Strategy Studio ยท Stage 1 of 4: Diagnose
Five Forces assessor
Rate the five competitive forces on a market with evidence, see how attractive the market is overall, and find what would change it.
Section 01: Build your analysis
The tool opens on a worked example. Change anything: the analysis follows, and your work is kept on this device.
The tool could not start in this browser. The worked example below is complete, but changes will not be calculated or kept.
Scripts are off, so this is the worked example as a finished analysis. Every part of it can be read; to build your own, turn scripts on.
Your inputs
The analysis
Worked example Northvale Cycles is fictional and its figures are simulated. Change anything and this becomes your own analysis.
The forces on the market
Cargo e-bikes sold to businesses, mainly delivery firms, in Northvale's home market
| Force | Rating | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Rivalry among existing competitors | 3 of 5 3Moderate | Four brands sell cargo bikes to businesses and none has more than a third of sales. Fleets buy on reliability and service, so price wars are rare. |
| Threat of new entrants | 3 of 5 3Moderate | Online brands and van makers could enter, but fleet buyers want proven reliability and a servicing network, which take years to build. |
| Bargaining power of suppliers | 4 of 5 4Strong | Two firms make most cargo-rated motors and batteries, and lead times reached 20 weeks in 2024. |
| Bargaining power of buyers | 4 of 5 4Strong | A few large delivery firms buy fleets of 50 or more and negotiate hard on price and service terms. |
| Threat of substitutes | 3 of 5 3Moderate | Small electric vans and walking couriers can do the same work; the van charges from 2027 make vans dearer. |
| Average force | 3.4 | Moderately attractive |
Overall attractiveness
- Average force
- 3.4of 5
- Reading
- Moderately attractiveaverage force 2.5 to 3.5
On your ratings the market is moderately attractive (average force 3.4 of 5): profits are possible, but some forces will squeeze them. The strongest forces are suppliers and buyers (4 of 5), so a strategy for this market has to deal with them. No single one-point change would move the market into another band.
- Attractive average force below 2.5
- Moderately attractive average force 2.5 to 3.5
- Unattractive average force above 3.5
- The bands are the platform's teaching convention; every force is weighted equally.
What would change it
- Rivalry 3A large rival cutting its fleet prices to win the first contracts in the low-emission cities.one point weaker: average 3.2; one point stronger: average 3.6, unattractive
- New entrants 3A van maker launching its own cargo bike and servicing it through its existing dealers.one point weaker: average 3.2; one point stronger: average 3.6, unattractive
- Suppliers 4Qualifying a second motor supplier, or a new motor maker entering the market.one point weaker: average 3.2; one point stronger: average 3.6, unattractive
- Buyers 4Selling to many smaller firms and councils, and tying fleets in with service contracts lasting several years.one point weaker: average 3.2; one point stronger: average 3.6, unattractive
- Substitutes 3A delay to the van charges would strengthen this force; stricter limits on vans would weaken it.one point weaker: average 3.2; one point stronger: average 3.6, unattractive
Checks
No problems found: the market is defined and every force has evidence.
Section 02: About this tool
What it is for, how to use it, what it cannot do, and where it stands in the IB course.
Purpose
To judge how much profit a market is likely to leave for the businesses in it, by weighing the forces that push profit down, and to find which of those forces a strategy could act on.
IB syllabus status
Porter's five forces are not in the guide. Neither the toolkit (Business management guide, pp. 13 to 15) nor the syllabus (pp. 21 to 36) names them, so this tool is enrichment, offered for readers beyond the IB course and as a way of organizing evidence about a market. The guide's tool from Porter is his generic strategies, an HL-only toolkit tool (p. 14).
How to use it
- Define the market narrowly, by who buys what, where. The forces on bicycles in general and on cargo bikes sold to delivery firms are different.
- For each force, read the prompt questions, then rate the force from 1 (very weak) to 5 (very strong) and write the evidence for the rating. A strong force takes profit away.
- Say what would change each force, for better or worse. These notes are where strategy can act.
- Read the overall attractiveness and the strongest forces. The tool shows what a one-point change in each force would do to the average.
- Use the result to judge whether the market is worth entering or growing in, and which forces an option must deal with.
Limitations
- It is not part of the IB course. Use it, if at all, to organize evidence about a market that a question asks about, and name the course's own tools where they fit.
- It describes an industry, not a business. Two businesses in the same market can face it very differently, depending on their strengths.
- Averaging the five ratings treats every force as equally important, which is rarely true; one overwhelming force can matter more than the rest together.
- It is a snapshot. Technology, regulation and new entrants can change the forces quickly.
- It leaves out forces some writers add, such as governments or businesses that sell complementary products.
A model is an aid to judgement, not a universal answer. Use what it shows, then decide, and say why.
Section 03: Using what it shows
The recommended use is to name the one or two forces that decide the answer and say what the business would do about them. For Northvale, buyer and supplier power matter most; a second motor supplier and service contracts with fleets are the responses. Rating all five forces at equal length is description; using the strongest to shape the option is analysis.
Read alongside
Arjun Agrawal | The Business Brief, https://the-business-brief-dun.vercel.app/strategy-studio/five-forces/. Original teaching material, not an IB publication. The organizations in the teaching cases are fictional unless a case says otherwise.