- Responsibility and a say in how the work is done: 1
- Only 21% of the night shift agree that they are consulted about changes that affect their work, against 38% on days (Exhibit 3).
- Training and the chance of promotion: 1
- Night-shift pickers had two hours of training on the new system, against six on days, and only 33% say they have had the training they need (Exhibits 2 and 3).
- Fair and supportive supervision: 2
- 48% of the night shift say their team leader helps them solve problems, against 74% on days, and their team leaders have 0.6 years' experience in the role (Exhibits 2 and 3).
- Recognition and feedback for good work: 2
- Seven of the 24 leavers interviewed left mainly because targets changed without warning (Exhibit 5), so what staff heard about their work was new targets rather than feedback. This is a judgement, as the case has no direct measure.
- Interesting, varied work and a sense that it makes a difference: 2 each
- The scanners now tell pickers what to pick and in what order, and only 29% of the night shift would recommend Halden as a place to work (Exhibit 3). Both ratings are judgements.
- Pay compared with similar jobs elsewhere: 3
- Only 4 of the 24 leavers left mainly for better pay elsewhere (Exhibit 5), so pay is rated middling rather than the main grievance. It can change only at the annual review in April.
- Working conditions: 3
- Two of the 24 leavers named the shift pattern as their main reason for leaving (Exhibit 5).
- Job security and relationships with colleagues: 3 each
- The exhibits say little about either, so both are rated midway, as judgements.
- Targets that effort can actually reach: 2 (HL)
- Eleven of the 24 leavers said nobody explained the new scanners properly (Exhibit 5), so effort does not reliably produce the performance asked for.
- Pay and treatment seen as fair beside colleagues: 2 (HL)
- The night shift had a third of the day shift's training on the same system (Exhibit 2), an obvious comparison for staff in the same warehouse.
- Good performance reliably rewarded, and rewards that staff value: 3 each (HL)
- The case says little about either belief, so both are rated midway, as judgements.