Strategy Studio · Stage 4 of 4: Plan

Stakeholder salience

Judge each stakeholder's power, the legitimacy of its claim and its urgency, place it in one of seven classes, and see what each class asks of managers and how a stakeholder could move between classes.

Back to 1.4 Stakeholders

Enrichment Not in the guide Worked example: fictional

What the tool is for, and its limits

Section 01: Build your analysis

The tool opens on a worked example. Change anything: the analysis follows, and your work is kept on this device.

Scripts are off, so this is the worked example as a finished analysis. Every part of it can be read; to build your own, turn scripts on.

Your work is kept on this device as you type.

Your inputs

Stakeholders

Power: Can it impose its will on the business? Legitimacy: Is its claim proper and appropriate by the norms of its society? Urgency: Is the claim time-sensitive and critical to it, so that it calls for attention now?

  1. Class Definitive (power, legitimacy and urgency; salience high)

  2. Class Definitive (power, legitimacy and urgency; salience high)

  3. Class Definitive (power, legitimacy and urgency; salience high)

  4. Class Dominant (power and legitimacy; salience moderate)

  5. Class Dominant (power and legitimacy; salience moderate)

  6. Class Dependent (legitimacy and urgency; salience moderate)

  7. Class Discretionary (legitimacy only; salience low)

  8. Class Dormant (power only; salience low)

  9. Class Dangerous (power and urgency; salience moderate)

  10. Class Demanding (urgency only; salience low)

The analysis

Worked example Northvale Cycles is fictional and its figures are simulated. Change anything and this becomes your own analysis.

The three attributes

Northvale Cycles. Decision: Launch fleet cargo bikes for delivery firms, with a second assembly shift and direct sales

Stakeholder salience: power, legitimacy and urgencyThree overlapping circles for power, legitimacy and urgency. 1 The Marsh family (owners): definitive (power, legitimacy and urgency); 2 Assembly staff: definitive (power, legitimacy and urgency); 3 Independent dealers: definitive (power, legitimacy and urgency); 4 The bank: dominant (power and legitimacy); 5 City council: dominant (power and legitimacy); 6 Delivery firms: dependent (legitimacy and urgency); 7 Neighbours of the works: discretionary (legitimacy only); 8 A direct-online e-bike brand: dormant (power only); 9 A former parts supplier: dangerous (power and urgency); 10 An anonymous online account: demanding (urgency only).POWERLEGITIMACYURGENCYDORMANT8DISCRETIONARY7DEMANDING10DOMINANT45DANGEROUS9DEPENDENT6DEFINITIVE123
  • Each numbered circle is a stakeholder, numbered as in the inputs
  • Its region shows the attributes it holds, and its class
  • Salience: high with three attributes, moderate with two, low with one

Three stakeholders are definitive, with a powerful, legitimate and urgent claim: The Marsh family (owners), Assembly staff and Independent dealers. Their claims come first. Dominant: The bank and City council, whose influence is assured; keep the formal channels open. Dangerous: A former parts supplier, with power and urgency but no legitimate claim; plan for the risk without rewarding the pressure. Dependent: Delivery firms, whose urgent, legitimate claim relies on others to enforce it. Watch The bank (definitive if it gained urgency), City council (definitive if it gained urgency), A former parts supplier (definitive if it gained legitimacy), Delivery firms (definitive if it gained power), A direct-online e-bike brand (dangerous if it gained urgency) and An anonymous online account (dangerous if it gained power). Salience is about whose claims managers notice, not whose claims are right: a dependent stakeholder can hold the most just claim of all.

Classes and what they ask of managers

Each stakeholder's power, legitimacy and urgency, its class, its salience and what the class asks of managers
No.StakeholderPowerLegitimateUrgentClassWhat it asks of managers
1The Marsh family (owners)Restoring profit while keeping control of the business.UtilitarianYesYesDefinitiveSalience highGive its claim priority now: consult it before the decision is final and agree how the claim will be met.Your plan: Agree the case, the budget and the review dates at the December board.
2Assembly staffA second shift means evening work, and a smaller range could mean fewer jobs.UtilitarianYesYesDefinitiveSalience highGive its claim priority now: consult it before the decision is final and agree how the claim will be met.Your plan: Consult the staff council before deciding; ask for volunteers first and pay a shift premium.
3Independent dealersDirect fleet sales could bypass them and take their servicing work.UtilitarianYesYesDefinitiveSalience highGive its claim priority now: consult it before the decision is final and agree how the claim will be met.Your plan: Pay dealers a commission on fleet sales in their area and use them for servicing.
4The bankThe loan for tooling and stock being repaid on time.UtilitarianYesNoDominantSalience moderateKeep formal channels open, such as board reports, lender reviews or account meetings, and watch for the urgency that would make it definitive.Your plan: Show the cash flow forecast and the review points before the loan is drawn.
5City councilCleaner deliveries in the low-emission zone, and safe cycle lanes.CoerciveYesNoDominantSalience moderateKeep formal channels open, such as board reports, lender reviews or account meetings, and watch for the urgency that would make it definitive.Your plan: Brief the council on the plan and ask about the grant.
9A former parts supplierRenewal of a contract that ended under its own terms, or it will publish claims about battery safety.NormativeNoYesDangerousSalience moderateIdentify the risk and plan for it, but do not reward illegitimate pressure; protect the business and the people the pressure could harm.Your plan: Do not renew under pressure; publish the battery test results and take legal advice on the claims.
6Delivery firmsReliable bikes, repairs within a day and a fair price, before the van charges start.NoYesYesDependentSalience moderateWeigh the claim on its merits now. If a powerful ally takes it up, it becomes definitive, so act before that happens.Your plan: Run a paid trial with one firm and share the results with the others.
8A direct-online e-bike brandNone on this decision; it competes for the same customers.UtilitarianNoNoDormantSalience lowLittle contact is needed now, but keep it in view: with an urgent or a legitimate claim it would become dangerous or dominant.Your plan: Track its prices and any move into fleets.
7Neighbours of the worksQuiet evenings, without noise and traffic from a late shift.NoYesNoDiscretionarySalience lowNothing forces managers to engage, so engaging is a choice, often made on ethical grounds or for goodwill.Your plan: Explain the shift hours and keep deliveries to the daytime.
10An anonymous online accountDaily demands that Northvale drop the fleet plan.NoNoYesDemandingSalience lowBothersome rather than dangerous: acknowledge it and watch it, without letting it take attention from legitimate claims.Your plan: Note it and do not engage; answer real questions about the plan in public.

How each could move

Attributes are not fixed: a stakeholder gains power through allies, urgency when a deadline nears, legitimacy when a claim is recognized. Each line shows the class it would move to.

  • The Marsh family (owners) (definitive)Their urgency would ease if profit recovered without the plan.losing power: dependent; losing legitimacy: dangerous; losing urgency: dominant
  • Assembly staff (definitive)Their power over the shift would fall if enough volunteers came forward.losing power: dependent; losing legitimacy: dangerous; losing urgency: dominant
  • Independent dealers (definitive)A commission on fleet sales in their area would ease the urgency of their claim.losing power: dependent; losing legitimacy: dangerous; losing urgency: dominant
  • The bank (dominant)A missed forecast would make its claim urgent at once.gaining urgency: definitive; losing power: discretionary; losing legitimacy: dormant
  • City council (dominant)Complaints about heavy cargo bikes in cycle lanes would make its claim urgent.gaining urgency: definitive; losing power: discretionary; losing legitimacy: dormant
  • A former parts supplier (dangerous)Its power would fade if the battery test results were published first.gaining legitimacy: definitive; losing power: demanding; losing urgency: dormant
  • Delivery firms (dependent)A large fleet order would give them power and make them definitive.gaining power: definitive; losing legitimacy: demanding; losing urgency: discretionary
  • A direct-online e-bike brand (dormant)A move into fleet sales would make it a rival to watch closely, though still not a claimant to consult.gaining legitimacy: dominant; gaining urgency: dangerous; losing power: not a stakeholder here
  • Neighbours of the works (discretionary)A start date for the shift would make their claim urgent, and the council could lend them power through planning conditions.gaining power: dominant; gaining urgency: dependent; losing legitimacy: not a stakeholder here
  • An anonymous online account (demanding)A much larger following would give it power and make it dangerous.gaining power: dangerous; gaining legitimacy: dependent; losing urgency: not a stakeholder here

The seven classes

Definitive (power, legitimacy and urgency; definitive)
A powerful, legitimate claim that needs attention now. For managers: Give its claim priority now: consult it before the decision is final and agree how the claim will be met.
Dominant (power and legitimacy; expectant)
Its influence on the business is assured; owners, lenders and large customers are often here. For managers: Keep formal channels open, such as board reports, lender reviews or account meetings, and watch for the urgency that would make it definitive.
Dangerous (power and urgency; expectant)
Presses its claim urgently and has the power to act, but the claim is not legitimate, so it may turn to coercion. For managers: Identify the risk and plan for it, but do not reward illegitimate pressure; protect the business and the people the pressure could harm.
Dependent (legitimacy and urgency; expectant)
An urgent, legitimate claim with no power to enforce it, so it depends on others, such as regulators, the courts, the media or managers’ own values. For managers: Weigh the claim on its merits now. If a powerful ally takes it up, it becomes definitive, so act before that happens.
Dormant (power only; latent)
Can affect the business but has no legitimate or urgent claim on this decision, so it has little reason to act yet. For managers: Little contact is needed now, but keep it in view: with an urgent or a legitimate claim it would become dangerous or dominant.
Discretionary (legitimacy only; latent)
A legitimate claim with no power behind it and no urgency. For managers: Nothing forces managers to engage, so engaging is a choice, often made on ethical grounds or for goodwill.
Demanding (urgency only; latent)
Presses its claim insistently, with neither power nor a legitimate claim. For managers: Bothersome rather than dangerous: acknowledge it and watch it, without letting it take attention from legitimate claims.

Checks

No problems found: the decision is stated, every judgement has evidence, and every definitive and dangerous stakeholder has a plan.

Section 02: About this tool

What it is for, how to use it, what it cannot do, and where it stands in the IB course.

Purpose

To decide whose claims managers must attend to first, and why, by separating power from legitimacy and adding urgency, and to see which groups could quickly become more salient.

IB syllabus status

Enrichment Not in the guide

Stakeholder salience is not in the guide and is not one of its toolkit tools, so this tool is enrichment. It extends the analysis of 1.4, whose content statements are internal and external stakeholders and conflict between stakeholders, both at AO2 (Business management guide, p. 24). The three attributes and seven classes come from Ronald Mitchell, Bradley Agle and Donna Wood (1997), explained in the platform's own words.

Serves 1.4 Stakeholders

How to use it

  1. State the decision. Legitimacy and urgency belong to a claim, and a claim is about a particular decision.
  2. List the stakeholders and the claim each makes, in a sentence.
  3. For each, judge three things: whether it has power over the business, and of what kind; whether its claim is legitimate by the norms of the society it sits in; and whether the claim is urgent, both time-sensitive and critical to it. Record why.
  4. Read the classes: definitive stakeholders hold all three attributes and come first; each other class shows what that group asks of managers.
  5. Read how each could move. A group that gains an ally, a deadline or recognition changes class, sometimes overnight, so plan for the moves that matter.

Limitations

  • The attributes are judgements made by managers, and different managers will judge them differently; the theory is about salience as managers perceive it.
  • Treating each attribute as present or absent simplifies. Power, legitimacy and urgency all come in degrees.
  • Legitimacy is contested. A claim one group sees as proper another may not, and the tool records your judgement, not a fact.
  • Salience describes whose claims managers are likely to notice, not whose claims deserve attention. Used to justify ignoring weak groups, it raises questions of ethics.

A model is an aid to judgement, not a universal answer. Use what it shows, then decide, and say why.

Section 03: Using what it shows

Recommended use

The recommended use is to separate claims that are powerful from claims that are right. For Northvale, the owners, the staff and the dealers are definitive and come first; the delivery firms' claim is urgent and legitimate but has no power behind it yet, and a large order would change that; the former supplier is dangerous, and the answer to it is evidence, not a renewed contract. A strong answer says whose claims come first and why, and what would move a group from one class to another.

Read alongside