For teachers Teacher resource area

Classroom activity ยท Portfolio analysis, then the board

Tausi: four plans for one marketing reserve

A drinks maker has one reserve and four plans that each spend all of it. Groups place the portfolio with the figures, argue the plans in a board meeting where each director pushes a different product, and set a milestone that would show the chosen plan is working.

Time
45 minutes
Groups
of 5
Built on
The case file Tausi Beverages
Subtopics
4.1 Introduction to marketing; 4.5 The seven Ps of the marketing mix; 4.4 Market research
Level
SL and HL

Source: Arjun Agrawal framework Source: Simulated data

The business in the case is fictional and its figures are simulated. The lesson plan is the platform's suggestion, not an IB requirement.

Open the case file

Before the lesson

  • Students read the Tausi Beverages case file, at least Exhibits 3, 5, 6 and 7.
  • A blank Boston Consulting Group matrix per group, on paper or on the board.

The roles

Each role is a stakeholder in the case. What they want and what worries them are taken from the case file, so students argue from the evidence.

  1. Brian Otieno, marketing manager

    Wants
    A plan that builds the brands.
    Worried about
    Estimates he cannot defend if they turn out wrong.
    In the lesson
    Presents the plan the group prefers and defends its estimates.
  2. Wanjiru Kamau, managing director

    Wants
    Profitable growth, and a portfolio with a future.
    Worried about
    Spending the reserve on the wrong product.
    In the lesson
    Chairs the meeting and decides, with an eye on the portfolio's future.
  3. Joseph Kamau, founder and chair

    Wants
    The brand, and the relationships he built with distributors.
    Worried about
    Dropping a product the distributors have stocked for ten years.
    In the lesson
    Argues against dropping any product the distributors have stocked for years.
  4. Hassan Abdi, head of sales

    Wants
    Products his team can sell into shops.
    Worried about
    Losing the cola, which gets the sales team into price-conscious shops.
    In the lesson
    Argues for the products the sales team needs in shops.
  5. Faith Njeri, finance manager

    Wants
    A return on the reserve.
    Worried about
    A plan that earns back less than it spends for two years.
    In the lesson
    Argues for the plan with the best return over two years.

The lesson, phase by phase

Tausi: four plans for one marketing reserve: 45 minutes in 5 phases
Minutes Clock Phase What happens
10 0 to 10 Place the portfolio Groups place each product on the matrix with figures from the retail audit in Exhibit 3, its share against the largest rival and its segment's growth, not by impression.
8 10 to 18 Read the evidence critically Each group writes one reason to doubt the price test (Exhibit 5) and one reason to doubt the survey (Exhibit 6) before it reads the plans.
12 18 to 30 The board meeting Brian presents the four plans in Exhibit 7 and the one he backs. Joseph, Hassan and Faith each argue their position for a minute; Wanjiru decides.
5 30 to 35 Set the milestone The group agrees one measurable milestone for the chosen plan, and what Tausi will do if it is missed.
10 35 to 45 Debrief Take the questions below in order, then compare the groups' plans with the case's own debrief.
45 minutes in all

Each group produces: A recommendation of about 250 words with the plan, the portfolio reasoning, one milestone and the main risk, as the case's exercise sets it.

Debrief

Ask these in order. Take answers from several groups before you give your own view.

  1. Where did each product sit on the matrix, and which figures put it there?
  2. Is a shopper who says they would try a product the same as a sale? What does that do to the plans that rely on the survey?
  3. Does a price cut that raises revenue also raise profit? Use the price test to answer.
  4. Which plan has the best return over two years, and which over three? Which should the board care about more?
  5. What would make Wanjiru right to keep the cola, whatever the matrix says?

What the case file's debrief says

Tausi's four products sit in the four boxes of the BCG matrix, and the plans differ in which box they feed. The strongest answers use the matrix as a starting point rather than a verdict: they check it against contribution, capacity and the evidence on how Ginger Zing can grow, and they set a milestone that turns a three-year hope into a decision that can be reviewed.

Errors to listen for

  • Placing products on the BCG matrix without figures. Use share against the largest rival and the segment's growth.
  • Treating the 55% who would try a product as forecast sales.
  • Assuming that a price cut which raises revenue also raises profit.
  • Reading the panel's shares as shares of a whole national market.