Paper 1 · Practice case

Volta Ridge Chocolate: the private-label contract

A bean-to-bar chocolate maker is offered a five-year contract to make chocolate under a multinational’s brand. Work through it as you would the real paper: the pre-released statement first, then the full case, the questions and the clock.

Industry
Food manufacturing Ghana, fictional organization
The full case
868 words the first 203 released in advance
Marks
30 Section A 20 · Section B 10
Duration
1 h 30 plus 5 minutes' reading time

Fictional Source: Original practice question Illustrative example

Volta Ridge Chocolate Ltd, its people, places and figures are invented for this practice case; the country is real. The questions are the platform's own, set in the structure the guide gives Paper 1, and the guidance is written for them: it is not an IB markscheme.

Section 01: The pre-released statement

About three months before the examination you receive a few context topics to research and about the first 200 words of the case. Everything else is unseen until the day.

IB requirement Illustrative example

The format is the guide's (p. 41); the topics and the case are invented for practice.

  1. Traceability in agricultural supply chains

    How do food businesses prove where a raw material came from and how it was grown? What does it cost a small supplier to keep the records, and who pays?

  2. Private-label and contract manufacturing

    Why do brand owners pay other firms to make their products, and what does the maker gain and give up when its own name is not on the pack?

  3. Climate change and the supply of crops

    How can changing weather affect the price, quality and reliability of a crop such as cocoa, and how might a manufacturer reduce the risk?

Kept on this device. About five hours of research in all is what the course allows (guide, p. 22).

Section 02: The case

The opening is what you have before the day. Tag what matters in it now; open the full case for the examination, and keep tagging.

Volta Ridge Chocolate: the private-label contract

The opening, released in advance: 203 words.

Click or press Enter on a sentence to tag it, or select a few words with the mouse and choose a tag.

Volta Ridge Chocolate Ltd (VRC) makes bean-to-bar chocolate in the Volta Region of Ghana. It was founded in 2017 by Efua Mensah, a food scientist, and her brother Kojo Mensah, an accountant, who wanted more of Ghana's cocoa to be turned into finished products at home instead of being exported as raw beans.

VRC buys its beans directly from 140 farming families who belong to the Tsala Hills Growers' Cooperative. It ferments, dries, roasts and grinds the beans in its own factory, on the edge of a market town, then moulds and wraps the bars. Its 52 employees work two shifts a day and make about 410,000 bars a year in four flavours: dark, milk, ginger and a seasonal bar made with local fruit. Efua leads product development and quality; Kojo runs finance and sales.

VRC is a private limited company. Efua and Kojo own 70% of the shares, and the rest belong to friends and relatives who invested in 2017. Most bars are sold under the Volta Ridge brand in hotels, airport shops and supermarkets in Accra, and a growing number are sold online to customers in Europe. The company's slogan, "Chocolate made where the cocoa grows", is printed on every wrapper.

On the day, the case continues with new information.

The full case: open it on examination day

In 2025, VRC's sales revenue was GH₵15.6 million and its cost of sales was GH₵9.4 million. Online sales to Europe earned GH₵2.1 million, up from GH₵1.4 million in 2024, but sending chocolate through hot weather is expensive: every parcel needs insulated packaging and cooling packs, and about one parcel in twenty arrives damaged. (paragraph 4)

Over the past year, changes in the exchange rate have raised the value in cedis of VRC's sales in euros, but the packaging it imports has become more expensive. VRC pays the cooperative within a week of each delivery of beans, while hotels and supermarkets take up to 45 days to pay VRC. (paragraph 5)

In March 2026, Norrvik Confectionery Group, a European multinational that sells chocolate in more than 30 countries, offered VRC a five-year contract. VRC would make 600,000 bars a year of single-origin Ghanaian chocolate to Norrvik's recipe, wrapped under Norrvik's brand, at a fixed price of GH₵18 a bar. Norrvik would pay 60 days after each delivery, send two engineers to advise on quality, and insist that every bean can be traced back to the farm. (paragraph 6)

VRC's factory is close to its limit. To accept the contract, it would need a second production line costing GH₵4.5 million, which would take five months to install and test. Norrvik has offered to lend half of this at a low rate of interest, on condition that VRC sells only to Norrvik in Europe for the length of the contract. The rest could come from a bank loan at 21% a year, or from selling a 25% stake in VRC to Riverbend Impact Partners, an investment fund that backs businesses with social aims. (paragraph 7)

Kojo is keen. "Six hundred thousand bars a year is more than we sell today," he told the board. "The contract would spread our costs over far more bars and give us income we can count on." Efua is less sure. She points out that Norrvik's customers will never see the Volta Ridge name, and that a single buyer taking more than half of the factory's output could later demand lower prices. (paragraph 8)

The farmers have concerns of their own. VRC pays the cooperative 15% more than local buyers do, but the cooperative's chair, Abla Kudjoe, says that two unusually dry seasons have cut yields and that families need a higher price to keep their children in school rather than working on the farms. Norrvik's contract would require proof that no child labour is used. VRC believes it can provide this, but the farmers would need help to keep the records. (paragraph 9)

Inside the factory, the mood is mixed. Production workers are paid a daily wage, and wrapping staff are paid for each bar they wrap. Efua makes most decisions about production herself and checks every new batch, which managers say keeps quality high but slows everything down. Since January, three of the eight supervisors have left for a fruit-juice factory nearby that offers permanent contracts and health insurance. A staff survey found that workers value their training and the company's purpose, but feel they are rarely asked for their views. (paragraph 10)

VRC's marketing team surveyed 300 online customers in 2025. Of these, 62% said the "made in Ghana" story was the main reason they bought, and 44% said they would pay more for bars that named the farming family who grew the beans. In Accra, however, imported mass-market chocolate sells for about half VRC's price, and supermarket buyers have asked for bigger discounts. (paragraph 11)

VRC's competitors at home are few: two other small chocolate makers in Ghana sell mainly to tourists, and neither exports. Efua believes that VRC's lead in quality would last only a few years if it stopped developing its own brand. (paragraph 12)

The board must reply to Norrvik by the end of June. Kojo believes the contract is the safest route to growth. Efua would rather build the Volta Ridge brand in Europe, with Riverbend's investment and a new range of bars that name the farming families, even if growth is slower. (paragraph 13)

Your evidence

Nothing tagged yet.

    Section 03: Before the examination

    Know who the decision affects and which tools could help, before you see the questions.

    Stakeholder analysis

    Recommended strategy

    For each stakeholder: what they want from the decision, how much power they have over it, and where they stand. Then compare with the model.

    Stakeholder What they want Power Stance Remove

    Compare with a model analysis
    Stakeholder What they want Power Stance on the decision Paragraph
    Efua Mensah (founder, shareholder) Building the Volta Ridge brand and keeping its purpose High Against 8
    Kojo Mensah (founder, shareholder) Secure growth and income the business can count on High For 8
    Tsala Hills Growers’ Cooperative A higher price for beans, and help with the records the contract needs Low Mixed 9
    Norrvik Confectionery Group A reliable, traceable supply at a fixed price High For 6
    Production workers and supervisors Secure contracts, training and a voice Low Mixed 10
    Riverbend Impact Partners A return from a business with social aims Low Mixed 7
    Online customers in Europe Chocolate with a true Ghana story, delivered undamaged Low Against 11

    The platform's reading of the case. Power and stance are judgements: defend your own from the evidence.

    Which tools fit this case?

    Recommended strategy IB requirement

    Choose the tools you would use. A tool earns its place when it changes the argument; Paper 1 is not set on HL-only content (guide, p. 43).

    Tools you would use
      How well each tool fits
      • SWOT analysis : possible, with care. Useful to organize your own notes before the paper; on its own in an answer it restates the case, so use it to find the argument, not as the argument.
      • STEEPLE analysis : a strong fit. The case is full of external factors: dry seasons (environmental), child labour and traceability (ethical, legal), the exchange rate on euro sales (economic).
      • Ansoff matrix : a strong fit. Efua’s plan is market development (the brand in Europe) with product development (bars that name the families); the contract is a different kind of growth. It frames the choice of direction.
      • Decision tree : a weak fit. The case gives no probabilities or payoffs: drawing a tree would mean inventing figures.
      • Break-even analysis : possible, with care. Relevant to the second line, but the case gives no fixed costs or cost per bar, so a calculation would need assumptions you must state.
      • Ratio analysis : possible, with care. The gross profit margin can be worked from the case; there is no statement of financial position for liquidity ratios.
      • Force field analysis (HL): not for Paper 1. An HL-only tool: Paper 1 questions are not set on HL extension content (guide, p. 43).
      • Porter's generic strategies (HL): not for Paper 1. An HL-only tool: Paper 1 questions are not set on HL extension content (guide, p. 43).

      Section 04: The paper

      Section A: answer every question (20 marks). Section B: answer one of the two (10 marks). Build each answer in its parts, tie the evidence to it, then mark it against the guidance.

      IB requirement Recommended strategy

      The structure, times and marks are the guide's (pp. 41 and 43). The suggested split, about 54 min for Section A, follows the teacher support material's advice of about 60% of the time; it is not an IB rule.

      Section A

      1. 1 (a) Define AO1 1.2

        Define the term private limited company. [2]

        Where to look: paragraph 3.

        The first precise element of the meaning, in your own words.
        The second element that completes it. An example is not a definition.
        Evidence for this answer

        What the answer still needs

          Guidance and self-mark

          Source: Assessment explanation Illustrative example

          One mark for each of the two elements. A definition that only describes VRC earns at most one.

          Award marks for

          Where marks are lost

          • Defining a public limited company, or limited liability alone.
          • Writing about VRC instead of defining the term.

        • 1 (b) Calculate AO4 3.5

          Calculate VRC's gross profit margin for 2025 (show all your working). [2]

          Where to look: paragraph 4.

          Write the formula before any figures.
          The figures from the case, with their units.
          The answer with its unit, rounded once, at the end.
          Evidence for this answer

          What the answer still needs

            Guidance and self-mark

            Source: Assessment explanation Illustrative example

            One mark for a correct method with the case figures, one for the answer with its unit.

            Award marks for

            Answer: (15.6 − 9.4) ÷ 15.6 × 100 = 6.2 ÷ 15.6 × 100 = 39.74%

            Where marks are lost

            • Dividing by the cost of sales.
            • Giving the answer without the % sign.
            • Writing only the final figure, with no working.

          • 2 (a) State AO1 1.4

            State two external stakeholders of VRC. [2]

            Where to look: paragraphs 2, 6, 7, 11.

            One external stakeholder named in the case.
            A second, different external stakeholder.
            Evidence for this answer

            What the answer still needs

              Guidance and self-mark

              Source: Assessment explanation Illustrative example

              One mark for each external stakeholder of VRC, up to two. A line each is enough.

              Award marks for

              Where marks are lost

              • Naming employees or shareholders, who are internal stakeholders.
              • Explaining at length: state asks for a name, not a paragraph.

            • 2 (b) Explain AO2 1.5

              Explain two advantages to VRC of accepting Norrvik’s contract. [6]

              Where to look: paragraphs 6, 7, 8.

              Identify the advantage, explain it with business knowledge, then apply it: a case fact and its effect on VRC.
              A distinct second point, with its own evidence. Identify the advantage, explain it with business knowledge, then apply it: a case fact and its effect on VRC.
              Evidence for this answer

              What the answer still needs

                Guidance and self-mark

                Source: Assessment explanation Illustrative example

                For each advantage: identify it (1), explain it with business knowledge (1), and apply it to VRC with evidence from the case (1). Two advantages that overlap earn the second set of marks only for the new point.

                Award marks for

                Where marks are lost

                • Two points that are really one, such as "more sales" and "more revenue".
                • Advantages to Norrvik or the farmers instead of to VRC.
                • No figure or fact from the case in either point.

              • 3 (a) Describe AO1 3.2

                Describe two external sources of finance VRC could use to pay for the second production line. [4]

                Where to look: paragraph 7.

                Name the source, then describe what it is and how it would work for VRC.
                A distinct second point, with its own evidence. Name the source, then describe what it is and how it would work for VRC.
                Evidence for this answer

                What the answer still needs

                  Guidance and self-mark

                  Source: Assessment explanation Illustrative example

                  For each source: one mark for a relevant external source, one for a description of it in the context of VRC.

                  Award marks for

                  Where marks are lost

                  • Retained profit, which is an internal source.
                  • Two kinds of loan described the same way, with no difference between them.

                • 3 (b) Suggest AO2 2.4

                  Suggest two ways VRC could improve the motivation of its production workers. [4]

                  Where to look: paragraph 10.

                  Propose a way, then say how it would work at VRC, using what the staff survey says workers value.
                  A distinct second point, with its own evidence. Propose a way, then say how it would work at VRC, using what the staff survey says workers value.
                  Evidence for this answer

                  What the answer still needs

                    Guidance and self-mark

                    Source: Assessment explanation Illustrative example

                    For each way: one mark for a relevant financial or non-financial reward, one for linking it to VRC’s workers.

                    Award marks for

                    Where marks are lost

                    • A list of rewards with no link to VRC’s workers.
                    • Pay rises with no reason why they would work here.

                  • Section B

                    The question you are answering
                  • 4 Discuss AO3 1.5, 1.6

                    Discuss whether VRC should accept Norrvik’s contract. [10]

                    Where to look: paragraphs 4, 6, 7, 8, 9, 11, 12, 13.

                    The organization, the decision it faces, and what it is trying to achieve.
                    Developed: business knowledge, a case fact, and the consequence for this organization.
                    Developed the same way, with its own evidence.
                    Which matters more here, and why: size, likelihood, timing, stakeholders.
                    What the case does not tell you, and how that weakens the judgement.
                    A decision, and the condition it depends on.
                    Evidence for this answer

                    What the answer still needs

                      Guidance and self-mark

                      Source: Assessment explanation Illustrative example

                      Level descriptors written by the platform for this question. They are not the IB’s markbands, which are in the guide and are not reproduced here. Place the answer in the level that best describes it.

                      What an answer could draw on

                      • For: scale and lower average cost; five years of secure revenue at GH₵18 a bar; a low-interest loan for half of the GH₵4.5 million line; skills from Norrvik’s engineers; a route to traceability that could also strengthen VRC’s own brand.
                      • Against: VRC’s name is invisible on Norrvik’s bars, so the contract does not build its brand; a buyer of more than half the output gains bargaining power; selling only to Norrvik in Europe blocks the online growth (GH₵1.4 million to GH₵2.1 million); 60 days’ credit strains cash flow; the farmers would need help to keep records.
                      • Weighing: how far 600,000 bars depend on yields that dry seasons have cut; whether the fixed price covers rising bean costs over five years; what the 62% who buy for the Ghana story would make of private-label growth.
                      • Limitations of the case: no cost per bar, so the contract’s profit cannot be worked out; no detail of what happens if VRC cannot supply 600,000 bars; the survey is of online customers only.
                      Which level best fits your answer?
                      Choose Marks What a response at this level does
                      0 Nothing relevant to the contract.
                      1 to 2 Some knowledge of growth or contracts, with little use of VRC’s situation.
                      3 to 4 Points for or against, applied in places, mostly one-sided or listed rather than argued.
                      5 to 6 Arguments on both sides using case evidence, such as the fixed price and the exclusivity condition, but not weighed against each other.
                      7 to 8 Balanced, developed arguments that use the evidence, with some weighing and a conclusion that follows from them.
                      9 to 10 As 7 to 8, with a judgement that weighs the arguments against VRC’s aims and states the condition it depends on, and explains how a limitation of the case, such as the missing cost per bar, affects that judgement.

                      Where marks are lost

                      • A verdict in the first line, then only the arguments that support it.
                      • Ignoring the exclusivity condition, which is the price of the cheap loan.
                      • A conclusion that repeats the arguments instead of weighing them.

                    • 5 Examine AO3 1.3

                      Examine whether VRC should raise the price it pays the Tsala Hills Growers’ Cooperative for its beans. [10]

                      Where to look: paragraphs 2, 9, 11, 12.

                      The organization, the decision it faces, and what it is trying to achieve.
                      Developed: business knowledge, a case fact, and the consequence for this organization.
                      Developed the same way, with its own evidence.
                      Which matters more here, and why: size, likelihood, timing, stakeholders.
                      What the case does not tell you, and how that weakens the judgement.
                      A decision, and the condition it depends on.
                      Evidence for this answer

                      What the answer still needs

                        Guidance and self-mark

                        Source: Assessment explanation Illustrative example

                        Level descriptors written by the platform for this question. They are not the IB’s markbands. Place the answer in the level that best describes it.

                        What an answer could draw on

                        • For: corporate social responsibility and VRC’s purpose; children kept in school rather than working, which Norrvik’s contract will check; a secure supply of beans after two dry seasons; a stronger story for the 44% who would pay more for bars that name the farming family.
                        • Against: higher costs at a time when supermarket buyers want discounts and imported chocolate sells at half VRC’s price; a fixed contract price of GH₵18 a bar would not rise with bean costs; VRC already pays 15% above local buyers.
                        • Stakeholder conflict: farmers and VRC’s mission against shareholders’ profit and Kojo’s case for growth; how Riverbend, an investor with social aims, would see it.
                        • Limitations of the case: no figure for the cost of beans in a bar, so the effect on profit cannot be measured; the 44% is from online customers, not Accra shoppers.
                        Which level best fits your answer?
                        Choose Marks What a response at this level does
                        0 Nothing relevant to the price paid to the farmers.
                        1 to 2 Some knowledge of CSR or stakeholders, with little reference to VRC.
                        3 to 4 Points about the farmers or VRC’s costs, applied in places, mostly one-sided.
                        5 to 6 Arguments for and against, using case evidence, but listed rather than weighed.
                        7 to 8 Balanced arguments that weigh the ethical case against the cost, with a conclusion that follows.
                        9 to 10 As 7 to 8, with a judgement that considers the conflict between stakeholders, states what it depends on, and explains how a gap in the case, such as the missing bean cost, limits it.

                        Where marks are lost

                        • Treating ethics and profit as if one simply wins.
                        • Forgetting that VRC already pays 15% more than local buyers.

                      Section 05: Your paper

                      Your self-marked total and your timed attempts, kept on this device. A self-mark is your own judgement against the platform's guidance, never a grade.

                      Your total and attempts need JavaScript. The guidance under each question needs nothing.

                      Nothing self-marked yet.

                      Other practice cases: Cairnside Climbing . The Paper 1 page explains each part of the paper.