For teachers Teacher resource area

Classroom activity · Teams commit, then defend

Price, cost and a half-price order

Teams of three run the Atelier Barro Decision Room as the studio's owner, manager and throwers. They work the numbers before each commitment, defend their choices to another team, and finish on the question the case is built to test: is an order below average cost a loss?

Time
50 minutes
Groups
of 3
Built on
The Decision Room Atelier Barro: price, cost and a half-price order
Subtopics
3.3 Costs and revenues; 5.5 Break-even analysis
Level
SL and HL

Source: Arjun Agrawal framework Source: Simulated data

The business in the case is fictional and its figures are simulated. The lesson plan is the platform's suggestion, not an IB requirement.

Open the Decision Room

Before the lesson

  • Students read the Atelier Barro case file, at least Exhibits 1, 3 and 5.
  • One device per team with the Decision Room open, and a calculator.

The roles

Each role is a stakeholder in the case. What they want and what worries them are taken from the case file, so students argue from the evidence.

  1. Inês Carvalho, owner

    Wants
    A business that pays her a living and keeps its reputation for premium, hand-made work.
    Worried about
    Being forced into a price war, or into making cheap mugs for other brands.
    In the lesson
    Holds the final say. Keeps the studio's premium position in view and asks what each choice does to it.
  2. Rui Mendes, studio manager

    Wants
    A stable business and a sensible workload in the shop and at dispatch.
    Worried about
    A rushed November with the hotel order on top of the busy season.
    In the lesson
    Works the figures from Exhibit 1 before every commitment and reads them out to the team.
  3. The two throwers

    Wants
    Earnings, which depend on the number of mugs made.
    Worried about
    Fewer mugs, and so lower pay, if sales fall after a price rise.
    In the lesson
    Speaks for the people paid by the mug. Asks what each choice does to the number of mugs made.

The lesson, phase by phase

Price, cost and a half-price order: 50 minutes in 6 phases
Minutes Clock Phase What happens
5 0 to 5 Set up Read the briefing aloud. Each student predicts, on paper and alone, which price will leave the studio with the most profit, and keeps the prediction for the debrief.
12 5 to 17 Round one, the cost rise Rui works out the contribution per mug and the break-even quantity at the price the team favours, using the new costs in Exhibit 1 and the estimated sales in Exhibit 3. Only then does the team commit. Remind teams that the card and platform fee is a share of the price.
10 17 to 27 Round two, the hotel's order Before committing, each team writes down the change in November profit if it accepts 300 mugs at the hotel's price, and what it would change in December (Exhibit 5). Judging a special order on contribution is part of the HL toolkit's contribution analysis; an SL class can treat it as a question about contribution per unit.
8 27 to 35 Defend it to another team Pairs of teams swap board packs. Each team has two minutes to defend its choices and one minute to question the other's.
10 35 to 45 Debrief Take the questions below in order, then open the room's own debrief together.
5 45 to 50 Exit ticket Each student writes the break-even quantity at the team's chosen price, rounded the right way, and one sentence on why it is rounded that way.
50 minutes in all

Each group produces: Two sentences to Inês for each round, each with the figure that decided it.

Debrief

Ask these in order. Take answers from several groups before you give your own view.

  1. Which price did your team choose, and what would have to be true about the sales estimate in Exhibit 3 for it to work?
  2. Why does the card and platform fee matter more when the price rises?
  3. Was the hotel's price below the cost of a mug? Which cost is the right comparison, and when would the answer change?
  4. What might the order cost the studio's ability to charge its shop price?
  5. Look back at your prediction from the start. What changed your mind, if anything?

What the Decision Room's debrief says

The trade-offs

  • Price against volume. A higher price raises contribution per mug but sells fewer mugs. The best price depends on how sales respond, and the survey's estimate is itself uncertain.
  • Fixed costs against revenue. Cutting marketing lowers the break-even quantity but can lower sales by more.
  • Contribution now against the price position later. The hotel order adds profit this month and may cost some of the brand's ability to charge €22 or more.

Misconceptions to listen for

  • Rounding the break-even quantity down. €8,140 ÷ €14.82 is 549.26; at 549 mugs there is a small loss, so the answer is 550.
  • Rejecting the hotel order because €11 is below the average cost of a mug. With spare capacity and fixed costs already covered, the comparison is with variable cost.
  • Treating the margin of safety as a sum of money. It is a number of mugs, or a share of sales.