For teachers Teacher resource area

Classroom activity ยท Board meeting in role

Bellbird: the board meeting before the bank

A profitable retailer is about to break its overdraft limit. Groups of six hold Bellbird's board meeting, with the family, the finance manager, the bank and the largest supplier each pressing their own interest, and leave with one plan and a memo the bank would accept.

Time
50 minutes
Groups
of 6
Built on
The case file Bellbird Home and Garden
Subtopics
3.7 Cash flow; 3.2 Sources of finance; 3.5 Profitability and liquidity ratio analysis
Level
SL and HL

Source: Arjun Agrawal framework Source: Simulated data

The business in the case is fictional and its figures are simulated. The lesson plan is the platform's suggestion, not an IB requirement.

Open the case file

Before the lesson

  • Students read the Bellbird case file, at least Exhibits 3 and 6 to 8.
  • Print one copy of Exhibit 6 per group, or keep the case open on one device per group.

The roles

Each role is a stakeholder in the case. What they want and what worries them are taken from the case file, so students argue from the evidence.

  1. Lena Kowalski, finance manager

    Wants
    A plan the bank will accept, and a forecast that holds.
    Worried about
    A breach of the limit that damages her credibility with the bank.
    In the lesson
    Presents the forecast and the four options, and answers questions on the figures.
  2. Helen Marsh, managing director and shareholder

    Wants
    Growth, with the business still in the family's hands.
    Worried about
    Being the generation that sold the land, gave away control or closed a store a year after opening it.
    In the lesson
    Chairs the meeting and puts the decision to a vote.
  3. Jim Marsh, founder, director and shareholder

    Wants
    The business he built, and the Mount Gravatt site where it began.
    Worried about
    Selling the freehold to solve a problem that lasts three months.
    In the lesson
    Speaks for the business he founded and the Mount Gravatt site.
  4. Peter Marsh, shareholder outside the business

    Wants
    Dividends and the value of his shares.
    Worried about
    Dilution if new shares are sold, or a cut in dividends.
    In the lesson
    Speaks for the shareholder outside the business, his dividends and the value of his shares.
  5. Moreton Commercial Bank

    Wants
    Repayment, and security for what it lends.
    Worried about
    Lending more to a business whose liquidity has fallen.
    In the lesson
    Says what the bank needs to see by Friday, from its reply in Exhibit 7.
  6. Harbourline Outdoor Imports and other suppliers

    Wants
    Payment on time.
    Worried about
    Being used as a free source of finance by a customer that already pays late.
    In the lesson
    Says what the supplier will and will not accept, from Exhibit 8.

The lesson, phase by phase

Bellbird: the board meeting before the bank: 50 minutes in 5 phases
Minutes Clock Phase What happens
8 0 to 8 Read the forecast Every student finds, in Exhibit 3, the months in which the overdraft is over its limit and the worst closing balance. Check the answers as a class before anyone argues.
8 8 to 16 Prepare the roles Each student ranks the four options in Exhibit 6 from their role's point of view and writes the one sentence they will open with.
14 16 to 30 The board meeting Lena presents for two minutes. Each role responds in turn, the bank and the supplier last. Helen calls a vote; she has the casting vote.
8 30 to 38 Write the memo Each group writes the board's decision as the case asks, a memo of about 250 words with the forecast it produces, its main risk and two changes for next year.
12 38 to 50 Debrief Take the questions below in order, then compare the groups' choices with the case's own debrief.
50 minutes in all

Each group produces: A memo to the board of about 250 words, as the case's exercise sets it.

Debrief

Ask these in order. Take answers from several groups before you give your own view.

  1. Bellbird made a profit. Why is it still short of cash?
  2. Is the problem seasonal, structural or both? Which part does your chosen option deal with?
  3. When does the money from each option arrive, and does it arrive before the August breach?
  4. Which stakeholder could block your plan, and what would you offer them?
  5. What would make your choice wrong, and what would Bellbird do then?

What the case file's debrief says

Bellbird's problem is a three-month shortfall of about A$780k at its worst, sitting on top of a year of fast growth that used up the business's working capital. The strongest plans match the remedy to that shape: short-term finance for the seasonal gap now, and a separate decision, after the season, about the expansion that caused it.

Errors to listen for

  • Treating profit as cash. Bellbird is profitable and still short of cash.
  • Choosing the option that raises the most money rather than the one that fits the size and timing of the gap.
  • Missing that the leaseback and the new shares arrive after the August breach.
  • Recommending the closure of Coralwood as a cash measure without reading its month-by-month effect.