Strategy Studio · Stage 2 of 4: Generate options

Ansoff planner

Place your own growth options on the Ansoff matrix by product and market, with the method of growth and the risk you see, and read the usual risk of each direction.

Back to 1.5 Growth and evolution

IB toolkit tool SL and HL Worked example: fictional

What the tool is for, and its limits

Section 01: Build your analysis

The tool opens on a worked example. Change anything: the analysis follows, and your work is kept on this device.

Scripts are off, so this is the worked example as a finished analysis. Every part of it can be read; to build your own, turn scripts on.

Your work is kept on this device as you type.

Your inputs

Growth options

For each option, decide whether the product and the market are existing or new for this business, and say why in "What it involves".

  1. Products
    Markets

    Placed in Market development (usual risk: moderate)

  2. Products
    Markets

    Placed in Market penetration (usual risk: lowest)

  3. Products
    Markets

    Placed in Market development (usual risk: moderate)

  4. Products
    Markets

    Placed in Product development (usual risk: moderate)

  5. Products
    Markets

    Placed in Diversification (usual risk: highest)

The analysis

Worked example Northvale Cycles is fictional and its figures are simulated. Change anything and this becomes your own analysis.

Your options on the matrix

Northvale Cycles. Sells now: City, commuter, cargo, children's and road bikes. To whom: Riders in its home country, through about 120 dealers and its own website.

Market penetration

Lowest risk

  1. 2 Win back commuters with lower prices

Product development

Moderate risk

  1. 4 A bike subscription for commuters

Market development

Moderate risk

  1. 1 Fleet cargo bikes for delivery firms
  2. 3 City bikes for dealers abroad

Diversification

Highest risk

  1. 5 Electric scooters for sharing schemes

Five options: one in market penetration, one in product development, two in market development and one in diversification. The lowest usual risk is "Win back commuters with lower prices" (market penetration); the highest is "Electric scooters for sharing schemes" (diversification). Usual risk is not the whole story: a low-risk direction can still be a poor option if the market has no room to grow, and the risk notes say what the matrix cannot.

From the lowest usual risk to the highest

Your options from the lowest usual risk to the highest, with the method and your risk notes
No.OptionDirectionUsual riskMethodYour risk note
2Win back commuters with lower pricesCut the price of the commuter e-bike, online and through dealers, to recover share from the direct-online brands.Market penetrationLowestInternal (organic) growthA price war with rivals whose costs are lower, about €1,200 a bike against €1,450, could cut margins further.
4A bike subscription for commutersA monthly fee covering a bike, servicing and theft cover, offered to the city riders who already buy Northvale bikes.Product developmentModerateInternal (organic) growthIt ties up cash in a fleet of bikes for rent, and the cost of theft and damage is unknown.
1Fleet cargo bikes for delivery firmsThe cargo bike it already makes, adapted with lockable boxes and a service contract, sold direct to delivery firms in low-emission cities. Businesses are a new market for Northvale.Market developmentModerateInternal (organic) growthFleet buyers are new to Northvale: they negotiate hard and expect repairs within a day. If the fleet version needs a new frame, this becomes diversification.
3City bikes for dealers abroadSell the existing city bikes through twelve dealers in a neighbouring country, with a local distributor.Market developmentModerateStrategic allianceTwelve dealers is a small base, the customers and rivals are unknown, and servicing at a distance is costly.
5Electric scooters for sharing schemesBuild electric scooters for city operators that rent them by the minute, with a scooter maker as partner.DiversificationHighestJoint ventureNorthvale knows neither scooters nor sharing operators, several operators have failed, and margins are thin.

Risk notes for each quadrant

Market penetration (existing products, existing markets; usual risk lowest)
Selling more of what the business already makes to the customers it already serves, by winning share or selling more often. Watch for: A market with little room to grow, price cuts that rivals match, and margins squeezed by the effort to win share.
Product development (new products, existing markets; usual risk moderate)
New or changed products for customers the business already knows. Watch for: Development costs, products that customers do not want after all, and new products taking sales from existing ones.
Market development (existing products, new markets; usual risk moderate)
Existing products sold in new places, to new segments or through new channels. Watch for: Customers the business does not know, rivals already established there, different laws and tastes, and the cost of distribution.
Diversification (new products, new markets; usual risk highest)
New products for new markets, where both are unfamiliar. Related diversification, which builds on skills the business has, is less risky than unrelated diversification. Watch for: Missing skills and knowledge, managers stretched across too much, and the cost of learning a market from nothing.

Direction is not method: any direction can be pursued by internal growth or by one of the external methods in 1.5, which are mergers and acquisitions, takeovers, joint ventures, strategic alliances and franchising.

Checks

No problems found: every option has a method and a risk note.

Section 02: About this tool

What it is for, how to use it, what it cannot do, and where it stands in the IB course.

Purpose

To classify each growth option by how far it takes the business from the products and customers it knows, and to set the usual risk of that direction beside the risks particular to the option.

IB syllabus status

IB toolkit tool SL and HL

The Ansoff matrix is one of the guide's toolkit tools for SL and HL, suggested for units 1 and 4 (Business management guide, p. 14), and taught at AO2 and AO4 alongside the syllabus content (p. 13). The methods of growth offered are internal growth and the external methods the guide names for 1.5 (p. 24).

Serves 1.5 Growth and evolution

How to use it

  1. Say what the business sells now and to whom. "New" only means something against that starting point.
  2. Add each option, with a sentence on what it involves.
  3. For each option, decide whether the product is existing or new for this business, and whether the market is. The tool places it in a quadrant as you choose.
  4. Choose the method of growth, internal or one of the external methods in 1.5. Direction and method are separate decisions.
  5. Write the main risk of each option in your own words, then read the quadrant notes for the risks that usually come with its direction.
  6. Take the options that survive into the decision tree and the option appraisal.

Limitations

  • It shows direction, not method. Franchising, a joint venture and an acquisition are ways of growing, and any of them can serve any direction.
  • It says nothing about profit or affordability. A low-risk option can still be a poor one if its market has no room to grow.
  • Existing and new are matters of degree. A modified product, or a neighbouring market, sits between the boxes, and the placement needs a reason.
  • Usual risk is an average. A business with the right skills can diversify more safely than one without them can develop a new product.

A model is an aid to judgement, not a universal answer. Use what it shows, then decide, and say why.

Section 03: Using what it shows

Recommended use

The recommended use is to argue the placements that are not clear-cut and to let the risk notes, not the quadrant, carry the judgement. Northvale's fleet bike is market development only if the fleet version is the same product; say so, and say what would make it diversification. Then compare options on more than risk.

Read alongside