Entrepreneurship and Innovation LabBriefing 01 of 06

Finding and testing an opportunity

Where start-up ideas come from, how to find out whether customers really have the problem, and how to say what you offer them in words they would recognize.

Step
1 of 6: Spot and test the opportunity
IB status
Maps to 1.1, 4.1, 4.2, 4.4, with enrichment
Reading
About 7 minutes

The questionIs this a problem people will pay to have solved?

Most new businesses begin with a solution: an app, a product, a shop the founder would like to run. The ones that last more often begin with a problem: something people struggle with often enough, and care about enough, to pay for a better answer. This briefing covers the work between an idea and a business: spotting opportunities, testing them with the people who would pay, and putting what you offer into words.

None of that work needs much money. It needs conversations, observation and honesty about what you hear. The aim is to find out, cheaply and early, whether the opportunity is real, before the founder's savings are spent finding out the expensive way.

Section 01: Where opportunities come from

IB course Source: Enrichment

An opportunity is not the same as an idea. An idea is a possible product; an opportunity is a situation in which a particular group of people has a need, cares enough to pay or switch to have it met, and can be reached at a cost below what they would pay. Many good ideas are poor opportunities, because too few people have the problem, or they have it but will not pay, or the only way to reach them costs more than they spend.

Opportunities usually come from change. A new law creates a need for compliance; a technology makes something cheap that used to be expensive; a price rise makes people look for substitutes; a shift in attitudes creates demand that existing businesses are slow to serve. That is why the toolkit's STEEPLE analysis is a good place to look for them, and why a founder's own frustration is often the start: someone close to a problem notices change before the market does.

The guide asks you to analyse the opportunities and challenges of starting up a business (1.1, AO2). The opportunities below are the common sources; the challenges, from raising finance to winning the first customers, are what the rest of the Lab helps you test.

A change in the environment

New laws, technologies, prices and attitudes create needs that did not exist before. A STEEPLE analysis is a systematic way to look for them.

A problem you have yourself

It gives a founder insight and commitment. But one person's problem is not a market until other people are shown to share it.

A gap in the market

A need that existing businesses ignore or meet badly. The test is whether the gap is empty because nobody has noticed it, or because there is no money in it.

An underserved niche

A small, well-defined group whose needs mass-market products do not fit. A niche market (4.2) can suit a small business that serves it well.

A cheaper or better way

Technology or a new process can make something affordable that used to be expensive, or let a small business do what only large ones could.

Section 02: Customer discovery: test the problem before the product

IB course Source: Enrichment

Customer discovery means talking to and watching potential customers to understand their problem before building anything. The idea, which comes from start-up practice rather than the IB course, is simple: the founder's beliefs about customers are hypotheses, and the people who would pay are the only ones who can confirm them. In the guide's terms (4.1), starting from the product is product orientation and starting from the customer is market orientation; customer discovery is market orientation practised before the business exists.

Its tools are the guide's methods of primary research (4.4): interviews, observations, surveys and focus groups. What makes customer discovery different is what it asks. People are poor at predicting what they will do and kind enough to tell founders what they want to hear, so good questions ask about past behaviour, current spending and real decisions, never about hypothetical futures. The best evidence that a problem is real is that people have already tried to solve it: they have paid for a workaround, built a spreadsheet, or put up with something annoying every week.

The sampling method matters too (4.4). Interviewing people at a market, or friends of friends, is convenience sampling: quick and cheap, but the people you meet may not be typical of the customers you need. Say who you spoke to, and treat the results as clues rather than measurements.

Questions that mislead, and questions that reveal
Instead of asking AskWhy
Would you use a refill delivery service? When did you last buy cleaning products, and where?People predict their own behaviour badly. Past behaviour is evidence.
Do you care about plastic waste? What have you done about it in the past month?Almost everyone agrees with a value when asked. Actions show how much it matters.
How much would you pay? What do you spend on this now?A stated price is a guess. Current spending is a fact.
Is this a good idea? What would stop you using something like this?Inviting praise teaches nothing. Objections reveal the real barriers.

Section 03: Market validation: evidence that people will pay

IB course Source: Enrichment

Customer discovery shows that people have a problem. Market validation asks the harder question: will enough of them pay you, at a price that can sustain the business, to solve it? The answer comes from experiments that ask customers to commit something real, and from an honest estimate of how many such customers you can reach.

Evidence varies in strength. What people say is the weakest kind; what they do is stronger; what they commit, such as time, a deposit or a signed letter, is stronger still; and what they pay is the strongest of all. A validation experiment should aim as high up that ladder as it can, and should set its success criterion before it starts: decide in advance what result would mean the idea is wrong, because founders, like everyone, tend to notice the evidence that supports what they already believe.

For the size of the opportunity, secondary research (4.4), such as government publications and market analyses, gives the number of potential customers. Build the estimate up from the customers you can actually reach and serve, rather than taking a share of the whole market: a forecast that says "if we win just 1% of the national market" is not evidence of anything.

What people say

Survey answers, compliments, likes. Useful for finding questions to test, weak as proof.

What people do

Sign-ups, return visits, time spent, the workarounds they already use.

What people commit

A deposit, a letter of intent from a business customer, a place on a pilot, an introduction to a colleague.

What people pay

Pre-orders, a paid pilot, repeat purchases. The strongest evidence there is.

Section 04: Value propositions: what you do for customers, in their words

IB course Source: Enrichment

A value proposition states, for a particular group of customers, the problem you solve or the job you do for them, what changes when they use you, and why that is better than the alternatives, including doing nothing. It is written in the customer's language, not the founder's: customers do not buy "an app-based last-mile refill logistics platform"; they buy not having to think about running out of washing-up liquid.

It is related to, but wider than, the unique selling point of the IB course (4.2). The USP is the feature or benefit that sets a product apart from competitors; the value proposition is the whole promise to a segment, of which the USP is usually one part. Writing it well also forces a choice of segment, which the guide's segmentation and targeting (4.2) make explicit: a proposition that tries to speak to everyone usually persuades no one.

A useful form is: for a named segment who has a named problem, the offer gives a named benefit, unlike the main alternative, which has a named weakness. Each blank is an assumption, and each can be tested in customer interviews before a product exists.

Features and benefits

A feature is what the product has; a benefit is what changes for the customer. Lead with the benefit and use the feature as the proof.

The alternatives

Customers always have one, even if it is putting up with the problem. A proposition that ignores the alternatives cannot say why anyone would switch.

Specific enough to test

"Saves time" cannot be tested; "no trip to a refill shop, ever" can.

Section 05: Common mistakes

The mistake

If people say they like the idea, the market is validated.

Why it is wrong

Opinions are the weakest evidence. People are polite and poor at predicting what they will do. Look for behaviour, commitments and, best of all, payment.

The mistake

A big market means a big opportunity.

Why it is wrong

What matters is the part of the market you can reach, win and serve at a profit. A small, well-defined niche you can reach cheaply is often a better start than a huge market full of established rivals.

The mistake

A value proposition is a list of features.

Why it is wrong

Features describe the product. A value proposition describes what changes for a particular customer, and why that beats the alternatives, including doing nothing.

Section 06: Key terms

Start-up terms the IB course does not use are defined here, as enrichment. Terms from the course link to the platform's glossary.

Customer discovery Source: Enrichment

Interviewing and observing potential customers to understand their problem, and how they deal with it now, before building a solution.

Market validation Source: Enrichment

Gathering evidence, ideally commitments and payments, that enough customers will buy at a price that can sustain the business.

Value proposition Source: Enrichment

A statement of what a business does for a particular customer segment, and why that is better than the alternatives.

Confirmation bias Source: Enrichment

The tendency to notice, remember and believe evidence that supports what we already think.

Section 07: Check your understanding

The platform's own questions, not IB questions. Try each one before opening the answer.

  1. What turns an idea into an opportunity?

    Answer

    Evidence that a defined group of people has the problem, cares enough to pay or switch, and can be reached at a cost below what they would pay, at a time when the market is ready.

  2. Why is "Would you use this?" a weak interview question, and what would you ask instead?

    Answer

    It asks people to predict their own future behaviour, which they do badly and politely. Ask about the past instead, such as the last time they had the problem, what they did and what it cost.

  3. Put these in order of strength as evidence: a pre-order, a survey answer, a sign-up to a waiting list.

    Answer

    The survey answer is weakest (what people say), then the sign-up (what people do), then the pre-order (what people pay).

  4. How does a value proposition differ from a USP?

    Answer

    The USP (4.2) is the feature or benefit that sets a product apart from competitors. A value proposition is the whole promise to a particular segment, covering the problem, the benefit and why it beats the alternatives; the USP is usually one part of it.

  5. Refill Round's survey found that 62 of 120 shoppers would consider a refill delivery. Why would it be a mistake to plan on half the city subscribing?

    Answer

    Saying they would consider it is weak evidence, and a convenience sample at markets over-represents people who already shop that way. The founders assume only one in ten of the interested households would subscribe, and test even that with paid pre-orders.

Section 08: Use it

Put the briefing to work on Refill Round's example, then on your own idea.

  • Start-up feasibility assessment Score up to three start-up ideas on weighted criteria, with must-haves, a pass mark, sensitivity to the weights and an optimism test.
  • Business Model Canvas builder Build a Business Model Canvas in nine blocks, mark each entry as an assumption or as evidence, rate its risk, and get the riskiest assumptions to test first.

Section 09: What is IB content here, and what is not

Each idea in this briefing, checked against the IB Business management guide (first assessment 2024).

Each idea, whether it is IB content, a toolkit tool or enrichment, and where it sits in the guide
IdeaStatusIn the guide
Entrepreneurship, and the challenges and opportunities for starting up a business IB content
Guide, p. 23: Both content statements are taught to AO2.
Market orientation versus product orientation IB content
Guide, p. 31: AO2. Customer discovery is market orientation before launch.
Primary and secondary market research, qualitative and quantitative research, and sampling methods IB content
Guide, p. 31: Why and how organizations carry out market research is AO3; the methods are AO2.
Niche and mass markets, the USP and differentiation IB content
Guide, p. 31: Value propositions build on all three.
SWOT and STEEPLE analysis IB toolkit
Toolkit, guide p. 14 Toolkit tools for scanning for opportunities and judging them.
Customer discovery and market validation Source: Enrichment
Not in the guide. Related to: Start-up practice that uses the primary research methods of 4.4 as experiments.
The value proposition Source: Enrichment
Not in the guide. Related to: Related to the USP, but not a term the guide uses.

Written in the platform's own words. Checked against: Business management guide, first assessment 2024 (published February 2022, updated May 2022), pp. 13 to 14, 23, 31. Every business named is fictional and every figure simulated. Updated 3 November 2026.