For teachers Teacher resource area
Classroom activity ยท Evidence first, then the board
Silvertree: why do the nurses leave?
A pay rise has not stopped nurses leaving a chain of clinics. Pairs first sort the evidence on why they leave, then groups of five hold the board meeting where the head of people must win support for a plan that deals with the cause, not the cost.
- Time
- 48 minutes
- Groups
- of 5
- Built on
- The case file Silvertree Clinics
- Subtopics
- 2.4 Motivation and demotivation; 2.1 Introduction to human resource management
- Level
- SL and HL
The business in the case is fictional and its figures are simulated. The lesson plan is the platform's suggestion, not an IB requirement.
Before the lesson
- Students read the Silvertree Clinics case file, at least Exhibits 4, 5 and 7.
- A two-column table on paper or a whiteboard, headed hygiene factors and motivators.
The roles
Each role is a stakeholder in the case. What they want and what worries them are taken from the case file, so students argue from the evidence.
-
Thandiwe Mokoena, head of people
- Wants
- A plan that deals with why nurses leave.
- Worried about
- Being asked for a quick saving rather than a lasting fix.
- In the lesson
- Proposes one option, or a sequence led by one, and links it to the evidence.
-
Dr Pieter van Wyk and Dr Aisha Patel, founders and shareholders
- Wants
- Good clinics at a fair price, where patients see the same faces.
- Worried about
- A business that runs on agency staff and loses the continuity of care it was built on.
- In the lesson
- Played by one student for both founders. Asks whether the plan brings back the continuity of care the clinics were built on.
-
Atlantic Health Partners, investor
- Wants
- A margin above 10% and a return on its investment.
- Worried about
- Rising costs, and spending that does not change anything.
- In the lesson
- Asks what the plan costs each year and how its effect will be measured.
-
Nurses
- Wants
- Workable rotas, a manageable workload, development and fair pay.
- Worried about
- Rotas that leave no room for life outside work, and no way to progress.
- In the lesson
- Says, from Exhibits 4 and 5, what would make a nurse stay.
-
Clinic managers
- Wants
- Fully staffed clinics they have time to run.
- Worried about
- Giving up control of the rota, or adding work to an already wide span of control.
- In the lesson
- Says what the plan asks of a manager who already runs a wide span of control.
The lesson, phase by phase
| Minutes | Clock | Phase | What happens |
|---|---|---|---|
| 10 | 0 to 10 | Why do nurses leave? | In pairs, students sort the reasons in the exit interviews (Exhibit 5) and the survey (Exhibit 4) into hygiene factors and motivators, and circle the two reasons cited most often. |
| 8 | 10 to 18 | Match the options | Groups match each of the five options in Exhibit 7 to the reasons it addresses, and cross out any option that addresses none. |
| 12 | 18 to 30 | The board meeting | Thandiwe proposes. The investor and the founders question her; the nurses and the clinic managers each give their view in a minute. The board decides. |
| 8 | 30 to 38 | Write the recommendation | Each group writes a recommendation of about 250 words, with the evidence for it, its yearly cost and effect, and how it will be measured clinic by clinic. |
| 10 | 38 to 48 | Debrief | Take the questions below in order, then compare the groups' plans with the case's own debrief. |
| 48 | minutes in all | ||
Each group produces: A recommendation to the board of about 250 words, as the case's exercise sets it.
Debrief
Ask these in order. Take answers from several groups before you give your own view.
- The pay rise made more nurses feel fairly paid, and turnover rose anyway. What does that tell you, in Herzberg's terms?
- Which option is cheapest on paper, and does it do anything about why nurses leave?
- At HL, how would you calculate labour turnover at one clinic, and why does the formula divide by the average number of nurses?
- At HL, which of the needs in self-determination theory does each option meet?
- What would you expect to see within a year if your plan is working?
What the case file's debrief says
Silvertree's problem is not pay. The pay rise moved the measure it was meant to move, and turnover rose anyway. The evidence from the exit interviews, the survey and Observatory points to the rota, the workload and the lack of a future. The strongest answers follow that evidence, and notice that the cheapest option on paper, a contracted agency, is a way of paying less for the problem rather than solving it.
Errors to listen for
- Recommending more pay because pay usually motivates, without reading the survey and the exit interviews.
- Treating the contracted agency's saving as a solution.
- Calculating labour turnover with the number of nurses at the end of the year rather than the average.
- Using Herzberg to label factors without showing which ones the evidence points to.