For teachers Teacher resource area
Classroom activity · Teams pitch to a panel
Five routes, one founder: pitching a way to grow
Five teams each make the case for one of Marigold's routes to growth, and a panel playing the founder and the people with money at stake chooses one. The class then commits the panel's choice in the Decision Room and decides together how to make it work.
- Time
- 45 minutes
- Groups
- of 4
- Built on
- The Decision Room Marigold Kitchens: which way to grow?
- Subtopics
- 1.5 Growth and evolution; 1.4 Stakeholders
- Level
- SL and HL
The business in the case is fictional and its figures are simulated. The lesson plan is the platform's suggestion, not an IB requirement.
Before the lesson
- Students read the Marigold Kitchens case file, at least Exhibits 3, 6 and 7.
- One device for the class with the Decision Room open, shown on the board.
The roles
Each role is a stakeholder in the case. What they want and what worries them are taken from the case file, so students argue from the evidence.
-
Meera Rao, founder and sole owner
- Wants
- Control, the quality of the food and the future of the business she built.
- Worried about
- Losing the character of the food and of the business.
- In the lesson
- Chairs the panel and makes the final choice against her own four aims (Exhibit 6).
-
Banyan Growth Partners (possible investor)
- Wants
- A return on its investment and a sale of its stake in five to seven years.
- Worried about
- A business that grows too slowly to sell at a good price.
- In the lesson
- Sits on the panel and asks every team how fast its route grows the business and what Banyan could sell later.
-
The bank
- Wants
- Interest, and repayment of the loan.
- Worried about
- Lending against forecasts for a city Marigold has never traded in.
- In the lesson
- Sits on the panel and asks what each route borrows and how sure the forecasts are.
-
Employees (118)
- Wants
- Jobs, pay, training and the chance of promotion.
- Worried about
- Growth could bring promotion, or a new owner's rules and more pressure.
- In the lesson
- Sits on the panel and asks what each route means for the people who grew with Marigold.
The lesson, phase by phase
| Minutes | Clock | Phase | What happens |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5 | 0 to 5 | What does Meera want? | Every student ranks Meera's four aims from Exhibit 6, alone. Choose the panel of four, who prepare their questions while the teams work. |
| 12 | 5 to 17 | Build the case | Each of five teams takes one route from Exhibit 3, organic growth, franchising, the joint venture, the acquisition or staying focused, and prepares a pitch of ninety seconds with its figures and its answer to the strongest objection. |
| 12 | 17 to 29 | Pitches and questions | Each team pitches, and the panel asks one question. Teams may not count anyone else's sales as Marigold's revenue. |
| 6 | 29 to 35 | The decision | The panel chooses a route in front of the class and gives one reason for it. Commit it in the Decision Room, then decide round two, making it work, as a class vote. |
| 10 | 35 to 45 | Debrief | Take the questions below in order, then open the room's own debrief together. |
| 45 | minutes in all | ||
Each group produces: Each team's ninety-second pitch, and the panel's decision with its reason.
Debrief
Ask these in order. Take answers from several groups before you give your own view.
- Which aim did the winning route serve, and which did it give up?
- Why are franchisees' sales not Marigold's revenue? What does Marigold actually earn from a franchise?
- Exhibit 7 shows how many franchise inquirers could fund a restaurant. What does that do to a plan for twelve franchises?
- Does buying Tiffin Lane bring economies of scale automatically? What would have to happen first?
- If Mumbai sales in the first year were well below forecast, which route would you choose now?
What the Decision Room's debrief says
The trade-offs
- Speed against control. The routes that grow fastest, franchising and the acquisition, are the ones that loosen control of the kitchen, which is Marigold's advantage.
- This year against later years. Organic growth lowers profit in year two and raises it by year four; light-touch franchising does the reverse.
- Money against ownership. The acquisition is paid for with 30% of the company. Meera keeps a majority, but gains a partner who expects to sell.
- Reach against the aims. Only the joint venture and the acquisition reach three cities quickly, and both strain the aim of keeping control.
Misconceptions to listen for
- Counting franchisees' sales (₹228m in year two) as Marigold's revenue. Marigold's revenue from franchising is the royalties and fees.
- Assuming an acquisition brings economies of scale automatically. The purchasing savings depend on integrating menus, suppliers and systems, and integration can raise costs before it lowers them.
- Treating the route with the highest forecast profit as the answer, without asking whose profit it is and what was given up for it.