Strategy Studio · Stage 4 of 4: Plan

Strategic fit check

Test a chosen strategy at three levels, its fit with the environment, the readiness of the capabilities it needs and a McKinsey 7S consistency check of the organization behind it, judged by the weakest of the three.

Section 01: Build your analysis

The tool opens on a worked example. Change anything: the analysis follows, and your work is kept on this device.

Scripts are off, so this is the worked example as a finished analysis. Every part of it can be read; to build your own, turn scripts on.

Your work is kept on this device as you type.

Your inputs

A. Fit with the environment

The opportunities and threats that matter most, from your SWOT, STEEPLE or Five Forces. For each, say how well the strategy answers it.

B. The capabilities it needs

What the business must be able to do for the strategy to work, the level it has now and the level it needs, from 1 (none) to 5 (strong).

C. The 7S consistency check

Describe each of the six other elements as it is and as the strategy needs it, and rate how far it supports the strategy now.

Structure (hard element)

How the organization is divided up, and who reports to whom.

Systems (hard element)

The processes and routines: budgets, pay and bonuses, recruitment, information.

Shared values (soft element)

What people believe the organization stands for; the centre of the model.

Style (soft element)

How leaders actually behave and where they spend their time.

Staff (soft element)

The people: how many, of what kinds, and how they are developed.

Skills (soft element)

What the organization as a whole is distinctively good at.

Conflicts between elements

Pairs of elements that pull in different directions, such as a new structure with the old bonus system.

The analysis

Worked example Northvale Cycles is fictional and its figures are simulated. Change anything and this becomes your own analysis.

Fit at three levels

Northvale Cycles. Strategy: Fleet cargo e-bikes for delivery firms in the low-emission cities, sold direct with service contracts and built on a second assembly shift

External fit
+61%Strong
Capability readiness
57%Major gaps
7S alignment
2.7Misaligned (of 5)
Strategic fit at three levelsStrategic fit at three levels. External fit: +61%, strong; Capability readiness: 57%, major gaps; 7S alignment: 2.7 of 5, misaligned. Weak fit. The capabilities the strategy needs are not ready: close the largest gaps, by building, borrowing or buying them, before or while launching. The organization is not aligned behind the strategy: change the elements that pull against it before asking people to deliver it.External fitStrong+61%Capability readinessMajor gaps57%7S alignmentMisaligned2.7 of 5

External fit +61% (strong), capability readiness 57% (major gaps) and 7S support averaging 2.7 of 5 (misaligned). Weak fit. The capabilities the strategy needs are not ready: close the largest gaps, by building, borrowing or buying them, before or while launching. The organization is not aligned behind the strategy: change the elements that pull against it before asking people to deliver it. The largest capability gaps are servicing fleets within a day (2 of the 5 needed) and selling to businesses: tenders, contracts and account management (1 of the 4 needed). Structure, Systems and Staff pull against the strategy, and structure sits at the centre of the most conflicts. Fit is judged by the weakest level, not the average: a strategy the organization cannot deliver fails however well it suits the market.

  • External fit: strong +40% or more; partial 0% to +40%; poor below 0%
  • Capability readiness: ready 80% or more; gaps to close 60% to 80%; major gaps below 60%
  • 7S alignment: aligned average support 4 or more; partly aligned average support 3 to 4; misaligned average support below 3
  • The bands are the platform's teaching convention.

A. Fit with the environment

Each factor in the environment, its importance, how the strategy answers it and the weighted score
FactorKindImportanceFitWeighted
Low-emission zones restricting vansThe fleet bike is built for the delivery routes the van charges will push off the road.Opportunity5+2Exploits it or defends well+10
Growth in city deliveriesMore parcels need more vehicles, and fleets of bikes grow with them.Opportunity4+2Exploits it or defends well+8
Rising prices for motors and batteriesFleet contracts fix prices for years, so rising component costs squeeze the margin unless the contracts allow for them.Threat4−1Fits it poorly−4
Direct-online brands with home deliveryFleets need repairs within a day, which online-only brands cannot yet offer; the dealer network is the defence.Threat3+1Answers it+3
A possible grant for business cargo bikesA grant would cut the price for fleet buyers; the plan does not depend on it.Opportunity3+2Exploits it or defends well+6
External fit: the weighted total against the best possible (38)+61%

B. Capability readiness

Each capability's importance, its level now and the level needed, and how any gap will be closed
CapabilityImportanceNowNeededGapRoute
Designing and building cargo e-bikesThe cargo bike leads its segment; a fleet version needs heavier-duty parts but no new skills.5440No gap to close
Selling to businesses: tenders, contracts and account managementNorthvale has only ever sold through dealers and online; hire an experienced fleet sales manager.4143Buy it, by hiring or acquisition
Servicing fleets within a dayA two-person service desk today; partner with dealers in each city for repairs, paid by the job.5253Borrow it through a partner
Finance for fleet leasingFleets prefer to lease; work with a leasing company rather than lend from Northvale's own balance sheet.3132Borrow it through a partner
Assembly capacity for fleet volumesA second shift would add the capacity, if the staff council agrees to it.4341Build it in house
Readiness: the weighted levels held against those needed57%
The gaps to close, largest first
  1. Servicing fleets within a day: 2 of the 5 needed, importance 5 (weighted gap 15). Borrow it through a partner.
  2. Selling to businesses: tenders, contracts and account management: 1 of the 4 needed, importance 4 (weighted gap 12). Buy it, by hiring or acquisition.
  3. Finance for fleet leasing: 1 of the 3 needed, importance 3 (weighted gap 6). Borrow it through a partner.
  4. Assembly capacity for fleet volumes: 3 of the 4 needed, importance 4 (weighted gap 4). Build it in house.

C. The 7S consistency check

The seven elements and the conflicts between themMcKinsey 7S consistency check, shared values at the centre. Structure: support 2 of 5; Systems: support 2 of 5; Shared values: support 4 of 5; Style: support 3 of 5; Staff: support 2 of 5; Skills: support 3 of 5. Conflicts recorded: Systems with Strategy; Structure with Style; Staff with Structure.StrategyBeing tested1 conflictStructureSupport 2 of 52 conflictsSystemsSupport 2 of 51 conflictShared valuesSupport 4 of 5StyleSupport 3 of 51 conflictStaffSupport 2 of 51 conflictSkillsSupport 3 of 5
  • Green ring: supports the strategy (4 or 5)
  • Red ring: pulls against it (2 or less)
  • Dashed red line: a conflict you recorded
Each of the six elements as it is, as the strategy needs it, and how far it supports the strategy now
ElementNowThe strategy needsSupport
StructureHard elementSales organized by dealer regions, with no team for business customers.A fleet accounts team with authority over prices and service terms, working with the dealers.2Pulls against it
SystemsHard elementSales bonuses paid on units shipped to dealers; orders planned in seasonal batches.Bonuses that count fleet contracts and service revenue, tracking of repair times, and monthly fleet invoicing.2Pulls against it
Shared valuesSoft elementWell-made bikes that last, and pride in the family's craft.The same, with reliability as a promise kept every working day.4Supports it
StyleSoft elementThe managing director decides most things herself, after consulting the family.Fleet decisions delegated to an accountable fleet lead, within clear limits.3Neutral
StaffSoft element140 people, strong in assembly, with two people on the service desk.Field technicians, a fleet sales manager and enough assemblers for a second shift.2Pulls against it
SkillsSoft elementFrame building and quality assembly.Fleet servicing, selling to businesses and managing contracts.3Neutral
Average support2.7
Conflicts between elements
  • Systems against StrategyBonuses reward units shipped to dealers, so the sales team gains nothing from a fleet contract.
  • Structure against StyleA fleet team needs authority to agree prices, but every price now goes to the managing director.
  • Staff against StructureField technicians have no place in a structure built around dealer regions.

At the centre of the most conflicts: Structure. Change there first, or the other changes will be pulled back.

Checks

No problems found: the strategy is stated, the environment and capabilities are judged, every gap has a route and every element is described.

Section 02: About this tool

What it is for, how to use it, what it cannot do, and where it stands in the IB course.

Purpose

To find out, before committing, whether the organization can deliver the strategy it has chosen, and what must change first, the strategy itself, the capabilities, or the structure, systems, people and culture.

IB syllabus status

Enrichment Not in the guide

The strategic fit check and the McKinsey 7S framework are not in the guide, so this tool is enrichment. Its parts draw on IB content, the opportunities and threats of SWOT and STEEPLE, both toolkit tools for SL and HL (Business management guide, p. 14), strategic objectives in 1.3 (p. 23), strategies for change in 2.1 (p. 25), organizational structure in 2.2 (p. 25) and cultural clashes in 2.5, which is HL only (p. 27). The seven elements come from Robert Waterman, Thomas Peters and Julien Phillips (1980).

Serves 1.3 Business objectives , 2.1 Introduction to human resource management , 2.2 Organizational structure , 2.5 Organizational (corporate) culture

How to use it

  1. State the strategy being tested, as specifically as you can.
  2. List the factors in the environment that matter most, from your SWOT, STEEPLE or Five Forces. Weight each by importance and rate how well the strategy answers it, from −2 (works against it) to +2 (exploits it or defends against it).
  3. List the capabilities the strategy needs, with the level the business has now and the level it needs, and choose how to close each gap: build, borrow or buy.
  4. Describe each of the six other 7S elements as it is and as the strategy needs it, rate how far it supports the strategy now, and record the pairs of elements that pull against each other.
  5. Read the verdict from the weakest level, then plan the changes it calls for, starting with the element at the centre of the most conflicts.

Limitations

  • Every rating is a judgement, and the three scores combine judgements; small differences mean little.
  • The weighting by importance and the bands for each level are the platform's teaching convention, not a standard.
  • It tests fit, not whether the strategy is right. A perfectly aligned organization can still pursue a poor strategy.
  • Soft elements such as shared values and style are hard to observe, so their ratings need evidence from behaviour, not from documents.

A model is an aid to judgement, not a universal answer. Use what it shows, then decide, and say why.

Section 03: Using what it shows

Recommended use

The recommended use is to say what must change before the strategy can work, and in what order. For Northvale, the fleet strategy suits its environment (external fit +61%), but the business is not yet built to deliver it: readiness is 57%, with fleet servicing and selling to businesses the largest gaps, and the structure, the bonus system and the staff mix pull against it. The check does not overturn the recommendation; it sets its conditions, a servicing partnership with the dealers, a fleet sales manager and a new bonus scheme before the first contracts.

Read alongside