For teachers Teacher resource area
Classroom activity ยท Leadership team in role, against the clock
Leading Halden through ninety days and one bad night
Groups of four become Halden's leadership in miniature: the new site manager, a team leader, a night-shift picker and an owner. They read the evidence shift by shift, choose an approach to leadership, then lead through a crisis against the clock.
- Time
- 47 minutes
- Groups
- of 4
- Built on
- The Decision Room Halden Distribution: how to lead in the first ninety days
- Subtopics
- 2.3 Leadership and management; 2.4 Motivation and demotivation
- Level
- SL and HL
The business in the case is fictional and its figures are simulated. The lesson plan is the platform's suggestion, not an IB requirement.
Before the lesson
- Students read the Halden Distribution case file, at least Exhibits 2, 3 and 4.
- One device per group with the Decision Room open, and a timer the class can see.
The roles
Each role is a stakeholder in the case. What they want and what worries them are taken from the case file, so students argue from the evidence.
-
Amara Osei, site manager
- Wants
- Restoring performance, keeping the client and establishing her authority.
- Worried about
- Failing in her first role at Halden, in front of owners who hired her from outside.
- In the lesson
- Makes each decision after hearing the others, and has to explain it to them.
-
Team leaders
- Wants
- Authority to run their teams, and support when they need it.
- Worried about
- Being bypassed by the new manager, or left alone with problems they cannot solve.
- In the lesson
- Says what support the team leaders need, and what they can run without the manager.
-
Night-shift pickers (58)
- Wants
- Being trained, consulted and treated fairly.
- Worried about
- More pressure without more support.
- In the lesson
- Speaks from the night shift's evidence, its turnover, its training and how little it was consulted.
-
Halden's owners
- Wants
- Keeping the client and the site's profitability.
- Worried about
- A third of the warehouse's work leaving at the end of the year.
- In the lesson
- Keeps the client's deadline in front of the group, and asks what each choice risks for the contract.
The lesson, phase by phase
| Minutes | Clock | Phase | What happens |
|---|---|---|---|
| 6 | 0 to 6 | The deadline | Read the client's deadline (Exhibit 4) and the room's three objectives aloud. Each group agrees which objective it would give up last. |
| 10 | 6 to 16 | Evidence, shift by shift | Groups compare the two shifts in Exhibits 2 and 3 and write the three differences that matter most. Take one difference from each group before anyone chooses. |
| 8 | 16 to 24 | Round one, the approach | Each role argues for one minute from its own interest, then Amara chooses the approach for the first ninety days and the group commits. |
| 6 | 24 to 30 | Round two, the night the scanners fail | Start the timer at three minutes. The group must commit before it runs out; Amara decides if the group cannot agree. |
| 12 | 30 to 42 | Debrief | Take the questions below in order, then open the room's own debrief together. |
| 5 | 42 to 47 | Exit ticket | Each student names the leadership style the group used in round two and says, in two sentences, whether it would have worked on the day shift. |
| 47 | minutes in all | ||
Each group produces: A one-paragraph account of the group's two decisions, naming the leadership style behind each and the evidence it rested on.
Debrief
Ask these in order. Take answers from several groups before you give your own view.
- Did your group lead both shifts the same way? What in Exhibits 2 and 3 should decide that?
- Which style did the crisis push you towards, and is that a problem for the ninety-day plan?
- What is the difference between a paternalistic and a democratic leader, using Halden's founder (Exhibit 6) as the example?
- When would stepping back and leaving a team to decide be the right call at Halden?
- If most night-shift leavers had left over pay, what could leadership alone have achieved?
What the Decision Room's debrief says
The trade-offs
- Speed against capability. Directive leadership raises performance fastest; only consultation and training raised the night shift's capability.
- Consistency against fit. One style for everyone is easy to explain; matching the style to each team works better and has to be explained.
- Care against results. The founder's paternalistic style built loyalty the site still relies on, but it did not prepare anyone for a new system.
Misconceptions to listen for
- Treating one leadership style as the best. Each works in some situations and damages others.
- Confusing paternalistic with democratic leadership. A paternalistic leader cares about the staff but still decides alone.
- Treating laissez-faire as always a failure of leadership. With an expert team, stepping back can be the right decision.