People and Culture: Analysis

Motivation analysis

Each motivation theory is a lens that picks out different things about the same job. Rate what a job offers now, from pay and security to responsibility and purpose, and the tool reads the ratings through Taylor, Maslow and Herzberg and, at HL, McClelland, Deci and Ryan, equity theory and expectancy theory. It then suggests the rewards and the training that fit, each with its catch.

Back to 2.4 Motivation and demotivation

Status
SL and HLAO2, AO3
Worked example
The night shift at Halden Distribution, a fictional warehouse

Section 01: How to use it

  1. Rate what the job offers now on each factor, from 1 (poorly) to 5 (very well). Base each rating on evidence, such as a staff survey, exit interviews, pay rates elsewhere or what staff say.

  2. Tick the facts about the job that decide which methods of payment are possible, such as whether each person's output can be counted.

  3. At HL, rate the staff's beliefs about fairness and rewards, and choose their dominant need if the evidence shows one.

  4. Read what each theory sees, then the rewards and training that fit, each with its drawback. Your analysis is kept on this device; download it as JSON or CSV, or print it.

Where it sits in the course. Subtopic 2.4, Motivation and demotivation (guide, p. 26). The theories of Taylor, Maslow and Herzberg are for SL and HL; McClelland's acquired needs theory, Deci and Ryan's self-determination theory, and equity and expectancy theory are HL only. All the theories are AO3, so answers are expected to judge how well a theory explains a situation. Financial rewards, non-financial rewards and the types of training are for SL and HL at AO2. The ratings, the factors each theory reads and the threshold for a need that is met are the platform's teaching model, not part of the guide.

Show content for

Showing everything. HL-only material is marked HL.

Analysis

The night shift at Halden Distribution, a fictional warehouse

Source: Simulated data SL and HL

The ratings are one reading of the evidence in the Halden Distribution case: its staff survey (Exhibit 3), the exit interviews with night-shift leavers (Exhibit 5) and the figures by shift (Exhibit 2). The ratings are judgements made for this example, and every figure in the case is simulated.

Your changes are kept in this browser, on this device only.

The job Pickers on the night shift at Halden Distribution, since the new scanning system arrived

Why the worked example is rated this way
Responsibility and a say in how the work is done: 1
Only 21% of the night shift agree that they are consulted about changes that affect their work, against 38% on days (Exhibit 3).
Training and the chance of promotion: 1
Night-shift pickers had two hours of training on the new system, against six on days, and only 33% say they have had the training they need (Exhibits 2 and 3).
Fair and supportive supervision: 2
48% of the night shift say their team leader helps them solve problems, against 74% on days, and their team leaders have 0.6 years' experience in the role (Exhibits 2 and 3).
Recognition and feedback for good work: 2
Seven of the 24 leavers interviewed left mainly because targets changed without warning (Exhibit 5), so what staff heard about their work was new targets rather than feedback. This is a judgement, as the case has no direct measure.
Interesting, varied work and a sense that it makes a difference: 2 each
The scanners now tell pickers what to pick and in what order, and only 29% of the night shift would recommend Halden as a place to work (Exhibit 3). Both ratings are judgements.
Pay compared with similar jobs elsewhere: 3
Only 4 of the 24 leavers left mainly for better pay elsewhere (Exhibit 5), so pay is rated middling rather than the main grievance. It can change only at the annual review in April.
Working conditions: 3
Two of the 24 leavers named the shift pattern as their main reason for leaving (Exhibit 5).
Job security and relationships with colleagues: 3 each
The exhibits say little about either, so both are rated midway, as judgements.
Targets that effort can actually reach: 2 (HL)
Eleven of the 24 leavers said nobody explained the new scanners properly (Exhibit 5), so effort does not reliably produce the performance asked for.
Pay and treatment seen as fair beside colleagues: 2 (HL)
The night shift had a third of the day shift's training on the same system (Exhibit 2), an obvious comparison for staff in the same warehouse.
Good performance reliably rewarded, and rewards that staff value: 3 each (HL)
The case says little about either belief, so both are rated midway, as judgements.
What the job offers now, from 1 (poorly) to 5 (very well)
  1. 3
  2. 3
  3. 3
  4. 3
  5. 2
  6. 2
  7. 1
  8. 2
  9. 1
  10. 2
Beliefs about rewards, 1 to 5 HL
  1. 2
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 3
The job

This is the worked example. With JavaScript on, you can change every rating and the analysis follows.

What the theories see

Reading. Grievances and little drive: hygiene factors average 2.8 and motivators 1.5 out of 5. The lowest unmet need on Maslow's hierarchy is esteem.

Implication. The rewards that fit best: job enrichment, empowerment and training. Fix what causes dissatisfaction first, then build what motivates.

Taylor: scientific management

Output can be counted, so Taylor would study the job, set a standard method and target, train people in it and pay a piece rate for output above the standard. The job already offers little say or variety, so tighter standards and close monitoring risk deepening the demotivation: the criticism made of digital Taylorism, an HL idea in subtopic 5.9. Watch quality: pay for speed can raise errors.

Maslow: the hierarchy of needs

The lowest need not met is esteem (1.3 out of 5). Maslow would expect it to drive behaviour now, so rewards aimed at higher needs will do less until it is met.

Maslow's hierarchy for this jobMaslow's levels, scored from the ratings out of 5: Physiological 3.0, met; Safety 3.0, met; Social 3.0, met; Esteem 1.3, not met; Self-actualization 2.0, not met. The lowest level not met is esteem.012345met from 3Self-actualization2.0 not metEsteem1.3 lowest unmetSocial3.0Safety3.0Physiological3.0

Herzberg: motivation and hygiene

Both scales are low. Herzberg would fix the hygiene factors first, starting with fair and supportive supervision, to end the dissatisfaction, then build the motivators, starting with responsibility and a say in how the work is done.

Herzberg's two scales for this jobHygiene factors average 2.8 and motivators 1.5 out of 5, which places the job in the part of the chart labelled "Grievances and little drive". The dashed lines mark a rating of 3.Motivated, butwith grievancesFew complaintsand real motivationGrievances andlittle driveFew complaints,but little drive1122334455Hygiene factors (average)Motivators (average)This job (2.8, 1.5)

McClelland: acquired needs HL

Choose the dominant need of the staff, if the evidence shows one, to see whether the job feeds it.

Deci and Ryan: self-determination HL

The weakest of the three basic needs is autonomy (1.0 out of 5). Deci and Ryan would expect intrinsic motivation to stay low until it is met, through empowerment and a say in how the work is done. Controlling rewards and close monitoring would make it worse.

Autonomy 1.0, competence 1.5, relatedness 3.0, each out of 5.

Adams: equity theory HL

Staff are likely to feel under-rewarded beside the people they compare themselves with. Adams would expect them to restore the balance by cutting effort, asking for more, or leaving, whatever else improves. Perceived fairness matters, so open, consistent decisions on pay help.

Vroom: expectancy theory HL

The illustrative index is 0.06 on a scale from 0 to 1. The weakest belief is expectancy, and because the three combine by multiplication it holds the others back: strengthen it with reachable targets, training and the right equipment.

Expectancy 0.25 × instrumentality 0.50 × valence 0.50 = 0.06, an illustrative index, not a measurement.

HL McClelland, Deci and Ryan, equity theory and expectancy theory are HL-only content, hidden while you are viewing SL content.

The ratings as a table
Factor Rating, 1 to 5
Pay compared with similar jobs elsewhere3
Job security3
Working conditions: safety, comfort and hours3
Relationships with colleagues and a sense of belonging3
Fair and supportive supervision2
Recognition and feedback for good work2
Responsibility and a say in how the work is done1
Interesting, varied work2
Training and the chance of promotion1
A sense that the work makes a difference2
Pay and treatment seen as fair beside colleagues HL2
Targets that effort can actually reach HL2
Good performance reliably rewarded HL3
Rewards that staff actually value HL3

Which factor speaks to which theory, the threshold of 3 for a need that is met and the expectancy index are the platform's teaching model. The theories themselves set no numbers.

The rewards that fit

The financial and non-financial rewards the guide names, and its types of training, chosen by the platform's rules from the ratings and the job.

Financial rewards

  • Open, consistent decisions on pay and treatment Worth considering HL

    Pay itself is rated 3, but fairness beside colleagues only 2. Consistent rules on pay, hours and training remove a sense of injustice that no bonus would fix.

    Against: Perceptions of fairness are hard to change once they have set in.

    Equity, Herzberg (hygiene)

  • Piece rates, with a guaranteed minimum Worth considering

    Output can be counted for each person, so pay can follow it.

    Against: Pay for speed can raise errors and stress, and it works against autonomy.

    Taylor

  • Performance-related pay Worth considering

    A bonus for agreed targets links reward to performance, which strengthens the belief that good work is rewarded.

    Against: It needs targets that are fair to measure, and those who miss out may feel the system is unfair.

    Expectancy (instrumentality), Herzberg (recognition)

  • Profit-related pay Worth considering

    The work is done in teams, so a bonus from profit gives everyone a shared interest in the result.

    Against: One person’s effort makes little difference to total profit, and in a bad year the bonus disappears.

    Maslow (social), equity

  • An employee share ownership scheme Worth considering

    Shares reward staying and give staff a stake in the firm’s future.

    Against: The link to effort is weak, and staff savings become tied to their employer.

    Maslow (safety and esteem)

Non-financial rewards

  • Job enrichment Strong fit

    The work itself (2), responsibility (1) and growth (1) are the motivators. Complete, challenging tasks with responsibility for the result build them.

    Against: It needs training and support, and staff may expect pay to rise with it.

    Herzberg (motivators), Maslow (esteem and self-actualization)

  • Empowerment Strong fit

    Responsibility is rated 1. Authority to make decisions about their own work, with training and trust, meets the need for autonomy.

    Against: It needs managers willing to let go and a culture that accepts some mistakes.

    Deci and Ryan (autonomy), Herzberg (responsibility)

  • Job rotation Worth considering

    Moving between tasks adds variety and builds a multi-skilled team that can cover absences.

    Against: If every task is dull it only swaps one dull task for another.

    Herzberg (the work itself)

  • Job enlargement Worth considering

    More tasks of a similar level give more variety.

    Against: Staff may see it as more work for the same pay.

    Herzberg (the work itself)

  • Purpose: showing the difference the work makes Worth considering

    Showing staff the effect of their work on customers and the community builds meaning.

    Against: Claims of purpose that do not match how the business behaves breed cynicism.

    Maslow (self-actualization), Deci and Ryan

  • Teamwork Worth considering

    Relationships are rated 3. Teams with shared goals meet social needs and spread skills.

    Against: Teams can bring conflict and members who rely on others’ effort.

    Maslow (social), Deci and Ryan (relatedness)

Training

  • Training Strong fit

    Training and promotion are rated 1 and reachable targets 2. Induction for new starters, then training on the job and off the job, builds competence and the belief that effort will succeed.

    Against: It costs time and money, and trained staff may be poached.

    Deci and Ryan (competence), expectancy, Herzberg (growth)

Section 02: What it leaves out

Every model simplifies. Say so in an answer, and say what else you would want to know.

  • The ratings are judgements. Two people reading the same evidence can rate a job differently, and the analysis is only as good as the evidence behind the ratings.
  • Which factors each theory reads, the threshold of 3 for a need that is met and the expectancy index are the platform's teaching model. The theories set no numbers, and Vroom's three beliefs cannot be measured.
  • One set of ratings treats a workforce as one person. People differ, and the same job can meet one person's needs and not another's.
  • The rewards are chosen by the platform's rules from the ratings. A real decision weighs their cost, the culture, the labour market and what staff say they want.
  • Every theory has its critics, set out in the notes on motivation and demotivation. The tool shows what each theory would say, not which one is right.

Section 03: Read and practise next