Paper 1 · Practice case

Cairnside Climbing: a second centre

A partnership running a busy indoor climbing centre is invited into a joint venture to open a second one. Work through it as you would the real paper: the pre-released statement first, then the full case, the questions and the clock.

Industry
Leisure services Canada, fictional organization
The full case
811 words the first 198 released in advance
Marks
30 Section A 20 · Section B 10
Duration
1 h 30 plus 5 minutes' reading time

Fictional Source: Original practice question Illustrative example

Cairnside Climbing, its people, places and figures are invented for this practice case; the country is real. The questions are the platform's own, set in the structure the guide gives Paper 1, and the guidance is written for them: it is not an IB markscheme.

Section 01: The pre-released statement

About three months before the examination you receive a few context topics to research and about the first 200 words of the case. Everything else is unseen until the day.

IB requirement Illustrative example

The format is the guide's (p. 41); the topics and the case are invented for practice.

  1. Subscription business models

    Why do services from gyms to software charge a monthly fee, and what happens to a subscription business when customers start to leave or prices rise?

  2. Inclusion and access in leisure services

    How can sports and leisure businesses serve people on low incomes, older adults or people with disabilities, and what does it cost them?

  3. The changing reach of social media marketing

    How has the reach of unpaid posts on social media changed for small businesses, and what are the alternatives to paying for promoted posts?

Kept on this device. About five hours of research in all is what the course allows (guide, p. 22).

Section 02: The case

The opening is what you have before the day. Tag what matters in it now; open the full case for the examination, and keep tagging.

Cairnside Climbing: a second centre

The opening, released in advance: 198 words.

Click or press Enter on a sentence to tag it, or select a few words with the mouse and choose a tag.

Cairnside Climbing is an indoor climbing centre in Tarrant Harbour, a port city in the Canadian province of Nova Scotia. It was opened in 2019 by three friends who met on the city's climbing walls: Priya Sandhu, a physiotherapist; Luc Arsenault, a builder; and Hana Brooks, who had managed a sports shop. They converted a disused fish warehouse into a bouldering hall with 200 climbing routes, a training area, a children's wall and a small café. The partners describe it as "a friendly place to climb, not a gym": staff learn members' names, and the routes are reset every week so that regulars always have something new to try.

Cairnside is a partnership. The three partners share the profits equally, and each has unlimited liability for the business's debts. Members pay CA$75 a month for unlimited climbing, and visitors can buy a day pass for CA$22. The centre is open from 7 am to 10 pm every day, and its after-school youth club is full most weeks. Cairnside employs 9 full-time staff and 18 part-time instructors and route setters, most of them students. Beginners' courses run on weekend mornings, and climbing shoes can be rented at the desk.

On the day, the case continues with new information.

The full case: open it on examination day

Membership has grown from 600 in 2020 to 2,100 today, largely through short climbing videos that the partners post on social media. The centre is now crowded between 5 pm and 9 pm, when most members visit. In October, Hana asked members at the reception desk to fill in a survey, and 412 did: 71% said the centre was too busy in the evenings, and 58% said they would use a second centre if one opened nearer their home. One member in three is a student. (paragraph 3)

Last year Cairnside's revenue was CA$2.3 million, of which memberships brought in CA$1.8 million and day passes, courses, shoe rental and the café the rest. After paying themselves, the partners kept CA$140,000 of profit in the business. (paragraph 4)

Rising demand has brought problems. Neighbours have complained to the city council about parking and noise after 9 pm. Part-time instructors are paid by the hour and are often given shifts at short notice; two of them told Priya they would leave if the rotas did not improve. Last month the most experienced route setter left to join a national gym chain that is adding climbing walls to its gyms, at prices about 20% below Cairnside's. Luc, who manages the staff, prefers to make decisions quickly himself. Priya would like the instructors to help plan the shifts and the routes. Hana spends most of her time on marketing and leaves the staff to organize themselves. (paragraph 5)

In September, Maritime Mill Developments, a property company, invited Cairnside to open a second centre in a new building it is constructing in Fenwick, a growing town 25 kilometres away. Many of Fenwick's new residents are young families who moved out of Tarrant Harbour, and some of them already drive to Cairnside at weekends. Maritime Mill proposes a joint venture: it would provide the space and pay for most of the fit-out, and the two businesses would jointly own a new company to run the centre. Cairnside would receive 60% of the profits, but it would have to contribute CA$350,000 and manage the centre. (paragraph 6)

The partners do not have CA$350,000. The bank has offered a loan, but only if the partners give personal guarantees backed by their homes. Luc thinks they should first turn the partnership into a private limited company. Hana would rather wait a year and use retained profit. Priya is worried that managing two sites would leave nobody with enough time for the staff in Tarrant Harbour. (paragraph 7)

The partners have estimated the costs of the second centre. Its fixed costs would be CA$46,800 a month, and each member would contribute CA$60 a month after variable costs such as cleaning, chalk and wear on the climbing holds. Maritime Mill says that the building's other tenants, a medical centre and 140 flats, will bring plenty of customers. It took the Tarrant Harbour centre almost two years to reach 780 members. (paragraph 8)

The partners have also noticed changes in their market. More new members are older adults and families, who prefer quieter daytime sessions; on weekday mornings the centre rarely has more than 30 climbers. Social media has been Cairnside's main source of new members, but the cost of promoted posts has risen, and the partners' videos now reach fewer people than they did two years ago. A local school has asked whether Cairnside could offer free sessions for students from low-income families, an idea Priya strongly supports. (paragraph 9)

The city council has said that it will renew Cairnside's late-night licence only if the centre reduces noise and helps members find parking. Luc estimates that new doors and a shuttle bus from a nearby car park would cost CA$60,000. (paragraph 10)

The partners must answer Maritime Mill by January. (paragraph 11)

Your evidence

Nothing tagged yet.

    Section 03: Before the examination

    Know who the decision affects and which tools could help, before you see the questions.

    Stakeholder analysis

    Recommended strategy

    For each stakeholder: what they want from the decision, how much power they have over it, and where they stand. Then compare with the model.

    Stakeholder What they want Power Stance Remove

    Compare with a model analysis
    Stakeholder What they want Power Stance on the decision Paragraph
    Luc Arsenault (partner) Growth, and limiting personal risk by forming a company High For 7
    Hana Brooks (partner) Growth paid for from retained profit, without new debt High Mixed 7
    Priya Sandhu (partner) Time for the staff and for inclusive sessions High Against 7
    Maritime Mill Developments A tenant that draws visitors to its new building High For 6
    Part-time instructors and route setters Fair shifts and a say in their work Low Mixed 5
    Members A less crowded centre and fair prices Low For 3
    Neighbours and the city council Less parking pressure and noise late at night High Mixed 10
    The bank A loan that is repaid, secured by guarantees High Mixed 7

    The platform's reading of the case. Power and stance are judgements: defend your own from the evidence.

    Which tools fit this case?

    Recommended strategy IB requirement

    Choose the tools you would use. A tool earns its place when it changes the argument; Paper 1 is not set on HL-only content (guide, p. 43).

    Tools you would use
      How well each tool fits
      • SWOT analysis : possible, with care. Helps you sort the case before the paper; in an answer, use it to find the argument rather than to restate the case.
      • Ansoff matrix : a strong fit. The second centre is market development: the existing service in a new town. Daytime sessions for families could be market penetration or product development. It frames the direction of growth.
      • Break-even analysis : a strong fit. The case gives fixed costs and contribution per member: 780 members a month is the test any recommendation must face.
      • STEEPLE analysis : possible, with care. Some external factors (the council, a national chain, social media reach), but the decision turns more on Cairnside’s own finance and people.
      • Descriptive statistics : possible, with care. The survey’s percentages can be read and questioned; there is no raw data to work further.
      • Decision tree : a weak fit. No probabilities or payoffs are given: a tree would mean inventing them.
      • Force field analysis (HL): not for Paper 1. An HL-only tool: Paper 1 questions are not set on HL extension content (guide, p. 43).
      • Gantt chart (HL): not for Paper 1. An HL-only tool: Paper 1 questions are not set on HL extension content (guide, p. 43).

      Section 04: The paper

      Section A: answer every question (20 marks). Section B: answer one of the two (10 marks). Build each answer in its parts, tie the evidence to it, then mark it against the guidance.

      IB requirement Recommended strategy

      The structure, times and marks are the guide's (pp. 41 and 43). The suggested split, about 54 min for Section A, follows the teacher support material's advice of about 60% of the time; it is not an IB rule.

      Section A

      1. 1 (a) Define AO1 1.2

        Define the term partnership. [2]

        Where to look: paragraph 2.

        The first precise element of the meaning, in your own words.
        The second element that completes it. An example is not a definition.
        Evidence for this answer

        What the answer still needs

          Guidance and self-mark

          Source: Assessment explanation Illustrative example

          One mark for each of the two elements.

          Award marks for

          Where marks are lost

          • Describing Cairnside instead of defining the term.
          • Leaving out liability, which is what distinguishes a partnership from a company.

        • 1 (b) Outline AO1 1.2

          Outline one disadvantage to Cairnside’s partners of unlimited liability. [2]

          Where to look: paragraphs 2, 7.

          Name it, then give a brief account of what it means for the partners, with a case fact.
          Evidence for this answer

          What the answer still needs

            Guidance and self-mark

            Source: Assessment explanation Illustrative example

            One mark for the disadvantage, one for a brief account of it for the partners.

            Award marks for

            Where marks are lost

            • A general disadvantage of partnerships, such as disagreements, that has nothing to do with liability.

          • 2 (a) Calculate AO4 5.5

            Calculate the number of members the second centre would need each month to break even (show all your working). [2]

            Where to look: paragraph 8.

            Write the formula before any figures.
            The figures from the case, with their units.
            The answer with its unit, rounded once, at the end.
            Evidence for this answer

            What the answer still needs

              Guidance and self-mark

              Source: Assessment explanation Illustrative example

              One mark for the method with the case figures, one for the answer in members.

              Award marks for

              Answer: 46,800 ÷ 60 = 780 members a month

              Where marks are lost

              • Dividing by the CA$75 membership fee instead of the CA$60 contribution.
              • Giving the answer in dollars.

            • 2 (b) Explain AO2 4.4

              Explain two limitations of the survey Hana carried out in October. [6]

              Where to look: paragraph 3.

              Identify the limitation, explain why it matters for market research, then apply it to Hana’s survey.
              A distinct second point, with its own evidence. Identify the limitation, explain why it matters for market research, then apply it to Hana’s survey.
              Evidence for this answer

              What the answer still needs

                Guidance and self-mark

                Source: Assessment explanation Illustrative example

                For each limitation: identify (1), explain with knowledge of market research (1), apply to the survey (1).

                Award marks for

                Where marks are lost

                • Two limitations that are really one, such as "small sample" and "not representative" with the same reason.
                • Limitations of surveys in general, with nothing from Hana’s.

              • 3 (a) List AO1 2.4

                List two non-financial rewards Cairnside could offer its part-time instructors. [2]

                Where to look: paragraph 5.

                A non-financial reward, named.
                A second, different one.
                Evidence for this answer

                What the answer still needs

                  Guidance and self-mark

                  Source: Assessment explanation Illustrative example

                  One mark for each relevant non-financial reward, up to two. A word or phrase each is enough.

                  Award marks for

                  Where marks are lost

                  • Financial rewards, such as a higher hourly rate.
                  • Explaining at length: list asks for the names only.

                • 3 (b) Analyse AO2 2.3

                  Analyse two effects on Cairnside’s staff of the partners’ different leadership styles. [6]

                  Where to look: paragraph 5.

                  Name the style, show how it works in Cairnside, then follow its effect on the staff.
                  A distinct second point, with its own evidence. Name the style, show how it works in Cairnside, then follow its effect on the staff.
                  Evidence for this answer

                  What the answer still needs

                    Guidance and self-mark

                    Source: Assessment explanation Illustrative example

                    For each effect: identify the style (1), analyse how it works (1), and carry it to its effect on Cairnside’s staff (1).

                    Award marks for

                    Where marks are lost

                    • Describing each style with no effect on the staff.
                    • Three styles described briefly instead of two effects analysed.

                  • Section B

                    The question you are answering
                  • 4 Recommend AO3 1.5, 3.2

                    Recommend whether Cairnside should open the second centre through the joint venture with Maritime Mill Developments. [10]

                    Where to look: paragraphs 3, 4, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10.

                    The organization, the decision it faces, and what it is trying to achieve.
                    Developed: business knowledge, a case fact, and the consequence for this organization.
                    Developed the same way, with its own evidence.
                    Which matters more here, and why: size, likelihood, timing, stakeholders.
                    What the case does not tell you, and how that weakens the judgement.
                    A decision, and the condition it depends on.
                    Evidence for this answer

                    What the answer still needs

                      Guidance and self-mark

                      Source: Assessment explanation Illustrative example

                      Level descriptors written by the platform for this question. They are not the IB’s markbands. Place the answer in the level that best describes it.

                      What an answer could draw on

                      • For: demand the centre cannot meet in the evenings (71% too busy); a partner that provides the space and most of the fit-out; 60% of the profits; the medical centre and 140 flats as nearby customers; a step ahead of the national gym chain.
                      • Against: CA$350,000 the partners do not have, and personal guarantees on their homes under unlimited liability; 780 members a month needed to break even, more than a third of today’s total; management time that Priya fears the first centre would lose; shared control with a property company.
                      • Weighing: whether turning into a private limited company first changes the risk; whether waiting a year for retained profit loses Fenwick to a rival; whether 58% saying they would use a second centre would turn into 780 paying members.
                      • Limitations of the case: no figures for Fenwick’s population or demand, no length for the joint venture agreement, and a survey of existing members only.
                      Which level best fits your answer?
                      Choose Marks What a response at this level does
                      0 Nothing relevant to the joint venture.
                      1 to 2 Some knowledge of joint ventures or growth, with little reference to Cairnside.
                      3 to 4 Points for or against, applied in places, mostly one-sided.
                      5 to 6 Arguments on both sides with case evidence, such as the CA$350,000 and the survey, but not weighed.
                      7 to 8 Balanced arguments, some weighing, and a recommendation that follows from them.
                      9 to 10 As 7 to 8, with a clear recommendation that weighs risk against opportunity for the partners, states its conditions, such as forming a company first, and explains how a limitation of the case affects it.

                      Where marks are lost

                      • No recommendation, or one that sits on the fence.
                      • Using the break-even figure without comparing it with the membership the centre could expect.

                    • 5 To what extent AO3 4.5

                      To what extent is social media marketing likely to remain an effective way for Cairnside to win new members? [10]

                      Where to look: paragraphs 3, 9.

                      The organization, the decision it faces, and what it is trying to achieve.
                      Developed: business knowledge, a case fact, and the consequence for this organization.
                      Developed the same way, with its own evidence.
                      Which matters more here, and why: size, likelihood, timing, stakeholders.
                      What the case does not tell you, and how that weakens the judgement.
                      A decision, and the condition it depends on.
                      Evidence for this answer

                      What the answer still needs

                        Guidance and self-mark

                        Source: Assessment explanation Illustrative example

                        Level descriptors written by the platform for this question. They are not the IB’s markbands. Place the answer in the level that best describes it.

                        What an answer could draw on

                        • Effective: it built membership from 600 to 2,100; climbing videos suit a visual activity; low cost compared with traditional media; it reaches students, a third of members.
                        • Less effective: videos reach fewer people than two years ago and promoted posts cost more; new members are increasingly older adults and families who may not be reached the same way; a national chain can outspend a partnership.
                        • Other ways: partnerships with schools and the medical centre in Fenwick; word of mouth; a quieter daytime offer promoted to families.
                        • Limitations of the case: no figures for the cost of promoted posts or for how members first heard of the centre.
                        Which level best fits your answer?
                        Choose Marks What a response at this level does
                        0 Nothing relevant to social media marketing.
                        1 to 2 Some knowledge of promotion, with little reference to Cairnside.
                        3 to 4 Points on social media applied in places, mostly one-sided.
                        5 to 6 Arguments both ways, using case evidence, but not weighed into a view on the extent.
                        7 to 8 Balanced, weighed arguments and a conclusion on the extent that follows from them.
                        9 to 10 As 7 to 8, with a judgement on how far social media will stay effective as the membership changes, its conditions, and how a gap in the case limits it.

                        Where marks are lost

                        • Answering whether social media is good in general, not for Cairnside’s changing membership.
                        • No answer to "to what extent".

                      Section 05: Your paper

                      Your self-marked total and your timed attempts, kept on this device. A self-mark is your own judgement against the platform's guidance, never a grade.

                      Your total and attempts need JavaScript. The guidance under each question needs nothing.

                      Nothing self-marked yet.

                      Other practice cases: Volta Ridge Chocolate Ltd . The Paper 1 page explains each part of the paper.