Entrepreneurship and Innovation LabTool 01 of 06

Which idea deserves your next six months?

Founders rarely have one idea. They have three, and a favourite. Score each one against the criteria that decide whether a start-up can work, weight the criteria by how much they matter, and see which idea leads, whether it clears the pass mark, and how far the answer rests on judgements you might be getting wrong.

Back to 1.1 What is a business? Also for 4.4 Market research

Tool
Start-up feasibility assessment
IB status
Enrichment; builds on 1.1, 4.4
Example
Refill Round, fictional; figures simulated
Saved
On this device only

Section 01: Start-up feasibility assessment

Source: Enrichment Source: Simulated data

The example. Two student founders want to cut single-use plastic in their city, and have three ideas: Refill Round, a subscription that delivers refills of cleaning products in reusable bottles by electric cargo bike; a refill shop with its own premises; and a service supplying refills in bulk to offices and cafés. All three are fictional, and the scores are the founders' simulated judgements.

Without JavaScript the ranking below is for the example's weights and scores, and changing them does not recalculate it.

The ideas, up to three
Weights and scores

Weight each criterion from 0 to 5, then score each idea from 1 (poor) to 5 (excellent).

  1. Customer need Must-haveHow painful is the problem, and how sure are you? 5: customers already pay to work around it. 1: you assume they care.
    5
  2. Willingness to pay Must-haveWill customers pay enough? 5: customers have paid or pre-ordered at your price. 1: no evidence, or a free alternative is good enough.
    4
  3. Market size and growthAre there enough customers within reach, and is their number growing? 5: large and growing. 1: small or shrinking.
    3
  4. Competition and differentiationIs there a reason to choose you over the alternatives? 5: a clear difference that rivals cannot easily copy. 1: the same as established rivals.
    3
  5. Reaching customersCan you find and win customers at a sensible cost? 5: a cheap channel that already works. 1: no clear way to reach them.
    4
  6. Unit economics Must-haveDoes each sale or customer contribute well above what it costs to win and serve? 5: strong contribution, cheap to win. 1: every sale loses money.
    4
  7. Start-up cost and fundingCan you fund the start without betting everything? 5: little money needed. 1: far more than you could raise.
    3
  8. Founders' skills and fitDo the founders have the skills, contacts and commitment it needs? 5: a strong fit. 1: a business the founders know nothing about.
    3

Ranking

Each idea's weighted total, its share of the maximum and the verdict
Idea Rank Total Share Bar Verdict
Refill Round1102 / 14570.3%Worth testing further
Office refills288 / 14560.7%Worth testing further
Refill shop385 / 14558.6%Below the pass mark

Reading. Refill Round scores 70% of the maximum, ranked first of 3, above the pass mark of 60%. No single change of weight changes the idea ranked first.

Optimism test. If every score for Refill Round is one point too generous, it falls to 50% of the maximum and no longer passes, and Office refills would rank first instead. The case rests on scores a founder is likely to overrate, so gather evidence for the closest calls before committing.

Your assessment is kept on this device only.

Section 02: How to use it, and what to watch for

Steps

  1. Name up to three ideas, with one line each on who it serves and how.
  2. Weight each criterion from 0 (irrelevant to you) to 5 (decisive). Agree the weights before you look at the totals, or they will drift towards your favourite.
  3. Score each idea from 1 (poor) to 5 (excellent) on each criterion, using the hints. A must-have criterion scored below 2 is a fatal flaw, whatever the total.
  4. Read the ranking, then the sensitivity and the optimism test. If the leader changes with one weight, or drops below the pass mark when its scores fall by a point, the decision is closer than the totals suggest.

Section 03: What the terms mean here

Weighted total

The sum, over all the criteria, of each weight times the score. The most an idea could score is the sum of the weights times 5.

Pass mark

60% of the maximum: the platform's suggested bar for an idea worth testing further. It is a convention, not a rule.

Must-have

A criterion an idea cannot fail and still work, however well it does elsewhere. A must-have scored below 2 is flagged as a fatal flaw.

Optimism test

The leading idea's scores each lowered by one point, to see whether the case for it survives the generosity founders usually show their favourite.

Section 04: Where it sits in the IB course

Weighted scoring is a decision-making method, not one of the guide's toolkit tools, so this tool is enrichment. It works best beside the toolkit's own situational tools: a SWOT analysis or a STEEPLE analysis supplies the evidence behind the scores. The challenges and opportunities of starting up a business are IB content (1.1, AO2).

The ideas behind the tool are in the briefing Finding and testing an opportunity.