me8154
I am consulted about changes that affect my work3821
I have had the training I need to use the new system7233
My team leader helps me solve problems7448
I would recommend Halden as a place to work5829

66 day-shift and 46 night-shift employees responded. Across both shifts, the average share agreeing with the five statements is 53%, the engagement score used in the Decision Room.

Source Simulated teaching data.
Exhibit 5

Why night-shift leavers left (exit interviews with 24 of the 28)

Source: Simulated data From the case file: Halden Distribution
Nobody explained the new scanners properly
11
Targets changed without warning
7
Better pay elsewhere
4
The shift pattern
2
Source Simulated teaching data, from exit interview notes. Each leaver gave one main reason.

The board pack

Source: Simulated data
Measure Now After your decisions Change
On-time dispatch after ninety days91.4%Not decided
On-time dispatch in peak weekNot yet knownNot decided
Picking errors per 1,000 orders5.2Not decided
Labour turnover, annual rate34.1%Not decided
Engagement score53 out of 100Not decided
Lumen Home's contractAt riskNot decided
Queued orders out on time on the crisis nightNot yet knownNot decided
Lumen Home's urgent orders out on time that nightNot yet knownNot decided
Overtime cost that night£0Not decided

Section 02: Choose your approach

How will you lead for the first ninety days?

Look at Exhibits 2 and 3 by shift. Ask whether the problem is effort, skill, the system or the way the change was made.

How will you lead for the first ninety days?
See what happens

Consequence

Targets on every wall, and dispatch climbs, for now

Within six weeks on-time dispatch rises to 95.8% and errors fall to 3.1 per 1,000 orders: clear instructions fix the easy problems quickly. But the night shift's real gap, training on the new system, is treated as a discipline problem. Eleven night-shift pickers leave in three months, and their replacements are slower than the people they replace. In peak week dispatch reaches 96.2%: better, but short of the client's 97%. Lumen Home puts the contract under review.

How people react

  • Lumen Home Mixed Sees improvement, but not enough.
  • Day shift Mixed Values the clarity and resents the warnings.
  • Night shift Negative Feels blamed for a system nobody taught them.
  • Team leaders Negative Sidelined by targets set above them.

Risks now

  • Control works fastest where the problem is effort. Where the problem is skill or the system, it raises pressure without raising capability.

The theory behind it

Autocratic leadership brings fast decisions and clear standards. It is useful in a crisis or with inexperienced staff, at the cost of motivation and of the ideas the people doing the work could contribute.

The figures after this choice
On-time dispatch after ninety days 95.8% +4.4% on now
On-time dispatch in peak week 96.2% Was Not yet known on now
Picking errors per 1,000 orders 3.1 −2.1 on now
Labour turnover, annual rate 41% +6.9% on now
Engagement score 44 out of 100 −9 out of 100 on now
Lumen Home's contract Under review Was At risk on now
See what happens

Consequence

Morale recovers; the system does not

Long-serving staff respond. Turnover falls towards 29% a year and the engagement score rises to 58. But nobody is trained on the scanners, and the night shift still works around the system rather than with it. On-time dispatch is 93.1% at ninety days and 93.9% in peak week. Lumen Home gives notice that it will move its contract.

How people react

  • Long-serving staff Positive Feel looked after again.
  • Night shift Mixed Appreciate the attention; still struggle with the scanners.
  • Lumen Home Negative Leaves at the end of the year.
  • The owners Negative Paid a bonus and lost a third of the work.

Risks now

  • Care without capability. Goodwill does not close a skills gap.

The theory behind it

Paternalistic leadership means the leader decides, in what she sees as the staff's interest, and looks after their welfare. It builds loyalty, as the founder's style did, but keeps decisions at the top and does not by itself build skills.

The figures after this choice
On-time dispatch after ninety days 93.1% +1.7% on now
On-time dispatch in peak week 93.9% Was Not yet known on now
Picking errors per 1,000 orders 4.6 −0.6 on now
Labour turnover, annual rate 29% −5.1% on now
Engagement score 58 out of 100 +5 out of 100 on now
Lumen Home's contract Lost Was At risk on now
See what happens

Consequence

Slow to start, and then the night shift finds the fix

The first month is slow, and at ninety days dispatch is only 92.8%. Then the night-shift group finds that half the scanner faults come from a charging rota that leaves handsets flat at 3 a.m., and that the system's pick paths send pickers across the building twice. Fixing both, and training everyone in the redesigned process, lifts peak-week dispatch to 97.4%. Lumen Home renews. Engagement rises to 63 and turnover falls towards 27.5% a year.

How people react

  • Night shift Positive Sees its ideas adopted.
  • Team leaders Positive Lead the working groups and grow into the role.
  • Lumen Home Positive Renews after an anxious two months.
  • The owners Mixed Were worried in the second month.

Risks now

  • Consultation takes weeks the business may not have. Here it worked because the deadline was four months away.

The theory behind it

Democratic leadership shapes decisions with the people affected. It is slower, but it uses their knowledge and builds commitment to the result.

The figures after this choice
On-time dispatch after ninety days 92.8% +1.4% on now
On-time dispatch in peak week 97.4% Was Not yet known on now
Picking errors per 1,000 orders 3.4 −1.8 on now
Labour turnover, annual rate 27.5% −6.6% on now
Engagement score 63 out of 100 +10 out of 100 on now
Lumen Home's contract Renewed Was At risk on now
See what happens

Consequence

Freedom works where people already know what to do

The day shift's experienced team leaders keep their zones near 98%. The night shift's two new team leaders, untrained on the system and unsupported, make different rules for different zones, and night-shift dispatch slips to 88%. Across the site, dispatch is 92.0% at ninety days and 91.6% in peak week. Lumen Home gives notice.

How people react

  • Day-shift team leaders Positive Enjoy the trust.
  • Night-shift team leaders Negative Feel abandoned.
  • Night pickers Negative Get different rules from different leaders.
  • Lumen Home Negative Leaves at the end of the year.

Risks now

  • Delegation without readiness. Autonomy suits capable, motivated teams and fails inexperienced ones.

The theory behind it

Laissez-faire leadership gives minimal direction. It can release the talent of an expert team; with an inexperienced team it amounts to an absence of leadership.

The figures after this choice
On-time dispatch after ninety days 92% +0.6% on now
On-time dispatch in peak week 91.6% Was Not yet known on now
Picking errors per 1,000 orders 5.6 +0.4 on now
Labour turnover, annual rate 36% +1.9% on now
Engagement score 50 out of 100 −3 out of 100 on now
Lumen Home's contract Lost Was At risk on now
See what happens

Consequence

Different teams, different leadership, one result

For the night shift Amara is directive: a clear process, daily coaching on the floor and training for every picker in the first month. She delegates to the day shift's experienced team leaders, asking only for results, and consults both shifts on the system, adopting the night shift's ideas on the charging rota and the pick paths. At ninety days dispatch is 95.1%; in peak week it is 97.8%. Lumen Home renews. Turnover falls towards 26% a year. Some day-shift staff ask why the night shift gets more attention, and Amara has to explain the difference more than once.

How people react

  • Night shift Positive Trained, coached and listened to.
  • Day shift Mixed Trusted, and a little puzzled by the difference.
  • Lumen Home Positive Renews.
  • Team leaders Positive Night leaders learn; day leaders lead.

Risks now

  • People see different treatment before they see the reason for it. It needs explaining.

The theory behind it

Situational leadership matches the style to the task and to the readiness of the people: more direction where skill or confidence is low, more delegation where it is high.

The figures after this choice
On-time dispatch after ninety days 95.1% +3.7% on now
On-time dispatch in peak week 97.8% Was Not yet known on now
Picking errors per 1,000 orders 2.9 −2.3 on now
Labour turnover, annual rate 26% −8.1% on now
Engagement score 61 out of 100 +8 out of 100 on now
Lumen Home's contract Renewed Was At risk on now
Optional. Saved on this device only.

Section 03: The night the scanners fail

Two weeks before peak, a failed update takes the scanners down. 3,200 orders are queued, 2,000 of them Lumen Home's next-day orders, and the trucks leave at 6 a.m. What do you do?

This round is about decision-making under time pressure. Some secondary sources place scientific and intuitive decision-making in subtopic 2.3 as HL-only content; that has not been checked against the Guide.

Two weeks before peak, a failed update takes the scanners down. 3,200 orders are queued, 2,000 of them Lumen Home's next-day orders, and the trucks leave at 6 a.m. What do you do?
See what happens

Outcome

Most orders out, and nobody's priorities set

Within twenty minutes every picker has a zone and a paper list. The night is fast and loud, and by 6 a.m. 2,870 of the 3,200 orders are on the trucks (89.7%). But orders were picked in the order they came, so 220 of Lumen Home's 2,000 urgent orders miss the trucks. Overtime costs £1,850. The team leaders, sidelined, say afterwards that they could have run it.

How people react

  • Pickers Positive Relieved that someone took charge.
  • Team leaders Negative Sidelined in the moment they could have led.
  • Lumen Home Mixed Unhappy about 220 late orders.

Risks now

  • Fast intuitive decisions can miss what a few minutes of analysis would have caught.

The theory behind it

Directive leadership and intuitive decision-making are often right in a crisis, when speed matters more than consultation. Intuition is fast, but it can miss what analysis would have caught, here the client's priorities.

The figures after this choice
Queued orders out on time on the crisis night 89.7% Was Not yet known on now
Lumen Home's urgent orders out on time that night 89% Was Not yet known on now
Overtime cost that night £1,850 +£1,850 on now
See what happens

Outcome

A slow start, and leaders who learn

The two new team leaders take forty minutes to agree a plan. By 6 a.m. 2,610 orders are out (81.6%), including 1,620 of Lumen Home's 2,000 (81.0%). Overtime costs £1,200. The team leaders' confidence grows, and the review they write afterwards is the best the site has produced, but Lumen Home's operations director calls at 7 a.m.

How people react

  • Team leaders Positive Grow in confidence.
  • Lumen Home Negative Calls to complain about 380 late orders.

Risks now

  • Delegating in a crisis develops people and costs speed when they are inexperienced.

The theory behind it

Delegation builds capability over time. In a crisis its cost is speed, and the cost is highest when the people trusted with the decision are new to it.

The figures after this choice
Queued orders out on time on the crisis night 81.6% Was Not yet known on now
Lumen Home's urgent orders out on time that night 81% Was Not yet known on now
Overtime cost that night £1,200 +£1,200 on now
See what happens

Outcome

Fewer orders out, but the right ones

Amara and the shift's data analyst sort the queue by promised delivery. Lumen Home agrees that 60 of its orders can go a day late if the rest are guaranteed. Picking starts later, and by 6 a.m. only 2,350 orders are out (73.4%), but 1,940 of Lumen Home's 2,000 urgent orders are among them (97.0%). Two smaller clients complain about delays. Overtime costs £1,850.

How people react

  • Lumen Home Positive Its promise to customers is kept.
  • Smaller clients Negative Their orders go out a day late.
  • Pickers Mixed Frustrated by the slow start.

Risks now

  • Prioritizing one client can breach promises to others. Whether that was right depends on their contracts.

The theory behind it

Scientific decision-making gathers and analyses data before deciding. It is slower, but it can find what matters most, here one client's orders.

The figures after this choice
Queued orders out on time on the crisis night 73.4% Was Not yet known on now
Lumen Home's urgent orders out on time that night 97% Was Not yet known on now
Overtime cost that night £1,850 +£1,850 on now
Optional. Saved on this device only.

Section 04: Debrief

The debrief opens when you have made every decision.

The trade-offs

  • Speed against capability. Directive leadership raises performance fastest; only consultation and training raised the night shift's capability.
  • Consistency against fit. One style for everyone is easy to explain; matching the style to each team works better and has to be explained.
  • Care against results. The founder's paternalistic style built loyalty the site still relies on, but it did not prepare anyone for a new system.

The evidence that matters

  • Exhibit 2. Night-shift turnover of 51.9% against 22.2% on days, and two hours of training per person. The problem is concentrated, and it is a problem of skill.
  • Exhibit 3. Only 21% of the night shift feel consulted about changes. The new system was imposed on the people who had to make it work.
  • Exhibit 4. The deadline. Four months is long enough for consultation to pay off, and not long enough for it to drift.

What would change your mind?

  • If the client's deadline were four weeks away instead of four months, which approach would you choose?
  • If the night shift's team leaders had ten years' experience, what would change?
  • If most night-shift leavers had cited pay, what could leadership alone achieve?

Misconceptions this tests

  • Treating one leadership style as the best. Each works in some situations and damages others.
  • Confusing paternalistic with democratic leadership. A paternalistic leader cares about the staff but still decides alone.
  • Treating laissez-faire as always a failure of leadership. With an expert team, stepping back can be the right decision.

Every first decision, side by side

The figures straight after each first-round choice, before any later decision.

Measure Now Autocratic turnaroundPaternalistic careDemocratic redesignLaissez-faire delegationSituational leadership
On-time dispatch after ninety days 91.4% 95.8%93.1%92.8%92%95.1%
On-time dispatch in peak week Not yet known 96.2%93.9%97.4%91.6%97.8%
Picking errors per 1,000 orders 5.2 3.14.63.45.62.9
Labour turnover, annual rate 34.1% 41%29%27.5%36%26%
Engagement score 53 out of 100 44 out of 10058 out of 10063 out of 10050 out of 10061 out of 100
Lumen Home's contract At risk Under reviewLostRenewedLostRenewed
Queued orders out on time on the crisis night Not yet known Not yet knownNot yet knownNot yet knownNot yet knownNot yet known
Lumen Home's urgent orders out on time that night Not yet known Not yet knownNot yet knownNot yet knownNot yet knownNot yet known
Overtime cost that night £0 £0£0£0£0£0

Exam link

Leadership questions reward the situation: which style fits these people, this task and this deadline, and why. Try the practice questions for 2.3 in the Assessment Centre.